21:02:29 <ttx> #startmeeting project
21:02:30 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Oct  8 21:02:29 2013 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is ttx. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
21:02:32 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
21:02:34 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'project'
21:02:36 <ttx> #link http://wiki.openstack.org/Meetings/ProjectMeeting
21:02:45 <ttx> #topic General stuff
21:02:58 <ttx> #info 9 days to release, RC1s published for everything but Swift at this point
21:03:07 <jd__> o/
21:03:13 <shardy> o/
21:03:15 <ttx> #info At the end of the week I plan to switch to "safe, extremely release-critical fixes only" mode
21:03:22 <notmyname> swift should be ready Real Soon Now
21:03:26 <ttx> #info So if you have "embarassing but not critical" bugs, we should handle them in a RC2 window this week
21:03:46 <ttx> We'll go into details for each project as the situation is difefrent for everyone
21:03:49 <ttx> sdague, annegentle, jeblair: anything from QA/Docs/Infra programs ?
21:04:16 <sdague> a number of the races look addressed that were a part of the rc run up - http://status.openstack.org/elastic-recheck/
21:04:28 <ttx> annegentle_: how is doc release shaping up ?
21:04:39 <jgriffith> o/
21:04:43 <sdague> however, the neutron ones are still problematic, Bug 1224001 in particular
21:04:45 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1224001 in neutron "test_network_basic_ops fails waiting for network to become available" [Critical,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1224001
21:05:10 <markmcclain> sdague: we merged a fix for that today
21:05:17 <sdague> markmcclain: ok, great
21:05:22 <markmcclain> a system util was causing a kernel fault
21:05:29 <sdague> interesting
21:05:47 <ttx> annegentle_, jeblair: anything to mention ?
21:05:55 <jeblair> ttx: no, thanks
21:06:33 <ttx> #topic Oslo status
21:06:38 <ttx> markmc: hi
21:06:42 <ttx> #info Oslo stable/havana branch was cut
21:06:48 <markmc> good evening
21:06:52 <ttx> Any critical bugfix that would need urgent codecopy to consuming projects ?
21:06:54 <markmc> I had a look over bugs and reviews
21:07:00 <markmc> don't see anything scarey
21:07:08 <ttx> good thing :)
21:07:27 <ttx> markmc: anything you wanted to mention ?
21:07:36 <markmc> nope, all quiet on the oslo front
21:07:38 <ttx> Questions about Oslo ?
21:07:39 <markmc> dhellmann, you?
21:07:52 <dhellmann> nothing from me
21:07:58 <markmc> cool
21:08:02 <ttx> cool
21:08:04 <ttx> #topic Keystone status
21:08:07 <dolphm> o/
21:08:11 <ttx> moar time for the others
21:08:14 <ttx> dolphm: hi!
21:08:18 <ttx> #info Keystone RC1 is out
21:08:31 <ttx> No bug on the havana-rc-potential list:
21:08:34 <ttx> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/keystone/+bugs?field.tag=havana-rc-potential
21:08:40 <dolphm> i've been using havana-backport-potential :(
21:08:47 <ttx> ha. ha.
21:08:51 <dolphm> https://bugs.launchpad.net/keystone/+bugs?field.tag=havana-backport-potential
21:08:53 * ttx looks
21:09:19 <ttx> anything you think is critical enough to warrant an RC2 ?
21:09:27 <dolphm> the only bug i think warrants an RC is https://bugs.launchpad.net/keystone/+bug/1234873
21:09:28 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1234873 in keystone "restarting mysql, Keystone doesn't reconnect, AttributeError" [High,Fix committed]
21:09:28 * ttx looks into that high one
21:09:38 <dolphm> it's a one line, obvious fix
21:09:47 <ttx> ew, that one is pretty ugly indeed
21:10:10 <ttx> if we open an RC2 window now what else would you include in it ?
21:10:31 <ttx> bug 1233329 (also fixcommitted)
21:10:32 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1233329 in keystone "034 migration fails for SQLite if there is data in the user table" [Medium,Fix committed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1233329
21:10:33 <dolphm> if we have a clean way to backport a fix to https://bugs.launchpad.net/keystone/+bug/1231657 -- i'd like to include taht
21:10:35 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1231657 in keystone "DB2 disconnect not handled pessimistically" [Medium,In progress]
21:10:43 <dolphm> in master, we're fixing the same issue by switching to oslo.db
21:11:03 <dolphm> so that wouldn't quite be backportable unless we slip a discrete fix into master first, then nuke it with oslo.db
21:11:24 <ttx> dolphm: it's fine to not cherrypick in that case
21:11:50 <ttx> dolphm: we just need to be extra careful with the patch though
21:12:09 <dolphm> understood
21:12:15 <dolphm> the fix would be coming from oslo code either way
21:12:33 <ttx> dolphm: ok, let's open a RC2 window now with 1234873 1233329 and 1231657
21:12:44 <dolphm> it'll either be oslo-incubator to keystone.common.sql.core, or the fix will be in keystone.openstack.common.db
21:13:00 <ttx> dolphm: note that we have https://review.openstack.org/#/c/50455/ proposed already ?
21:13:24 <ttx> dolphm: will talk to you just after meeting to create the RC2 and target stuff to it
21:13:28 <dolphm> oh interesting, thanks
21:13:38 <ttx> dolphm: you can look into that one in the mean time
21:13:46 <ttx> Anything else that may affect us ?
21:13:55 <dolphm> that is all!
21:13:57 <ttx> Other news / questions about Keystone ?
21:14:24 <ttx> #topic Ceilometer status
21:14:28 <ttx> jd__: hey
21:14:32 <jd__> yop
21:14:33 <ttx> #info Ceilometer RC1 is out
21:14:45 <ttx> A few bugs on the havana-rc-potential list, but nothing serious enough to trigger RC2 so far ?
21:14:50 <ttx> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/ceilometer/+bugs?field.tag=havana-rc-potential
21:14:58 <jd__> no indeed
21:15:14 <ttx> Anything standing between you and release at this time that I should know about ?
21:15:48 <jd__> nothing nor nobody
21:15:54 <ttx> OK, you should probably start working on the release notes then :)
21:16:03 <ttx> we'll do another checkpoint on Thursday
21:16:08 <jd__> ack
21:16:13 <ttx> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/ReleaseNotes/Havana
21:16:18 <ttx> Other news / questions about Ceilometer ?
21:16:36 <jd__> no news
21:16:57 <ttx> #topic Swift status
21:17:01 <ttx> notmyname: o/
21:17:06 <notmyname> hello!
21:17:07 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/swift/+milestone/1.10.0-rc1
21:17:14 <ttx> You told me you're likely to give me a SHA for 1.10.0-rc1 later today ?
21:17:21 <notmyname> that's the plan :-)
21:17:29 <notmyname> getting the final reviews for the in progress bugs
21:17:45 <ttx> OK, the three inporgress bugs left are the last blockers ?
21:17:51 <ttx> inprogress*
21:18:09 <notmyname> the memcache one (the high priority one) is the most important.
21:18:16 <notmyname> ttx: but ya, that's all I'm tracking right now
21:18:34 <ttx> OK, just send me an email if you complete all today and I'll will create havana release branch ("milestone-proposed") and tag from it first thing tomorrow
21:18:43 <notmyname> ttx: worst case, if the med priority ones don't land, it's not a blocker
21:18:57 <notmyname> ttx: ok, I'll let you know asap
21:19:03 <ttx> ok just make sure https://launchpad.net/swift/+milestone/1.10.0-rc1 looks all Implemented and FixCommitted by the end of your day :)
21:19:08 <notmyname> ttx: I also have the authors/changelog update proposed. just needs to land
21:19:10 <ttx> (can be done by punting some bugs out)
21:19:12 <notmyname> ok
21:19:24 <ttx> Note that once you send me the SHA you can consider master opened for Icehouse business
21:19:33 <ttx> since I'll branch from there
21:19:36 <notmyname> sounds good
21:19:46 <ttx> Other news / questions about Swift ?
21:19:52 <notmyname> I'm good
21:20:03 <ttx> notmyname: thx!
21:20:19 <ttx> #topic Glance status
21:20:23 <ttx> markwash: o/
21:20:23 <markwash> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/glance/+bugs?field.tag=havana-rc-potential
21:20:27 <ttx> #info Glance RC1 is out
21:20:28 <markwash> o/
21:20:51 <ttx> A few "Critical" bugs on the havana-rc-potential list, but no fixes yet
21:21:08 <markwash> Yes, I just updated that list to reflect what I hope to accomplish for rc2 by this week
21:21:25 <ttx> markwash: shall we open an RC2 window now with the critical ones there ?
21:21:37 <markwash> ttx: yes please
21:22:08 <ttx> markwash: shall we add all those to the RC2 list ? We can refine later if it goes west
21:22:23 <markwash> yes, I guess I'm missing out on some of the mechanics here (as usual)
21:22:45 <ttx> markwash: I'll convert the tagged list to a RC2-targeted list just after meeting
21:23:02 <markwash> from what I definitely understand, I want to get those patches approved in master, and then hope that they apply cleanly to rc2 / milestone proposed whichever branch
21:23:11 * markwash hopes that makes sense
21:23:48 <ttx> markwash: the fix needs to land in master first
21:23:52 <markwash> right
21:24:00 <markwash> approved / landed
21:24:01 <ttx> so the easiest is to only propose to milestone-proposed when that happens
21:24:09 <markwash> sounds good to me!
21:24:18 <ttx> I can check them and approve them wen they are proposed to m-p
21:24:35 <ttx> so... the easiest is... you backport and I check :)
21:24:43 <markwash> +1
21:24:46 <markwash> sounds like the right way to go
21:24:56 <ttx> don't forget to work on https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/ReleaseNotes/Havana at some point too
21:25:02 <markwash> thanks for the reminder
21:25:18 <ttx> We'll refine the RC2 list on Thursday so that we complete the RC2 by end of week
21:25:34 <ttx> Other news / questions about Glance ?
21:25:47 <markwash> that's it from me!
21:25:51 <markwash> Two new core members!
21:25:55 <ttx> yay
21:25:57 <markwash> zhiyan and flwang
21:26:06 <ttx> #topic Neutron status
21:26:10 <ttx> markmcclain: hola
21:26:11 <markmcclain> hi
21:26:17 <ttx> #info Neutron RC1 is out, RC2 window already opened
21:26:21 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/havana-rc2
21:26:34 <ttx> 6 backports needed
21:26:42 <ttx> 2 bugs with master fixes in progress
21:27:22 <ttx> of the 6 backports some were already proposed and are stuck at various stages in the queue
21:27:38 <ttx> markmcclain: how far are you for those last two master fixes ?
21:27:51 <ttx> bug 1224001
21:27:53 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1224001 in neutron "test_network_basic_ops fails waiting for network to become available" [Critical,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1224001
21:27:58 <ttx> bug 1236970
21:27:59 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1236970 in neutron "plumgrid plugin is missing quota table" [High,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1236970
21:28:26 <markmcclain> plumgrid not too far off
21:28:45 <markmcclain> 1224001: already merged https://review.openstack.org/#/c/50424/
21:29:11 <ttx> hmm, is it partial-bug then ?
21:29:16 <ttx> or closes-bug ?
21:29:21 <markmcclain> was waiting to officially call this one fixed
21:29:49 <ttx> Let's make it tentatively FixReleased ?
21:30:03 <ttx> so that we know we are not waiting on something ?
21:30:20 <markmcclain> yeah that works for me
21:30:38 <ttx> done
21:31:00 <ttx> markmcclain: so you are in good shape for the RC2. Anything else you want to add to it ?
21:31:24 <markmcclain> yeah I think we're ok for now
21:31:32 <markmcclain> nothing else new from me
21:31:45 <ttx> markmcclain: if we are still ok tomorrow we might just cut it
21:31:57 <ttx> (if all merges)
21:32:05 <ttx> Don't forget to work on https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/ReleaseNotes/Havana too
21:32:09 <markmcclain> ok.. that works for me
21:32:12 <ttx> Other news / questions about Neutron ?
21:32:18 <markmcclain> thanks for the reminder.. I'll update
21:32:47 <ttx> #topic Cinder status
21:32:50 <ttx> jgriffith: hi!
21:32:57 <ttx> #info Cinder RC1 is out
21:33:29 <ttx> A few "High" bugs on the havana-rc-potential list, but only fix is bug 1235187
21:33:30 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1235187 in cinder "VMware: Failed to create volume from image after session timeout" [Undecided,Fix committed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1235187
21:33:36 <ttx> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/cinder/+bugs?field.tag=havana-rc-potential
21:34:15 <jgriffith> ttx: hola
21:34:18 <jgriffith> bad wifi
21:34:31 <ttx> jgriffith: would you consider any of those RC2-worthy, if they get fixed before end of week ?
21:34:41 <jgriffith> so far my answer has been no
21:34:55 <jgriffith> The only one I care about is the glance API spec
21:35:08 <ttx> jgriffith: Right, let's do another checkpoint on Thursday but I'd say at this point a RC2 is not warranted
21:35:15 <jgriffith> agreed
21:35:23 <ttx> OK, maybe use your time to start working on the Havana release notes :)
21:35:29 <jgriffith> Yes :(
21:35:36 * jgriffith has been remiss
21:35:48 <ttx> the funniest part of the PTL job. You should delegate that one :)
21:35:54 <ttx> Other news / questions about Cinder ?
21:35:58 <jgriffith> ha!  Indeed I should
21:36:11 <jgriffith> last check we've all but eradicated the gate issues
21:36:14 <jgriffith> I'm happy about that
21:36:24 <ttx> "want to be ptl in place of the PTL ? Start by doing my release notes"
21:36:25 <jgriffith> s/issues/failing cinder items/
21:36:32 <jgriffith> haha!
21:37:02 <jgriffith> I may try that approach :)
21:37:02 <ttx> jgriffith: yes, the gate is in way better shape this week. Makes me less worried about spinning RCs
21:37:09 <jgriffith> indeed
21:37:15 <jgriffith> was frightened last week
21:37:35 <jgriffith> anyway... I'm good with RC1 so far
21:37:51 <ttx> jgriffith: ok thx!
21:37:54 <ttx> #topic Nova status
21:37:58 <ttx> russellb: hi!
21:38:06 <ttx> #info Nova RC1 is out
21:38:18 <ttx> Lots of bugs on the havana-rc-potential list:
21:38:22 <ttx> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bugs?field.tag=havana-rc-potential
21:39:34 <ttx> Do we have a russellb around ?
21:39:40 <russellb> yep
21:39:40 <russellb> sorry
21:39:52 <ttx> russellb: No fix worthy of an RC2 at this point though, right ?
21:39:52 <russellb> i've been very strict on RC bugs as we led up to rc1
21:39:56 <russellb> right
21:40:01 <russellb> IMO, anyway
21:40:05 <russellb> but will be watching this week
21:40:15 <russellb> (and next week)
21:40:37 <ttx> ok, we'll do another checkpoint tomorrow
21:40:45 <russellb> sounds good
21:41:11 <ttx> but you seem to have a solid release so far
21:41:15 <russellb> \o/
21:41:15 <ttx> Other news / questions about Nova ?
21:41:21 <russellb> i know i need to do release notes too
21:41:29 <russellb> we've at least been tracking some upgrade notes along the way
21:41:35 <russellb> but i'll flesh all that out soon
21:41:45 <ttx> there is a bit of NOva info in i, which is why you don't get the painful ping
21:41:49 <russellb> heh
21:41:59 <russellb> i created the page early in the cycle to start tracking stuff :)
21:42:21 <ttx> #topic Heat status
21:42:25 <ttx> shardy: o/
21:42:28 <shardy> o/
21:42:31 <ttx> #info Heat RC1 is out, RC2 window already opened
21:42:36 <ttx> #link https://launchpad.net/heat/+milestone/havana-rc2
21:42:48 <ttx> We have 6 open bugs -- are they all likely to be fixed in the next few days ?
21:43:06 <shardy> Yes, I think so, mostly small but fairly important fixes AFAICS
21:43:22 <shardy> I'll chase through the reviews and patches tomorrow
21:43:30 <ttx> shardy: yes, so far your fixes were pretty well-contained, I enjoyed reviewing them
21:43:37 <ttx> as in: I actually understood them
21:43:57 <shardy> Yeah, mostly pretty simple fixes, so far :)
21:44:09 <ttx> I'd like to publish your RC2 before the end of the week
21:44:20 <ttx> so I'll track progress on those last 6 closely
21:44:25 <shardy> Yep, that sounds good, and I think we should be on-target for that
21:44:37 <ttx> You need to start working on https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/ReleaseNotes/Havana , too
21:44:56 <shardy> Yes, will do
21:44:58 <ttx> usually between RC windows :)
21:45:08 <ttx> Other news / questions about Heat ?
21:45:18 <shardy> That's all from me, thanks!
21:45:28 <ttx> shardy: thx!
21:45:39 <ttx> #topic Horizon status
21:45:41 <gabrielhurley> \o
21:45:43 <ttx> gabrielhurley: o/
21:45:47 <ttx> #info Horizon RC1 is out
21:45:53 <ttx> A few interesting things on your havana-rc-potential list:
21:45:57 <ttx> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/horizon/+bugs?field.tag=havana-rc-potential
21:46:00 <gabrielhurley> I think a Horizon RC2 would be a good idea, while not strictly required.
21:46:09 <gabrielhurley> https://bugs.launchpad.net/horizon/+bug/1235053 is the most notable bug
21:46:11 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1235053 in horizon "Create Project: Unable to retrieve default quota values" [High,Fix committed]
21:46:20 <gabrielhurley> but https://bugs.launchpad.net/horizon/+bug/1234317 would be great to do
21:46:22 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1234317 in horizon "Need another translation imports for Havana release" [High,Confirmed]
21:46:23 <ttx> yes
21:46:33 <gabrielhurley> and https://bugs.launchpad.net/horizon/+bug/1211535 is a nice-to-have
21:46:36 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1211535 in horizon "HorizonMiddleware class causes excessive session creation" [Medium,In progress]
21:46:36 <ttx> I think we can open a RC2 window now
21:46:55 <ttx> and target those two "high" + any fixcommitted left on the list
21:47:01 <gabrielhurley> I'd almost do it just to hae the extra week and a half of translations, but those two bugs seem worthwhile
21:47:03 <ttx> like that typo
21:47:04 <gabrielhurley> yep
21:47:05 <gabrielhurley> sounds good
21:47:17 <ttx> will be on it just after meeting
21:47:23 <gabrielhurley> perfect
21:47:35 <gabrielhurley> I haven't seen any other noteable bugs come in though, which is a good sign
21:47:54 <ttx> will push 1211535 on the list as requested
21:48:04 <ttx> we can refine it out if the fix doesn't come in time
21:48:15 <ttx> objective is to publish Thursday or Friday
21:48:23 <gabrielhurley> sounds good
21:48:28 <ttx> and then go into retentive mode
21:48:40 <gabrielhurley> we'll get these all taken care of quick
21:48:48 <ttx> Note that we already have a backport proposal for the fix for bug 1234119
21:48:49 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1234119 in horizon "typo: "gruop" and "remove from"" [Low,Fix committed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1234119
21:49:00 <ttx> I'll unfreeze it when properly targeted
21:49:07 <ttx> Also you'll have to copy some of your internal release notes to https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/ReleaseNotes/Havana
21:49:28 <ttx> Other news / questions about Horizon ?
21:49:38 <gabrielhurley> nope, that's it
21:49:42 <ttx> gabrielhurley: thx!
21:49:59 <ttx> #topic Incubated projects
21:50:22 <ttx> Trove got an RC2 published today
21:50:49 <ttx> that would be the only havana-incubated project I do releases for at this point
21:50:58 <ttx> hub_cap: questions ?
21:51:30 <hub_cap> nosir
21:51:36 <hub_cap> thx for cutting my rc2
21:51:47 <ttx> #topic Open discussion
21:51:51 <ttx> Questions anyone ?
21:52:08 <hub_cap> 1 q... how often does this meeting actually have open discussion?!?!
21:52:11 <hub_cap> :P
21:52:19 <ttx> when I go embarassingly too fast
21:52:29 <ttx> ok, let's end this early so that I can open RC2 windows for Keystone/Glance/Horizon before falling asleep
21:52:43 <hub_cap> thx ttx!
21:52:49 <dolphm> yay
21:52:54 <lifeless> :)
21:52:58 <ttx> if you have questions just ping me on irc
21:53:00 <ttx> #endmeeting