13:00:28 <baoli> #startmeeting PCI passthrough 13:00:29 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Jan 6 13:00:28 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is baoli. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 13:00:30 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 13:00:32 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'pci_passthrough' 13:00:59 <baoli> Hi there 13:01:05 <pczesno> hi 13:01:06 <beagles> hi 13:01:17 <shaohe_feng> hi baoli 13:01:24 <baoli> Hope everyone had a wonderful holidays. 13:02:34 <sadasu> Hello! 13:02:45 <riwinters> Hello 13:03:01 <baoli> sadasu, riwinters, Hi 13:03:06 <moshele> hi 13:03:33 <baoli> #topic Bugs 13:04:41 <baoli> moshele: a quick question to your bug, wonder why 'bus' is left out. 13:05:12 <baoli> https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bug/1407721 13:05:13 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1407721 in nova "Add slot and func range to pci_passthrough_whitelist " [Undecided,In progress] 13:05:20 <moshele> I can add the bus also 13:07:31 <baoli> moshele, I was thinking that we might as well support '-' in all the fields of the pci address. 13:07:46 <moshele> ok, np 13:07:56 <moshele> I will update the bug and code 13:08:03 <baoli> moshele: cool. thanks 13:08:46 <baoli> moshele, please update the bug description accordingly. 13:08:53 <moshele> will do 13:10:06 <baoli> yongli is not here. But anyone has any update on Bugs? 13:11:15 <baoli> we need to make some progress on the pci init bugs. 13:12:12 <baoli> ok, let's move on, then. 13:12:20 <baoli> #topic Reviews 13:13:02 <shaohe_feng> baoli: https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bug/1222990 13:13:04 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1222990 in nova "Cannot specify subset of PCI devices for PCI passthrough" [Wishlist,Confirmed] 13:13:32 <moshele> is that related to my bug? 13:13:37 <shaohe_feng> baoli: I'm going to fix this bug 13:13:55 <shaohe_feng> moshele: did you file thi bug? 13:14:27 <shaohe_feng> moshele: can you elaborate the item 2? 13:14:39 <moshele> no, I asking if my bug "Add slot and func range to pci_passthrough_whitelist " doesn't solved this also 13:14:51 <moshele> ? 13:15:11 <shaohe_feng> moshele: sorry, misuderstand. 13:17:04 <moshele> nevermind 13:18:57 <baoli> shaohe_feng: a few things described in the bug have been addressed in Juno and various enhancements we are doing now. So I'd suggest to change the status of this bug, and open new ones if necessary with clear objectives. 13:20:32 <shaohe_feng> baoli: do you know which have been addressed? 13:21:00 <baoli> shaohe_feng: item 1. item 2: we have tags 13:21:24 <baoli> and item 4 with tags 13:22:20 <baoli> item 3: consult with Yongli, there exists a patch for some of it. 13:23:02 <shaohe_feng> baoli: so I need to do nothing on the bug? 13:24:06 <shaohe_feng> baoli: all of item 1, 2, 4 have ben taken? 13:27:29 <baoli> shaohe_feng: they either have already been taken care of, or worked on, I believe. But you are welcome for any enhancement that makes sense. 13:27:56 <baoli> shaohe_feng, item 3 may need to be completed. 13:28:55 <shaohe_feng> baoli: thank you for your info 13:29:06 <shaohe_feng> baoli: so I can take item 3, rihgt? 13:29:23 <baoli> shaohe_feng, sure, consult with Yongli first on that one. 13:29:48 <shaohe_feng> baoli: got it. I will. 13:30:02 <baoli> there is a patch for 'nova pci-list' 13:30:13 <shaohe_feng> baoli: any other bugs can I take? 13:31:01 <shaohe_feng> baoli: is there a untake list for nova pci bugs? 13:31:27 <baoli> shaohe_feng: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Passthrough#Agenda_on_Jan._6th.2C_2015 13:31:42 <baoli> So we tagged all the PCI bugs if we haven't missed any 13:33:01 <shaohe_feng> baoli: thank you, I will look at them. 13:33:16 <baoli> shaohe_feng: you are welcome 13:33:27 <baoli> ok, back to reviews 13:34:02 <baoli> Thanks to Daniel Berrange, we now have a couple of +2s on a couple of the reviews. Hopefully they will get another +2 soon. 13:36:17 <pczesno> baoli i added two new reviews to the list 13:36:33 <pczesno> baoli the add numa awareness to pci device scheduling 13:37:15 <baoli> pczesno: ok, just saw them. 13:37:41 <pczesno> any feedback appreciated 13:39:49 <baoli> pczesno: sure. 13:44:28 <moshele> I have remark regarding the neutron split, currently SRIOV MD is in tree so there is no action item there 13:45:08 <baoli> moshele: thanks for the update 13:45:14 <sadasu> there was discussion in the ML2 meeting right before the break 13:45:24 <baoli> #topic Blueprints 13:46:04 <baoli> So none of our BPs have been approved so far. 13:46:07 <moshele> irenab manage to convince them to stay in tree for now 13:46:17 <sadasu> moshele: I think ire nab was of the opinion that it should stay in the tree 13:46:40 <sadasu> but there were other thoughts about that also being taken out of the tree 13:48:02 <moshele> yes, if it will grow and be hard to manage, but for kilo it is in tree for other releases time will tell 13:48:56 <baoli> moshele: can you update https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Passthrough#Agenda_on_Jan._6th.2C_2015 on the ml2 split? 13:50:41 <moshele> yes 13:52:30 <moshele> also regarding the blueprints any update regrading this https://blueprints.launchpad.net/neutron/+spec/api-specify-vnic-type? 13:53:08 <pczesno> moshele: i've no update 13:55:20 <moshele> baoli: I updated the wiki 13:55:21 <baoli> #topic CI Testing 13:55:39 <baoli> moshele: cool, thanks. 13:55:47 <baoli> Any update on the CI side? 13:57:35 <shaohe_feng> baoli: yongli can not join this meeting today. 13:57:53 <shaohe_feng> baoli: for some personal issue 13:57:56 <baoli> shaohe_feng: np 13:58:13 <shaohe_feng> baoli: So I think no update 13:59:01 <baoli> Anything else to bring up? 14:00:08 <baoli> Thanks everyone. see you next time. 14:00:13 <moshele> bye 14:00:15 <baoli> #endmeeting