02:06:53 <xinranwang> #startmeeting openstacksdk-cyborg
02:06:54 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Apr 29 02:06:53 2021 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is xinranwang. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
02:06:55 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
02:06:57 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'openstacksdk_cyborg'
02:07:36 <xinranwang> #topic roll all
02:07:42 <xinranwang> #info xinranwang
02:07:43 <brinzhang> #info brinzhang
02:08:10 <wenpingsong> #info wenpingsong
02:08:11 <chenke> #info chenke
02:08:13 <xinranwang> #topic ptg summary
02:08:40 <xinranwang> last week we have ptg meeting for 3 days, thanks for your attending.
02:09:21 <xinranwang> chenke:  here's the link, you can go through it, please feel free to ping me if any questions. https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/cyborg-xena-ptg
02:09:59 <chenke> ok. thanks.
02:10:09 <xinranwang> #topic using lauchpad in xena release
02:11:06 <wenpingsong> yesterday merged the patch in stackanlystic project: https://review.opendev.org/c/x/stackalytics/+/788397
02:11:07 <xinranwang> we have switched to launchpad in this release. I will create the tasks by today, please feel free to assign it to yourself.
02:11:46 <chenke> coo;
02:11:48 <chenke> cool
02:11:49 <brinzhang> xinranwang: xena release task has been created, you can recheck
02:12:11 <brinzhang> https://launchpad.net/openstack-cyborg
02:12:41 <brinzhang> may you need to check the dealine is ok ^^ https://launchpad.net/openstack-cyborg/xena
02:14:20 <xinranwang> ok, I didn't see any new bp or bugs created after ptg
02:15:32 <chenke> seems https://launchpad.net/~cyborg-team didn't has my name and wenping's name.
02:16:30 <wenpingsong> maybe we need to add by ourself.
02:17:23 <xinranwang> I am not sure if I can add you guys, yes, please try to add yourself first
02:19:04 <brinzhang> xinranwang: yes, after ptg there is no bugs created on launchpad
02:19:22 <xinranwang> anyway, we will track the tasks  by laucnpad. please link the bug/bp on lauchpad with your commit.
02:19:48 <wenpingsong> cool
02:20:42 <xinranwang> brinzhang:  yeah, i will create others according to our ptg discussion, you can pick them up then
02:21:01 <xinranwang> you can also create bug/bp by yourselves.
02:21:02 <brinzhang> xinranwang: yeah
02:21:37 <xinranwang> #topic vgpu support
02:21:38 <brinzhang> chenke: you and wenpingsong's name are not contains in the launchpad team, but it's ok to tracing the bugs
02:22:10 <xinranwang> I think nova team has started review specs in these days.
02:22:43 <xinranwang> some reproposed spec are already merged.
02:23:05 <wenpingsong> yeah
02:23:07 <brinzhang> yes, they start
02:23:30 <xinranwang> let's try to ping them to review vgpu specs
02:23:56 <wenpingsong> ok i'll ping them again.
02:25:32 <xinranwang> heads up: sean mooney  became nova specs core in x release, and he's familiar with pci management in nova. we can also asks if he's willing to help review.
02:25:54 <xinranwang> #topic smartnic support
02:26:39 <xinranwang> I got some comments from alex and sean, I will update the spec before the holiday.
02:27:26 <xinranwang> #topic AoB
02:27:52 <xinranwang> anything else you wanna bring up here?
02:28:09 <chenke> xinranwang
02:28:29 <xinranwang> chenke: yes
02:28:42 <chenke> about the cold migration. I am not family with nova's code.
02:28:51 <chenke> familiar
02:29:27 <chenke> maybe needs other's contributer to do this.
02:30:02 <xinranwang> chenke:  no hurry, cold migration is low priority.
02:30:48 <xinranwang> brinzhang and wenpingsong  are doing more operation with high priority, let's see.
02:31:25 <chenke> I saw your guys ptg conclusion. seems we have a lot of to do list.  actually I agree with your guys decision.
02:31:45 <brinzhang> xinranwang: nothing from mine
02:31:48 <wenpingsong> yeah, cold migration is complex, let's put it in next release.
02:32:06 <xinranwang> ok, great.
02:32:23 <xinranwang> no meeting next week
02:32:35 <chenke> I  want to know ,does any company use our cyborg?
02:32:59 <wenpingsong> yeah
02:33:06 <xinranwang> afaik, china telecom
02:33:21 <chenke> Our project is getting better and better, I think it can attract more people
02:33:50 <xinranwang> i think they are your customers, right? chenke
02:34:03 <brinzhang> chenke: we have talked this question on PTG too
02:34:21 <brinzhang> there is need some new people to contributors to join us
02:34:45 <chenke> brinzhang . sorry for absent. please let me your guys idea.
02:35:02 <brinzhang> now I have invite some guys from our team, and in next release, you can see some patches submitted
02:35:28 <xinranwang> brinzhang: that's great
02:35:40 <xinranwang> hope we get more and more contributors.
02:36:09 <chenke> brinzhang greate
02:36:22 <chenke> Also this requires Wang P to find a way to promote our great project.
02:36:37 <chenke> :)
02:36:44 <brinzhang> cool
02:36:58 <wenpingsong> i think the big problem is we cannot bind and unbind accelerator to vm, this is not flexible to use.
02:37:30 <xinranwang> chenke: lol, I am trying
02:37:47 <xinranwang> wenpingsong:  you mean we should support attach/detach ops?
02:38:01 <wenpingsong> yes
02:38:54 <chenke> agree. If i am a user. I also want to attach/detach it dynamicly.
02:39:20 <brinzhang> wenpingsong: this release I think we cannot start this work, resume/pause operation is high priority than this
02:40:53 <xinranwang> nova has also discussed this, https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-xena-ptg L375
02:41:08 <xinranwang> maybe we should take with them
02:42:27 <wenpingsong> cool
02:42:36 <xinranwang> there's no agreement so far, I think it's low prioprity in nova as well.
02:42:45 <xinranwang> but we can ask them
02:43:14 <chenke> agree
02:43:42 <wenpingsong> agree
02:43:52 <wenpingsong> nothing from myside
02:44:00 <xinranwang> ok, anything else?
02:44:23 <xinranwang> so let's wrap up the meeting quickly
02:44:32 <xinranwang> #endmeeting