15:01:02 #startmeeting oslo 15:01:03 Meeting started Mon Apr 1 15:01:02 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is bnemec. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:01:04 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:01:06 The meeting name has been set to 'oslo' 15:01:26 courtesy ping for amotoki, amrith, ansmith, bnemec, dansmith, dims, dougwig 15:01:26 courtesy ping for e0ne, electrocucaracha, garyk, gcb, haypo, hberaud, jd__ 15:01:26 courtesy ping for johnsom, jungleboyj, kgiusti, kragniz, lhx_, moguimar, njohnston 15:01:27 courtesy ping for raildo, redrobot, sileht, sreshetnyak, stephenfin, stevemar, therve 15:01:27 courtesy ping for thinrichs, toabctl, zhiyan, zxy, zzzeek 15:01:28 To be added or removed from the ping list, please submit a patch to http://git.openstack.org/cgit/openstack/oslo.tools/tree/ping_me.py 15:01:34 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Oslo#Agenda_for_Next_Meeting 15:01:35 o/ 15:01:45 o/ 15:02:06 o/ 15:02:06 o/ 15:02:11 \o 15:02:14 o/ 15:02:43 Dan Smith proposed openstack/oslo.tools master: Remove dansmith from ping_me.py https://review.openstack.org/649056 15:02:53 Just FYI, this will be my last Oslo meeting. I won the lottery and am retiring to a tropical island in the Caribbean. 15:02:54 * dansmith chuckles 15:02:59 (someone had to) 15:03:46 He he. 15:04:15 o/ 15:04:20 * bnemec should have merged the unrolling patch before adding the instructions for the ping list. 15:04:22 tropical island... strange choice 15:04:29 Now they're all going to merge conflict. 15:05:02 hberaud: I happen to like the ocean, despite my distinctly non-oceanic current location. :-) 15:05:17 #topic Red flags for/from liaisons 15:05:34 The big thing from last week was that oslosphinx is no longer working. 15:05:34 Nothing that I am aware of from Cinder. 15:05:50 Nothing from Octavia 15:05:55 Which _shouldn't_ be a problem since that project has been retired for years, but quite a few projects are still using it. 15:05:57 Merged openstack/oslo.tools master: Include add/remove info in ping script output https://review.openstack.org/647535 15:05:59 Merged openstack/oslo.tools master: Unroll the ping list https://review.openstack.org/647536 15:06:00 Merged openstack/oslo.tools master: Remove flaper87 from ping list https://review.openstack.org/647537 15:06:02 bnemec: I hope you'll love it 15:06:07 Including a couple of oslo projects, unfortunately. 15:06:58 stephenfin sent a message to openstack-discuss about the oslosphinx thing. 15:07:01 * bnemec finds the link 15:07:22 #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-March/004368.html 15:07:39 If you have any questions about this, I recommend asking him. 15:07:50 I will answer what I can, but he's the docs expert. 15:07:54 I need to work through the retirement process for the repo itself. I'll probably wait til the end of the week for that 15:08:10 stephenfin: Sounds good, thanks. 15:09:50 I guess the only other thing we ran into last week was that oslo.db's lower-constraints didn't work with postgresql 10. 15:10:43 Not sure that would affect most people, but FYI in case you're still running an older version of psycopg. 15:10:56 #topic Releases 15:11:16 We released oslo.db for stein last week. 15:11:32 Which is noteworthy because it was a feature release on a stable branch. 15:11:49 But it was needed to fix the issue I just mentioned (changing requirements forces a feature release). 15:12:13 Because of that problem, I've been holding off on doing any other master releases in case we happen to run into a similar situation with another library. 15:12:39 I'd rather not get into a situation where we released master and can't fix something in stein as a result. 15:14:33 Will still be holding off on releases for this week, but we'll get everything released soon since I think this is release week for Stein. 15:14:48 At least I assume it is since the release update email last week was R-1. :-) 15:15:00 #topic Action items from last meeting 15:15:20 "bnemec to rebase https://review.openstack.org/#/c/597612" 15:15:41 Done 15:15:52 Finally went a week without merge conflicting that one. :-) 15:16:08 "Oslo cores to single approve git -> https patches" 15:16:16 I believe that's pretty much done. 15:16:42 There might be a few that ran into ci failures that are still open, but I saw a lot of them merge last week. 15:16:59 And that was it for action items. 15:17:13 #topic PTG Schedule 15:17:19 #link https://www.openstack.org/ptg#tab_schedule 15:17:26 FYI for anyone who didn't see this on the list. 15:17:39 Oslo has a day, but split over two days. 15:17:45 Friday afternoon and Saturday morning. 15:18:20 If anyone is flying out Friday night please let me know so we can get your topics discussed in the Friday session. 15:18:33 I've heard a fair number of people are doing that. 15:19:37 #topic PTG Team Photo 15:20:07 We haven't actually done one of these since I've been PTL because I'm camera-shy, but if anyone wants to do a team photo let me know. :-) 15:20:47 We're a pretty small team so it shouldn't be too hard to get us all together at once. 15:21:07 That was it for the agenda this week. 15:21:08 #topic Weekly Wayward Review 15:21:54 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/597612/ 15:22:11 And kgiusti already approved it so that's it for this topic. :-) 15:22:18 :D 15:22:38 can you take a look for the workflow part on it please => https://review.openstack.org/645203 15:23:51 hberaud: I'll take a look after the meeting. Seems like it should be fine though. 15:24:04 bnemec: thanks 15:24:10 #topic PTG Topics 15:24:25 I guess I should have mentioned this earlier, but a reminder that there is an etherpad for PTG topics. 15:24:27 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/oslo-train-topics 15:24:38 If you have anything to discuss face-to-face, please add it there. 15:25:04 Has there been any talk of adding etcd as a backend for TaskFlow? I.e. an alternative to zookeeper/redis? 15:25:38 johnsom: There's hasn't been a lot of taskflow talk, period. :-/ 15:25:43 Etcd is a “base service” so it might be nice to have that as an option. 15:25:58 Agreed. 15:26:11 Ok. 15:26:15 Is taskflow using tooz to talk to the backend? 15:26:21 If so, it might already work. 15:27:22 I don’t think that got done. 15:27:27 Not sure though 15:27:36 Okay 15:27:38 Stephen Finucane proposed openstack/oslosphinx master: Retire oslosphinx https://review.openstack.org/649070 15:27:44 * bnemec doesn't know much about taskflow 15:28:17 Last I heard, there was some talk about moving it out of openstack, but I don't think anything ever came of it. 15:28:33 Right, I remember that too 15:28:35 We had also discussed keeping it where it is, but adopting a single +2 policy since there are so few contributors. 15:29:28 We are looking at taking the next step and enabling jobboard, so I was curious about the state of etcd support. 15:29:43 For now, I would say it's in maintenance mode. We'll keep it working, but nobody is doing feature development that I'm aware of. 15:30:04 Yeah, that was my feeling as well. 15:30:30 #topic Open discussion 15:30:46 I guess we're kind of there already, but if anyone has topics to discuss before we close, now is the time. 15:32:14 #action bnemec to review https://review.openstack.org/645203 15:32:51 Alright, looks like we're done. 15:32:55 Thanks for joining everyone! 15:32:58 #endmeeting