17:02:52 <LouisF> #startmeeting service_chaining
17:02:53 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Mar 10 17:02:52 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is LouisF. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:02:54 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:02:56 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'service_chaining'
17:03:00 <LouisF> s3wong: thx
17:03:08 <s3wong> LouisF: NP :-)
17:03:24 <LouisF> cathy is on business trip
17:04:06 <LouisF> i will be out also next week at onf - suggest we cancel next weeks meeting
17:04:38 <LouisF> there were a couple of actions from last week
17:05:20 <LouisF> raofei was to provide a link to service insertion idea
17:06:07 <LouisF> is raofei on?
17:07:15 <LouisF> ok moving on, farad were you able to verify that patch works?
17:07:42 <fsunaval> yes. we work just fine with the latest master.
17:07:59 <LouisF> fsunaval: ok great thx
17:08:17 <fsunaval> in any case, I have also modified our code to make sure of the l2 extension api and my changes with the l2 extension api also seem to work fine.
17:08:21 <fsunaval> more testing is needed though.
17:09:57 <LouisF> fsunaval: ok thx
17:10:41 <LouisF> mohankumar: what is the status regarding the horizon work?
17:11:25 <mohankumar> HI LouisF , We are in the integration part ..
17:12:10 <LouisF> mohankumar: do you have a patch for review?
17:12:30 <mohankumar> Yes , just sec
17:13:08 <mohankumar> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/258430/
17:13:48 <mohankumar> LouisF , i ve asked some help from Akihiro on integration part
17:13:49 <LouisF> mohankumar: thx, everyone please review
17:14:10 <mohankumar> LouisF , i may  update this patch soon
17:14:17 <LouisF> mohankumar: ok great
17:15:12 <mohankumar> Regarding Heat changes , Code is ready and sanity tests were passed
17:15:58 <LouisF> regarding tacker work, a new patch has been posted for the tacker to networking-sfc driver
17:16:07 <LouisF> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/290771
17:16:44 <LouisF> s3wong: thanks for all the work you did on this spec
17:18:21 <LouisF> this driver will be part of the tacker server and will interface between the tacker vnffg/vnfm plugins and networking-sfc API
17:21:13 <LouisF> once the spec is approved to can start to look at actually implementing that driver..
17:21:29 <LouisF> please comment on that spec
17:22:00 <fsunaval> will do Louis.
17:22:11 <LouisF> fsunaval: thanks
17:23:14 <LouisF> #topic sdn controller drivers
17:23:22 <fsunaval> do you want me to commit the l2 extension API changes or should we hold off on that since things work just fine as is ?
17:23:37 <LouisF> we currently have ovs driver and onos driver
17:24:25 <LouisF> we are thinking of adding other sdn controller drivers depending on level of interest..
17:24:53 <LouisF> in particular odl, ovn, dragonflow..
17:25:51 <LouisF> if anyone has a driver they want to work on please speak up
17:26:42 <fsunaval> I can look at ovn driver
17:26:55 <LouisF> fsunaval: great thanks
17:27:54 <LouisF> #topic future enhancements
17:29:07 <LouisF> there was a list of potential enhancements on a previous meeting log
17:30:13 <LouisF> SDN controller drivers, support of a mixed chain of VM, container, physical device, integration with upstream Tacker,  enhancement of Flow Classifier, Horizon, OAM, Heat,  tempest tests
17:31:01 <LouisF> this is a big list so we can only take on items where is interest
17:31:27 <mohankumar> LouisF , you know any priorities on these ?
17:32:14 <LouisF> mohankumar: i think horizon, heat and tempest is definite work
17:32:28 <mohankumar> SDN controller driver we already supporting ONOS
17:33:03 <LouisF> right - i was thinking of other sdn controllers/backends: odl, ovn,..
17:34:21 <LouisF> i think that a sfc of mixed devices: VMs, containers,  BMs is also important
17:34:34 <mohankumar> LouisF , yes
17:34:54 <fsunaval> LouisF: +1
17:35:05 <LouisF> mohankumar: and we have the tacker/networking-sfc spec done..
17:36:21 <mohankumar> LouisF ,  i went through spec , will dig deep
17:36:32 <LouisF> mohankumar: thanks
17:38:05 <LouisF> regarding a mixed SFC with SFs on VMs and BMs, I think ironic-neutron integration will be very useful
17:39:32 <LouisF> other suggestions, ideas?
17:40:08 <LouisF> #topic open discussion
17:41:20 <LouisF> ok i will close meeting for today
17:41:41 <mohankumar> okay
17:41:49 <LouisF> i will cancel the meeting for next week as cathy and I will be out
17:42:02 <LouisF> thanks all
17:42:08 <fsunaval> thanks everyone.
17:42:11 <mohankumar> Thanks
17:42:14 <LouisF> #endmeeting