15:00:56 <carl_baldwin> #startmeeting neutron_l3
15:00:56 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Oct  8 15:00:56 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is carl_baldwin. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:57 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:59 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'neutron_l3'
15:01:44 <carl_baldwin> #topic Announcements
15:01:51 <carl_baldwin> Any announcements?
15:02:10 <regXboi> not from here
15:02:21 <mlavalle> a little more that 2 weeks for the summit
15:02:38 <carl_baldwin> mlavalle: You beat me, I was typing that very announcement.
15:02:56 <mlavalle> :-)
15:03:00 <carl_baldwin> I look forward to seeing as many of you there as possible.
15:03:11 * amuller has a minor panic attack
15:03:33 <amuller> 2.5 weeks jeez
15:03:35 * carl_baldwin has had his share of those too
15:03:44 <regXboi> amuller: time flies when you are having fun
15:03:49 <carl_baldwin> amuller: Yes, it always comes quickly.
15:04:37 <carl_baldwin> #topic Bugs
15:04:40 <carl_baldwin> mlavalle: ping
15:04:50 <mlavalle> hi
15:05:21 <mlavalle> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1365473
15:05:21 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1365473 in neutron "Unable to create a router that's both HA and distributed" [High,In progress] - Assigned to John Schwarz (jschwarz)
15:05:42 <mlavalle> this one had a partial fix merged this week by Adolfo
15:06:08 <carl_baldwin> My thinking on this is that we should merge it soon.  amuller, what is your feeling?
15:06:16 <mlavalle> assigned now to jschwarz
15:06:18 <Swami> mlavalle: yes the agent side got merged but the server side is still in review.
15:06:31 <carl_baldwin> I still need to finish looking over the server side stuff.
15:06:37 <amuller> carl_baldwin: funny I'm in a meeting with jschwarz right now about the server patch
15:06:41 <amuller> we still need to review it
15:06:41 <jschwarz> XD
15:06:51 <regXboi> what's the link for the server side patch?
15:07:04 <jschwarz> regXboi, https://review.openstack.org/143169
15:07:12 <mlavalle> jschwarz: you working on the servier side of this
15:07:15 <mlavalle> ?
15:07:27 <jschwarz> mlavalle, I was reviewing it and fixing a couple of issues I had it with
15:07:32 <regXboi> #link https://review.openstack.org/143169 server side patch for LP bug 1365473
15:07:32 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1365473 in neutron "Unable to create a router that's both HA and distributed" [High,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1365473 - Assigned to John Schwarz (jschwarz)
15:07:39 <fitoduarte> .
15:07:42 <jschwarz> most of the work was done by other people (such as Adolfo and Rajeev)
15:08:00 <mlavalle> so you driving it to the finish line?
15:08:02 <vikram> Hi All... Sorry for joining late
15:08:04 <jschwarz> mlavalle, yes
15:08:08 <mlavalle> :-)
15:08:48 <mlavalle> regXboi: I'll update that patch in the agenda bug tracker list
15:08:56 <regXboi> mlavalle: ack and thanks
15:09:00 <mlavalle> anything else on this one?
15:09:16 <mlavalle> ok
15:09:25 <carl_baldwin> No, let’s just get it in there so that others can try it out.
15:09:27 <mlavalle> next up https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/149435
15:09:27 <openstack> Launchpad bug 149435 in update-manager (Ubuntu) "Update Manager freezes when clicking "install updates" after having cancelled root password insertion" [Undecided,Invalid]
15:09:53 <mlavalle> pavel_bondar has been actively working on this one.... any updates for this meeting?
15:10:16 <pavel_bondar> mlavalle: pbobably not this one
15:10:43 <mlavalle> need any help?
15:10:44 <pavel_bondar> s/pbobably/pbrobably/
15:11:17 <mlavalle> I guess no, moving on
15:11:24 <mlavalle> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1486795
15:11:24 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1486795 in neutron "DVR: create or update port by using notify specific host rather than fanout" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Oleg Bondarev (obondarev)
15:11:26 <carl_baldwin> Am I the only one seeing a bug on update-manager?
15:11:28 <haleyb> mlavalle: was that the right bug before?
15:11:43 <johnbelamaric1> that wasn't it
15:11:46 <pavel_bondar> mine was https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1494351
15:11:46 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1494351 in neutron "Observed StaleDataError in gate-neutron-dsvm-api tests if reference IPAM driver is used" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Pavel Bondar (pasha117)
15:11:52 <mlavalle> sorry
15:12:01 <mlavalle> didn't see the error
15:12:14 <mlavalle> pavel_bondar: I menat that bug
15:12:19 <carl_baldwin> Amazing that you and Pavel could read each other’s minds.
15:12:22 <mlavalle> any comments on it?
15:12:45 <pavel_bondar> so, I am pretty close with it,most tests are passed now
15:13:14 <pavel_bondar> see a few errors in logs, that concerns me, so investigating with them
15:13:21 <mlavalle> cool, need any help?
15:13:32 <pavel_bondar> need a review soon
15:13:39 <pavel_bondar> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/223123
15:13:59 <pavel_bondar> I hope tomorrow would be nice day to review it
15:14:10 <mlavalle> thanks!
15:14:14 <pavel_bondar> after I remove all the debug from the patch
15:14:42 <mlavalle> so, now moving on to https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1486795
15:14:42 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1486795 in neutron "DVR: create or update port by using notify specific host rather than fanout" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Oleg Bondarev (obondarev)
15:15:08 <mlavalle> this one has been taken over by obondarev
15:15:30 <mlavalle> he pushed first WIP patchset this past Tuesday
15:15:30 <carl_baldwin> Strange that it seems like the same url as before but looks like it came up with the right bug this time.
15:15:42 <carl_baldwin> Nm, different bug.
15:16:07 <mlavalle> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/231555/
15:16:49 <mlavalle> obondarev also took over of a closely related bug:
15:17:24 <mlavalle> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1486828
15:17:24 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1486828 in neutron "DVR: Notify specific agent when dealing with floating ips" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Oleg Bondarev (obondarev)
15:17:54 <mlavalle> same situation, he pushed an initilal WIP patchset this past Tuesday
15:18:19 <mlavalle> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/231455/
15:18:42 <mlavalle> so I guess we need to keep and eye on these two and review the fixes as they evolve
15:18:56 <mlavalle> any comments?
15:19:31 <regXboi> I think those bugs have multiple patches - at least I've seen a lot of related patches to the various CRUD operations
15:20:15 <mlavalle> ok, moving on, we have a new one: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1476097
15:20:15 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1476097 in neutron "[fwaas]Support fwaas to control east-west traffic in dvr router" [High,Triaged] - Assigned to lee jian (leejian0612)
15:20:38 <mlavalle> This one was triaged yesterday by armax and classified as rfe
15:20:51 <regXboi> has that one been approved by the drivers team yet?
15:21:07 <mlavalle> don't know..... maybe carl_baldwin knows
15:21:24 <mlavalle> already has someone assigned to it
15:21:30 <carl_baldwin> Not as far as I know.
15:22:20 <mlavalle> ok, I can ping armax and see what's the status from his point of view
15:22:29 <Swami> carl_baldwin: mlavalle: I am in discussion with the FwaaS team on fixing this issue.
15:22:40 <mlavalle> great!
15:23:11 <mlavalle> any further comments?
15:23:54 <mlavalle> ok, that's all the bugs I have this week..... regXboi do you have any?
15:24:01 <regXboi> mlavalle: not today
15:24:11 <mlavalle> ok, done with bugs
15:25:08 <mlavalle> carl_baldwin: done with bugs
15:25:23 <carl_baldwin> mlavalle: Thanks
15:26:37 <carl_baldwin> #topic Routed network segments
15:27:03 <carl_baldwin> I’m starting to get some feedback on this review.  I think we’ve got a direction to go.
15:27:15 <carl_baldwin> What we need is people willing to work  on it.
15:28:20 <carl_baldwin> I’m actually pretty excited about getting to work on this in Mitaka.  I think it will be something that a number of operators will appeciate.
15:28:39 <amuller> carl_baldwin: Sorry I haven't had the chance to review it yet
15:28:43 <amuller> I do intend to though
15:28:51 <vikram> carl_baldwin: I am willing to help after the BGP work ;)
15:28:56 <carl_baldwin> amuller: I will value your feedback as always.
15:29:06 <mlavalle> carl_baldwin: do you have a milesttone in mind for this work?
15:29:13 <Swami> carl_baldwin: count me in
15:29:25 <carl_baldwin> vikram: Swami: great.
15:29:31 <tidwellr> carl_baldwin: you're proposing a phased approach right, we won't have everything done in Mitaka?
15:29:36 <mlavalle> I am also interested in helping, but I need to wrap up the dns work
15:30:18 <carl_baldwin> tidwellr: Right, I don’t see how it will all get done in Mitaka.  My goal would be to be able to boot a VM on a routed network and get some of the other model changes lined up for N.
15:31:35 <carl_baldwin> Some of the longer pole stuff should have a good head start during Mitaka.
15:32:54 <carl_baldwin> Feedback is still welcome and encouraged on the spec.
15:32:57 <carl_baldwin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/225384/
15:33:08 * mlavalle will read the spec
15:33:24 * regXboi will look for time to re-read
15:33:41 <carl_baldwin> I’d like to have a discussion with Calico on it too.  I think it could fit what they’re working on better than the previous attempts.
15:33:49 <carl_baldwin> Thanks!
15:33:58 <carl_baldwin> #topic DVR
15:34:07 <Swami> carl_baldwin: hi
15:34:07 <carl_baldwin> haleyb: regXboi: Swami: hi
15:34:17 <Swami> patches are up for review.
15:34:19 <carl_baldwin> How is the dvr job failure rate looking lately?
15:34:26 <regXboi> It's still not good
15:34:35 <regXboi> It's better, but still not good
15:34:37 <Swami> carl_baldwin: until we push in the patch I don't expect the failure rate to go down.
15:35:08 <carl_baldwin> Swami: Do you have a link handy for that patch?
15:35:12 <Swami> the gate is broken now.
15:35:16 <Swami> carl_baldwin: yes
15:35:26 <regXboi> aren't the bugs in the agenda?
15:35:31 <regXboi> er I mean Patch Sets
15:35:32 <Swami> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/228582/
15:35:52 <Swami> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/229561/
15:36:08 <Swami> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/230079/
15:36:31 <Swami> carl_baldwin: right now all these patches are chained. I have not seen any failures to fip so far in these patches.
15:36:50 <Swami> It would be great if we all can review this and push the patch upstream to see the change in the gate.
15:37:06 <carl_baldwin> Swami: Thanks.
15:37:10 <regXboi> The agenda has three other patch sets ?!?! what are those?
15:37:19 <Swami> I wanted to make DVR voting again before the summit, if we delay there are chances that we might get more bugs down the road.
15:37:38 <Swami> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/225319/
15:37:49 <carl_baldwin> haleyb: regXboi: are you able to review the patch sets?
15:38:07 <regXboi> yes, I will take a look at them
15:38:11 <carl_baldwin> Swami: I agree, getting the job in to voting shape should be a priority.
15:38:31 <Swami> There was also another bug that was reported for DVR and IPV6. #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1501969
15:38:31 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1501969 in neutron "No dhcp IPv6 assigned (slaac/slaac) with interface-add after VM boot" [Medium,Confirmed] - Assigned to Swaminathan Vasudevan (swaminathan-vasudevan)
15:38:35 <haleyb> carl_baldwin: yes, I know i looked at the ARP cache one, just waiting for jenkins to be happy now.  Will look at the other two ast well
15:38:47 <Swami> I will work on that bug after the stability issues are resolved.
15:39:12 <regXboi> that bug is likely going to be needed for multinode DVR
15:39:26 <Swami> regXboi: which bug?
15:39:32 <regXboi> 1501969
15:39:46 <carl_baldwin> haleyb: Ping me if you +2
15:39:47 <Swami> regXboi: This only happens when you have a VM and then attach a router.
15:39:59 <haleyb> carl_baldwin: will do
15:40:08 <Swami> regXboi: right now there is no issue in the gate.
15:40:16 * regXboi isn't convinced
15:40:50 <regXboi> but that's ok - we work on the ones we've got and then deal with the next crop
15:41:11 <Swami> regXboi: right now in multinode in the gate I am see that there is one common test that consistently fails for both DVR and non DVR routers.
15:41:29 <Swami> regXboi: understood.
15:42:10 <Swami> That's all I have from the DVR side, it would be great if we can review it quickly and make the gate stable.
15:42:48 <carl_baldwin> Thanks.
15:42:58 <carl_baldwin> #topic BGP dynamic routing
15:43:17 <tidwellr> hi
15:43:21 <vikram> hi
15:43:59 <tidwellr> refactoring https://review.openstack.org/#/c/201621/ per good feedback
15:44:08 <tidwellr> will break into smaller patches
15:44:21 <tidwellr> also introducing a slight change to the model
15:44:58 <tidwellr> I'd like to model autonomous systems explicitly as their own entity, unique on address scope and ASN
15:45:56 <vikram> tidwellr: reason for this change?
15:47:38 <tidwellr> a couple reasons
15:48:07 <vikram> tidwellr: ok
15:48:17 <tidwellr> it's a nice decoupling between address scopes and BGP speakers,  and it gives us a place to hang policy
15:48:36 <carl_baldwin> tidwellr: Sounds okay to me.
15:49:07 <carl_baldwin> tidwellr: Anything else?
15:49:11 <vikram> tidwellr: I think I need more understanding .. Will catch you offline
15:49:18 <tidwellr> vikram: ack
15:49:31 <carl_baldwin> #topic DNS
15:49:34 <carl_baldwin> mlavalle: hi
15:49:37 <mlavalle> hi again
15:49:58 <mlavalle> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/212213/ is complete with all the functionality for floating ips
15:50:25 <mlavalle> earlier this week I incorportated all the changes requested by the designate team
15:50:51 <carl_baldwin> Any more on the gate?
15:50:59 <mlavalle> they wanted to have the PTR's in /24 zones
15:51:06 <mlavalle> not delete the PTR zones
15:51:19 <mlavalle> and make PTR optional based on config parameter
15:51:23 <mlavalle> all that is in
15:51:38 <mlavalle> right now I am fixing the failures in the unit tests
15:52:03 <mlavalle> it seems I have a problem with the allembic script that is breaking the unit tests execution
15:52:18 <mlavalle> I have also started modifying the nova side
15:52:33 <mlavalle> it seems to be not a big deal
15:52:43 <mlavalle> so I will be pushing something at the end of this week
15:52:58 <mlavalle> and I think I have time to devote to the presentation for Tokyo
15:53:18 <mlavalle> so I will send something to Kiall and carl_baldwin early next week
15:53:21 <carl_baldwin> mlavalle: Let’s find a time to work on that early next week.
15:53:28 <carl_baldwin> :)
15:53:37 <mlavalle> yeah, i'll send you a first draft
15:53:50 <mlavalle> that's all I have this week
15:53:53 <carl_baldwin> mlavalle: let us now when the patch is in good shape test-wise or if you need anything.
15:54:09 <carl_baldwin> mlavalle: Thanks
15:54:15 <carl_baldwin> #topic Address Scopes
15:54:46 <carl_baldwin> I spent yesterday beginning to rebase and test out the patches again.  I want to get them merged before summit.
15:55:11 <carl_baldwin> I’ve even been able to clean them up a little more.
15:55:33 <carl_baldwin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+topic:bp/address-scopes,n,z
15:57:48 <carl_baldwin> That is all.
15:57:54 <carl_baldwin> #topic Open Discussion
15:58:10 <regXboi> do we have an ETA on py34 being fixed?
15:59:48 <regXboi> I'll take it to the channel
15:59:51 <carl_baldwin> regXboi: On that patch?
15:59:57 <regXboi> no I mean in general
16:00:03 <carl_baldwin> Thanks, all!  Great work.
16:00:06 <carl_baldwin> #endmeeting