21:02:36 #startmeeting project 21:02:36 Meeting started Tue Sep 3 21:02:36 2013 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is ttx. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 21:02:37 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 21:02:39 The meeting name has been set to 'project' 21:02:41 #link http://wiki.openstack.org/Meetings/ProjectMeeting 21:02:48 #topic General stuff 21:02:55 #info Feature Freeze is EOD tomorrow, together with the havana-3 branch cut 21:03:01 #info havana-3 publication is planned for Friday. 21:03:13 That leaves today and tomorrow to merge stuff, before we defer or use exceptions 21:03:39 sdague, annegentle, mordred: news from QA/Docs/Infra programs ? 21:04:22 o/ 21:04:29 ttx: string freeze and feature freeze coincide, yes? 21:04:40 gabrielhurley: good point, yes 21:04:46 cool, just making sure 21:05:05 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Havana_Release_Schedule 21:05:22 Nova is in the most need of docs based on doc bugs 21:05:24 #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bugs/?field.tag=nova 21:05:52 i really want to figure out how to push for more help from nova contributors on that 21:05:57 we're continuing to reorganize the openstack-manuals repo around the new titles that are overarching for OpenStack 21:06:02 annegentle: I hope feature freeze will drive dozens of developers to help you 21:06:07 Our docs boot camp starts next Monday 21:06:09 we have no shortage of people trying to push features in, so we can probably afford to raise the bar 21:06:12 ttx: I hope so/think so too 21:06:15 russellb: yes 21:06:43 Any other general announcement before we dive into project-specific stuff ? 21:06:59 that's it 21:07:10 #topic Oslo status 21:07:16 markmc: hi! how is France ? 21:07:19 hey 21:07:21 #link https://launchpad.net/oslo/+milestone/havana-3 21:07:21 good, good 21:07:25 very French? 21:07:26 so, I'm not really here :) 21:07:34 2 Low blueprints left 21:07:37 well, my whiskey is irish right now 21:07:45 guru-meditation-report looks extremely close, with a small test mismatch 21:07:47 yeah, so looks like the guru meditation one is almost merged 21:07:56 cache-backend-abstraction looks a bit more far away 21:08:00 right, agree 21:08:14 these are the two that don't pose a regression risk 21:08:18 markmc: would you require a FFe for things that wouldn't merge by tomorrow's deadline ? 21:08:30 how about we defer cache-backend-abstraction to icehouse 21:08:38 and give guru-meditation-report another week 21:08:54 we can require the FFE process if you like 21:08:57 * markmc is easy 21:09:05 mostly because they don't pose a risk 21:09:06 markmc: ok, so one FFe for guru-meditation-report if it needs a couple more days 21:09:14 ok 21:09:18 I'll look at it tomorrow, but should be fine 21:09:24 great, ahsnk 21:09:25 Questions about Oslo ? 21:09:26 thanks 21:09:41 markmc: you can return to your Muscat 21:09:48 thanks :) 21:09:50 #topic Keystone status 21:09:56 dolphm: hello! 21:09:57 o/ 21:10:05 #link https://launchpad.net/keystone/+milestone/havana-3 21:10:15 2 blueprints left 21:10:24 which was the same blueprint last week :) 21:10:26 bp list-limiting was split from bp filtering-backend-support 21:10:33 right 21:10:43 how far is that ? Can be merged today or tomorrow ? 21:10:47 they've both been in review, but it was sort of two features rolled into one, so the blueprints and reviews were both split apart 21:10:53 83% done, 16% under review, 0% in progress, 0% not started 21:11:31 feature complete and in review, but not user-facing or exposing anything new for havana (so not a big deal if it doesn't land) 21:11:41 dolphm: ok 21:12:00 Would you require a feature freeze exception for it if it fails to land by tomorrow ? 21:12:15 no 21:12:30 ok, merge or wait. Perfect. 21:12:36 You have 4 havana-3 bugs... anything h3-critical in there ? Or should I just defer to RC1 anything that doesn't make it ? 21:13:11 none of those should block havana-3 21:13:24 dolphm: OK. anything specific you wanted to tell us ? 21:13:38 nope! 21:13:49 happy feature freeze, everyone! 21:13:58 #topic Ceilometer status 21:14:02 jd__: hey 21:14:07 o/ 21:14:08 #link https://launchpad.net/ceilometer/+milestone/havana-3 21:14:14 61% done, 23% under review, 15% in progress, 0% not started 21:14:27 5 >Low blueprints left 21:14:50 at this stage I don't think any low bp not started will go in indeed :) 21:14:59 jd__: heh 21:15:00 Quick status update 21:15:18 Is api-group-by likely to land by tomorrow ? 21:15:36 ttx: no 21:16:07 jd__: would you consider requesting a FeatureFreeze exception for it ? Or defer to icehouse ? 21:16:18 FFE 21:16:42 jd__: ok, we'll discuss it together tomorrow 21:16:49 ack 21:17:07 what about alarm-service-patitioner / alarm-audit-api ? 21:17:29 all the patches have been presented for review now 21:17:45 so we just need to ping-pong with eglynn at this stage to get things merged 21:17:47 it looks pretty good 21:18:17 jd__: ok, so that might merge. If it doesn't, would you do a FFE for that as well ? 21:18:43 very likely 21:18:52 same for alarming-logical-combination ? 21:19:01 yep 21:19:11 paginate-db-search is medium, would that be deferred if it doesn't make it ? 21:19:21 yes, it could be deferred 21:19:43 jd__: ok, we'll look how disruptive those FFE features are and how much more time they actually need 21:19:50 will ping you tomorrow 21:19:54 not much I hope :) ok! 21:19:59 You have 6 havana-3 bugs... anything h3-critical in there ? 21:20:10 Maybe https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1219776 ? 21:20:11 Launchpad bug 1219776 in ceilometer "PostgreSQL migration is broken" [Critical,In progress] 21:20:23 or should I just defer to RC1 anything else that doesn't make it ? 21:20:25 yes this one break devstack-gate actually 21:20:36 ah, sounds worthy of a backport then 21:20:37 the other can be deferred 21:20:41 ok, thx 21:20:45 jd__: anything you wanted to mention ? 21:20:49 nop 21:20:55 cool, thx 21:20:59 #topic Swift status 21:21:02 notmyname: o/ 21:21:05 hello 21:21:06 #link https://launchpad.net/swift/+milestone/1.9.3 21:21:12 * notmyname hasn't updated LP yet :-( 21:21:26 notmyname: anything specific you wanted to raise ? 21:21:47 we're thinking of splitting of the swift-bench bin into a separate repo 21:22:00 still under discussion 21:22:17 things are coming along well for the havana release 21:22:28 notmyname: sounds doable to me 21:22:33 the big stuff right now is finishing up the DiskFile abstraction 21:22:38 and the DBBroker abstraction 21:23:18 other than that, we're still doing well 21:23:20 notmyname: sounds interesting. Will read blueprints when you file them :P 21:23:27 I think there is one :-) 21:23:34 just need targeting, and perhaps split 21:23:38 ok :) 21:23:41 Questions about Swift ? 21:24:20 notmyname: thx! 21:24:24 #topic Glance status 21:24:33 markwash: o/ 21:24:36 #link https://launchpad.net/glance/+milestone/havana-3 21:24:41 71% done, 28% under review, 0% in progress, 0% not started 21:24:44 o/ 21:24:50 2 blueprints left 21:24:57 all reviews are submitted 21:25:03 My favorite, api-v2-property-protection 21:25:06 glance scrubber refactoring should roll in tonight 21:25:17 markwash: ok 21:25:20 api v2 property protection is fighting its way off the ropes 21:25:25 Anything you think would need a feature freeze exception if it fails to land by tomorrow ? 21:25:58 protected properties if it feels close enough 21:26:01 I'm generally fine with FFEs if it's likely that adding a few days will make a difference 21:26:18 ok, we'll discuss it when/if necessary 21:26:35 there is a bp in next (async processing) that might be ready soon if we have enough bandwidth 21:26:46 and get lucky 21:26:53 ok, we'll retroactively add it to h3 if it makes it 21:26:54 You have 4 havana3-targeted bugs... 21:27:03 Any chance bug 1213241 will be covered before EOD Thursday ? Looks heavy 21:27:04 Launchpad bug 1213241 in glance "Pickled data in Glance database enables remote code execution" [Critical,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1213241 21:28:25 I think it should be easy to do. I am taking it on 21:28:25 should have updated the assignee 21:28:25 can you clarify the timing on these things. I'm confused about the gap between FF and RC 21:28:38 sure 21:28:44 what is expected to happen during that time? known bugs? or only unknowns that pop up? 21:29:06 Very early thursday morning I'll cut a release branch for H3 (milestone-proposed) 21:29:18 we can still backport H3-critical bugfixes to it 21:29:38 early thursday morning == what time UTC? 21:29:41 To track that, we clean up the H3 bug list so that it only contains stuff we'll go through the hassle to backport 21:30:12 I'd say 0800 UTC. Some people would call it "late on Wednesday". I call it "EOD Wednesday" 21:30:52 so at what point does I1 effectively open up? 21:31:01 markwash: but we can still backport bugfixes that land in master, to milestone-proposed 21:31:11 until H3 publication. 21:31:14 * markwash is sorry he has not completely clarified this for himself before 21:31:18 I1 opens up after RC1 21:31:36 (the icehouse development branch opens once you produce a first release candidate 21:31:46 gotcha 21:31:52 Details at https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/ReleaseCycle 21:32:15 So I'll keep that critical bug in the buglist and defer the others to the RC1 buglist 21:32:21 markwash: anything you wanted to mention ? 21:32:37 I'm good, thank you for the hand-holding 21:32:48 markwash: np 21:32:48 #topic Neutron status 21:32:53 markmcclain: hi! 21:32:56 #link https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/havana-3 21:33:00 70% done, 29% under review, 0% in progress, 0% not started 21:33:09 lots of recent progress I see 21:33:20 hi 21:33:32 yes.. lots of reviews lately 21:33:38 So that's 15 >Low blueprints still in progress... 21:33:53 How is ipsec-vpn-reference going ? 21:34:01 it is in final testing 21:34:05 I expect it to merge 21:34:11 ok 21:34:29 markmcclain: Would you consider granting a feature freeze exception to any of those 15 if they fail to make it by EOD tomorrow ? 21:34:42 service nagios3 restart 21:34:51 NobodyCam: [ OK ] 21:34:53 doh 21:34:59 sorry 21:35:09 there are 2 that might be good candidates for an FFE 21:35:31 they're relatively isolated from rest of code base and the code is already written 21:35:40 just need to bake a bit more 21:35:50 markmcclain: names, for reference ? 21:36:24 (I'll defer everything else that doesn't make it, and keep those ones for us to review) 21:36:33 VCNS and NVP Firewall Plugin 21:36:47 thx! You also have 34 H3-targeted bugs. Is there anythign H3-critical in there ? Or can I just defer to RC1 anything that isn't FixCommitted when I cut the branch ? 21:36:47 sounds good 21:37:20 deferring should be fine.. I'll scan the list again tomorrow to double check 21:37:31 markmcclain: ok. anything else you wanted to raise ? 21:37:40 nothing new 21:37:51 markmcclain: ok, thx! 21:37:52 #topic Cinder status 21:37:56 jgriffith: hola! 21:37:59 #link https://launchpad.net/cinder/+milestone/havana-3 21:38:00 hey there 21:38:05 73% done, 26% under review, 0% in progress, 0% not started 21:38:11 Also lots of progress recently 21:38:17 working on it 21:38:22 I expect a few more to land tonight 21:38:29 5 Medium blueprints still in progress 21:38:32 and a couple I think I'm going to kick out 21:38:43 * jgriffith is looking... 21:38:55 Would you consider a feature freeze exception for any of those ? 21:39:14 ttx: nope 21:39:20 ttx: 3 of them I expect to land today 21:39:28 if they don't I'd consider exceptions 21:39:39 qemu assisted snaps, zadara and vmdk driver 21:39:42 ok 21:39:57 You've also got 8 H3-targeted bugs.. anything H3-critical in there ? 21:40:09 I expect this to sort itself pretty well by tmororw night 21:40:12 (bug 1219950 is not assigned to anyone fwiw) 21:40:15 Launchpad bug 1219950 in cinder "C:\iSCSIVirtualDisks dir created during tests" [Undecided,New] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1219950 21:40:31 jgriffith: ok, anything else on your mind ? 21:40:32 thanks... I missed that one 21:40:47 nope, not for now 21:40:51 Questions on Cinder ? 21:41:12 #topic Nova status 21:41:12 russellb: hey 21:41:16 #link https://launchpad.net/nova/+milestone/havana-3 21:41:18 hey 21:41:20 64% done, 35% under review, 0% in progress, 0% not started 21:41:25 progress 21:41:33 a lot of it is really close 21:41:36 we're pushing hard 21:41:46 Nice progress but still a long way to go... 15 >Low blueprints 21:41:56 Quick status update on the "High" prio stuff... 21:42:06 yeah, i know a lot will get deferred, i accepted that a while ago, heh 21:42:07 How is compute-api-objects going on ? 21:42:20 it's fine, there's still some patches up for review 21:42:28 but we basically rescoped it to covered what we *know* will make it 21:42:35 so just tying up the last ends on it 21:42:42 russellb: heh 21:42:44 :) 21:42:50 encrypt-cinder-volumes ? 21:42:58 the two encryption ones are probably going to get deferred 21:43:04 i'm giving it a little more time for a ML discussion to play out 21:43:12 ok 21:43:19 fix-libvirt-console-logging ? 21:43:20 but basically ... it's not *actually* usable ... 21:43:22 heh 21:43:33 libvirt console logging has promise, needs review time, but can make it i think 21:43:38 fwiw that would be (actually is) considered a bug 21:43:49 true, so I definitely think we can make an exception for it 21:43:53 it's just a significant bugfix :) 21:43:58 right 21:44:07 improve-block-device-handling ? 21:44:21 i expect an update on that one first thing in the morning to cover last bit of concern, then it will be merged tomorrow 21:44:40 cold-migrations-to-conductor and live-migration-to-conductor ? 21:44:42 cold migration to conductor doesn't look good, will probably get deferred 21:44:54 live migration looks in good shape, last patch under review, can make it 21:44:58 Could any of these trigger a featurefreeze exception request ? 21:45:04 yes 21:45:09 primarily the libvirt console log one 21:45:29 and compute-api-objects in case its new scope needs a couple more hours 21:45:30 live migration to conductor and improve block devices as well ... 21:45:38 but only because i think it would just need another day if so 21:45:42 right 21:45:43 yeah 21:45:57 What about the Medium-prio ones ? Any FFE candidate lost in there ? 21:46:12 i'm not seeing anything that would get an exception other than just needing a couple extra days for review time / final tweaks 21:46:15 Port to oslo.messaging ? 21:46:28 port to oslo.messaging ... markmc has been aggressively updating that and rebasing it 21:46:32 just needs review time 21:46:40 can I ask about https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/hyper-v-rdp-console ? The Nova reviews are under review but nothing's merged. There's a Horizon review to support that feature, but if it's not gonna land in Nova then it needs to be pushed off. 21:46:41 poor guy is chasing it hard on vacation too 21:46:50 could use a FFE too ? 21:46:55 ttx: yes 21:47:01 gabrielhurley: seems incredibly unlikely to make it 21:47:08 cool. that's all I needed to know. :-) 21:47:11 gabrielhurley: it's fairly complex, and a bit down the list 21:47:26 russellb: You've got like 37 bugs targeted to H3, are any of those H3 blockers ? 21:47:32 Maybe one of the 4 critical ones ? 21:47:40 err. 3 21:47:41 bug 1216720 21:47:43 Launchpad bug 1216720 in nova "Security groups with source groups no longer work" [Critical,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1216720 21:47:56 not sure if it's an h3 blocker ... definitely an rc blocker though 21:48:06 i know vishy saw it 21:48:09 agreed, the other two don't sound that critical to me 21:48:10 (related to a patch he did) 21:48:12 yeah same 21:48:17 just haven't made it to review/lower them 21:48:22 OK, will defer them to RC1 if they don't make it by branch cut time. 21:48:28 lots of people like to mark their bugs as ciritical :-) 21:48:33 sounds perfect 21:48:41 that's why we have guidelines to protect us from them 21:48:54 https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Bugs 21:49:02 russellb: anything else you wanted to mention ? 21:49:07 don't think so 21:49:13 Any question on Nova ? 21:49:19 just general request for understanding on the stuff that doesn't make it :-) 21:49:34 the heat is really turning up on me this week on that stuff, heh 21:49:57 queue the glenn frey song 21:50:00 that's what happens when 100 blueprints are delievered in the last dev milestone :-) 21:50:13 that's it, thanks! 21:50:35 russellb: yes, I don't know how to set expectations right... people submitting their work for H3 should know it has chances to skip 21:50:51 russellb: but they are always surprised 21:50:54 yep 21:50:59 #topic Heat status 21:51:01 shardy: o/ 21:51:05 o/ 21:51:06 #link https://launchpad.net/heat/+milestone/havana-3 21:51:11 85% done, 14% under review, 0% in progress, 0% not started 21:51:14 nearly there.. 21:51:24 4 blueprints left... quick status update on the high-prio ones: 21:51:31 one* 21:51:35 heat-trusts and parallel-delete are really close 21:51:36 heat-trusts 21:52:00 yep, I think that should make it by EOD tomorrow, down to very minor comments now after several iterations 21:52:13 similar with parallel-delete I think 21:52:21 Anything you'd consider asking a feature freeze exception for in the unlikely case it doesn't make it in time? heat-trusts ? 21:52:30 I'm less confident about vpnaas and UpdatePolicy 21:52:47 Yep definitely heat-trusts, and probably parallel-delete 21:53:08 I'd like the others to land, but if they don't I think we'll bump them as it probably means too much review rework 21:53:51 right. And even if you could handle them... we need to reduce disruption to let QA/Docs catch up with the added features 21:54:15 9 bugs targeted to H3, any H3 blocker in them ? 21:54:17 yep, both were really proposed too late 21:54:40 No, I think we can just defer any which don't land in time to rc1 21:54:49 ok willdo 21:54:54 shardy: anything else you want to raise ? 21:55:03 No, all good, thanks! 21:55:09 thanks! 21:55:10 #topic Horizon status 21:55:14 gabrielhurley: o/ 21:55:16 Lemme make this easy ;-) 21:55:17 The bugs all have patches and will likely merge today. The custom CA cert blueprint is merging currently. That just leaves the Cisco N1K/custom router dashboard BP, which is perenially pretty close, but is so narrow in scope and so isolated that I'm not unlikely to FFE it if it doesn't make it in time. There are a handful of bugs I've already marked as RC1. 21:55:20 #link https://launchpad.net/horizon/+milestone/havana-3 21:56:13 leaves me speechless 21:56:16 "not unlikely"... that was a nice double-negative 21:56:22 100% done, 0% under review, 0% in progress, 0% not started 21:56:49 100% for > Low, yeah 21:56:50 :-) 21:56:53 Looks like custom CA is marked implemented now 21:56:55 my team kicked ass these last few weeks 21:57:05 it *just* merged, literally right now 21:57:13 heh 21:57:36 ok then, anything else on Horizon? 21:57:42 nope, we're good 21:58:08 gabrielhurley: next cycle you should go first so that you don't have the full hour to prepare answers for my repetitive questions 21:58:12 haha 21:58:18 #topic Incubated projects 21:58:21 a challenge. I like it 21:58:40 devananda, hub_cap, NobodyCam: 2 minutes, any question ? 21:58:48 2 things, 1) we need more time for this next cycle lol 21:58:50 and 2) 21:58:51 hugs 21:58:55 just notes that ironics devs are starting to come back from vacation 21:59:09 #info Trove graduated from incubation and will be part of the Icehouse integrated release in 7 months 21:59:28 +1 21:59:32 #info Ironic will do incubation for another cycle 21:59:42 :) 21:59:59 Trove havana-3 looking almost done: https://launchpad.net/trove/+milestone/havana-3 22:00:25 #endmeeting