08:00:26 <gmann> #startmeeting qa
08:00:27 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Nov 30 08:00:26 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gmann. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:00:28 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:00:31 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'qa'
08:00:40 <gmann> who all here today?
08:01:11 * masayukig[m] is read only mode
08:02:26 <gmann> masayukig[m]: seems like no other member today. let's wait for a while
08:02:47 <masayukig[m]> heh, yeah
08:03:16 <apart> o/
08:03:52 <gmann> apart: hi
08:04:31 <gmann> let's start and finish early
08:04:38 <gmann> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/QATeamMeeting#Agenda_for_Nov_30th_2017_.280800_UTC.29
08:04:44 <gmann> ^^ today agenda
08:05:04 <gmann> no action item from previous meeting
08:05:07 <gmann> #topic Office Hours Summary
08:05:24 <gmann> no office hour last week.
08:05:33 <gmann> #Tempest
08:05:52 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/tempest+status:open
08:06:01 <gmann> open reviews for tempest ^^
08:06:27 <gmann> zuul v3
08:06:31 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/tempest+branch:master+topic:zuulv3-tempest
08:06:38 <gmann> all base pacthes are merged.
08:06:49 <gmann> now we need to migrate other jobs one by one
08:07:53 <gmann> i can help on that, last week i did for novaclient and reviewed bunch of other migration patches
08:08:44 <masayukig> gmann: I'm actually not sure, but is there any list of that?
08:09:01 <gmann> masayukig: i do not think we have list yet
08:09:21 <masayukig> gmann: ok..
08:09:35 <gmann> those are mainly common jobs which other projects also use,
08:10:21 <chandankumar> \o/
08:10:27 <gmann> i think we need to move those into tempest but  can confirm with infra team if those are considered as common jobs and maintained on projects-config side
08:11:14 <masayukig> gmann: yeah, there are still about 10 legacy jobs on tempest
08:11:23 <gmann> yea
08:11:25 <masayukig> For example, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/521241/
08:11:45 <gmann> and those are legacy on other project side also. like nova
08:12:12 <masayukig> indeed
08:12:12 <gmann> hen  i tried to do migration on nova side, i found all jobs nova use is of tempest one so there is no work required
08:12:32 <gmann> once all tempest jobs are done then they are also all done
08:13:03 <masayukig> OK, I see
08:13:21 * masayukig is waving to chandankumar
08:13:24 <gmann> anything else on Tempest side?
08:13:36 * chandankumar waves back to masayukig gmann
08:13:42 <gmann> apart: hows scenario manger things going on ?
08:14:00 <gmann> one of congress member asked if scenario manager is ready to use
08:14:18 <apart> Something need review
08:14:38 <masayukig> apart: cool, I need to look at it
08:14:44 <gmann> apart you maintaining that under same topic?
08:14:52 <gmann> that can help to do fast review on thsoe
08:15:18 <apart> Later I will give a list
08:15:27 <gmann> ok thanks
08:15:35 <apart> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/519546/
08:15:53 <apart> And how about this?
08:16:26 <chandankumar> gmann: masayukig can we get this merged https://review.openstack.org/#/c/523610/2 ?
08:17:01 <gmann> apart: i see, so in those bugs for which that query was added, deleted msg was not there?
08:17:23 <masayukig> chandankumar: yeah, I was thinking to review that..
08:17:40 <gmann> chandankumar: yea sure.
08:17:48 <chandankumar> mtreinish: thank you for updating the stestr patch
08:18:09 <gmann> apart: i mean, if we had such bugs then we might miss in that e-r query
08:18:17 <apart> I just think that is not ssh issue
08:18:32 <chandankumar> gmann: masayukig before merging stestr patch we need to fix dependent projects which uses testr. i will create an etherpad to track
08:18:41 <chandankumar> to run tempest tests
08:18:58 <gmann> apart: ok, let me check the bug logs for that query and ll reply on gerrit
08:19:16 <apart> ：)
08:19:21 <masayukig> chandankumar: ok, nice. but I think we can merge https://review.openstack.org/#/c/523610/ at least
08:19:29 <chandankumar> masayukig: yup
08:19:31 <gmann> chandankumar: will it break other project?
08:19:59 <chandankumar> gmann: masayukig http://codesearch.openstack.org/?q=testr%20last&i=nope&files=&repos=
08:20:28 <chandankumar> gmann: most of the projects are using are dependent on .testrepository for subunit which needs to be fixed to use stestr
08:21:39 <chandankumar> most of them are used in gate hooks scripts with in project
08:21:49 <gmann> yea but those is not broken now i mean that will be migration effort, not something dependent on
08:22:05 <chandankumar> gmann: yes we can say that migration effort
08:22:33 <gmann> yea, so we can merge that patch which does not break anyone
08:22:42 <gmann> chandankumar: thanks for etherpad, that will help
08:22:51 <chandankumar> let me create that
08:23:07 <gmann> anything else on Tempest side?
08:23:51 <chandankumar> gmann: masayukig since ptg dublin is announced, i think we need to start thinking about the topics
08:23:51 * masayukig just realized that apart is zhufl? :-p
08:24:09 <gmann> masayukig: :) heh
08:24:14 <apart> Yeah:)
08:24:15 <gmann> chandankumar: yea but we have time for that
08:24:26 <masayukig> chandankumar: yeah,
08:24:44 <gmann> may be after new year vacation is right time
08:24:52 <apart> I don’t know how to change the name
08:24:53 <masayukig> yeah, things are changing very fast
08:25:06 <chandankumar> apart: use /nick zhufl
08:25:30 <gmann> let's move next
08:25:37 <masayukig> +1
08:25:40 <gmann> #topic Critical Reviews
08:25:49 <gmann> any critical reviews ?
08:26:45 <gmann> let's move to open then
08:26:45 <masayukig> this is very quick one https://review.openstack.org/#/c/519566/
08:27:25 <gmann> masayukig: done
08:27:27 <gmann> #topic Open Discussion
08:27:36 <masayukig> gmann: Thanks :)
08:27:57 <chandankumar> masayukig: gmann please have a look at this thread http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-November/124686.html
08:28:02 <chandankumar> heat tempest gabbi thread
08:28:36 <gmann> chandankumar: yea, i am not sure if they do not really need plugin it is not mandatory
08:29:01 <gmann> one things on ML was on Patrole extensions for other project tests
08:29:03 <gmann> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-November/124995.html
08:29:32 <gmann> i prefer to do inside patrole if not so many projects.
08:29:50 <chandankumar> gmann: i think we need to expand tempest to auto discover and run gabbi tests behind the scene, it will help to expand the project scope
08:30:23 <gmann> but need more feedback from felipe or samantha
08:30:34 <gmann> both are not here
08:31:05 <gmann> chandankumar: humm not sure, tempest is ok to run tempest like tests only
08:31:25 <gmann> that will make tempest a test runner instead of testing suits
08:32:22 <chandankumar> may be we can make tempest as a test runner + framework, (/me is not sure, better to have discussion)
08:32:33 <chandankumar> later
08:33:24 <gmann> i do not think test runner is good idea, stestr is there
08:34:56 <masayukig> I'm actually not sure what's the pain point now..
08:34:56 <gmann> back to Patrole - if anyone has more idea/feedback please share on ML. i think we can choose the best way and provide support as many projects might want policy testing.
08:35:14 <gmann> masayukig: yea, i also did not understand that
08:36:01 <masayukig> +1 to the Patrole
08:36:21 <gmann> I think i am done, anything else to discuss
08:36:45 <gmann> or we can close early and go home as its too cold in tokyo today :)
08:37:15 <masayukig> heh, yeah
08:37:23 <zhufl> :)
08:37:42 <gmann> ... 3
08:37:50 <gmann> .. 2
08:37:54 <chandankumar> .1
08:37:57 <gmann> . 1
08:37:58 <masayukig> heh
08:37:59 <gmann> thanks all
08:38:12 <gmann> #endmeeting