13:32:08 <gmann> #startmeeting qa
13:32:09 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Mar 17 13:32:08 2020 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gmann. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
13:32:10 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
13:32:13 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'qa'
13:32:16 <gmann> who all here today?
13:32:26 <kopecmartin> \o/
13:34:23 <gmann> kopecmartin: seems two of us.
13:34:36 <kopecmartin> yeah
13:34:36 <rh-jelabarre> three
13:34:46 <gmann> rh-jelabarre: hi
13:35:07 <soniya29> hi
13:35:15 <paras333> gmann:  hey Gm!
13:35:18 <gmann> hi
13:35:21 <gmann> let's start
13:35:32 <gmann> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/QATeamMeeting#Agenda_for_next_Office_hours
13:35:38 <gmann> ^^ today agenda
13:36:59 <gmann> #topic Announcement and Action Item (Optional)
13:37:34 <gmann> no AI from previous meeting
13:37:55 <gmann> #topic Ussuri Priority Items progress
13:38:08 <gmann> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/qa-ussuri-priority
13:39:03 <gmann> Remove/migrate the .testr.conf to .stestr - masayukig
13:39:26 <openstackgerrit> Lee Yarwood proposed openstack/devstack-plugin-ceph master: Updates script to use latest version of Ceph  https://review.opendev.org/676722
13:39:34 <gmann> i did not see patches for this, will wait for masayukig  response.
13:39:40 <openstackgerrit> Liang Fang proposed openstack/devstack-plugin-open-cas master: Initial repo  https://review.opendev.org/713173
13:40:21 <gmann> py2.7 drop plan for QA - gmann
13:40:48 <gmann> this is almost done for all QA projects. and i released few of the tools.
13:40:55 <gmann> I will do audit for those and mark complete
13:41:10 <gmann> new whitebox plugin for tempest
13:41:47 <gmann> this is +2 from me. may be  masayukig can re-review this - https://review.opendev.org/#/c/656890/
13:42:05 <gmann> Improving Tempest cleanup: mkopec
13:42:17 <gmann> i think i have not reviewed that ?
13:42:30 <kopecmartin> this is still ongoing, we have a few patches to review
13:42:50 <kopecmartin> yeah, there's a new patch by Lukas (he's no here atm)
13:43:07 <gmann> kopecmartin: ok, can you add those with single topic
13:43:17 <kopecmartin> sure
13:43:25 <gmann> thanks
13:43:46 <gmann> #topic OpenStack Events Updates and Planning
13:43:59 <gmann> Vancouver Summit & PTG
13:44:56 <gmann> As you all might have seen the ML thread that OSF still deciding the June event whether to do virtually or physically.
13:45:44 <gmann> also as per expected attandance for QA, i have marked QA as runtime booking of space in PTG if we have physical PTG and any of us attend that.
13:46:17 <gmann> otherwise I will think on holding it virtually.  sometime during May or April end
13:46:44 <gmann> #topic Sub Teams highlights (Sub Teams means individual projects under QA program)
13:46:49 <gmann> Tempest
13:47:07 <gmann> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/q/project:openstack/tempest+status:open
13:47:14 <gmann> these are open request
13:47:30 <gmann> other than that no specific update form me.
13:47:34 <gmann> anyone ?
13:48:12 <paras333> Added patch yesterday https://review.opendev.org/#/c/713151/ for this old bug https://launchpad.net/bugs/1676207
13:48:13 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1676207 in tempest "test_create_router_set_gateway_with_fixed_ip is flaky" [Low,In progress] - Assigned to Paras Babbar (pbabbar)
13:48:40 <paras333> gmann:  it will be great if you can review, it was among the high importance bug we discuss last time
13:48:42 <gmann> paras333: thanks.
13:49:14 <gmann> is it on bug etherpad ?
13:49:20 <gmann> paras333: imp seems low in LP
13:49:29 <gmann> anyways we will discuss on bug topic
13:49:44 <paras333> ok
13:49:55 <gmann> Patrole
13:50:14 <gmann> gate is broken for Patrole. with my change in nova policies
13:50:25 <gmann> i am fixing here #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/711367/
13:50:36 <gmann> seems i need to fix reno
13:50:51 <gmann> other that that no major updates from patrole
13:51:18 <gmann> grenade
13:51:44 <gmann> ironic grenade job on stein was broken due to Tempest constraint
13:51:51 <gmann> it is fixed and working now- #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/713014/
13:52:31 <gmann> I had to use stable constraint for old node tempest run for stein job also. old node in stein is rocky which has Tempest pinned.
13:52:50 <gmann> this we might need to do on every release move to EM
13:52:53 <tosky> grenade: I need to complete the requested fixes for the zuulv3 jobs, I was driven away by other duties; hopefully I will upload a new version before the end of the week
13:53:08 <gmann> or when we cap the Tempest on any stable branch
13:53:26 <gmann> tosky: thanks for that. i was about to ask that.
13:53:36 <gmann> sounds good. take your time
13:54:27 <gmann> anyting else on any other project ?
13:55:17 <gmann> one update is openstack-heath nodejs job is  udpated to 10 LTS #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/711380/
13:55:36 <gmann> thanks to vishalmanchanda to fixing it and making gate green.
13:55:59 <gmann> #topic Community goal tracking
13:56:29 <gmann> py2 drop we already discussed. contributor guide role is not started yet.
13:56:46 <gmann> #topic Bug Triage
13:56:50 <gmann> kopecmartin: soniya29 go ahead
13:57:27 <kopecmartin> very lacking core reviews , we should gain attention a little more if possible
13:57:49 <gmann> ok, patches listed on etherpad right ?
13:57:58 <kopecmartin> there is plenty of fixes ready for reviews, listed in the etherpad
13:57:58 <kopecmartin> yes
13:58:13 <kopecmartin> and some of them are there for weeks
13:58:26 <gmann> ok, I started burning the volume json schema things last week which are pending for long time.
13:58:42 <gmann> I will check etherpad one also this week
13:58:49 <kopecmartin> yeah, i've seen some reviews regarding the json schema in general
13:59:08 <kopecmartin> i was about to review them for some time .. I will reserve time for that too
13:59:23 <gmann> cool thanks
13:59:26 <gmann> https://bugs.launchpad.net/tempest/+bug/1866270
13:59:27 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1866270 in tempest "CI job 'grenade-py3' broken" [Undecided,New]
13:59:42 <gmann> "how do we deal with CI failures related bugs? it's not tempest's fault, it's infra, where should we redirect these bugs? "
13:59:55 <gmann> is it job issue ? or infra
14:00:21 <kopecmartin> i think infra, let me check
14:00:33 <kopecmartin> yeah, a host was not found ..
14:00:41 <paras333> seems like scheduler was not able to find a host
14:00:43 <paras333> so yes infra
14:01:32 <gmann> i mean it is compute side issue which can be due to various reason
14:01:59 <kopecmartin> i see, so should we change the project to compute?
14:02:07 <gmann> in those cases, we need to comment and mark invalid for Tempest/grenade and open for that project
14:02:25 <gmann> we need more info on that. I will comment on that
14:02:29 <paras333> very less logs here to say
14:02:40 <gmann> https://bugs.launchpad.net/tempest/+bug/1863161
14:02:42 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1863161 in tempest "stackviz failing on stable jobs with py3.5 while installation" [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to Ghanshyam Mann (ghanshyammann)
14:03:16 <gmann> stackviz is fixed for py3.5 but i think i had Tempest patch also not to fail job for any failure in stackviz
14:03:24 <gmann> i will check if that is not merged yet.
14:03:53 <gmann> 3.5 is dropped form Tempest but we restored its support in stackviz as rocky job still use py3.5 on their xenail node
14:03:56 <gmann> xenial
14:04:22 <gmann> so till rocky is EOl we can keep supporting it. pinning stackviz is too complex
14:05:56 <gmann> https://bugs.launchpad.net/tempest/+bug/1783405
14:05:57 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1783405 in tempest "Slow tests randomly timing out jobs (which aren't marked slow)" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Ghanshyam Mann (ghanshyammann)
14:06:47 <gmann> this is something we keep monitoring and if we find the slow test then we mark it slow. we did complete first phase of this but I will say to keep it open for ussuri cycle in case we find more slow tests.
14:07:23 <kopecmartin> ah, ok , good to know
14:07:37 <paras333> ack
14:07:44 <gmann> commented on LP also
14:07:48 <gmann> any other bug to discuss ?
14:07:53 <gmann> paras333: your ?
14:08:06 <paras333> I added that in etherpad
14:08:51 <kopecmartin> for the record: https://launchpad.net/bugs/1676207
14:08:52 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1676207 in tempest "test_create_router_set_gateway_with_fixed_ip is flaky" [Low,In progress] - Assigned to Paras Babbar (pbabbar)
14:08:53 <gmann> link
14:09:04 <paras333> https://review.opendev.org/#/c/713151/
14:09:42 <kopecmartin> background: there's a question on how to obtain fixed ips without a race condition
14:10:15 <paras333> yeah so the only suggestion I thought is to create the external network and use that for the fixed IP
14:10:40 <gmann> what is frequency of this ?
14:10:48 <paras333> rather than using the network id which is shared among many other tests as that's what causing the race
14:10:49 <gmann> is it happening on gate too ?
14:11:03 <gmann> yeah, dedicated network will be good approach here.
14:11:14 <paras333> I see it is open from 2017 and people have seen this a lot and then we put the skip flag like 3 years ago
14:11:25 <kopecmartin> not that big frequency nowadays, that's why we decreased priority  , but if we can solve, i'd do it
14:11:27 <gmann> anyways. I will add this in e-r if not yet there and see what is occurance
14:11:52 <gmann> yeah, we can get paras333 fix in parallel.
14:12:13 <gmann> I will review that in this week or today if find time
14:12:19 <kopecmartin> thanks
14:12:26 <paras333> thanks guys!!
14:12:27 <gmann> anything else on bug side ?
14:12:34 <kopecmartin> not from my side
14:13:03 <paras333> nothing else!!
14:13:19 <gmann> kopecmartin: what you think on maintaining the critical or  High importance bugs  section also in report so that we triage/fix/review them on priority.
14:13:40 <gmann> critical is 0 but i see 6-7 high priority bug hanging without much attensions
14:14:00 <gmann> section in etehrpad i mean
14:14:14 <kopecmartin> gmann: hmm, ok , let me increase the priority on the related bugs, i forgot i got those powers :)
14:14:55 <gmann> kopecmartin: i mean priority you set as per triage policy or like frequency and imp of bugs as usualy.
14:15:20 <gmann> i mean all High priority or critical merked bug in separate section on etherapd so that we keep checking them
14:15:30 <kopecmartin> oh, sure, no problem
14:15:32 <kopecmartin> i'll do it
14:15:36 <paras333> gmann:  yeah I like the idea
14:15:44 <kopecmartin> i'll divide them into two sections, makes sense
14:16:05 <gmann> thanks. because our main idea is to fix critical the high priority first and then rest all
14:16:45 <gmann> and i will say good progress on bug things, it has decreased a lot
14:16:56 <gmann> #topic Critical Reviews
14:17:16 <gmann> any critical review ?
14:17:32 <chandankumar> gmann, in other news, tripleo ci team has moved almost all the jobs to centos-8 running py3
14:17:40 <chandankumar> *tripleo jobs
14:18:18 <gmann> chandankumar: great.
14:18:37 <gmann> i think few of the projects like kolla were waiting for that
14:19:11 <gmann> not sure if that can help ansible modules also which still running centos7. few of my py2 cleanup patches failing on that job
14:19:19 <chandankumar> gmann, if something got missed, we get it done
14:19:33 <chandankumar> gmann, do you have job link?
14:19:37 <gmann> +1
14:20:43 <gmann> chandankumar: this one is one of it- #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/710680/
14:21:16 <chandankumar> gmann, thanks, adding to my list
14:21:23 <gmann> thanks
14:21:25 <gmann> #topic Open Discussion
14:21:41 <gmann> anything else to discuss ?
14:23:00 <gmann> ok, let's close for today. thanks everyone for jojning
14:23:03 <mtreinish> gmann: just a heads up I'm planning a new stestr release in the next month
14:23:13 <mtreinish> it'll drop support for python 2
14:23:17 <gmann> mtreinish: ok.
14:24:03 <gmann> mtreinish: i think almost all projects moved to py3 but we might need to check on swift which still running py2 jobs
14:24:16 <gmann> they can use cap in that case
14:24:34 <openstackgerrit> Mohammed Naser proposed openstack/devstack master: zuul: Added reference tenant configuration  https://review.opendev.org/713454
14:24:42 <gmann> mtreinish: will you add cap in g-r also ? for py2 version
14:25:23 <mtreinish> I wasn't planning on it, but it might be necessary. I'll be setting a python requires for >=3.5 for the stestr 3.0.0 release so that might cause an issue on python2 if u-c says 3.0.0
14:25:37 <mtreinish> gmann: https://github.com/mtreinish/stestr/pull/287
14:27:00 <gmann> stable branches py2 cap to 2.0.0 i think but we can see if it break things on py2 jobs on ussuri onwards if any swift is known one
14:28:16 <gmann> thanks for updates.
14:29:11 <gmann> #endmeeting