08:00:03 <gmann> #startmeeting qa
08:00:04 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Sep  7 08:00:03 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gmann. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:00:05 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:00:08 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'qa'
08:00:19 <gmann> Who all here today?
08:00:21 <masayukig> o/
08:00:53 <masayukig> But I have to go in 15mins or so..
08:01:18 <gmann> masayukig, ohk
08:01:33 <gmann> let's wait for more members
08:01:47 * masayukig nods
08:02:17 <martinkopec> o/
08:02:30 <gmann> martinkopec, hi
08:02:45 <martinkopec> gmann, hi
08:03:12 <gmann> chandankumar, andreaf ..
08:03:19 <gmann> let's start
08:03:21 <gmann> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/QATeamMeeting#Agenda_for_September_7th_2017_.280800_UTC.29
08:03:27 <gmann> today agenda ^^
08:03:37 <gmann> #topic Previous Meeting Action review
08:03:51 <gmann> #link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/qa/2017/qa.2017-08-31-17.00.html
08:03:57 <gmann> nothing from last meeting
08:04:50 <masayukig> good :)
08:04:56 <gmann> #topic PTG
08:05:24 <gmann> andreaf sent mail on 2 more things for PTG
08:05:40 <gmann> 1. Pike Retrospective: #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/qa-pike-retrospective
08:06:04 <gmann> that is nice way to improve the things, so please add in that etherpad
08:06:12 <gmann> things went good or bad
08:06:25 <masayukig> gmann: yeah, I just put some my thoughts :)
08:06:39 <gmann> masayukig, thanks
08:07:27 <gmann> next is QA Social evening
08:07:31 <gmann> #link https://beta.doodle.com/poll/84mwxxbrtsmsaw4x
08:07:39 <gmann> put your vote for preferable time
08:08:14 <gmann> anyone local there who can suggest good restaurant
08:08:53 <gmann> anyways we will find there
08:09:08 <gmann> last but most imp is sessions etherpad
08:09:10 <gmann> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/qa-queens-ptg
08:09:24 <gmann> place your idea which needs to be discussed in PTG
08:09:39 <gmann> we have first 2 days as help hours and next for design discussions
08:09:54 <gmann> andreaf, will arrange that once we all are done
08:10:25 <gmann> andreaf, i will let you know my nova related sessions to avoid conflict with QA one
08:11:24 <gmann> as we do not have much time left for PTG, please add ideas by today or tomorrow max
08:11:37 <masayukig> gmann: ok
08:11:54 <gmann> masayukig, when you are traveling
08:12:07 <masayukig> gmann: I put one already :)
08:12:15 <gmann> masayukig, nice
08:12:52 <gmann> #topic Gate Stability
08:13:13 <gmann> not much on this from my side
08:13:27 <gmann> masayukig, martinkopec you have anything to discuss on gate ?
08:13:40 <masayukig> nothing from me
08:13:46 <martinkopec> gmann, not from my side
08:13:53 <gmann> #topic Tempest
08:14:24 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/tempest+status:open
08:14:41 <gmann> ^^ current open reviews for tempest
08:14:48 <chandankumar> hello
08:15:13 <gmann> chandankumar, hi
08:15:24 <gmann> Bug Triage:
08:15:26 <masayukig> I have to go, see you all tomorrow and/or in Denver :)
08:15:47 <gmann> masayukig, see you, ll ping tomorrow
08:15:56 <gmann> to have beer at airport :)
08:16:04 <masayukig> gmann: heh, nice :)
08:16:05 <gmann> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/pike-qa-bug-triage
08:16:10 <chandankumar> masayukig: see ya :-)
08:16:21 <masayukig> chandankumar: o/
08:16:26 <gmann> its felipemonteiro turn
08:16:58 <gmann> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tempest-weekly-bug-report
08:17:21 * andreaf o/
08:17:43 <gmann> seems like he did not or added report so he owe many beer :)
08:17:47 <gmann> andreaf, HI
08:18:14 <gmann> next week is PTG but chandankumar turn
08:18:24 <gmann> andreaf, we discussed about PTG things
08:18:35 <chandankumar> gmann: i will try to juggle with bugs when you guys are at ptg :-)
08:18:37 <andreaf> gmann: great, sry I'm late
08:18:44 <gmann> andreaf, asked to add ideas on etherpad max by tomorrow
08:18:44 <chandankumar> gmann: do we have meeting next week?
08:18:51 <andreaf> gmann: thanks
08:18:53 <gmann> chandankumar, we might skip, andreaf ?
08:19:07 <chandankumar> +1
08:19:10 <gmann> andreaf, when you will start planning for sessions schedule
08:19:24 <andreaf> gmann: if I may add one thing, if you have specific constraints (timewise) for your session please add it to the etherpad so I can try to fit things together
08:19:49 <gmann> andreaf, +1 but nova things needs to be schedule too :)
08:20:09 <gmann> only conflict for me otherwise i am available all the time
08:20:31 <andreaf> gmann: I think we have enough sessions for one day (or less) so I was planning to try and fit everything on Wednesday for sessions
08:20:58 <andreaf> gmann: and leave Thu / Fri for code sprint
08:21:14 <andreaf> gmann: which gives more flexibility for joining other sessions
08:21:23 <gmann> andreaf, +1 that will help mostly.
08:21:24 <andreaf> gmann: but it depends on availability of folks
08:21:29 <gmann> andreaf, i will check with mriedem and put my schedule accordingly
08:21:39 <andreaf> gmann: cool
08:22:19 <andreaf> Thursday / Friday if possible I would like to finish off pending patch series and start PoC on new specs or refine details as needed
08:22:35 <gmann> andreaf, nice
08:23:02 <andreaf> it would be cool to close the test.py stable interface and to start getting into more details on things like gate monitoring or HA testing
08:23:13 <gmann> andreaf, you think we can cover mon and tues full day ?
08:24:12 <andreaf> well I guess if not I'll let the PTG bot know the room is going to be deserted for 30min or 1h
08:24:41 <gmann> ok
08:25:05 <andreaf> I hope there will be big screens everywhere with the dyn schedule shown everywhere :D
08:25:17 <gmann> is it ?
08:25:33 <gmann> like flight schedule on airport
08:25:39 <andreaf> I don't know - I just hope
08:25:52 <andreaf> heh
08:26:31 <gmann> anything else or we move next to patrole?
08:26:35 <chandankumar> yup
08:26:45 <chandankumar> Here is the review of https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:goal-split-tempest-plugins
08:26:54 <gmann> #topic Patrole
08:26:57 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/patrole
08:27:05 <gmann> patrole 0.2.0 is released
08:27:22 <chandankumar> zaqar magnum zun tempest plugin split goal repo creation patches proposed
08:27:46 <gmann> chandankumar, thanks
08:27:50 <gmann> chandankumar, nice work
08:29:04 <gmann> chandankumar, you had wiki page too for tracking ?
08:29:04 <chandankumar> that's it
08:29:10 <chandankumar> gmann: yup
08:29:15 <chandankumar> gmann: i will update that
08:29:27 <gmann> chandankumar, thanks
08:30:00 <gmann> #topic Critical Reviews
08:30:11 <gmann> any critical reviews?
08:31:26 <gmann> if nothing let's move to open
08:31:28 <gmann> #topic Open Discussion
08:31:38 <gmann> anything else to discuss
08:31:44 <mwarad> hi.. i have a query here.. not sure if its rite forum
08:31:48 <chandankumar> andreaf: so we are skipping next week meeting?
08:31:54 <gmann> mwarad, go ahead
08:32:00 <mwarad> there are exercise shipped along with devstack...
08:32:08 <andreaf> chandankumar: yes we are
08:32:10 <mwarad> is it maintained by tempest team?
08:32:31 <mwarad> i find those are in stale state and many failures...
08:32:39 <gmann> mwarad, yea qa team maintain devstack too
08:32:42 <mwarad> exercise.sh
08:32:47 <gmann> mwarad, link please
08:32:55 <andreaf> mwarad: it's part of devstack, but it's a really legacy thing
08:33:45 <mwarad> i think its not updates along the openstack versions.. will there be any plans?
08:33:57 <andreaf> mwarad: I'll check but I think we haven't run those in CI for a long time
08:34:09 <gmann> yea, seems so
08:34:34 <mwarad> at the very top level, I could see there are deprecated cli as well...
08:34:48 <gmann> yea even removed cli also
08:34:51 <andreaf> mwarad: you can get a basic system healthcheck by running integration tests - running some basic scenario tests will give you quite good coverage about the functionality of the system
08:35:04 <gmann> andreaf, are those for CI or just for reference ?
08:35:17 <mwarad> ok thanks... do you folks see any use-case of maintaining that?
08:35:44 <mwarad> i mean, i could raise a bug and if possible i could start modifying scripts...
08:36:04 <mwarad> if we have already have alternative to exercise.sh then we leave it that way or perhaps remove it?
08:36:37 <gmann> for me those seems more for CLI functional tests
08:37:05 <andreaf> mwarad: heh I guess the folks who would know are probably not online yet sdague dtroyer - I don't know what it the reason for having them around still
08:37:36 <andreaf> mwarad: you can file a bug and we can continue the discussion on it
08:37:44 <mwarad> sure, thanks
08:38:24 <gmann> anything else to discuss ?
08:38:29 <gmann> if not we can close early
08:39:06 <andreaf> I haven't seen zhufl nick on the etherpad
08:39:21 <gmann> on PTG one?
08:39:26 <andreaf> so I guess she won't be coming to the PTG at the end - gmann have you heard from her?
08:39:31 <andreaf> yeah
08:40:07 <chandankumar> may be in next ptg, we will meet all
08:40:10 <gmann> andreaf, not final things. last thing she updates to apply to get the passport
08:40:24 <gmann> chandankumar, yes. hope so
08:40:38 <gmann> but i did not hear if she got visa
08:40:45 <chandankumar> gmann: let me know when you visit india, we can get meet.
08:40:55 <chandankumar> *to meet
08:41:04 <gmann> chandankumar, in dec but i am going to noida side, you are in pune ?
08:41:23 <chandankumar> gmann: i am in pune, i will drop by delhi, my friends are there
08:41:28 <gmann> ll ping her tomorrow and check
08:41:33 <gmann> chandankumar, cool
08:41:54 <gmann> thanks all for joining
08:42:08 <gmann> see you in denver or later
08:42:14 <gmann> have safe journey
08:42:31 <gmann> #endmeeting