14:03:26 <hberaud> #startmeeting releaseteam
14:03:26 <opendevmeet> Meeting started Fri Jul  2 14:03:26 2021 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is hberaud. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:03:26 <opendevmeet> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:03:26 <opendevmeet> The meeting name has been set to 'releaseteam'
14:03:35 <hberaud> Ping list: elod armstrong
14:03:46 <ttx> o/
14:03:48 <elodilles> o/
14:04:06 <hberaud> Will just wait a one minute for folks
14:04:08 <ttx> we need the OFTC edition of the ping list :)
14:04:18 <elodilles> (i remembered that we will meet only next week :X)
14:04:22 <hberaud> #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/xena-relmgt-tracking
14:04:57 <hberaud> We're way down on line 176 now.
14:05:33 <hberaud> ok let's go
14:05:35 <hberaud> #topic Review task completion
14:05:48 <hberaud> Review any remaining trailing project exceptions => Done
14:06:02 <hberaud> All the patches are now merged https://review.opendev.org/q/topic:%22trailing-wallaby%22+(status:open%20OR%20status:merged)
14:06:39 <hberaud> And that's all for this topic
14:06:43 <hberaud> #topic Assign R-13 tasks
14:06:58 <hberaud> ttx: thanks for the MembershipFreeze stuff
14:07:12 <hberaud> I'm alredy on the email part
14:07:34 <hberaud> So we can move directly to the open discussion
14:07:50 <hberaud> #topic Open Discussion
14:08:06 <hberaud> Anything else to discuss today?
14:08:40 <hberaud> elodilles: maybe you want to say something about all these EOLing tasks?
14:09:08 <elodilles> yes, I can say some words
14:09:43 <elodilles> so, the ocata-eol of the repos with deliverables is almost ready
14:10:09 <hberaud> excellent
14:10:09 <elodilles> only some patches remained without PTL approval
14:10:16 <hberaud> Yes
14:10:35 <elodilles> and as we said before this week,
14:10:43 <elodilles> maybe we could approve those
14:10:45 <elodilles> today
14:10:52 <hberaud> +1
14:11:02 <hberaud> I don't think we will have responses
14:11:20 <armstrong> ttx I will like to follow up your task if you don't mind
14:11:34 <hberaud> armstrong: o/
14:11:35 <ttx> sure
14:11:47 <armstrong> hello hberaud
14:12:18 <ttx> armstrong: are you available on Monday?
14:12:26 <elodilles> about the repos without deliverables: I've collected a list that should be *-eol tagged (ocata, newton, mitaka, etc)
14:13:00 <armstrong> Monday will be a busy day here
14:13:26 <ttx> The rest of my afternoons are really not open next week
14:13:50 <ttx> I can do 10am CT Monday, otherwise I'll likely do it in a morning
14:13:50 <hberaud> elodilles: I approved almost all the remaining patches, we just need to merge OSA after all the other patches
14:13:58 <ttx> and post the results on the etherpad for yuo to compare
14:14:17 <elodilles> hberaud: ++
14:14:22 <armstrong> let's do 10 am CT then
14:14:47 <ttx> ok I'll ping you around 10am CT/15UTC on Monday
14:14:58 <hberaud> it could be worth to finish the train transition too, let's wait for the puppet team
14:15:00 <armstrong> Ok thanks
14:15:41 <hberaud> I seen that you leave a comment few hours ago, I'll ping them too
14:15:57 <elodilles> hberaud: yes, I commented on the patch to get some team approval
14:16:02 <hberaud> tkajinam: Hello, Please can you have a look to => https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/790767
14:16:57 <elodilles> just the PTL-approved flag is missing there maybe :)
14:17:14 <elodilles> and about the repos without deliverables: I am planning to propose patches for those as discussed in the mail thread ( http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2021-June/thread.html#23347 )
14:17:35 <hberaud> +1
14:17:40 <hberaud> thanks
14:17:47 <elodilles> np
14:18:21 <hberaud> Anything else to discuss today?
14:18:45 <elodilles> nothing else from me I think
14:19:00 <hberaud> same thing here
14:20:43 <fungi> we've got a full zuul restart coming up later today
14:21:00 <fungi> will give you a heads up before we start, and watch to make sure there are no releases in progress first
14:21:07 <hberaud> ack
14:21:09 <hberaud> thanks
14:23:18 <elodilles> then I'll try to approve now the above mentioned patches :) just to not interfere with the zuul restart later
14:23:38 <hberaud> yes could be the right time
14:23:44 <ttx> nothing from me
14:23:58 <ttx> any stuck patch we need to review/unblock?
14:24:09 <hberaud> AFAIK nope
14:24:28 <ttx> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/796692 has been there for two weeks
14:24:55 <hberaud> yep PTL validation is missing
14:25:00 <ttx> Missing Murano PTL +1
14:25:02 <hberaud> I'll try to ping him
14:25:15 <ttx> +1 he probably skipped the notification
14:25:27 <ttx> the rest of patches are relatively young
14:25:59 <hberaud> yes
14:27:20 <hberaud> their (murano) IRC channel is nearly empty
14:27:35 <fungi> the zuul restart is underway now, btw
14:27:40 <fungi> sooner than i anticipated
14:27:46 <hberaud> elodilles: ^
14:28:00 <elodilles> :S
14:28:10 <elodilles> I've just approved some patches
14:28:43 <ttx> I wouldn't be surprised if Murano went AWOL, it's long overdue if you asked me. It's a bit irrelevant in a container world
14:29:09 <fungi> elodilles: you probably approved them after the restart, so will likely be fine
14:29:29 <fungi> elodilles: worst case zuul missed the approvals and you can just reapprove them if they don't end up in the queue
14:29:39 <hberaud> ttx: surely
14:30:00 <elodilles> fungi: ok, sure, I'll try to watch them
14:31:18 <fungi> in awol projects news, i've been struggling for weeks to get mistral engaged on a private report of a suspected vulnerability. seems like their dpl liaisons aren't particularly engaged these days
14:32:11 <hberaud> same things for keystone
14:32:12 <fungi> their security liaison isn't around at all, so i fell back on their release liaison who took weeks go get ahold of via separate pings through coworkers
14:32:16 <smcginnis> Does the TC still have liaisons for each project that check in each cycle?
14:32:29 <smcginnis> That was how we were trying to catch these zombie projects in the past.
14:33:05 <hberaud> at the end of wallaby we did a check with the TC
14:33:19 <fungi> yeah, i brought it up with their tc liaisons after a week or so of not getting replies in the bug tracker, e-mail, irc... and they helped try to hunt them down through alternative contacts
14:33:34 <fungi> but it still took a while
14:34:00 <fungi> in the meantime, the bug reporter went ahead and disclosed the vulnerability publicly because we were taking so long
14:34:02 <hberaud> to monitor the activity of projects and observe those who could be tagged as "unmaintained"
14:34:28 <hberaud> ouch
14:36:00 <fungi> also the awol security liaison for mistral is the only one with control over the project drivers/configuration in launchpad, so i can't even really check whether there are other private reports for it we don't know about, nor add other volunteers to look at their private security bugs in the future until we can get up with the current liaison
14:37:16 <hberaud> indeed that's problematic
14:38:07 <fungi> i only knew about this one because it was incorrectly reported against horizon first
14:39:04 <hberaud> I wouldn't be surprised if some other teams are in the same situation.
14:39:23 <fungi> yes, i expect they are, this one just happened to come to the vmt's attention through unfortunate circumstances
14:41:06 <hberaud> We faced some problematics on oslo too with our TaCT liaisons who are no longer active
14:42:38 <hberaud> I warned about this during our previous meeting and on the ML, however, we didn't get a lot of reply
14:42:40 <hberaud> Anyway
14:45:05 <hberaud> OK, thanks everyone. Let's wrap up.
14:45:11 <hberaud> #endmeeting