21:01:16 <ttx> #startmeeting project
21:01:17 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Jul 16 21:01:16 2013 UTC.  The chair is ttx. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
21:01:18 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
21:01:21 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'project'
21:01:25 * jgriffith changes nic to j
21:01:25 <ttx> #link http://wiki.openstack.org/Meetings/ProjectMeeting
21:01:55 <ttx> We'll cut the havana-2 branch in a few hours, so we'll spend this meeting gathering the neecssary sign-offs and deferrals
21:02:04 <ttx> #topic General stuff
21:02:12 <ttx> sdague, annegentle, jeblair/mordred: news from QA/Docs/Infra programs ?
21:02:25 <sdague> the neutron bug - https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1194026 might be solved now
21:02:28 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1194026 in neutron "check_public_network_connectivity fails with timeout" [Critical,Fix committed]
21:02:37 <ttx> sdague: \o/
21:02:48 <sdague> so we're giving it 24 hrs no recurrances then going to turn back on the gate for neutron
21:02:50 <ttx> sdague: any plan to reenable at the gate ?
21:02:52 <ttx> o
21:02:53 <ttx> k
21:03:00 <sdague> yeh, 24hrs without seeing it
21:03:06 <sdague> we've got 5 on the clock now
21:03:14 <markmc> cool
21:03:19 <jeblair> ttx: i'm about to send an email describing an upcoming behavioral change in zuul; should be on the -dev list soon
21:03:19 <jgriffith> nice!!
21:03:32 <sdague> also I think the last issue preventing grenade gating was fixed by jgriffith
21:03:32 <annegentle_> Working on Doc Boot Camp in CA in Sept, more details will come as we work them out.
21:03:38 * ttx should stop salivate on his keyboard, I blame mordred's links
21:03:52 <jeblair> (short version, it will be more agressive in dequeuing changes with merge conflicts in the gate)
21:04:00 <sdague> so I'm hoping that goes gating this week as well (going to give it a couple more days to make sure that flakey bit doesn't crop up again)
21:04:36 <sdague> actually both the cinder fix for grenade, and the neutron one are things we saw before randomly in the gate, just worse now, so overall gate stability should go up from these
21:04:46 <sdague> that's probably the QA highlights for this week
21:04:47 <ttx> annegentle_: great news
21:04:50 <jeblair> ttx: eot
21:04:58 <annegentle_> pretty excited
21:04:59 <sdague> only question is if there are concerns turning back on gate things
21:05:04 <sdague> with H2
21:05:26 <ttx> sdague: tomorrow most of the merging will be done
21:05:44 <sdague> ok, so if we wait until tomorrow afternoon, probably in the clear
21:05:52 <ttx> and actually I'd feel better if we reenabled the neutron set BEFORE we finalize the branch
21:06:02 <sdague> ok, will make that a priority
21:06:11 <ttx> so sometimes Wed/Thu
21:06:28 <sdague> lots of credit to nachi to getting to the bottom of it
21:06:40 <ttx> yeah, that was pretty impressive
21:06:55 <ttx> #topic Oslo status
21:07:02 <ttx> markmc: hi!
21:07:04 <markmc> hey hey
21:07:05 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/oslo/+milestone/havana-2
21:07:35 <ttx> All set I see ?
21:07:39 <markmc> I think we're done for h-2, yeah
21:07:44 <markmc> can I go for a drink now?
21:07:50 <markmc> h-3 is a whole other story
21:08:00 <markmc> gonna schedule a Oslo IRC meeting for Friday
21:08:07 <ttx> markwell, plenty of code proposed there already, so might not be a disaster
21:08:16 <ttx> arrh another mark
21:08:28 <markmc> yeah, some of the h-3 stuff just missed h-2
21:08:48 <ttx> markmc: anything you wanted to raise, apart from your glass ?
21:08:59 <markmc> ttx, nope
21:09:04 * markmc clinks glasses with ttx
21:09:04 <ttx> Questions about Oslo ?
21:09:24 * ttx saves time for other projects, might need it at the end
21:09:30 <ttx> #topic Keystone status
21:09:32 <dolphm> o/
21:09:36 <ttx> dolphm: hello!
21:09:39 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/keystone/+milestone/havana-2
21:10:03 <ttx> Two left in the tracked bps
21:10:16 <ttx> still likely to make it today ?
21:10:24 <ttx> inherited-domain-roles / catalog-optional ?
21:11:09 <dolphm> yes, bp catalog-optional is experiencing some git-review trouble, and bp inherited-domain-roles is getting some extra review attention & testing
21:11:27 <ttx> Shall I just defer anything that doesn't make it and cut the branch in 10 hours ?
21:12:07 <dolphm> i don't have any reason to think catalog-optional won't make it, but i'd really like that to be in m2
21:12:32 <ttx> ok, so if catalog-optional isn't in for any reason, i'll hold
21:12:40 <dolphm> appreciated
21:12:53 <dolphm> i'm working to help get that up for review now
21:13:20 <ttx> sounds good
21:13:21 <dolphm> other than that, we might actually have an m3-targetted bp land in m2
21:13:42 <dolphm> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/keystone/+spec/pluggable-remote-user
21:13:45 <hub_cap> showoff ;)
21:13:56 <ttx> dolphm: shit happens :)
21:13:58 <dolphm> lol
21:14:23 <ttx> dolphm: if it makes it, just switch the milestone
21:14:28 <dolphm> will do
21:14:28 <ttx> dolphm: Anything more about Keystone ?
21:14:32 <dolphm> that's all from me
21:14:34 <ttx> Questions anyone ?
21:15:00 <ttx> #topic Ceilometer status
21:15:03 <ttx> jd__: hey
21:15:07 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/ceilometer/+milestone/havana-2
21:15:07 <jd__> o/
21:15:36 <ttx> Looks all set, a few more hours to land that Low otherwise I'll just defer it
21:15:45 <jd__> ack
21:16:01 <ttx> About bug 1193906, looks like it's not on track to be fixed before Thursday...
21:16:03 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1193906 in ceilometer "Unable to sort data with MongoDB" [Critical,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1193906
21:16:07 <jd__> it might get in since it should be ready by now
21:16:16 * ttx refreshes
21:16:36 <jd__> only needs a +2 on that bug
21:16:44 <jd__> dhellmann_: might do that soon :)
21:16:50 <ttx> jd__: if it lands too late we can backport it to the milestone-proposed branch anyway
21:16:56 <ttx> I'll keep it on the target list
21:17:02 <jd__> ok
21:17:21 <ttx> jd__: may I cut the branch early tomorrow morning with what's in ?
21:17:37 <jd__> ttx: yes
21:17:44 <ttx> jd__: anything else you wanted to mention ?
21:17:48 <jd__> nop
21:17:59 <ttx> Your H3 is large but mostly Low stuff, so ttx.py didn't turn red
21:18:09 <ttx> Questions on Ceilometer ?
21:18:32 <ttx> #topic Swift status
21:18:34 <notmyname> hi
21:18:36 <ttx> notmyname: o/
21:18:40 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/swift/+milestone/1.9.1
21:18:49 <ttx> Not a lot on your list yet, but those are the early days :)
21:19:01 <ttx> notmyname: anything you wanted to raise ?
21:19:04 <notmyname> ya, not a lot to talk about yet for a release
21:19:16 <notmyname> we talked about adding erasure codes to swift: http://swiftstack.com/blog/2013/07/10/erasure-codes-with-openstack-swift/
21:19:34 <ttx> yes, sounds very interesting
21:19:51 <notmyname> I'm working on some more technical details that I hope to have ready this week
21:20:00 <ttx> do you expect that effort to be completed in that cycle, or rather the next ?
21:20:22 <notmyname> it will be done when it's done, but that will probably be after havana
21:20:29 <ttx> right
21:20:42 <ttx> notmyname: anything else ?*
21:20:55 <notmyname> nope
21:20:56 <ttx> Questions about Swift ?
21:21:12 <ttx> #topic Glance status
21:21:16 <ttx> markwash: o/
21:21:20 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/glance/+milestone/havana-2
21:21:38 <markwash> hello
21:21:52 <markwash> just one wee little bp left, so close!
21:21:55 <ttx> One left (glance-cinder-driver), is it likely to make it in the next hours ?
21:22:08 <markwash> also, I might have been mistaken about when you wanted to pull the trigger, thinking there was until thursday
21:22:36 <markwash> ttx, I don't want to release without it. . .
21:22:38 <markwash> well
21:22:45 <ttx> you've been mistaken. We cut the H2 branch at the end of the day
21:22:54 <markwash> so I gathered
21:22:57 <ttx> but then I can wait a few hours if that's what it needs
21:23:03 <stevebaker> what is that in hours?
21:23:16 <ttx> stevebaker: tomorrow morning my time
21:23:24 <ttx> ~0900 UTC
21:23:30 <stevebaker> k
21:23:42 <ttx> though.. tomorrow I probably won't be available until 1200 UTC so here you go
21:23:58 <ttx> markwash: how far is it ?
21:24:13 <markwash> it is very very close
21:24:22 <markwash> we noticed one issue that should be an easy fix
21:24:36 <ttx> ok, I'll hold to get that one in
21:24:37 <markwash> using cinderclient v1 instead of v2
21:24:54 <markwash> which jgriffith says should be a pretty much no-op change
21:25:01 <markwash> ttx <3
21:25:24 <ttx> markwash: just let me know if I shouldn't wait (i.e. you realize at the end of the day that it's more than a few hours away)
21:25:32 <markwash> ttx sure thing
21:25:32 <ttx> (or just defer it to H3 yourself)
21:25:45 <ttx> markwash: anything you wanted to mention ?
21:26:01 <markwash> thanks to everybody for the strong end push
21:26:15 <ttx> yes, i wouldn't have bet on that result a week ago :P
21:26:40 <ttx> Questions on Glance ?
21:27:17 <ttx> #topic Neutron status
21:27:21 <ttx> markmcclain: hi!
21:27:23 <markmcclain> hi
21:27:25 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/havana-2
21:27:42 <ttx> Large number still under review... and not so much room in H3 for deferring
21:27:58 <markmcclain> yeah.. also a bad week to have 4 reviewers mostly offline
21:28:38 <ttx> OK, so is any of those still likely to make it today ?
21:28:55 <ttx> I don't mind giving you a few more hours but i'm not sure that would help in any way
21:29:01 <markmcclain> there's a few reviews that may make it today
21:29:13 <markmcclain> and if they don't, we can defer to H3
21:29:13 <ttx> Shall I just defer anything that doesn't make it and cut the branch in 10 hours ?
21:29:38 <markmcclain> yeah.. there's nothing outstanding that should hold up h2
21:29:43 <ttx> (or i can wait until you get up in case you want to push a last few)
21:29:55 <ttx> (supposing you get up at your usual time)
21:30:41 <markmcclain> yeah.. let's see where we're at the end of today.. and send you an email, so you won't have to wait for me to wake up
21:30:59 <ttx> ok will cut unless you tell me otherwise
21:31:04 <ttx> You also have a few targeted bugs on the list. Anything you can't publish havana-2 with ? Or should I just push all those to h3 ?
21:31:19 <ttx> (if they are not completed today)
21:31:27 <markmcclain> I've clear most of them out
21:31:32 <markmcclain> 2 are working through the gate now
21:32:06 <ttx> i'll defer those which don't make it today
21:32:19 <markmcclain> that works
21:32:29 <ttx> unless your email tells me otherwise.
21:32:31 <ttx> markmcclain: anything you wanted to raise ?
21:32:52 <markmcclain> thanks to everyone for helping to get the renames through last week
21:33:10 <markmcclain> heat is the only one outstanding and will be completed early next week
21:33:12 <ttx> yes, good thing that was completed in time for h2
21:33:29 <ttx> Questions on Neutron ?
21:33:54 <ttx> #topic Cinder status
21:33:58 <ttx> jgriffith: hola!
21:34:01 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/cinder/+milestone/havana-2
21:34:01 <jgriffith> ttx: yo
21:34:21 <ttx> lots of new green, /me likes
21:34:32 <jgriffith> yay!
21:34:43 <jgriffith> Still not what I hoped for but our complete rate is getting better
21:34:59 <jgriffith> The remaining 3 should make it
21:35:04 <ttx> Those last two mediums are still likely to make it ?
21:35:06 <ttx> ok
21:35:11 <jgriffith> if they're not in by the time you're ready they can be deferred
21:35:19 <ttx> ack
21:35:29 <ttx> You have 3 bugs targeted against the milestone... anything that needs to be fixed BEFORE h2 publication ?
21:35:33 <jgriffith> Yeah, just talked to walst
21:35:58 <jgriffith> Those are in flight as well, but not critical if they don't make it
21:36:11 <jgriffith> I'll likely adjust the netapp one
21:36:23 <jgriffith> other two should make it if we get them reviewed and they're clean
21:36:34 <ttx> About bug 1197571
21:36:36 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1197571 in cinder "Upper bound on keystone-client in requires causes conflict" [Critical,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1197571
21:36:44 <ttx> the review looks abandoned, what's the status ?
21:37:14 <jgriffith> I'll update, got moved in to the *other* global bug
21:37:14 <ttx> still anything to fix in cinder ?
21:37:17 <ttx> right
21:37:22 <jgriffith> so no... there is not
21:37:29 <jgriffith> anything to fix in cinder that is
21:37:36 <jgriffith> technicaly there never was :)
21:37:38 <ttx> ok, just mark it invalid then
21:37:43 <jgriffith> ahh... perfect
21:38:06 <jgriffith> ttx: done
21:38:12 <ttx> jgriffith: anything else on your mind ?
21:38:25 <jgriffith> nada, I'll take a nother sweep through these tonight
21:38:28 <ttx> Questions on Cinder ?
21:38:29 <jgriffith> should be ready for you in the morning
21:38:47 <ttx> (if not i'll blatantly defer them)
21:38:50 <ttx> #topic Nova status
21:38:54 <ttx> russellb: hey
21:38:58 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/nova/+milestone/havana-2
21:39:02 <russellb> hi!
21:39:17 <russellb> so 3 blueprints left
21:39:18 <ttx> You deferred enough to be in good shape for H2, but H3 will need a serious reality check at the next meeting
21:39:21 <russellb> the first 2 should make it
21:39:30 <russellb> 3rd might make it
21:39:34 <russellb> and yes, havana-3 is a disaster
21:39:44 <russellb> going to email the ML about it
21:39:49 <ttx> ok
21:39:59 <ttx> Shall I just defer anything that doesn't make it and cut the branch in 10 hours ?
21:40:03 <russellb> yes
21:40:08 <russellb> nothing critical left that i really want to make it
21:40:10 <ttx> Or is there anything in those last 3 you're particularly attached to ?
21:40:10 <russellb> we'll get in what we can
21:40:12 <ttx> ok
21:40:16 <russellb> so just feel free to branch when ready
21:40:37 <russellb> actually, i'd really like the shelve-instance bp to make it
21:40:41 <russellb> i think it's all in the gate now though
21:40:45 <russellb> so we should be good
21:40:51 <ttx> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/nova-v3-api-filter is in h3 but already completed, I'll move it to h2 ?
21:40:52 <dansmith> 6th in line for merge
21:41:21 <russellb> ttx: ah yes
21:41:27 <ttx> willdo
21:41:28 <ttx> On the bugs side...
21:41:45 <ttx> https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bug/1195720 is critical but untargeted
21:41:47 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1195720 in nova "response to vm spawn may  contain invalid values" [Critical,Confirmed]
21:41:56 <russellb> hm, need to look at it
21:42:09 <ttx> should we try to fix it in H2 ?
21:42:27 <russellb> i will review
21:42:30 <russellb> i suspect we can downgrade it
21:42:40 <ttx> What about the 19 others ? Anything milestone-critical in that ?
21:42:51 <ttx> (those which are targeted to h2 currently)
21:43:14 <ttx> or should I defer anythign that doesn't make it ?
21:43:32 <russellb> defer anything that doesn't make it
21:43:41 <ttx> sounds good
21:43:43 <ttx> russellb: anything else you wanted to mention ?
21:43:48 <russellb> nope
21:44:17 <ttx> Any question on Nova ?
21:44:36 <ttx> #topic Heat status
21:44:40 <ttx> stevebaker: o/
21:44:42 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/heat/+milestone/havana-2
21:44:43 <stevebaker> hi
21:45:00 <ttx> Same comment as Nova, in good shape but your H3 will need to be trimmed.
21:45:00 <stevebaker> looking ok. that critical is seconds old
21:45:23 <ttx> One blueprint left: gzip-userdata. Still likely to make it ?
21:45:35 <stevebaker> I don't think so, sdake is travelling
21:45:48 <stevebaker> and there are objections to the solution
21:45:52 <ttx> stevebaker: ok, please defer it to h3 then
21:46:05 <stevebaker> will do
21:46:18 <ttx> On the bugs side you have 2 bugs left. Are they milestone-critical (and worth a backport to MP) or should they be deferred ?
21:46:49 <ttx> That recent critical might be a good candidate for a backport after the branch is cut
21:46:53 <stevebaker> any non-criticals remaining can be deferred
21:46:54 <ttx> (and before release)
21:46:58 <ttx> ok, sounds good
21:47:10 <stevebaker> ok, I expect that one will have a fix by the cut
21:47:28 <ttx> stevebaker: anything else you want to raise ?
21:47:34 <stevebaker> I don't think so
21:47:49 <ttx> Questions about Heat ?
21:48:40 <ttx> stevebaker: We'll probably skip next week meeting... please have a look at your H3 objectives and maybe reprioritize/defer a bit to make it more realistic
21:49:03 <ttx> unless you're pretty sure you can deliver everything in there :)
21:49:15 <stevebaker> ok, thanks
21:49:17 <ttx> #topic Horizon status
21:49:20 <ttx> gabrielhurley: o/
21:49:21 <gabrielhurley> \o
21:49:23 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/horizon/+milestone/havana-2
21:49:23 <gabrielhurley> Down to the wire here... the keystone v3 auth BP literally *just* became unblocked by openstack-requirements and should hopefully merge into Horizon shortly. the Heat topology BP and the remaining bug are both waiting on Jenkins.
21:49:39 <gabrielhurley> I expect everything to land today though
21:50:10 <gabrielhurley> As for H3, I'm gonna start paring down the list with the team in our meeting up next... I know it's way overbooked.
21:50:21 <ttx> gabrielhurley: if Murphy's law strikes, should I wait or just defer those which didn't make it ?
21:50:33 <gabrielhurley> I would *really* like to get these in
21:50:40 <gabrielhurley> I'm gonna be watching them closel
21:50:43 <gabrielhurley> closely
21:51:12 <ttx> gabrielhurley: ok, I will wait if shit happens. just make sure it doesn't :)
21:51:15 <gabrielhurley> If something goes horribly wrong I'll defer myself
21:51:26 <gabrielhurley> if you see all green at any point, go ahead and cut the release
21:52:08 <ttx> gabrielhurley: anything else you wanted to mention ?
21:52:14 <gabrielhurley> don't think so
21:52:22 <ttx> Questions on Horizon ?
21:53:12 <ttx> gabrielhurley: same comment as Russell and Steve: H3 will need a bit of a reality check... please work on it next week and we'll discuss the results in the meeting in two weeks
21:53:18 <gabrielhurley> yep
21:53:27 <ttx> #topic Incubated projects
21:53:30 <ttx> hub_cap: around ?
21:53:35 <hub_cap> aye
21:53:38 <ttx> Looking at trove since we'll be pushing out a H2 there...
21:53:43 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/trove/+milestone/havana-2
21:53:47 <hub_cap> wrt my h2, id like to quote the great joe cocker. you are so beautiful h2 me
21:53:53 <hub_cap> get it , get it?
21:53:59 <hub_cap> but srsly, cut it ttx when yer ready
21:54:01 <hub_cap> its done
21:54:07 <ttx> hub_cap: almost markwashrthy
21:54:13 <hub_cap> lol
21:54:19 <hub_cap> i can aspire
21:54:49 <ttx> hub_cap: will cut with what's in master in my tomorrow morning while you sleep.
21:54:55 <hub_cap> <3
21:55:15 <ttx> then you'll still have the option of backporting critical bugfixes if any to the milestone-proposed branch that will be created
21:55:16 <hub_cap> nothing else to report, h3 looks do-able as of now
21:55:24 <hub_cap> perfect ttx
21:55:29 <ttx> quick explanation of how this works
21:55:46 <ttx> when I cut branch I set all targeted bugs to fixreleased
21:56:06 <ttx> if you want to add a bug to the backport list, fix it in master first (it will turn to FixCommitted)
21:56:32 <ttx> then target it to h2 and it will appear on the list
21:56:43 * devananda follows along
21:56:49 <ttx> (it will be fixcommitted while the others are fixreleased, basically)
21:57:05 <hub_cap> k
21:57:09 <ttx> allows us to track that the fix is in master but you want it in h2
21:57:32 <ttx> hub_cap: I think we're all set
21:57:39 <ttx> devananda: quick progress report ?
21:57:44 <hub_cap> <3
21:57:49 <devananda> ttx: nothing release worthy at this point :(
21:58:09 <ttx> devananda: sure, but are you making progress ?
21:58:14 <devananda> yes :)
21:58:19 <ttx> good :)
21:58:21 <devananda> not as fast as I'd like, but yes :)
21:58:25 <ttx> Any question ?
21:58:34 <devananda> nope. that ^ explanation was very helpful
21:58:42 <hub_cap> +1 devananda
21:58:52 <hub_cap> my only Q tho ttx on it
21:58:53 <ttx> I think that explanation is in the wiki somewhere
21:59:06 <hub_cap> was once we have a fix commited in h2, how does it get into the h2 backport?
21:59:18 <hub_cap> we can take offline if needed, dont wanna hog gabrielhurley's meeting time
21:59:40 <ttx> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/PTLguide#Backporting_fixes_to_milestone-proposed_.28Wednesday.2FThursday.29
21:59:44 <hub_cap> perfect
22:00:07 <ttx> pointing to https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/GerritJenkinsGithub#Authoring_Changes_for_milestone-proposed
22:00:22 <ttx> ok, wrapping up
22:00:25 <ttx> thanks everyone
22:00:28 <ttx> #endmeeting