12:00:26 <xinranwang> #startmeeting openstack-cyborg
12:00:26 <opendevmeet> Meeting started Wed Aug 11 12:00:26 2021 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is xinranwang. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
12:00:26 <opendevmeet> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
12:00:26 <opendevmeet> The meeting name has been set to 'openstack_cyborg'
12:00:34 <xinranwang> #topic roll call
12:00:41 <xinranwang> #info xinranwang
12:00:43 <chenke> #info chenke
12:00:59 <brinzhang_> #info brinzhang_
12:01:02 <songwenping> #info songwenping
12:02:15 <xinranwang> #topic new PTL election season
12:02:37 <xinranwang> I hope you all see the mail talking about the new PTL election
12:03:13 <songwenping> have you alreay send the email?
12:03:35 <xinranwang> I'd like to step down and let others take this chance.
12:03:49 <chenke> I didn't saw it.
12:03:57 <xinranwang> songwenping:  I mean the mail from the community
12:04:10 <xinranwang> let me forward it to you
12:04:35 <chenke> xinran had make great contributions to our cyborg project
12:04:36 <brinzhang_> we can have the same decision, than to have a mailist
12:05:13 <brinzhang_> yes, a harwork girl, a beautiful girl ^^
12:05:24 <chenke> lol
12:05:26 <xinranwang> brinzhang_:  I didn't send any mail out, I mean the mail from helena
12:05:35 <xinranwang> chenke:  what's your email addr
12:05:58 <brinzhang_> xinranwang: yeah
12:05:59 <chenke> chen.ke14@zte.com.cn
12:06:55 <xinranwang> I have forward the mail to you guys.
12:07:03 <xinranwang> please check it.
12:07:26 <songwenping> thanks
12:07:40 <brinzhang_> ack, thanks
12:07:52 <songwenping> i may take some time to receive.
12:08:25 <xinranwang> no hurry, the elecion just starts
12:08:56 <chenke> sorry
12:09:09 <chenke> offline just
12:09:18 <chenke> now ok for me.
12:09:31 <chenke> please go on.
12:09:31 <xinranwang> how do you think about the candidate, any nimination or self-nomination?
12:09:32 <brinzhang_> dont worry, there is nothing above
12:09:39 <chenke> ok.
12:10:13 <chenke> I think brin and wenpeng are all good.
12:10:36 <chenke> wenping/wenpeng
12:10:38 <songwenping> brin is ok.
12:10:51 <xinranwang> yeah, everyone did a great job.
12:11:25 <brinzhang_> thanks for your approbate, I would like to try
12:11:43 <chenke> cool.
12:11:52 <songwenping> brin has more experience
12:12:16 <xinranwang> I also think brinzhang_ is good, he has a lot of experience of openstack community.
12:12:29 <chenke> actually brin had contributed to cyborg for  long time.
12:12:37 <xinranwang> and a lot of connection with other projects.
12:13:13 <chenke> hi xinran. will you continue for cyborg？
12:13:17 <brinzhang_> we are all ok in the community, and there is also need all to have work together
12:13:45 <xinranwang> chenke:  sure, I will continue contributing cyborg :)
12:13:51 <chenke> Cool.
12:14:00 <brinzhang_> I think yes, we need some drvier frm Intel ^^
12:14:29 <brinzhang_> xinranwang: right? and we want to get some suport from you too
12:14:58 <chenke> OK. Hope our guys can make cyborg more stronger.
12:15:13 <brinzhang_> sorry, slowy for me
12:15:28 <xinranwang> brinzhang_:  sure, we can have futhue cooperation. I am not leaving cyborg, don't worry. lol
12:15:36 <xinranwang> *futhur
12:15:37 <songwenping> cool
12:15:46 <chenke> @brin I saw your chinaday topic. Maybe We will meet in xinran' neijing
12:15:57 <chenke> Beijing
12:16:07 <chenke> lol
12:16:20 <songwenping> cool
12:16:21 <brinzhang_> need all your together, and we also need to cultivate fresh blood in cyborg
12:16:24 <xinranwang> chenke:  you have a topic too?
12:16:58 <chenke> zhurong has a topic. I will talk his topic
12:17:09 <xinranwang> ok, good that we have an agreement about the candidate.
12:17:19 <xinranwang> chenke:  cool, will zhurong come too?
12:17:23 <chenke> Yep.
12:17:29 <xinranwang> cool
12:17:46 <brinzhang_> chenke: yes, and xinranwang also is a speeker of that topic, but there is not covered her name, because of the author of the article
12:17:48 <chenke> @brin yes! We all plan to it.
12:17:58 <brinzhang_> and there is wenpingsong too ^^
12:18:22 <chenke> cool. then we can have a dinner at that time.
12:18:26 <xinranwang> hope we all can meet in beijing lol
12:18:42 <xinranwang> let's move on
12:18:47 <brinzhang_> the china day will continue two days, one online, and one day offline
12:18:53 <xinranwang> #topic new time slot
12:19:50 <xinranwang> I have send out a mail to the maillisting, the new time slot is 12:00-13:00 UTC, which is 20:00-21:00 Beijing Time
12:20:10 <chenke> It's Ok for me.
12:20:16 <xinranwang> brinzhang_:  will you come to beijing, or just stay online?
12:20:16 <brinzhang_> I have seen, I think that ok
12:20:41 <xinranwang> so we could have less conflict than the working time
12:20:43 <brinzhang_> xinranwang: Obey organizational arrangements
12:21:01 <xinranwang> got it
12:21:12 <brinzhang_> I would like going to beijing, offline may more intersting
12:21:19 <xinranwang> yeah
12:21:29 <xinranwang> hope you all can come to beijing
12:21:56 <songwenping> let's meet at Beijing soon.
12:21:56 <xinranwang> #topic pending patches
12:22:01 <brinzhang_> if possible, wenpingsong and I all go to beijing haha
12:22:12 <chenke> cool
12:23:40 <chenke> ping
12:23:45 <xinranwang> pong
12:24:12 <chenke> games. right?
12:24:29 <xinranwang> sorry I didn't get enough time to review all patches.
12:24:50 <brinzhang_> I saw there is not many patches in https://review.opendev.org/q/project:openstack%252Fcyborg+status:open
12:24:52 <xinranwang> do you have any patch wanna to highlight here?
12:25:12 <brinzhang_> we can review it recently
12:25:46 <songwenping> some specs need to review, about PMEM and xlinux FPGA driver
12:26:19 <songwenping> s/xlinux/xilinx
12:26:38 <xinranwang> songwenping:  ok, got it
12:26:41 <songwenping> and one question about mysql version
12:26:46 <chenke> Xilinx driver's author . I didn't konw. Do you all guys know him or her?
12:27:06 <songwenping> hi is from Inspur in beijing
12:27:42 <chenke> oh. your teammates.
12:27:47 <songwenping> we are not one subcompany
12:28:14 <songwenping> they also use cyborg
12:28:37 <brinzhang_> IMO, the highlight can say: Improve the accuracy of placement resource updates, and there is we will be contribute PMEM driver to Cyborg(but they are on the way)
12:29:39 <xinranwang> hope eric can join our meeting and introduce his team a bit
12:29:53 <xinranwang> songwenping:  how is going on with oslo db
12:30:01 <xinranwang> https://zuul.opendev.org/t/openstack/build/44e915449e09435fa850d5020bfcbe4c
12:30:16 <xinranwang> I saw the zuul failed here, with the version conflict
12:30:22 <brinzhang_> recent weeks, I will update the docs for the API and the microversion docs too, may leaves from yumeng
12:30:37 <xinranwang> can we use oslo.db>=8.4.0
12:30:45 <xinranwang> brinzhang_:  cool
12:30:58 <songwenping> tempest also failed for the patch:
12:31:05 <songwenping> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/cyborg-tempest-plugin/+/804053
12:31:12 <brinzhang_> this patch you update the oslo.db version >=10.0.0 https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/cyborg/+/802839
12:32:53 <xinranwang> songwenping:  I have test the tempest in local and it works well
12:33:08 <brinzhang_> the mainly question is how to maintain the stable branch's oslo.db version, right?
12:33:17 <brinzhang_> xinranwang, songwenping
12:33:35 <songwenping> it's wallaby and victoria failed
12:33:43 <xinranwang> I think so
12:33:58 <songwenping> ussuri and master is ok
12:34:05 <brinzhang_> xinranwang: the stable branch cannot update the local db version, so it will be ok always
12:34:06 <xinranwang> maintain the old version's oslo db
12:34:50 <brinzhang_> how about asking for gmann, he is an expert in this area
12:35:07 <brinzhang_> gmann: are you around?
12:35:13 <xinranwang> it's a good idea
12:35:37 <songwenping> all failure case is test_create_device_profile_conflict
12:35:41 <xinranwang> it seems he is not around
12:36:16 <xinranwang> yes, only when there is an db error, it failed
12:36:38 <brinzhang_> gmann: we update the oslo.db's version to 10.0.0, it keep the same with nova, but there is some failed case in stable branch, such as https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/cyborg-tempest-plugin/+/804053
12:36:45 <xinranwang> chenke:  maybe chenke can help look at it? he has the experience of tempest as well
12:36:53 <brinzhang_> gmann: do you some suggestion for this issue?
12:37:09 <chenke> hi xinran
12:37:24 <brinzhang_> xinranwang: we can left some comments for him, I think after he is online, he will reply us ^^
12:37:27 <songwenping> IMO, this has no relation with the oslo.db's version
12:38:06 <xinranwang> hi chenke, we got some tempest issue, could you please help on it
12:38:11 <chenke> agree brin. Thank xinran. I will check tomorrow.
12:38:28 <xinranwang> brinzhang_:  yeah, sure.
12:39:13 <songwenping> the reason is mysql's version is update, the conflict exception message is changed.
12:39:54 <songwenping> chenke: let's discuss offline.
12:40:03 <chenke> please add my review about that patch
12:40:19 <songwenping> hope you can give help
12:40:20 <brinzhang_> ok, songwenping, let's have a look tomorrow
12:40:33 <xinranwang> cool, thanks guys
12:40:44 <xinranwang> please involve me in the discussion as well
12:40:45 <xinranwang> :)
12:40:53 <songwenping> chenke: done
12:40:54 <xinranwang> let's move on
12:41:01 <brinzhang_> chenke has some experience, plase look into and give some suggestion
12:41:21 <songwenping> two patches: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/cyborg/+/797403 and https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/cyborg-tempest-plugin/+/804053
12:41:42 <brinzhang_> ack
12:42:09 <songwenping> thanks
12:42:43 <chenke> thanks
12:43:24 <songwenping> let's move on
12:44:01 <xinranwang> I think the first one is related to tempest error, no ?
12:44:16 <xinranwang> it is a workaround
12:46:03 <songwenping> yes
12:46:12 <xinranwang> anyway, we will continue discuss tmr with chenke please involve me:)
12:46:16 <brinzhang_> I think yes, it's blocked the new patches
12:46:23 <xinranwang> #topic  AoB
12:46:36 <xinranwang> anything else you wanna bring up here?
12:46:38 <songwenping> we cannot backport any patches
12:46:47 <songwenping> one suggestion
12:47:14 <brinzhang_> dont worry, we can have a solution for it ^^
12:47:24 <songwenping> how about two releases will be elected PTL once, so as not to control the progress of the project due to frequent changes to the PTL.
12:48:15 <chenke> I don't agree.
12:48:28 <brinzhang_> I think yes, if we frequently changes the PTL, there are many thing will be lost
12:49:15 <chenke> Ping
12:49:31 <xinranwang> pong, we saw your message
12:49:33 <brinzhang_> if one project changed the PTL at each release, there will a bad effect in community
12:49:58 <xinranwang> nomarlly, it is one election per release
12:50:17 <chenke> yes.
12:52:05 <xinranwang> I think we should always have the election to keep the community open
12:52:17 <songwenping> ok, let's go normarlly.
12:52:30 <brinzhang_> of course, we can have a vote at each release
12:52:52 <brinzhang_> we are all want the cyborg better and better, right~
12:53:24 <chenke> More open more better
12:53:47 <brinzhang_> any other topic?
12:54:05 <brinzhang_> I have to dinner
12:54:18 <brinzhang_> it's too later :(
12:54:20 <songwenping> nothing from myside
12:54:22 <chenke> oh ? so latter
12:54:49 <xinranwang> of course we need a election at each election.
12:55:06 <chenke> I want konw. wenping and brin are in the same team?
12:55:24 <brinzhang_> no, we are at same company
12:55:38 <xinranwang> and all of us should vote according to the contributions, experinece etc
12:55:56 <brinzhang_> good advice^
12:56:05 <chenke> Agree.
12:56:35 <chenke> ok. Will learn more when we meet in Beijing.
12:56:37 <xinranwang> so! please keep contributing cyborg!
12:56:41 <xinranwang> lol
12:56:46 <chenke> lol.
12:57:01 <brinzhang_> all, and we also need to cultivate new blood
12:57:02 <songwenping> hope to see u soon!
12:57:20 <xinranwang> good
12:57:31 <chenke> ok.
12:57:36 <xinranwang> do you have anything else you want bring up?
12:57:46 <chenke> no for me. thanks
12:57:51 <brinzhang_> nothing for me
12:58:06 <xinranwang> if nothing else, let's wrap up the meeting
12:58:11 <xinranwang> #endmeeting