16:00:29 <johnsom> #startmeeting Octavia
16:00:30 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Sep 11 16:00:29 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is johnsom. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:00:31 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:00:33 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'octavia'
16:01:02 <johnsom> Happy MS3 / Feature freeze week
16:01:13 <gthiemonge> Hi!
16:01:24 <ataraday_> hi
16:01:53 <cgoncalves> hi
16:02:12 <johnsom> #topic Announcements
16:02:27 <johnsom> It is feature freeze week for the Train release
16:02:35 <johnsom> #link https://releases.openstack.org/train/schedule.html
16:02:51 <johnsom> Oh, and our new PTL could not make the meeting today, so I am running it... lol
16:03:24 <johnsom> If you have a feature patch (not docs, bug fixes, or test patches) that is not on the priority review list, speak now....
16:03:32 <johnsom> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/octavia-priority-reviews
16:03:57 <openstackgerrit> Merged openstack/octavia master: Add long-running provider agent support  https://review.opendev.org/674140
16:04:27 <ataraday_> I want to ask about this bugfix
16:04:34 <ataraday_> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/681195/
16:04:51 <ataraday_> but I see it is for consideration for Train
16:04:58 <johnsom> Otherwise it will likely get held until the Ussuri
16:05:45 <johnsom> ataraday_ Yes, that is just a bug fix, so we still have two weeks for those.
16:05:51 <colin-> hello
16:07:00 <johnsom> I have added it to the priority review list
16:07:23 <ataraday_> johnsom, OK, thanks!
16:07:35 <johnsom> Any other Train feature candidates?
16:08:14 <johnsom> I think it will be just a bit later in the week before we make the feature freeze release.
16:08:32 <johnsom> Or maybe we will just wait for the RC1 week
16:08:51 <johnsom> Likely RC1 week actually
16:09:42 <johnsom> Also I want to mention that the Ubuntu 18.04 kernel -60 is bad. If you have any NAT rules setup the kernel will panic.
16:09:51 <johnsom> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/1842447
16:09:52 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1842447 in linux (Ubuntu) "Kernel Panic with linux-image-4.15.0-60-generic when specifying nameserver in docker-compose" [Undecided,Confirmed]
16:10:07 <johnsom> This was the root cause of our test jobs failing with RETRY_LIMIT.
16:10:35 <johnsom> I spent a bunch of time tracking this down as zuul doesn't capture the logs from those hosts.
16:10:54 <johnsom> Version -62 that came out Monday resolves the bug.
16:11:11 <johnsom> Anyway, if you are using floating IPs, skip the -60 kernel
16:11:26 <johnsom> Any other announcements this week?
16:12:43 <johnsom> #topic Brief progress reports / bugs needing review
16:13:10 <johnsom> I have been mostly consumed with doing reviews for features and fighting the gates to get our features merged.
16:13:26 <johnsom> I have made very slow progress on the failover patch. Hopefully that will change soon.
16:13:29 <colin-> shoutout to johnsom for patiently hand holding me through getting DIB to put haproxy 2.0 on a stable/stein amphora for me to test with. will be running with that this week and looking for any issues related to it
16:14:08 <johnsom> Also, I have made some progress on the PDF document goal. I think we will have one for Train, but it may have bugs. For example, there are whole sections that just don't render in the PDF.... joy
16:14:30 <johnsom> colin- Thanks. Glad you got it going.
16:14:52 <johnsom> I also posted a patch for DIB to stop it from silently ignoring element scripts....
16:15:18 <johnsom> #link https://review.opendev.org/680785
16:15:30 <johnsom> That would have made figuring out what we were doing wrong much easier....
16:15:49 <ataraday_> All refactor changes are ready, start working closely on jobboard controller
16:16:02 <johnsom> ataraday_ Awesome!
16:17:04 <johnsom> Any other updates this week?
16:17:41 <johnsom> #topic Cycle release highlights
16:17:48 <johnsom> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-September/009137.html
16:18:07 <johnsom> The foundation collects release "highlights" used for marketing, etc.
16:18:25 <johnsom> We need to have those in by tomorrow. I plan to put a patch up today.
16:18:55 <johnsom> Obviously log offloading is a new Train feature. As is cinder backed amphora.
16:19:06 <johnsom> I will probably add that the image size has been reduced.
16:19:25 <johnsom> Any other highlights I should include?
16:19:35 <johnsom> Assuming the VIP ACL patch lands, I will include that as well
16:19:43 <colin-> that's the only one i'd mention, VIP ACL
16:19:48 <colin-> lots of interest in that internally :)
16:19:59 <colin-> so i'm guessing the same is true elsewhere
16:20:14 <johnsom> Yeah, it is a popular one
16:20:34 <colin-> only other one*
16:21:35 <johnsom> Ok, well let me know if you think of something. I just wanted to ask to make sure I didn't miss something.
16:22:21 <johnsom> #topic Open Discussion
16:22:27 <johnsom> Other topics this week?
16:24:29 <johnsom> Ok, well if there is nothing else this week we can call the meeting.
16:24:32 <colin-> have we ever considered or proposed using anything other than keepalived for quorum between amp pairs?
16:24:46 <colin-> don't have anything in mind just curious
16:24:56 <johnsom> Yeah, CARP was proposed at one point, but it turned out to be horrible
16:25:05 <colin-> ok
16:25:37 <xgerman> There are some leader elect Lagos (Paxos, etc.) which have oython libraries — but then you need 3 or more amps...
16:25:39 <johnsom> Other than that, no I don't think we have had proposals for an alternate.
16:26:22 <johnsom> keepalived is actually pretty darn efficient at what it does. If you really get in and tune it you can have sub-second failover.
16:26:44 <colin-> o/ xgerman
16:26:55 <xgerman> always lurking :-)
16:26:57 <colin-> good info thanks guys
16:27:02 <johnsom> There was some talk of doing MAC address migration, but that doesn't play nice with the overlays and ML2 options like DVR.
16:27:35 <johnsom> Microsofts offering does MAC migration
16:28:14 <johnsom> At least it did last time I touched a MS server. lol, that has been a while now
16:29:02 <colin-> better knock on wood
16:29:25 <johnsom> colin- Oh, question for you, are you running OVS for your ML2?
16:29:50 <johnsom> I am hearing rumblings that there is a duplicate MAC address bug in OVS deployments.
16:30:04 <johnsom> I thought of you folks when I heard that.
16:31:35 <colin-> not usinv OVS, no, using a provider network model with linuxbridge and VLANs managed on the network equipment
16:31:55 <johnsom> Ok
16:34:02 <johnsom> If there is nothing else, I will close out the meeting
16:34:31 <johnsom> #endmeeting