20:00:22 <xgerman> #startmeeting Octavia
20:00:23 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Nov 11 20:00:22 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is xgerman. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
20:00:25 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
20:00:27 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'octavia'
20:00:33 <ajmiller> o/
20:00:35 <bana_k> hi
20:00:38 <blallau> hi
20:01:04 <xgerman> hi
20:01:17 <TrevorV> o/
20:01:20 <xgerman> so there is some crisis in Neutron land…
20:01:42 <xgerman> #topic Announcements
20:01:45 <johnsom> o/
20:02:10 <markvan_> o/
20:02:11 <xgerman> Good read: Nova cross service issues - more info on "protected instances”  #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/mitaka-nova-service-users
20:02:38 <xgerman> and even better read: Mitaka Release Schedule - #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Mitaka_Release_Schedule
20:02:55 <xgerman> key takeaway M1 is on 12/1 which is in less than one month!!
20:03:07 <xgerman> the whole M schedule is super tight IHMO
20:03:57 <dougwig> o/
20:04:38 <xgerman> lastly we got a stable/liberty branch for Octavia — so now we can do back ports ;-)
20:04:59 <xgerman> #topic Midcycle
20:05:15 <dougwig> hiya
20:05:24 <dougwig> we're not waiting on designate.
20:05:27 <dougwig> please see here: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/lbaas-mitaka-midcycle
20:05:56 <xgerman> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/lbaas-mitaka-midcycle
20:06:08 <xgerman> Thanks for setting that up and blogan no San Antonio?
20:06:09 <dougwig> i'd like to here what dates or locations will *not* work.  personally, i'm not so interested in seeing everyone +1 where they already live.   seattle likely makes the most sense, but we don't need to see 20 +1's there for that one.
20:06:15 <johnsom> Cool
20:06:35 <dougwig> do we have any new venues that anyone suggests?  if so, put it in there.
20:06:38 <blogan> boise!
20:06:58 <xgerman> in January?
20:07:04 <blogan> i mean if tehre's enough non-rackers that watn san antonio i'm sure we could set it up
20:07:14 <blogan> and our conference room wouldn't be bisected
20:07:17 <blogan> :)
20:07:22 <dougwig> heh, i *know* that i'm outvoted.  but it's available.  :)
20:07:29 <xgerman> that customer appreciation center is awesome
20:07:38 <johnsom> Yeah, the whole conference room thing cannot happen again.  That was not cool
20:07:49 <blogan> i would seriously do boise, though travel is always a maybe maybe not with us
20:08:13 <johnsom> Mmm, prop plane for me to Boise, but could make it happen.
20:08:14 <blogan> kevinbenton would totally do san antonio
20:08:25 <blogan> even though he doesn't do much with lbaas, i'm sure he'd sell it to his managers
20:08:37 <xgerman> lol
20:09:02 <dougwig> we had a rotation going for awhile. now we're seriously in danger of the rotation being: while (1) { seattle(); }
20:09:10 <dougwig> though there are worse things.
20:09:32 <xgerman> yep...
20:09:40 <xgerman> we can colocate with FWaaS in Seattle
20:10:06 <blogan> johnsom: btw the compute_noop_driver.build method does not take port_ids
20:10:24 <dougwig> alright, unless anyone here wants to discuss this more, please edit the etherpad, and we'll circle back later this week.
20:10:33 <xgerman> +1
20:10:40 <johnsom> blogan yeah, not back on 0.5.2 /stable
20:10:53 <blogan> lol i just saw your message in the main channel
20:11:04 <xgerman> #topic Brief progress reports
20:11:53 <johnsom> Can I get a review on:
20:12:01 <johnsom> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/243851/
20:12:12 <johnsom> Should be quick, fixes spares pool amps.
20:12:39 <johnsom> I will be testing VRRP soon and would like to have that merged and not fight on dependencies
20:13:01 <johnsom> Also, VRRP is fully functional now.  I will finish a refactor today and remove the WIP.
20:13:13 <blallau> Great
20:13:20 <xgerman> cool —> that should get into M1
20:13:23 <johnsom> There will be a follow up patch (working on smaller patches) that fixes failover flow for VRRP.
20:13:57 <johnsom> I would appreciate reviews soon after the WIP is removed so I can do bug fixes and get things wrapped up for M1.
20:14:22 <blallau> I'll do it
20:14:46 <johnsom> Thanks!
20:14:51 <xgerman> +1
20:15:32 <blallau> It's like a good book ;)
20:16:32 <xgerman> any other progress?
20:17:51 <xgerman> we added some anchor support: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/242277/
20:17:54 <bana_k> My co-workers are working on the heat
20:18:00 <xgerman> cool!!
20:18:06 <bana_k> so we made a good progress on it,
20:18:07 <blogan> bana_k: are they working in the heat as well?
20:18:20 <bana_k> reviews are under way
20:18:36 <markvan> I'm working on the heat stuff
20:18:54 <xgerman> welcome markvan — that is so cool!
20:19:10 <bana_k> hey Mark
20:19:40 <bana_k> can you please provide brief progress on that.
20:20:00 <markvan> jonesbr is has the main resource patches up, still under review
20:20:22 <bana_k> it ll be really great if octavia community also takes look at those patches.
20:20:31 <xgerman> links?
20:20:35 <markvan> I'm trying to work on the infra and testing side.  Stuck on the gate-neutron-lbaasv2-dsvm-scenario job failure...;) that's why I'm here today hint hint
20:20:38 <blallau> +1
20:20:49 <markvan> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/owner:%22Bryan+Jones%22+status:open,n,z
20:21:36 <xgerman> #link  https://review.openstack.org/#/q/owner:%22Bryan+Jones%22+status:open,n,z
20:22:11 <bana_k> xgerman thanks for the link.
20:22:29 <xgerman> no worries - usually trevorV is the king of that ;-)
20:22:53 <blogan> markvan: for stable/liberty branch or master?
20:23:47 <markvan> master, trying to understand what it will take to get function screnario tests working in devstack gates (for heat)
20:24:49 <xgerman> oh, ok
20:24:52 <markvan> with the nested vm being slow and ugly....are there thoughts on alternatives for testing?
20:24:54 <TrevorV> Sorry, I'm wiki-ing right now... thanks for keepin up xgerman
20:25:24 <xgerman> markvan we have Noop drivers which are faster not sure if they would sufficient for your usecase
20:25:50 <markvan> xgerman: thx, yup I'm working with those now to see if that will do the trick for us
20:26:29 <markvan> I'm more curious about your long term plans for dealing with devstack as more folks move to lbaasv2
20:26:48 <xgerman> we are hooping they will get better hardware
20:27:55 <xgerman> more and more services (e.g. magnum) are going vm in vm so we  might see some hardware improvements
20:29:02 <markvan> yes, I agree that would help, but seems like a long ways off
20:29:13 <blallau> Magnum is more container, no?
20:29:27 <xgerman> yep, but they need vm-in-vm as well
20:29:49 <blogan> lets just use carina
20:29:58 <blallau> ;)
20:30:05 <xgerman> let’s figure that out with infra...
20:30:11 <xgerman> :-)
20:30:18 <blogan> it was a shameless plug without any substance
20:30:43 <blogan> but yeah this needs to be solved bc it hurts real testing
20:30:44 <xgerman> you get pay $2 every time we say Carina?
20:30:47 <markvan> yup, need to be vocal out infra requirements to make this supported
20:30:59 <blogan> just $.01
20:31:04 <xgerman> lol
20:31:09 <xgerman> markvan +!
20:31:11 <xgerman> +1
20:31:39 <xgerman> ok, I think we are drifting into
20:31:41 <xgerman> #topic Open Discussion
20:32:23 <neelashah> has anyone brought up the need for Carina in Infra yet? just curious
20:32:42 <blogan> neelashah: i'd be surprised if Carina would be able to support Infra needs right now bc its in beta
20:33:16 <blogan> maybe ill ask someone here if its even possible
20:34:20 <neelashah> blogan thanks
20:34:28 <xgerman> +!
20:34:30 <xgerman> +1
20:34:58 <xgerman> ok,  we have some issue with werkzeug and so 0.11++ is bad for
20:35:00 <xgerman> now
20:35:51 <xgerman> https://github.com/mitsuhiko/werkzeug/issues/798 — they promise the next maintenance release will have a fix
20:36:37 <xgerman> I am tracking all of that in #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/octavia/+bug/1514644
20:36:37 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1514644 in octavia "Octavia amphora-agent doesn't work with werkzeug 0.11" [Critical,In progress] - Assigned to German Eichberger (german-eichberger)
20:36:41 <xgerman> my PSA
20:37:18 <xgerman> anything else?
20:37:32 <xgerman> without sbalukoff we don’t have that many yaks to shave
20:37:44 <xgerman> blogan/dougwig?
20:38:26 <xgerman> #endmeeting