14:00:05 <dansmith> #startmeeting nova 14:00:06 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Aug 25 14:00:05 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is dansmith. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:00:08 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:00:10 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'nova' 14:00:12 <cdent> o/ 14:00:13 <markus_z> o/ 14:00:17 <dansmith> #chair alaski 14:00:18 <openstack> Current chairs: alaski dansmith 14:00:19 <alaski> o/ 14:00:20 <takashin> o/ 14:00:20 <abhishekk> o/ 14:00:33 <bauzas> \o 14:00:39 <dansmith> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Nova 14:00:56 <dansmith> #topic Release 14:01:00 <raj_singh> o/ 14:01:08 <scottda> hi 14:01:09 <dansmith> #link Newton release schedule: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Nova/Newton_Release_Schedule 14:01:12 <rlrossit> o/ 14:01:21 <dansmith> #info Aug 22-26: final non-client library release (oslo) - so if you need things released from dependent libraries get them done soon 14:01:35 <dansmith> we had a couple critical fixes go into o.vo for newton which I think we're in good shape for now 14:01:41 <dansmith> any other things about the release? 14:02:02 <dansmith> I think we made some progress on outstanding cells and placement patches in the last week or so, which is good 14:02:10 <alaski> yep 14:02:15 <johnthetubaguy> there is a bug about os-vif still rumbing on 14:02:23 <edleafe> \o 14:02:28 <johnthetubaguy> I will try dig up the link, its about when you use ovs I think 14:02:37 <dansmith> johnthetubaguy: okay lets move onto the bugs part and you can link us 14:02:46 <dansmith> anything else on the release and scheduling? 14:03:01 <woodster_> o/ 14:03:06 <dansmith> #topic Bugs 14:03:14 <dansmith> #link check queue gate status http://status.openstack.org/elastic-recheck/index.html 14:03:33 <dansmith> the gate has been pretty suck recently but I think we merged some fixes yesterday so hopefully it's better? 14:04:09 <bauzas> aye 14:04:19 <dansmith> anything else on gate? 14:04:26 <johnthetubaguy> OSIC folks lit up some more capacity recently 14:04:31 <dansmith> ah excellent 14:04:33 <jlvillal> o/ 14:04:34 <johnthetubaguy> which should help with pure node terms 14:04:47 <alaski> nice 14:04:50 <dansmith> there's a question in here from matt I assume: 14:04:50 <dansmith> Should we make gate-tempest-dsvm-multinode-live-migration voting now? It's relatively stable after skipping the volume-backed tests and we can control it in tree. 14:04:53 <johnthetubaguy> although that was earlier in the week, so we should have seen that already 14:05:02 <dansmith> I thought he had a patch up for it already 14:05:17 <alaski> I think these notes are for last weeks meeting 14:05:19 <dansmith> but if it's stable I'm definitely good with more live migration voting 14:05:20 <dansmith> ah 14:05:29 <johnthetubaguy> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bug/1616240 14:05:29 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1616240 in OpenStack Compute (nova) "Traceback in vif.py execv() arg 2 must contain only strings" [High,New] 14:05:30 <alaski> yep, that job is voting now 14:05:42 <johnthetubaguy> thats the os-vif one that came up 14:05:44 <dansmith> okay 14:05:52 <dansmith> is anyone around that can work on that? 14:06:02 <johnthetubaguy> about ovs I think, looks like priv sep is spitting out something odd 14:06:02 <dansmith> danpb is at linuxcon this week and is pretty much offline from what I can tell 14:06:14 <alaski> jaypipes is out this week as well 14:06:21 <johnthetubaguy> I have been taking a peak, but its more a voage of discovery for me 14:07:07 <dansmith> okay well that would be good 14:07:19 <dansmith> otherwise we're kinda hamstrung until next week I think 14:07:27 <johnthetubaguy> so I will have a dig and see 14:07:30 <dansmith> thanks 14:07:33 <dansmith> any other critical bugs? 14:07:38 <johnthetubaguy> it kinda helps my neutron thinkings anyways 14:08:00 <johnthetubaguy> I admit I haven't gone looking recently 14:08:04 <johnthetubaguy> that just popped up in IRC 14:08:18 <dansmith> well, if they're not on fire in the gate, they're probably not too critical so that's good I guess 14:08:23 <dansmith> okay, on to: 14:08:25 <dansmith> #topic reminders 14:08:42 <dansmith> this is old but probably still legit as a reminder: 14:08:48 <dansmith> #info Stop proposing centralize / cleanup config option changes until at least after feature freeze on 9/2. 14:08:52 <bauzas> anyway, I guess we can still release a library version if that's fixing a regression ? 14:09:16 <dansmith> yeah I dunno, I guess we always can, but oslo likes to go into deep freeze I think 14:09:30 <dansmith> also generic reminder: #link Newton review focus list: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/newton-nova-priorities-tracking 14:09:48 <dansmith> and finally: 14:09:50 <dansmith> #help https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Nova/BugTriage#Weekly_bug_skimming_duty Volunteers for 1 week of bug skimming duty? 14:10:14 <dansmith> anything else here in reminders? 14:10:24 <dansmith> freeze is coming up next week 14:10:43 <dansmith> okay, moving on.. 14:10:48 <dansmith> #topic stable branch status 14:11:09 <dansmith> I think matt was poking for some important reviews last week which merged, so I assume the pipeline is somewhat cleared there 14:11:21 <dansmith> anyone have anything burning on a stable branch? 14:11:38 <dansmith> lyarwood is also at linuxcon, so not around atm 14:12:20 <dansmith> alright you peeps are doing great at keeping this short :P 14:12:25 <dansmith> #topic subteam highlights 14:12:30 <dansmith> alaski: go 14:12:34 <alaski> no cellsv2 meeting this week 14:12:52 <alaski> need reviews, they're on the priority etherpad 14:12:54 <alaski> fin 14:13:04 <dansmith> I like that "no meeting" is a highlight 14:13:15 <alaski> :) 14:13:19 <dansmith> edleafe: scheduler things? 14:13:21 <johnthetubaguy> heh 14:13:24 <edleafe> Very short meeting. Just pointed out some reviews that needed attention 14:13:31 <edleafe> That's it 14:13:35 <dansmith> cool 14:13:43 <bauzas> edleafe: I guess the placement series N? 14:14:13 <edleafe> bauzas: Jay had some RT stuff 14:14:30 <edleafe> but we didn't go over everything that we're working on 14:14:34 <johnthetubaguy> thats all updated on the etherpad now right? 14:14:35 <alaski> there's https://review.openstack.org/#/c/358361 14:14:39 <edleafe> johnthetubaguy: yes 14:14:47 <bauzas> edleafe: ack, will look at eavesdrop 14:14:52 <dansmith> PaulMurray isn't around.. anyone have anything from live migrate folks? 14:15:27 <johnthetubaguy> tdurakov might? 14:15:38 <bauzas> (I at least remember clicking the +W button for renaming test_tracker and getting rid of the old and scary test_resource_tracker \o/ ) 14:15:49 <dansmith> cool 14:16:03 <dansmith> okay, well, skipping live migration I guess 14:16:04 <edleafe> johnthetubaguy: looks like some of the links on the etherpad have merged, so I'll update 14:16:15 <dansmith> sdague: alex_xu: anything important for API? 14:16:19 <alex_xu> short meeting also. we talk about the left patches which we want to merge before freeze. for now, just 2 patches left 14:16:28 <alex_xu> #link https://review.openstack.org/356963 14:16:30 <dansmith> alex_xu: want to link those here? 14:16:37 <alex_xu> #link https://review.openstack.org/322944 14:16:45 <alex_xu> dansmith: yea, ^ that is it 14:16:47 <dansmith> cool, thanks 14:16:48 <dansmith> alex_xu: anything else? 14:16:59 <alex_xu> dansmith: that is all 14:17:03 <dansmith> alex_xu: cool thanks 14:17:09 <alex_xu> dansmith: np 14:17:15 <dansmith> moshele isn't around.. anyone have anything for PCI 14:17:19 <dansmith> ? 14:17:21 <lbeliveau> yeap 14:17:39 <lbeliveau> we have only one outstanding patch left for review (waiting for jaypipes) 14:17:51 <lbeliveau> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/349060 14:17:59 <dansmith> cool, and I was okay with it but want jaypipes to look first 14:18:04 <dansmith> so probably in good shape there 14:18:14 <lbeliveau> also, moshele told me they have plans to integrate PCI passthrough in the Mellanox CI 14:18:24 <dansmith> okay 14:18:26 <lbeliveau> that's it 14:18:29 <dansmith> cool 14:18:35 <dansmith> any subteams I'm missing? 14:19:03 <dansmith> okie doke 14:19:06 <dansmith> #topic stuck reviews 14:19:16 <cdent> not so much stuck as stalled and needing diverse input: 14:19:18 <cdent> #link: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/355263/ 14:19:32 <cdent> that's dealing with aggregates in placement or api database or both 14:19:47 <dansmith> cdent: a clear abuse of the stuck reviews section! 14:20:04 <cdent> dansmith: i am filled with shame, but something must be done 14:20:08 <dansmith> hah 14:20:22 <dansmith> anything else here? 14:20:27 <dansmith> stuck or stuck-abuse? 14:20:51 <dansmith> alrighty then 14:20:53 <johnthetubaguy> we should talk about that one in channel after the meeting I guess 14:20:59 <dansmith> sure 14:20:59 <bauzas> aye 14:21:06 <bauzas> because that sounds a big deal 14:21:22 <dansmith> okay, so moving on to: 14:21:26 <dansmith> #topic open discussion 14:21:36 <johnthetubaguy> I have a tiny-ish thing 14:21:37 <dansmith> I assume these topics are old so I will not list them here 14:21:39 <dansmith> johnthetubaguy: shoot 14:21:46 <johnthetubaguy> was at the neutron midycle last week 14:21:52 <alaski> dansmith: yep, we discussed them last week 14:22:18 <johnthetubaguy> was good talking about plans for ocata about tracking both port bindings across a live-migrate, having a way to atomically claim a port, etc 14:22:38 <johnthetubaguy> got some good progress on them understanding the issues we are facing 14:22:47 <dansmith> cool 14:22:51 <johnthetubaguy> will follow up with specs and ML summaries 14:22:56 <dansmith> sweet 14:22:59 <johnthetubaguy> but they seem very open to ideas, so thats all good 14:23:24 <dansmith> sdague is at the ops thingy this week, but seems not around so maybe he can summarize for us later as well 14:23:34 <abhishekk> Hi all, we need this fix to be backported to Mitaka. 14:23:42 <abhishekk> Melanie has proposed a fix for this and with reference to her patch I have added another patch. 14:23:49 <abhishekk> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/355091/ (submitted by melanie witt) 14:23:51 <sdague> yeh... it's just kicking off now, I'll be intermitently on/off rest of the week 14:23:57 <abhishekk> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/200870/ (image_ref approach) 14:23:58 <dansmith> sdague: okay 14:24:07 <abhishekk> Requesting community members to give their views on this. This issue is pending for almost 2 years. 14:24:19 <dansmith> abhishekk: it's been pending for longer than that 14:24:21 <alaski> abhishekk: that needs to merge in N before it can be backported, and it's somewhat contentious 14:24:29 <dansmith> I'm -1 on it but I'm in the minority I think 14:24:35 <dansmith> so I've been abstaining 14:24:56 <abhishekk> alaski: yes, and I will be grateful to get opinions on this 14:25:16 <bauzas> not sure I got the relationship with stable 14:26:05 <johnthetubaguy> dansmith: the new approach is less evil 14:26:05 <dansmith> okay anyway, 14:26:11 <dansmith> johnthetubaguy: it's less evil, agreed 14:26:18 <alaski> abhishekk: I'm planning to send out a ML post on that issue, and other related ones. I'd like more feedback before we proceed. 14:26:29 <abhishekk> melanie has proposed new solution for this, please give your reviews on this 14:26:55 <dansmith> anything else for open discussion? 14:27:04 <abhishekk> alaski: thank you, hopefully you will get positive feedback 14:27:42 <dansmith> anyone? 14:27:45 <dansmith> anyone? 14:27:49 <dansmith> bueller? 14:28:09 <dansmith> okay EOM 14:28:18 <dansmith> #endmeeting