15:00:09 <mlavalle> #startmeeting neutron_l3
15:00:10 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Jul 30 15:00:09 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is mlavalle. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:12 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:15 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'neutron_l3'
15:00:41 <mlavalle> hi, who is here for the Neutron L3 meeting?
15:00:46 <regXboi> moo
15:00:48 <pc_m> hi
15:00:49 <john-davidge> HI==i
15:01:11 <mlavalle> carl_baldwin is on vacation this week, so i'll be the chair today
15:01:22 <vikram_> Hi mlavalle
15:01:29 <pavel_bondar> hi
15:01:29 <mlavalle> agenda for today https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Neutron-L3-Subteam#Agenda
15:01:52 <mlavalle> #topic Annoucements
15:02:21 <mlavalle> Voting is open for Tokyo presentations here: https://www.openstack.org/summit/tokyo-2015/vote-for-speakers
15:02:40 <mlavalle> please go and vote for your favorite topics and speakers
15:02:47 <regXboi> mlavalle: in fact I think it ends today, doesn't it?
15:03:04 <pc_m> yes
15:03:04 <mlavalle> regXboi: you are correct
15:03:12 <regXboi> ok, thanks
15:03:21 * regXboi moves that up his to do list
15:03:41 <mlavalle> Liberty 3 is our up-coming milestone now: https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/liberty-3
15:03:48 * neiljerr` slides in late because he got the wrong meeting room...
15:04:00 <johnbelamaric> Hello
15:04:30 <johnbelamaric> pluggable IPAM is all merged :)
15:04:34 <mlavalle> the Launchpad page has the date set to Septmber 3. mestery said August 31st this past Tuesday during Neutron meeting
15:04:51 <neiljerr`> johnbelamaric: yay!
15:04:57 <mlavalle> johnbelamaric: congrats!
15:05:03 <john-davidge> johnbelamaric: woop woop!
15:05:26 <mlavalle> any other announcements from the team?
15:06:16 <mlavalle> ok, moving on.....
15:06:26 <mlavalle> #topic Bugs
15:07:07 <mlavalle> john-davidge: do you have any updates for the team regarding https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1471316?
15:07:08 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1471316 in neutron "_get_subnetpool_id does not return None when a cidr is specified and a subnetpool_id isn't." [High,In progress] - Assigned to John Davidge (john-davidge)
15:07:19 <john-davidge> So I think the discussion around this has opened a whole can of worms. This is probably something we should put on hold until we can discuss it further in Tokyo.
15:07:26 <john-davidge> For now I’d like to propose that we do two things…
15:07:34 <john-davidge> 1. Update the default subnetpool so that it can be defined by name rather than UUID. This will allow the feature to be used in its current state. I am happy to volunteer for this.
15:07:41 <john-davidge> 2. Update devstack so that it doesn’t fail when a default subnetpool is set. I already have a patch out for this #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/199038/ - would appreciate some reviews. I’ll remove the WIP if we agree on this.
15:07:58 <john-davidge> Any objections/concerns on those two action items?
15:08:52 <mlavalle> john-davidge: let's move ahead with those to action items. Will you submit a patchset for number 1
15:08:57 <mlavalle> ?
15:09:24 <john-davidge> mlavalle: Yes, I’ll get started ont hat right away
15:09:48 <mlavalle> john-davidge: thanks!
15:10:00 <mlavalle> the other bug I wanted to mention today is https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1388698
15:10:02 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1388698 in neutron "dhcp_agents_per_network does not work appropriately." [High,In progress] - Assigned to watanabe.isao (watanabe.isao)
15:10:09 <john-davidge> mlavalle: Thank you!
15:10:50 <mlavalle> there hassn't been any progress reported there since early April. I wrote this morning an email to the asignee to find out whether he is still working on it or not
15:11:27 <mlavalle> any other bugs that need to be discussed here today?
15:11:30 <regXboi> mlavalle: before we leave the topic of bugs, do we know what the current fail rate of the exp multinode dvr job is?
15:11:54 * regXboi couldn't find a number
15:12:13 <mlavalle> regXboi: that I don't know. does anybody know? maybe swammi if he is around?
15:12:47 <regXboi> mlavalle: IIRC, Swami is on PTO for *a while*, so I was hoping somebody else might know
15:13:07 <regXboi> mlavalle: if not, it is not a problem, it is just something else to go start looking at
15:13:36 <mlavalle> regXboi: since he is not around, i'll create an action item to find that out, so we have visibility next meeting
15:13:47 <regXboi> mlavalle: thx
15:14:14 <mlavalle> #action #mlavalle will find out  what the current fail rate of the exp multinode dvr job is
15:14:39 <mlavalle> #action mlavalle will find out  what the current fail rate of the exp multinode dvr job is
15:15:01 <mlavalle> moving on.......
15:15:17 <mlavalle> #topic Roter networks segments
15:15:27 <mlavalle> #undo
15:15:28 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0xacb3250>
15:15:42 <mlavalle> #topic Routed networks segments
15:16:18 <mlavalle> so the conversation has continued in the ML regarding this subject. Is there anything that needs to be discussed here?
15:16:46 <neiljerr`> I think that discussion is going to run for a while....
15:16:50 <regXboi> mlavalle: I don't think so - carl_baldwin should have a chance to process it and weigh in
15:17:24 <mlavalle> regXboi: I agree, I just wanted to find out if there is something that need to be said here
15:17:34 <mlavalle> carl_baldwin will read the minutes
15:17:40 <neiljerr`> I don't know when we start suggesting topics for Tokyo - but think that this will be an excellent one!
15:18:03 <mlavalle> neiljerr`: great suggstion
15:18:05 * regXboi checks the thread to make sure it has all the branches
15:18:41 <mlavalle> ok, moving on.......
15:18:42 <vikram_> neiljerr`:+1
15:18:51 <mlavalle> #topic BGP
15:19:31 <mlavalle> vikram_ any updates here
15:19:39 <vikram_> Yes
15:20:16 <vikram_> We are in a good shape w.r.t. agent scheduling + driver changes...Most of the changes are in my local devstack env
15:20:25 <vikram_> Will post them soon for review
15:20:56 <vikram_> ryan was working over the routes.. could not find him
15:21:25 <vikram_> Initial  CLI patch is out for review.. Need suggestions from all
15:21:38 <vikram_> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/205756/
15:22:06 <mlavalle> everybody is encourged to review
15:22:25 <vikram_> by when we should be ready for liberty-3
15:22:59 <regXboi> vikram_: how soon might the UTs be on that patch?
15:23:00 <mlavalle> vikram_: as early as possible.... mestery mentioned August 31st..... but the limiting factor is reviewers
15:23:36 <vikram_> regXboi: Will work on the unit test by this weekend
15:23:50 <regXboi> vikram_: thx
15:23:59 <vikram_> It will be great if all of us agree with the proposed cli
15:24:21 <vikram_> or any suggestion for the change.. it will avoid rework for us :-)
15:24:53 <vikram_> mlavalle: thanks.. will try our best to be on-time
15:25:02 <vikram_> *before time :-)
15:25:06 <mlavalle> :-)
15:25:18 <mlavalle> vikram_: anything else?
15:25:34 <vikram_> mlavalle: nothing from my end on this topic
15:25:48 <mlavalle> ok, let's move on.....
15:25:53 <mlavalle> #topic IPAM
15:26:13 * mlavalle gives johnbelamaric a few momments to bask under the glory
15:26:24 <mlavalle> ;-)
15:26:26 <johnbelamaric> :)
15:26:27 <pavel_bondar> :)
15:26:34 <johnbelamaric> pavel_bondar too :)
15:26:36 <mlavalle> and pavel_bondar of course
15:26:48 <mlavalle> thanks you very much for all your efforts
15:26:52 <johnbelamaric> we are starting our driver work - we have added networking-infoblox repo for that work
15:26:59 <mlavalle> we all agree it is a big achievment
15:27:34 <johnbelamaric> thanks for all the reviews too
15:27:45 <john-davidge> ++
15:28:06 <mlavalle> johnbelamaric, pavel_bondar any thing else to be said today?
15:28:14 <johnbelamaric> nope
15:28:22 <pavel_bondar> no from my side too
15:28:36 <neiljerr`> What do you guys plan to do next?
15:28:40 <mlavalle> #topic ML3 router plugin
15:28:53 <johnbelamaric> neiljerr`: first our driver, then we will see...
15:29:18 <mlavalle> last time we discussed this, use case were being gathered from the community here: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron-modular-l3-router-plugin-use-cases
15:29:37 <mlavalle> doesn anybody has anything to report about this topic?
15:30:34 <mlavalle> ok, let's move on.....
15:30:40 <mlavalle> #topic DNS
15:31:07 <mlavalle> I have made excellent progress on the internal side of this
15:31:12 <mlavalle> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/200952/
15:31:45 <mlavalle> this patchset is now fully functional. All the port CRUD operations work now fine with the new dns_name attribute
15:32:04 <johnbelamaric> mlavalle: nice!
15:32:12 <mlavalle> I created a couple of gists to show how the api behaves:
15:32:38 <mlavalle> https://gist.github.com/miguellavalle/bf2254c5ea7861656135
15:32:55 <mlavalle> https://gist.github.com/miguellavalle/6327f01c8422bb8039ef
15:33:38 <mlavalle> at this point some unit tests are failing, mostly dnsmasq related. I'll fix those today and then I think that patchset will be good to go
15:33:47 <mlavalle> please weigh in with your reviews
15:34:12 <mlavalle> and I am also already working on the external side, the integration with designate
15:34:22 <mlavalle> I expect to post code next week
15:34:56 <mlavalle> that's the update on this subject
15:35:03 <johnbelamaric> Ok, great. I am interested in the driver API for the external piece - we probably will create one as well
15:35:35 <mlavalle> fantastic.... i'll be pinging you as soon as i have code in gerrit
15:36:06 <mlavalle> #topic Address scopes
15:36:16 <johnbelamaric> thanks
15:36:24 <mlavalle> does any one has anything to report on this topic?
15:37:04 <vikram__> mlavalle:
15:37:14 <vikram__> few reviews for address scopes are open
15:37:47 <vikram__> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/194635/
15:38:14 <vikram__> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/197552/
15:38:48 <mlavalle> those 2 or are there more?
15:39:16 <vikram__> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/neutron+branch:master+topic:bp/address-scopes,n,z
15:39:35 <mlavalle> vikram__: thanks for the topic link.
15:40:24 <mlavalle> anything else?
15:41:10 <mlavalle> ok, moving on.....
15:41:12 <vikram__> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:bp/address-scopes,n,z
15:41:15 <vikram__> is better
15:41:26 <mlavalle> vikram__: thank you!
15:41:37 <vikram__> mlavalle: wc
15:41:53 <mlavalle> #topic IPv6
15:42:21 <mlavalle> sc68cal, HenryG: is there anything that needs to be discussed today regarding IPv6?
15:43:07 <HenryG> I think the initial doc patch got merged?
15:43:41 <john-davidge> HenryG: It did!
15:43:49 <HenryG> https://review.openstack.org/181049
15:43:49 * john-davidge needs to update prefix delegation docs
15:44:07 <mlavalle> HenryG: thnks for the url
15:44:36 <mlavalle> HenryG: anything else?
15:45:02 <HenryG> Prefix delegation needs more reviews, and I am giulty :(
15:45:26 <mlavalle> john-davidge: do you have the url?
15:45:33 <john-davidge> HenryG: You can redeem yourself right now! #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/158697/ :)
15:45:51 <mlavalle> john-davidge: Lol
15:45:58 <john-davidge> It’s been through a lot of iterations over the last couple of weeks and I’m very confident it’s ready to merge now
15:46:18 <HenryG> Yes, I think we may be able get that in "Real Soon Now" (TM)
15:46:27 <john-davidge> Then we can concentrate on getting the agent-side changes merged in time for Liberty-3
15:46:37 <regXboi> HenryG: that sounds like "the check is in the mail" :)
15:46:48 <john-davidge> HenryG: Ah yes, “Any Day Now”
15:47:40 <HenryG> Fine, hit me with an AI :)
15:47:49 <mlavalle> ok let's move on.... thanks for the update
15:48:06 <mlavalle> #topic Open discussion
15:48:28 <mlavalle> doesn anybody has any other topics not in the agenda?
15:49:21 <neiljerr`> Not today!
15:49:43 <mlavalle> ok guys, thank you so much for attending...see you all next week
15:49:55 <neiljerr`> Bye all!
15:49:55 <regXboi> mlavalle: thanks for running this
15:49:58 <regXboi> oom
15:49:59 <vikram__> thanks mlavalle for running
15:50:00 <john-davidge> thanks everyone
15:50:05 <vikram__> bye
15:50:10 <mlavalle> #endmeeting