14:09:38 <tobberydberg> #startmeeting publiccloud_sig
14:09:39 <pilgrimstack> Thierry Carrez told me you may be interested about RBAC
14:09:40 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Aug  1 14:09:38 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is tobberydberg. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:09:41 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:09:43 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'publiccloud_sig'
14:10:14 <priteau> tobberydberg: I see you just used publiccloud_sig to start the meeting, should I abandon https://review.opendev.org/#/c/673793/
14:10:15 <pilgrimstack> https://twitter.com/pilgrimstack/status/1155871543647461379
14:10:46 <pilgrimstack> We implemented RBAC in nova, neutron, cinder, glance, swift
14:11:23 <tobberydberg> priteau I guess you can do that :-)
14:11:27 <pilgrimstack> and maybe that could be interested to push it upstream if we are not the only one with that need
14:13:47 <pilgrimstack> Here are more details: http://paste.openstack.org/show/755216/
14:15:20 <tobberydberg> Looks nice pilgrimstack :-)
14:17:47 <tobberydberg> Not sure if you all saw my notice earlier about being caught up in another meeting ... so I mention it here now as well ....
14:18:37 <tobberydberg> priteau I would love to here more from that meeting you had yesterday ... can you post a link to the meeting notes from that?
14:18:53 <priteau> #link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/scientific_sig/2019/scientific_sig.2019-07-31-11.00.log.html
14:19:25 <tobberydberg> thanks
14:19:27 <priteau> This was a discussion around our exploration of using CloudKitty with Monasca, with details online on our blog
14:19:29 <priteau> #link http://www.stackhpc.com/cloudkitty-and-monasca-1.html
14:21:10 <tobberydberg> Nice priteau
14:21:25 <tobberydberg> So, one question for you if you have experience with this ...
14:21:47 <tobberydberg> https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15HtA15Lrf8UhkPqSTzM4Nan08aEUDQmHUl8XS7T2KO0/edit#gid=0
14:22:13 <tobberydberg> In document above we have identiefied some metrics and potential methods of measuring
14:22:56 <tobberydberg> Would be awesome if you could help out with identifying whioch metrics that would be possib le to measure with Monasca
14:23:23 <tobberydberg> More details about this can also be found at #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/publiccloud-sig-billing-implementation-proposal
14:24:01 <priteau> I would be happy to help. By Monasca do you mean pure Monasca-agent? Because you can use Ceilometer + Monasca (topic of the blog post I linked), or Monasca + Prometheus exporters (topic of another blog post to come)
14:25:35 <tobberydberg> I was primarly thinking of Monasca agent in that spreadsheet
14:25:58 <tobberydberg> But if you have experience with others, happy with help there as well! :-)
14:28:49 <priteau> The `instances` row should probably be turned into multiple rows, as you may want to monitor 1) the fact that an instance exists, with some details like flavor type 2) vcpus count 3) memory size 4) disk size 5) cpu utilisation 6) disk io 7) network io
14:29:07 <tobberydberg> So the goal for the near future is to find out which methods for gathering all metrics that is needed (spreadsheet) as well as what backend/s that are best suited
14:29:20 <tobberydberg> Yes ... totally agree priteau
14:29:43 <tobberydberg> the doc is in draft state, feel free to do any changes you like
14:30:28 <tobberydberg> I haven't had the time lately sadly to do much ... hope I can find some time during the vacation :-)
14:32:35 <priteau> Thanks for sharing the current state of your work
14:33:51 <tobberydberg> Well, early in the process indeed :-)
14:38:53 <tobberydberg> So, I will need to step out here full time unfortunate ... I'll leave the meeting open if you would like to continue discuss stuff. I will hopefully be able to moderate the meeting in two weeks ... if not I will write to the mailing list to see if we can find an alternate meeting slot
14:39:23 <tobberydberg> Thanks for today folks! And, feel free to continue :-)
14:42:19 <priteau> Thank you tobberydberg
14:46:52 <peschk_l> Thanks tobberydberg!
14:53:58 <tobberydberg> #endmeeting