15:01:25 <serverascode> #startmeeting operators_telco_nfv
15:01:26 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Apr  5 15:01:25 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is serverascode. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:01:27 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:01:30 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'operators_telco_nfv'
15:01:35 <shintaro> hi
15:01:37 <serverascode> #topic roll call
15:01:43 <serverascode> hi shintaro :)
15:01:46 <shintaro> o/
15:01:57 <serverascode> who else do we have?
15:02:06 <talonx> Hi, joining after a long time
15:02:08 <serverascode> I know adiren said he could not make it
15:02:11 <serverascode> hi talonx :)
15:02:16 <uli-k> Hi, long time no see....
15:02:16 <talonx> Hi :)
15:02:19 <talonx> Been a lurker mostly
15:02:22 <shintaro> I'm in the west coast so much easier to join :)
15:02:25 <serverascode> hi uli-k :)
15:02:37 <sergem> hello
15:02:46 <serverascode> hi sergem :)
15:03:10 <serverascode> shintaro what are you up to on the west coast?
15:03:30 <shintaro> OpenNetworkingSummit in Santa Clara
15:03:44 <serverascode> oh cool, I was hoping ot go to that but it didn't work out
15:03:58 <serverascode> sergem have you been to one of these meetings before?
15:04:10 <shintaro> very inspiring
15:04:20 <serverascode> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/ops-telco-nfv-meeting-agenda
15:04:40 <sergem> I'm serge from Sprint. Sometimes I lurk here.
15:04:52 <serverascode> ^^ that's the agenda if anyone wants to look or add to it, just one thing on it right now and that is some of the upcoming boston forum sessions
15:04:55 <sergem> I do attend the f2f at openstack
15:05:06 <serverascode> right, I think I remember now :)
15:05:32 <serverascode> ok so we have a few people, please take a second to look at the agenda and add it it, and we shall start at the start :)
15:05:50 <shintaro> I was wondering how the sessions are selected...
15:06:07 <serverascode> #topic boston forum sessions
15:06:19 <serverascode> shintaro I'm not sure how they are selected
15:06:25 <serverascode> anyone know?
15:06:38 <serverascode> #link http://forumtopics.openstack.org/
15:06:47 <serverascode> so to be clear those are submissions, not "accepted" sessions yet
15:06:56 <shintaro> right
15:07:13 <serverascode> I took a look through and added links to a few I thought interesting to NFV
15:07:46 <serverascode> probably the most important is the collaboration session
15:07:47 <shintaro> What I've heard is they are going to have 3 parallel sessions during the Summit
15:07:50 <serverascode> #link http://forumtopics.openstack.org/cfp/details/64
15:07:55 <serverascode> that shintaro wrote up
15:08:11 <shintaro> yes, Ildiko from the Foundation will help us
15:08:16 <serverascode> 3 parallel, ok that is a good number
15:08:28 <sergem> Is there something on containers?
15:08:48 <serverascode> yup a few
15:08:57 <serverascode> "life cycle management..."
15:09:09 <serverascode> openstack via kubernetes...
15:09:30 <serverascode> migration to containers...
15:09:42 <serverascode> kubernetes ops on openstack
15:09:58 <serverascode> I think a few more
15:10:12 <sergem> I couldn't open the link as I don't have ubuntu one login
15:10:22 <serverascode> oh really? interesting.
15:10:23 <shintaro> container was a hot topic in the OpsMeetup, too
15:10:36 <jamemcc> Hi - Sorry - I'm here now
15:10:49 <shintaro> hi jamemcc
15:10:50 <serverascode> sergem do you have an "openstack" id?
15:10:55 <serverascode> like launchpad?
15:11:01 <serverascode> if so that is the same
15:11:07 <serverascode> hi jamemcc
15:11:09 <sergem> I see Bin has a topic on contained, microservices
15:11:35 <serverascode> ah yes, ok iwll add that to our list
15:12:47 <serverascode> jamemcc we are just looking over the potential forum submissions
15:13:18 <jamemcc> The containers topic is big for LCOO - I will end up creating a spreadsheet to show which all seem to be in that category - simethign similar to the Ethercalc I created a little earlier - which I put the link in the agenda and is https://ethercalc.openstack.org/=qqdo5sfmri
15:13:31 <shintaro> jamemcc do you know how the sessions are going to be selected?
15:13:42 <serverascode> #link https://ethercalc.openstack.org/=qqdo5sfmri
15:14:01 <jamemcc> What I understand is it's a selection committee of 2 from User Group, 2 from TC and 2 from Foundation
15:14:14 <jamemcc> That was hearsay (twice)
15:14:25 <jamemcc> Then scheduled just liek the presenation topics
15:15:08 <jamemcc> I am thinking/hoping that if we can ourselvs be organizing the topics we are interested in and will participate and then give advice ont he order of them - that will help the schedulers a lot
15:15:08 <shintaro> ok great. so we just wait and see
15:16:13 <jamemcc> That was where I was thinking ahveing the List (either as you are doing Curtis) in the Agenda - or in the Ethercalc like I started
15:16:23 <jamemcc> would be helpful
15:16:39 <serverascode> the ethercalc looks great jamemcc
15:17:00 <serverascode> I think that is a really good idea to work with whoever is selecting the submissions and help out a bit
15:18:03 <serverascode> any other thoughts on the forum session?
15:18:18 <serverascode> if not I don't see any other items added except open discussion
15:18:30 <shintaro> so we prioritise the list?
15:20:12 <shintaro> or we announce our interest/intent to join on the list of sessions as a group?
15:20:30 <jamemcc> Yeah - makes sense - maybe a +1 approach to get started.
15:20:32 <serverascode> looks like there are 124 submissions
15:20:55 <shintaro> we can start with the list on ethercalc :)
15:21:02 <jamemcc> Some probbly dont' belong on the TelcoNFV WG (our) list
15:21:31 <serverascode> yeah for sure, I was just thinking about how many could be accepted if 3 parallel sessions over 4 days... :)
15:21:35 <jamemcc> One reason is if I saw Neutron I added ot to the list
15:22:26 <serverascode> out of curiosity what do you all think of the "blockchain in telelcom"?
15:22:31 <serverascode> I don't quite get that one
15:22:46 <sergem> isn't that pretty futuristic?
15:23:01 <shintaro> I don't get it either
15:23:10 <jamemcc> Yes - pretty far out there
15:23:46 <serverascode> ok, that's what I was thinking
15:23:50 <sergem> there are probably lots of diverse interest among us. In my company (Sprint), we are focused on VMs. So I am interested in all the container stuff
15:24:16 <sergem> like 'migration to containers' is a good one.
15:25:01 <serverascode> that one seems to be about the openstack control plane
15:25:16 <serverascode> #link http://forumtopics.openstack.org/cfp/details/96
15:25:48 <shintaro> yes. you have to be careful if it is openstack on container, or container on Openstack
15:25:58 <serverascode> heh yeah
15:26:07 <sergem> Ah yes.
15:26:25 <serverascode> I will add a comment to that one asking to differentiate
15:27:38 <serverascode> ok, any other thoughs on the forum sessions?
15:28:48 <serverascode> all right, I suppose we just check out the spreadsheet every once and a while and try to keep up with any messages on the mailing list regarding forum sessions
15:28:53 <serverascode> #topic open discussion
15:29:12 <serverascode> if anyone has any other ideas, thoughts, concerns now is the time :)
15:30:00 <shintaro> no form me
15:30:03 <shintaro> from
15:30:20 <jamemcc> In terms of the session "Collaboration between Telecom/NFV related groups
15:30:20 <jamemcc> "
15:31:36 <jamemcc> I asked if either or both of Brian Sullivan and Steven Wright of OPNFV could be there and they agreed
15:32:12 <serverascode> thanks jamemcc, does anyone know if people from OPNFV submitted any of those sessions?
15:32:16 <shintaro> great Ildiko said she invited people from ETSI as well
15:32:59 <sergem> Bin is from OPNFV
15:33:18 <serverascode> sergem, thanks
15:33:19 <shintaro> Resource reservation is from OPNFV as well
15:33:31 <shintaro> #link http://forumtopics.openstack.org/cfp/details/126
15:33:36 <jamemcc> Seems to me 2 ways the discussion could go - others not in our teams asking us questions or if not - and more helpful we can go through our individual WG goals and look for more ways to collaborate
15:34:02 <jamemcc> Just thinking through it ahead of time
15:34:33 <serverascode> hmm, and I wonder if some sessions can be double sessions
15:35:06 <serverascode> the one thing I don't like about the summit is that the first session tends to be questions about the group, just like you mention jamemcc
15:35:11 <jamemcc> Curtis - the Gluon topic is in essence OPNFV and the 1000+ Scale is one of their priorities
15:35:30 <jamemcc> Hmm at least one or 2 more - let me cross check - I should have and will add those to the Ethercalc
15:35:53 <serverascode> I don't see a gluon one
15:36:52 <jamemcc> Sorry - I mean this one: Containerized, Cloud Native Microservice in NFV Networking
15:37:06 <jamemcc> Bin Hu
15:37:14 <serverascode> ah ok
15:37:22 <shintaro> oh that was gluon
15:37:47 <serverascode> ok
15:37:48 <sergem> ah, more networking than containers
15:40:37 <serverascode> there's also 4 sessions related to vitrage/alarms
15:41:11 <serverascode> and I wonder if it would be worhtwhile to propose the nfv collaboration session be a double session
15:41:37 <shintaro> +1 40min is way too short
15:41:58 <serverascode> maybe we should add a column for potential double sessions?
15:42:18 <serverascode> jamemcc does that make sense to you?
15:42:43 <shintaro> oops I just added the column
15:43:00 <serverascode> I think that's a good idea :)
15:43:08 <serverascode> won't hurt to ask
15:43:39 <shintaro> right
15:44:16 <serverascode> ok anything else?
15:45:11 <serverascode> well I think that was a good discussion on the forum topics and I think it might help the people who are determining the schedule and submissions
15:45:41 <serverascode> so thanks everyone for coming to the meeting today, much appreciated, and hopefully around and after boston we will pick up some steam so to speak :)
15:45:56 <jamemcc> Thank you
15:45:57 <shintaro> thank you serverascode
15:46:08 <sergem> thanks
15:46:20 <serverascode> :)
15:46:23 <serverascode> #endmeeting