20:00:02 <johnsom> #startmeeting Octavia
20:00:03 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Aug 15 20:00:02 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is johnsom. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
20:00:04 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
20:00:06 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'octavia'
20:00:11 <nmagnezi> o/
20:00:14 <johnsom> Hi folks
20:00:32 <cgoncalves> hellowoeeee!
20:01:07 <johnsom> #topic Announcements
20:01:22 <johnsom> We are still running the Rocky priority bug list:
20:01:29 <johnsom> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/octavia-priority-reviews
20:01:55 <johnsom> Thank you to the folks that have been doing reviews there
20:02:08 <johnsom> We will talk about RC2 later in the agenda
20:02:24 <nmagnezi> We're planning to have another rc to include those?
20:02:32 <nmagnezi> Ha, ok :)
20:02:38 <johnsom> grin, that is what we will talk about
20:02:50 <johnsom> The PTG etherpad is up:
20:02:51 <nmagnezi> kk
20:02:57 <johnsom> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/octavia-stein-ptg
20:03:37 <johnsom> Please add any topic ideas you may have. I think we are are less than a month out, so in the next week or two I will start putting a rough agenda together
20:03:54 <johnsom> Any other announcements today?
20:04:52 <johnsom> #topic Brief progress reports / bugs needing review
20:05:15 <johnsom> I was on vacation with some relatives over the last week, so didn't get a lot done.
20:05:37 <johnsom> I addressed three bug reports that we recently got. Those are up for review.
20:06:27 <johnsom> I did tag the octavia-tempest-plugin for Rocky.  We aren't cutting stable branches there, but we are tagging the releases now.
20:06:48 <johnsom> That is the big summary for me.  Anyone else?
20:07:35 <johnsom> ok, moving on
20:07:37 <nmagnezi> I mainly focus on my deep dive into active standby. Some of the issues I have reported
20:07:43 <nmagnezi> Others will be reported next week
20:08:07 <nmagnezi> With fixes
20:08:17 <johnsom> Ok, let me know if you have questions or something I should look at (it's been busy, so I might have forgot something)
20:08:29 <cgoncalves> not much from my side. UDP testing and more work on TripleO-Octavia integration for better CI coverage
20:08:30 <nmagnezi> np, thank you :)
20:08:46 <johnsom> #topic Do we want to cut an RC2?
20:08:56 <nmagnezi> johnsom, right after that I plan to shift my focus to the migration tool that you wrote
20:09:57 <johnsom> Ok, so we have six open patches on the priority review list.  Do any of these look like things we need to merge and do an RC2?
20:10:27 * nmagnezi looks again
20:10:36 <cgoncalves> if we have the opportunity for an RC2, why not?!
20:11:02 <johnsom> True, I just need to have cores willing to review/vote/merge
20:11:55 <johnsom> The first three I can vote on. If you all think they are a priority I will make some time this afternoon to review.
20:12:05 <cgoncalves> it is my believe that most (if not all) top priority reviews look good and are small
20:12:05 <nmagnezi> This looks important https://review.openstack.org/#/c/591876/
20:12:16 <nmagnezi> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/591876/
20:12:40 <johnsom> I would like to have these merged and backported to stable/rocky by about this time on friday.
20:12:57 <cgoncalves> and stable/queens?! :D
20:13:03 <johnsom> Yeah, that was reported by a user
20:13:21 <johnsom> I was planning to cut queens after #6 on that list is merged
20:13:37 <johnsom> But #5 is a good one too
20:13:45 <johnsom> for queens that is
20:13:55 <cgoncalves> +1
20:14:20 <cgoncalves> "release early, release often"
20:14:23 <johnsom> German is out on vacation, so it's really down to the rest of us
20:15:14 <johnsom> Ok, so I am hearing, yes, we want an RC2.  I will cut one about this time in two days. We need to get these in and backported by then or they don't make it.
20:15:37 <johnsom> Then we backport them and do a followup release later.
20:15:52 <cgoncalves> perfect, thanks!
20:16:23 <johnsom> 2 and 3 might be a bit on the risky side to merge, I need to look at those patches and judge the risk.
20:16:43 <johnsom> Actually, 1,2, and 3 might be in that group
20:17:08 <johnsom> I will take a look.
20:17:25 <johnsom> Ok, any other RC2 discussion?  Any other patches landing soon?
20:18:41 <johnsom> #topic Open Discussion
20:18:52 <johnsom> Ok, how about any other topics
20:18:55 <cgoncalves> perhaps https://review.openstack.org/#/c/591893/
20:19:42 <johnsom> Ah, yes, missed that one for the list
20:20:01 <johnsom> So the summary here, is you can make a member pointed at the nova metadata IP and get the metadata for the amphora.
20:20:40 <johnsom> So, this adds a way to blacklist IPs from being members, defaulting to the metadata IP.
20:21:13 <nmagnezi> johnsom, not sure we can actually back port https://review.openstack.org/#/c/591893/ since it adds a config option
20:21:47 <nmagnezi> it looks like a very important patch, so maybe we can make an exception for security reasons?
20:22:06 <johnsom> Yeah, I think adding an option is better than changing an option. It has a valid default, so won't break people if they don't configure it.
20:22:34 <johnsom> Ah, I need to add the sample octavia.conf entry and a release note too.  (finished that patch late last night)
20:22:57 <nmagnezi> I will review it tomorrow morning my time either way
20:23:09 <nmagnezi> When did you plan to cut RC2 (if at all :) )
20:23:23 <johnsom> I think it falls into the "compatible config change" category, so can be backported.
20:23:40 <johnsom> It is a bit of a feature, but it does address a minor security concern
20:24:01 <nmagnezi> johnsom, +1. I agree. Just wanted to point this out so we can double check ourselves here
20:24:01 <cgoncalves> +1 for backporting
20:24:09 <johnsom> Yep.
20:24:38 <johnsom> It's a bummer, we don't even use the metadata service for the amps, so wish we could just turn it off, but we can't.
20:25:20 <nmagnezi> Yeah, IIRC we use config-drive for SSH keys right?
20:25:29 <johnsom> Right
20:25:42 <johnsom> Plus the only ssh key in that metadata is the public key
20:26:23 <johnsom> I'm not sure what all else is exposed there, but it's good to block it anyway
20:27:01 <johnsom> Any other topics today?
20:27:33 <cgoncalves> just a minor update that the networking-ovn team has been working actively on an octavia driver
20:27:35 <cgoncalves> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/577395/
20:28:05 <cgoncalves> I would like to have a non-voting CI job in octavia sometime in the near future
20:28:34 <johnsom> Ok, I am open to that
20:28:38 <nmagnezi> Sounds right to me
20:29:38 <johnsom> I can't wait to drop the neutron-lbaas jobs. We have a lot of jobs at the moment
20:30:50 <cgoncalves> +1
20:30:52 <nmagnezi> +100
20:31:38 <johnsom> I also need to look at nlbaas-dashboard. it looks like the docs job is grumpy there and I'm not sure why
20:32:39 <johnsom> Oh, right, we need to get this merged:
20:32:41 <johnsom> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/591261/
20:33:10 <nmagnezi> noted.
20:33:23 <johnsom> left overs from when horizon had integration tests
20:34:02 <johnsom> Ok, well, if we don't have any other topics, I will go grab lunch.
20:34:39 <nmagnezi> This patch looks good at a first glance
20:34:52 <cgoncalves> all right, thanks folks!
20:35:00 <johnsom> Yeah, we did something similar in octavia-dashboard a while ago
20:35:08 <johnsom> Ok, thanks folks!
20:35:13 <johnsom> #endmeeting