09:00:12 <gmann> #startmeeting qa
09:00:13 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Apr  7 09:00:12 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gmann. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
09:00:14 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
09:00:17 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'qa'
09:00:29 <gmann> hi who's here for today?
09:00:32 <masayukig> \o/
09:00:40 <gmann> masayukig: hi
09:00:43 <jlanoux> o/
09:00:55 <gmann> jlanoux: hi
09:01:05 <jlanoux> hi gmann
09:01:06 <masayukig> gmann: jlanoux: hi
09:01:12 <jlanoux> hi masayukig
09:01:17 <masayukig> :)
09:01:32 <dmellado> hi guys o/ ;)
09:01:38 <gmann> dmellado: hi
09:01:42 <tosky> hi
09:01:52 <gmann> tosky: hi
09:01:54 <jlanoux> hi
09:02:12 <gmann> let's start
09:02:24 <gmann> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/QATeamMeeting#Proposed_Agenda_for_April_7th_2016_.280900_UTC.29
09:02:32 <gmann> ^^ today agenda
09:02:51 <gmann> #topic Specs Reviews
09:02:59 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/qa-specs,n,z
09:03:13 <jordanP> hi
09:03:23 <gmann> jordanP: hi
09:03:35 <gmann> Still need to look into client refactor spec
09:03:43 <gmann> did not get time this week
09:03:55 <gmann> I think andrea updated that
09:04:14 <gmann> next one we were discussing yesterday was defcore tag one
09:04:16 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/301879/
09:04:49 <gmann> on discussion i am not in favor of that tag but need to review the spec and add comment there
09:05:24 <gmann> but more people can review that which will be helpful to set right direction for defcore list of tests
09:05:44 <masayukig> I'll look at it
09:06:01 <gmann> masayukig: Thanks
09:06:26 <gmann> next is from oomichi about swagger doc from schema
09:06:29 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/297473/
09:07:01 <gmann> It is pretty straight forward and LGTM except adding description for each element
09:07:36 <gmann> this will be helpful to have nice API doc from swagger or other tool
09:08:11 <gmann> any question or any other spec to discuss?
09:09:01 * gmann very tired today, want to go home early.. :)
09:09:15 <gmann> ok if nothing much let's move to next topic
09:09:33 <gmann> #topic Priority Items
09:09:46 <gmann> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/mitaka-qa-priorities
09:10:08 <gmann> in this first one, microversion one is completed
09:10:26 <masayukig> gmann: great
09:10:44 <gmann> BP is marked as closed and we can start implementing the tests for microversion
09:11:16 <gmann> - Health Dashboard
09:11:37 <gmann> masayukig: you want to update on dashboard if any new thing to know
09:12:16 <masayukig> yeah, we are changing some aggressively.
09:13:26 <masayukig> yup :) And we should have a design summit session for the future.
09:13:37 <gmann> masayukig: cool
09:13:42 <masayukig> (mtreinish already proposed it)
09:14:18 <gmann> +1, there are lot of feature we can add on that
09:14:32 <gmann> masayukig: Thanks
09:14:54 <gmann> next - Service Client Migrations
09:15:13 <gmann> so we are closed to complete network service client also along with compute
09:15:19 <gmann> just 2-3 patches more
09:15:44 <gmann> oomichi: has one for network
09:15:46 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/301294/
09:16:06 <masayukig> cool
09:16:31 <gmann> and m mocing last one from compute one - keypair client
09:16:33 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/302482/2
09:16:48 <dmellado> # startmeeting test
09:16:53 <dmellado> ohhh
09:16:55 <gmann> so in Mitaka we can have all compute and network one in lib
09:16:58 <dmellado> sorry
09:17:01 <dmellado> wrong channel
09:17:02 <gmann> dmellado: :)
09:17:39 <gmann> any other topic on priority item ?
09:17:55 <gmann> or we can move if masayukig have anything on CLI?
09:18:19 <masayukig> I have nothing about it :)
09:18:24 <gmann> ok
09:18:35 <gmann> #topic Tempest
09:19:16 <gmann> in morning i was discussing with mtreinish about layer 4 tests migration to their repo
09:19:34 <gmann> so he already moved zaqar and doing for trove
09:20:05 <tosky> I'm working on it for Sahara
09:20:20 <gmann> I checked that telemetry one are all in their tree so i need to check with them if they have those running on gate
09:20:28 <gmann> if so i will remove those from tempest
09:20:39 <gmann> tosky: yea, mtreinish mentioned that
09:20:45 <gmann> tosky: very nice, Thanks
09:21:01 <gmann> it will be nice if we are able to move all
09:21:19 <masayukig> really great (we're kicking out them :-P)
09:21:32 <gmann> only heat one needs to hold on till they merge the plugin and move tempest one to functional
09:21:39 <gmann> masayukig: yea
09:22:01 <gmann> because may times it block the gate if something wrong
09:22:17 <gmann> as today happened with Nova default flavor removal
09:22:44 <gmann> let's see how soon we can migrate those
09:23:36 <gmann> tosky: if you need any help on sahara one please let us know anytime
09:24:26 <masayukig> yeah, we can help each other ;)
09:24:31 <gmann> anything else on Tempest?
09:24:38 <gmann> yea we are good team :)
09:25:11 <tosky> sure, thanks - I already did for python-saharaclient tests, it's more a matter of checking the plugin code :)
09:25:46 <gmann> tosky: great, Thanks
09:26:29 <masayukig> ok, let's move on :)
09:26:34 <gmann> ok, les's jumped to Austin Summit
09:26:42 <gmann> Austin summit topic :)
09:26:50 <gmann> #topic Austin Summit
09:27:01 <gmann> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/newton-qa-summit-topics
09:27:39 <gmann> so we have many sessions proposal there
09:27:52 <masayukig> 9 sessions there?
09:28:32 <masayukig> The deadline is next week meeting.
09:28:33 <gmann> masayukig: yea
09:28:49 <gmann> yea oomichi  might be finalizing those in next week meeting
09:29:18 <dmellado> so then let's wait 'til then to see if there's any new session/votes
09:29:42 <gmann> only thing we discussed in Nova API meeting is not to conflict QA with API sessions
09:29:49 <gmann> dmellado: yea
09:30:02 <masayukig> I think "How to acceralate to apply tempest.lib to each project " and "What's necessary for a tempest plugin?" are similar/related things.
09:30:12 <gmann> so if anyone has some other sessions you can let oomichi know and he can short that out
09:30:31 <dmellado> masayukig: would you like to co-chair that and agree on a common schedule?
09:30:42 <gmann> masayukig: yea seems to, so those are for better doc only or anything more needed?
09:30:53 <dmellado> maybe we can merge them
09:31:17 <masayukig> dmellado: agree to merge
09:31:35 <masayukig> I'm not sure it's enough time or not, though.
09:31:58 <dmellado> we can drop some topics if needed
09:32:11 <dmellado> and if anyone has interest in going deep we can grab them after the tech talk
09:32:41 <dmellado> but let's discuss this off-meeting masayukig
09:33:00 <gmann> dmellado: m still not getting plugin one?
09:33:08 <gmann> what is actually needed
09:33:24 <dmellado> gmann: the point is that I'me seeing that a ton of projects still have doubts/issues with the plugin structure
09:33:39 <dmellado> and would like to cover that as a technical point of view
09:33:45 <dmellado> in-repo, separate repo
09:33:51 <dmellado> configurations, cookiecutter and so on
09:33:58 <gmann> dmellado: hummm, i think we have doc for those
09:34:04 <tosky> well, that's more a documentation issue/best practicies
09:34:12 <gmann> and with recommendation
09:34:16 <dmellado> I know, but still think that it'd be useful
09:34:35 <gmann> anyways let's find out what all issue there. nice to capture those and fix if any
09:34:40 <dmellado> that said, I think it could be moved to a topic in masayukig and we can co-chair the session
09:34:41 <gmann> dmellado: sure
09:34:49 <gmann> dmellado: +1
09:35:34 <gmann> so let's add more ideas before next week meeting
09:35:37 <masayukig> dmellado: ah, I'm not a proposer "How to acceralate to apply tempest.lib to each project", though :)
09:35:45 <dmellado> oh,
09:35:47 * dmellado checking
09:36:07 <dmellado> oh, it was oomichi
09:36:08 <gmann> masayukig: you can be default one :)
09:36:08 <masayukig> maybe, oomichi is the one
09:36:19 <dmellado> masayukig: yes, I'll talk with him about this
09:36:26 <gmann> dmellado: cool
09:36:32 <masayukig> dmellado: ok ;)
09:36:43 <dmellado> ;)
09:36:58 <gmann> anything else ?
09:37:27 <gmann> #topic Critical Reviews
09:37:46 <gmann> any reviews from anyone needs to bring up here
09:38:39 <gmann> ok, i will add mine if nothing else
09:38:41 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/302482/2
09:39:08 <gmann> we can complete compute service client after this
09:39:44 <gmann> #Open Discussion
09:39:56 <gmann> anything more to discuss or we close early
09:41:03 <gmann> ok, if nothing else, we can close.
09:41:08 <gmann> 5.....
09:41:12 <gmann> 4....
09:41:16 <gmann> 3...
09:41:19 <gmann> 2..
09:41:21 <gmann> 1.
09:41:27 <masayukig> Thanks everyone :)
09:41:28 <gmann> Thanks all for joining
09:41:39 <gmann> #endmeeting