16:00:05 <gibi> #startmeeting nova
16:00:06 <openstack> Meeting started Thu May 28 16:00:05 2020 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gibi. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:00:07 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:00:09 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'nova'
16:00:18 <gibi> o/
16:00:19 <lyarwood> \o
16:00:31 <artom> ~o~
16:00:52 <dansmith> o/
16:01:37 <melwitt> o/
16:01:39 <gibi> #topic Bugs (stuck/critical)
16:01:46 <gibi> no critical bugs
16:01:51 <gibi> #link 20 new untriaged bugs (0 since the last meeting): https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bugs?search=Search&field.status=New
16:02:06 <gibi> any bugs we need to talk about?
16:03:21 <gibi> #topic Release Planning
16:03:21 <gmann> o/
16:03:26 <gibi> we have 3 weeks until Victoria M-1 we should focus on looking at specs
16:04:05 <gibi> anything about the Victoria release to talk about?
16:04:26 * bauzas waves late
16:04:41 <gibi> #topic Stable Branches
16:04:49 <gibi> lyarwood any news?
16:04:55 <lyarwood> gibi: no news or releases this week
16:05:05 <gibi> lyarwood: thanks
16:05:09 <gibi> #topic Sub/related team Highlights
16:05:14 <gibi> API (gmann)
16:05:37 <gmann> pushed PoC for healthchecks
16:05:39 <gmann> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/731396/1
16:05:51 <gmann> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2020-May/015088.html
16:05:55 <gmann> ML thread ^^
16:06:15 <gmann> this is etherpad where you can see the sample response data - #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-healthchecks
16:06:44 <gmann> auth part is still TODO
16:07:04 <gmann> any early feedback before PTG discussion will be great.
16:07:35 <gmann> that's all from my side today.
16:07:49 <melwitt> coolness. IIRC we were thinking no auth right though. (dansmith had some ideas how to do that by caching info)
16:09:01 <gmann> +1, caching on service up also will be good. in current PoC i am checking via last_seen_up
16:09:38 <gmann> so caching that for CONF.service_down_time can save the time
16:10:00 <melwitt> ack
16:10:19 <gibi> do we have open issues regarding healthcheck that needs focus during the PTG or it is straigthforward?
16:10:49 <gmann> there are few things i would to discuss (in PTG ) like when to say healthy if all cell up or at least one.
16:11:20 <gmann> gibi: there are few which i think can be discussed in PTG.
16:12:01 <gibi> OK
16:12:02 <bauzas> about healthchecks, is it really something operators want ?
16:12:12 <bauzas> maybe we could ask them *before* the PTG ?
16:12:24 <bauzas> I'm pretty sure they already check the API :)
16:13:05 <gmann> i know in openstack-helm, they use RPC check for checking the nova services are up or not
16:13:09 <melwitt> I think it's something operators would want. for there to be an actual health check that is telling more than just that the wsgi is running
16:13:21 <gmann> calling on service  RPC Bus
16:13:33 <bauzas> melwitt: I do understand that
16:13:50 <dansmith> this is what we should be using the PTG time for right?
16:13:53 <bauzas> melwitt: but I can do a healthcheck by just verifying the microversions API :)
16:14:42 <gmann> dansmith: right. get more feedback if that is too expensive/time taking etc
16:15:02 <gibi> I just wanted to see there is a list of open issue to focus on during the PTG
16:15:25 <gmann> so let's wait for ML if any feedback and i would like to get team opinion on PoC patch and then PTG discussion
16:15:31 <gibi> OK
16:15:33 <gibi> moving on
16:15:38 <gibi> Libvirt (bauzas)
16:15:47 <bauzas> well, nothing to say :)
16:15:53 <bauzas> https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-libvirt-subteam
16:16:07 <bauzas> libvirt subteam folks, you can ask for any change review ^
16:16:14 <bauzas> thanks for aarents
16:16:26 <bauzas> that's it
16:16:48 <gibi> thanks
16:16:54 <gibi> #topic Stuck Reviews
16:17:00 <gibi> nothing on the agenda
16:17:03 <gibi> any stuck reviewS?
16:18:07 <gibi> #topic Virtual PTG
16:18:18 <gibi> our schedule is up in #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-victoria-ptg
16:18:42 <gibi> We will try use Jitsi videoconf (meetpad.opendev.org) tool (Zoom is a fallback)
16:19:16 <gibi> I did some time assignement for topics in the etherpad and during that I realized that we might have more topic than time
16:19:26 <gibi> but I have a question
16:19:27 <gibi> Do we want to extend the Thursday's slot (13:00 - 15:00 UTC) to include our weekly meeting by adding 15:00 - 17:00 slot to it?
16:20:08 <bauzas> we could do it
16:20:10 <gibi> that would add extra time for discussion and in return I would cancel the weekly IRC meeting
16:20:15 <bauzas> and in case we don't need it, meh
16:20:31 <bauzas> just ask for the timeslot
16:20:40 <bauzas> and we'll see whether we need it
16:22:05 <gibi> OK then I will extend our time accordingly
16:22:39 <gibi> anything else about the next week PTG?
16:22:57 <gibi> Are you excited?  ;)
16:23:47 <bauzas> suuuuuuuuuuuuu... actually no :p
16:23:58 <dansmith> hah
16:24:02 <bauzas> I can't eat cheese
16:24:10 <gibi> :)
16:24:26 <gibi> #topic Open discussion
16:24:44 <gibi> nothing on the agenda. Anything here to discuss?
16:25:57 <gibi> thank thank you for your time today
16:26:17 <gibi> #endmeeting