15:00:02 <primeministerp> #startmeeting 15:00:03 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Aug 14 15:00:02 2012 UTC. The chair is primeministerp. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:04 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:22 <primeministerp> Hi all welcome to the weekly Hyper-V meeting 15:00:42 <primeministerp> I sent out the agenda for discussion 15:00:49 <primeministerp> to start we'll discuss the submission 15:00:56 <primeministerp> #topic Hyper-V code submission 15:01:13 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: submitted the code yesterday 15:01:29 <primeministerp> as of last night we have successfully passed throught he jenkins and smokestack gates with a +1 15:01:43 <primeministerp> some comments have be made regarding some additional formating 15:01:57 <primeministerp> and we are in the process of the cleaning that up and resubmitting 15:02:13 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: do you want to raise the point on one of the comments 15:02:50 <primeministerp> tr3buchet: alexpilotti or are you planning to reply to the comments you had questions on directly? 15:03:00 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: that was for you 15:03:07 <primeministerp> tr3buchet: sorry about that 15:04:06 * primeministerp waits 15:06:44 <primeministerp> ok 15:07:16 <primeministerp> let's move on until alexpilotti is back 15:08:27 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: so based on those comments the only thing to fix is the indents in the volume.py? 15:09:09 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: I've asked pedro to take a look at the indents 15:09:55 <pnavarro> primeministerp: I'm on it 15:10:09 <primeministerp> pnavarro: i guess alexpilotti may have already done it 15:10:23 <primeministerp> he's skyping me while correcting it 15:11:15 <alexpilotti> primeministerp: pnavarro sotrry guys I was answering those comments 15:11:22 <primeministerp> grat 15:11:24 <primeministerp> er great 15:11:35 <primeministerp> mtaylor: any chance for some +1 love? 15:11:43 <primeministerp> vishy: +1 for hyper-v? 15:12:04 <alexpilotti> mtaylor: they ask to get rid of get_connection in driver.py 15:12:32 <alexpilotti> mtaylor: we kept it for compatibility w the essex code base. Do we have to remove it? 15:12:57 <primeministerp> vishy: ^^ 15:13:23 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: if we can't get a response in this meeting, send an email to the list asking 15:13:56 <primeministerp> ok I'll move on 15:14:01 <primeministerp> #topic hyper-v ci 15:14:21 <primeministerp> so the hyper-v ci has some issues, suffered a hw failure yesterday 15:14:54 <primeministerp> We'll be setting up to start the base unit tests on hyper-v to trigger from zuul 15:15:02 <primeministerp> and start building from that 15:15:46 <primeministerp> also we'll shooting for everything to be in place hopefully in the next 2 weeks 15:15:59 <alexpilotti> I removed get_connection from our code base, I'll waut for more comments to commit, as it is not affecting at all the code base 15:16:07 <primeministerp> ok 15:16:16 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: so it was completely unneeded? 15:16:23 <primeministerp> even for essex compat? 15:16:33 <alexpilotti> primeministerp: for essex it is 15:16:37 <primeministerp> ok 15:17:03 <primeministerp> hopefully we can get some comments 15:17:27 <mtaylor> alexpilotti: hey 15:17:35 <primeministerp> mtaylor: hey now 15:17:47 <mtaylor> so, is essex compat needed? 15:18:10 <alexpilotti> mtaylor: well, we can keep a separate driver.py 15:18:18 <mtaylor> I mean, this isn't going to get merged back into stable/essex... 15:18:40 <alexpilotti> mtaylor: for sure, it's just for our internal tests 15:18:42 <mtaylor> ah, I suppose you could - but why not just steer people towards folsom for hyperv support? 15:18:50 <mtaylor> gotcha 15:19:01 <alexpilotti> mtaylor: but since it was a 2 lines innocuous method, I just left it there 15:19:12 <primeministerp> well i guess that's a discussion we could have 15:19:26 <primeministerp> should be able to get backported to essex 15:19:29 <primeministerp> or do we not want to care 15:19:33 <alexpilotti> mtaylor: anyway, I just removed it, will send it w the next review 15:19:41 <primeministerp> we can leave the essex integration sort of where it is 15:20:24 <mtaylor> cool cool 15:20:27 <primeministerp> for hyper-v specifically we were always targeting folsom as the reintegration point 15:20:33 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: do we want to vote 15:20:38 <mtaylor> yeah - so, backported to essex... 15:20:45 <primeministerp> mtaylor: what's your take? 15:20:47 <mtaylor> would be adding a feature to stable/essex 15:20:56 <mtaylor> and I can say it just flat wont' happen 15:21:03 <primeministerp> perfect 15:21:08 <mtaylor> :) 15:21:10 <primeministerp> that's an easy answer to accept 15:21:20 <primeministerp> so 15:21:24 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: remove it and let's move on 15:21:37 <primeministerp> mtaylor: how's about some +1 love then once we address the comments ;) 15:22:05 <primeministerp> ok 15:22:06 <mtaylor> primeministerp: I'll do my best 15:22:11 <primeministerp> mtaylor: all i can ask 15:22:19 <primeministerp> mtaylor: every bit is appreciated 15:22:32 <primeministerp> ok 15:22:36 <primeministerp> moving on then 15:22:50 <primeministerp> #topic puppet/hyper-v/openstack 15:23:16 <primeministerp> so I've got the beginings of a puppet manifest for hyper-v/openstack 15:23:27 <primeministerp> I've spoke with our friends at puppetlabs 15:23:45 <primeministerp> they've been extremely helpful in some overall direction 15:23:59 <primeministerp> as well as put me in touch with some others doing puppet on windows. 15:24:19 <primeministerp> I was hoping someone from CERN was available 15:24:38 <primeministerp> as maybe we could tap them for some more testing and assistance on the puppet manifest 15:24:57 <primeministerp> I'll make note to reach out to Jose and see if there's interest in assisting 15:25:18 <primeministerp> if that's anything else that needs to be addressed? 15:25:24 <primeministerp> pnavarro: alexpilotti? 15:25:54 <alexpilotti> primeministerp: just waiting for somebody to comment 15:26:09 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: not sure if we're going to get it 15:26:11 <alexpilotti> primeministerp: on the code 15:26:21 <primeministerp> let's ask 15:26:34 <primeministerp> anyone any comments on the Hyper-V code that we can address now? 15:27:11 <primeministerp> this is definately the forum for any concerns to be addressed 15:27:12 <alexpilotti> mtaylor: how does it work with the comments? if the gerrit sum is > 0 we are simply in? 15:28:45 <alexpilotti> I left a comment on #Openstack-dev if anybody wants to discuss it here 15:28:50 <primeministerp> ok 15:28:52 <primeministerp> perfect 15:29:03 <primeministerp> we'll wait a few more before i close the meeting 15:29:07 <primeministerp> also 15:29:24 <primeministerp> jaypipes: jay! 15:29:38 <primeministerp> jaypipes: mind answering a quick question about the gerrit cycle 15:29:57 <jaypipes> primeministerp: sure thing 15:29:59 <primeministerp> jaypipes: if we are >0 does that mean we will offically be in 15:30:10 <primeministerp> or does some other magic have to happen 15:30:21 <primeministerp> is there a minimum number we have to hit 15:30:39 <jaypipes> primeministerp: you need to get 2 +2s from core reviewers and complete the Jenkins gate successfully 15:30:47 <primeministerp> jaypipes: thank you 15:30:50 <jaypipes> np! 15:31:00 <primeministerp> so time to start sending gifts to core reviewers 15:31:02 <primeministerp> ;) 15:31:09 <pnavarro> hehehehe 15:31:09 <primeministerp> just kidding 15:31:26 <pnavarro> I can propose an spanish jambon... 15:31:36 <primeministerp> pnavarro: that won't make out of my kitchen 15:31:56 <primeministerp> if it's what i think it is 15:32:27 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: is that good enough? 15:32:33 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: of an answer? 15:33:12 <alexpilotti> primeministerp: I got the same answer on #Openstack-infra 15:33:21 <primeministerp> o perfect 15:33:23 <primeministerp> ok then 15:33:37 <primeministerp> if no one has anything else to add, i'll call the meeting 15:33:39 <alexpilotti> primeministerp, jaypipes: given that the deadline is tonite, do we need two core reviewers doing it today? 15:33:58 <alexpilotti> primeministerp, jaypipes is there a list of core reviewers? 15:34:08 <primeministerp> hmm 15:34:45 <primeministerp> http://wiki.openstack.org/Nova/ReviewDays 15:34:53 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: ^ 15:35:08 <jaypipes> alexpilotti: yes, ASAP. 15:36:26 <alexpilotti> primeministerp, jaypipes how can we get who are the reviewers today? 15:36:43 <alexpilotti> primeministerp: jaypipes that list arrives to Aug 1st 15:36:44 <jaypipes> alexpilotti: all of nova core is on today. :) 15:36:50 <primeministerp> jaypipes: awesome 15:36:56 <jaypipes> alexpilotti: it's crunch time. 15:37:02 <primeministerp> perfect 15:37:04 <primeministerp> thanks jay 15:37:04 <alexpilotti> jaypipes: so, who can we ping for that? 15:37:23 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: i believe what he means is if we submit it someone will have to review it 15:37:25 <alexpilotti> jaypipes: is Tiago Mello a core reviewer? 15:37:30 <primeministerp> jaypipes: please clearify if i'm wrong 15:37:54 <vishy> alexpilotti: the get_connection compatibility is just for people that need backwords compatibility 15:38:05 <vishy> * drivers that need 15:38:15 <primeministerp> vishy: thanks for joining 15:38:23 <vishy> since hyper-v wasn't aound in essex I don't know that it matters 15:38:25 <alexpilotti> vishy: that's why we left it there. We just voted to remove it anyway 15:38:33 <vishy> oh, cool 15:38:35 <jaypipes> alexpilotti: vishy, bcwaldon, blamar, markwash, Johannes, _0x44, jkoelker, jk0, maoy, mikal, soren, termie 15:38:37 <alexpilotti> vishy: tx :-) 15:39:10 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: so are were clear on what needs to be done then? 15:39:16 <alexpilotti> vishy: is there something we can do to hep for the review? 15:39:34 <primeministerp> vishy: other than addressing the comments asap 15:39:36 <jaypipes> alexpilotti: answer comments and questions quickly and keep on reviewers to do the reviews... that's about it. 15:39:47 <vishy> alexpilotti: doubtful, there are just a million really big reviews that dropped right at the end 15:40:42 <pnavarro> vishy: you know pizzas, sodas, massages... 15:40:43 <alexpilotti> vishy: sorry for the silly qestion: does it mean that we will reviewed in case in the forthcoming days, or that we could not make it for Folsom? 15:41:27 <vishy> alexpilotti: we will decide whether to give it an FFE if it doesn't make it today 15:41:40 <primeministerp> vishy: and FFE is exactly what? 15:41:54 <primeministerp> Feature Freeze Exemption? 15:42:30 <vishy> Exception 15:42:31 <vishy> yes 15:42:45 <vishy> or maybe it is Exemption :p 15:43:06 <primeministerp> vishy: hehe 15:43:07 <Hitesh> primeministerp: Hi Peter 15:43:16 <Hitesh> pnavarro: Hi Pedro 15:43:20 <primeministerp> howdy hitesh 15:43:48 <alexpilotti> Hitesh: hi! 15:43:55 <Hitesh> primeministerp: Sorry for being late 15:44:14 <Hitesh> alexpilotti: Hi Alessandro 15:44:29 <alexpilotti> jaypipes: until what time do we have to commit updates to the review? 15:44:29 <primeministerp> alexpilotti: ok then, i think we know what we need to do 15:44:45 <alexpilotti> jaypipes: midnight PDT? 15:45:51 <jaypipes> alexpilotti: I think it might be up to vishy 15:46:00 <Hitesh> primeministerp: once the discussion done, please let me know to do iteams :) 15:46:10 <primeministerp> Hitesh: test the new code 15:46:22 <alexpilotti> vishy: until what time do we have to commit updates to the review? Midnight Pacific time? 15:46:37 <Hitesh> primeministerp: Ok :) 15:47:05 <primeministerp> Hitesh: you can also assist w/ puppet manifests for hyperv if you want 15:47:10 <Hitesh> pnavarro: currently we are not developing any feautre right? 15:47:20 <Hitesh> primeministerp: ok :) 15:47:44 <alexpilotti> vishy: sorry, reformulating: until what time can we commit updates to the review? Midnight Pacific time? 15:47:45 <primeministerp> Hitesh: I suggest reading throught the meeting notes once we're done so you can catch up 15:47:55 <Hitesh> primeministerp: Sure 15:47:59 <Hitesh> primeministerp: will do 15:48:24 <primeministerp> Hitesh: then take questions to the usual channel 15:49:43 <primeministerp> ok 15:49:44 <primeministerp> if that's it 15:49:57 <primeministerp> i know there's still the open question to vish alexpilotti 15:50:12 <primeministerp> however let's followup outside of this channel 15:52:13 <primeministerp> ok closing the meeting folks thanks for the comments, please take additinal comments to #openstack-hyper-v 15:52:35 <primeministerp> #endmeeting