17:00:18 <alaski> #startmeeting nova_cells
17:00:19 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Aug 31 17:00:18 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is alaski. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:20 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:22 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'nova_cells'
17:00:31 <dansmith> ohai
17:00:34 <melwitt> o/
17:00:41 <mriedem> o/
17:00:43 <alaski> gonna be a quick one today
17:00:49 <alaski> #topic Open discussion
17:00:52 <alaski> no real agenda
17:01:06 <dansmith> melwitt: your patch is ready and dependent on the fix?
17:01:30 <melwitt> dansmith: I just now pushed a new version pointing at the devstack change
17:01:55 <melwitt> changed from depending on the grenade hack patch to the devstack patch, that is
17:02:07 <dansmith> melwitt: right, that. so unless I find anything else we can +2 that yes?
17:02:07 <alaski> which fix?
17:02:47 <melwitt> alaski: we needed to do something to get the rabbit userid variable usable in grenade so the mq switch could login to rabbit
17:02:53 <alaski> I guess I can look at the depends-on
17:03:05 <alaski> melwitt: oh yeah, that one
17:03:22 <melwitt> without that, the switch fails auth missing the userid
17:03:25 <alaski> so your patch is ready other than that?
17:03:28 <melwitt> yes
17:03:31 <alaski> great
17:03:40 <dansmith> alaski: I will hit that when we're done here
17:03:53 <alaski> we have a couple of open devstack/grenade patches up that I may need to ping people on
17:04:11 <alaski> the only other things I'd like to see get in are my two patches
17:04:13 <alaski> but
17:04:24 <alaski> I'm having an issue with service_version that I need to resolve
17:04:31 <melwitt> alaski: I was just looking at https://review.openstack.org/#/c/356138/ and it looks like there might be legit tempest failures on the list servers negative tests?
17:04:31 <mriedem> to be clear, that's https://review.openstack.org/#/c/356138/
17:04:34 <mriedem> ?
17:04:47 <alaski> yes
17:05:02 <alaski> right now get_minimum_version or whatever returns 0
17:05:09 <alaski> even though every service says it's version 15
17:05:21 <dansmith> alaski: is that happening before any service record has been written?
17:05:24 <dansmith> that's a known quirk
17:05:34 <alaski> no, this is quite late
17:05:40 <dansmith> alaski: basically, if you're the first service you can't figure out what the real minimum is
17:05:41 <dansmith> okay
17:05:42 <alaski> like halfway through a tempest run
17:05:48 <dansmith> okay
17:05:54 <melwitt> okay, sorry I didn't realize the bug you're working through was on the bottom patch, I assumed it was on the WIP one
17:05:55 <dansmith> alaski: using the wrong binary name?
17:06:14 <alaski> dansmith: maybe. I just added some more logging to see what's going on
17:06:22 <alaski> but I'll check the code for that
17:06:41 <alaski> melwitt: well, the bug is on a merged patch. but isn't exposed until the bottom one
17:06:53 <melwitt> gotcha
17:06:56 <alaski> but it's very rare so I didn't see it until two days ago
17:07:36 <alaski> If I can fix that, and add testing for the current WIP one, those are what I'd like to get in
17:07:44 <alaski> but if not, we're still in a good spot I think
17:07:56 <mriedem> i'm asking sean about FF for devstack/grenade,
17:08:02 <mriedem> not sure if we have some more time there or not
17:08:02 <alaski> that's all I've got, just wanted to touch base real quick
17:08:04 <mriedem> before they branch it
17:08:08 <alaski> mriedem: okay
17:08:11 <mriedem> because i see https://review.openstack.org/#/c/362154/
17:08:15 <dansmith> alaski: they branch super late
17:08:16 <mriedem> and https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack-dev/grenade+branch:master+topic:setup_cell0_before_migrations
17:08:20 <dansmith> alaski: so I kinda expect not
17:08:24 <dansmith> er, mriedem ^
17:08:32 <dansmith> they branch well after the final release normally I think
17:08:35 <mriedem> are any of the nova changes dependent on devstack/grenade cahnges?
17:08:40 <alaski> also https://review.openstack.org/#/c/362154/
17:08:57 <alaski> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/356138/ is
17:09:01 <alaski> dependant
17:09:47 <mriedem> hmm, ok
17:09:49 <melwitt> my patch depends on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/363295/ in devstack
17:10:05 <alaski> there's also https://review.openstack.org/#/c/355602/ which should depend on one of the above patches
17:10:48 <alaski> so that's where things are at
17:10:50 <mriedem> ok, i can rebase those 2 devstack changes to line them up
17:10:58 <alaski> thanks
17:11:09 <alaski> anything else to mention?
17:11:25 <mriedem> what about https://review.openstack.org/#/c/362310/1 ?
17:11:30 <mriedem> that's the bottom of the grenade series
17:11:53 <alaski> there should be something depending on that somewhere, but that's needed too
17:12:05 <mriedem> it's the bottom of hte series and the nova change is dependent on that series
17:12:19 <alaski> ahh
17:12:34 <mriedem> my point being,
17:12:38 <mriedem> if we really want https://review.openstack.org/#/c/356138/ for FF
17:12:44 <mriedem> then we need those 2 grenade changes to land
17:12:53 <alaski> yes
17:13:23 <mriedem> ok i'm pinging sdague about that
17:13:28 <alaski> I want https://review.openstack.org/#/c/356138/ to land. but I don't think it has an upgrade impact, in that if it doesn't make it I think we're okay in O
17:13:47 <alaski> we just won't hit the goal I had hoped to hit
17:13:47 <mriedem> and even for ^,
17:13:55 <mriedem> we don't have anything going to cell0 yet right?
17:14:08 <alaski> mriedem: right, the WIP is the first patch to really use it
17:14:15 <mriedem> because https://review.openstack.org/#/c/267827/
17:14:46 <alaski> that's actually not necessary any more
17:14:51 <alaski> my WIP supercedes it
17:14:52 <mriedem> i'm not sure how https://review.openstack.org/#/c/267827/ even passes jenkins w/o depending on these other changes
17:14:55 <mriedem> oh
17:14:58 <mriedem> can we drop https://review.openstack.org/#/c/267827/ then?
17:15:04 <alaski> yes
17:15:52 <alaski> abandoned
17:16:15 <alaski> anything more?
17:16:46 <alaski> great. thanks all
17:16:49 <alaski> #endmeeting