17:00:06 <LouisF> #startmeeting service_chaining
17:00:10 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Sep 29 17:00:06 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is LouisF. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:12 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:14 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'service_chaining'
17:00:21 <LouisF> hi all
17:00:28 <pcarver> hi LouisF
17:00:32 <s3wong> hello
17:00:35 <LouisF> pcarver: hi
17:00:40 <LouisF> s3wong: hi
17:00:56 <doonhammer> hi all
17:01:05 <LouisF> doonhammer: hi
17:02:07 <LouisF> agenda for today https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/ServiceFunctionChainingMeeting#Agenda_for_the_Networking-SFC_Meeting_.289.2F29.2F2016.29
17:02:29 <LouisF> anything to add?
17:03:14 <doonhammer> LouisF: If we get this done we should be good
17:03:26 <LouisF> #topic current work items
17:03:31 <LouisF> doonhammer: yes
17:03:54 <LouisF> Replace OvsSfcAgent by L2 Agent Extension https://review.openstack.org/#/c/351789/
17:05:00 <LouisF> i saw an email from Bernard that he wont attend
17:05:30 <LouisF> is making progress
17:06:07 <LouisF> moving on
17:06:26 <LouisF> Tacker driver integration https://review.openstack.org/#/c/347568/
17:06:38 <LouisF> s3wong: what is the current status?
17:07:06 <s3wong> LouisF: it is merged. VNFFG w/ networking-sfc driver is now officially part of Tacker Newton release
17:07:17 <LouisF> s3wong: great news
17:07:52 <LouisF> s3wong: sridhar had some problems with the testing - is that resolved?
17:08:50 <s3wong> LouisF: yes --- I think it was likely a incompatibility between some Neutron base CLI in Newton
17:09:00 <LouisF> s3wong: ok
17:09:01 <s3wong> LouisF: but it was resolved (AFAIK)
17:09:21 <s3wong> LouisF: what I do know is that it works all the way to setting up flows in OVS
17:09:43 <s3wong> LouisF: but since it got in so late, the VNFFG feature in general is marked 'experimental' for Newton
17:09:59 <LouisF> s3wong: ok
17:10:25 <s3wong> LouisF: will need to update driver once symmetrical is supported by networking-sfc
17:11:07 <LouisF> s3wong: that work is under way - i expect to have the cli/api patch updated soon
17:11:24 <s3wong> LouisF: it's OK --- won't be Newton anyway :-)
17:11:37 <LouisF> s3wong: and the ovs driver/agent in a few weeks
17:11:58 <s3wong> LouisF: for more general NFV (OPNFV especially) perspective, I think ODL support for us is also important
17:12:46 <LouisF> s3wong: yes - do you know is any progress has been made on the odl driver?
17:13:11 <LouisF> anil is working on that I believe
17:13:25 <s3wong> LouisF: got an email from Anil earlier last week
17:14:12 <LouisF> what is his progress?
17:14:18 <s3wong> LouisF: he was asking for networking-sfc Tacker driver to set the abstract VNF type somewhere in the port-pair-group name
17:15:25 <s3wong> LouisF: seems to be moving along. I think he is in ODL Summit this week
17:15:41 <LouisF> s3wong: ok thanks
17:16:07 <LouisF> s3wong: thanks for your work on this
17:16:24 <s3wong> LouisF: np
17:16:45 <LouisF> Symmetric chain API https://review.openstack.org/#/c/308274/
17:17:00 <LouisF> this patch will be updated soon
17:17:19 <s3wong> LouisF: BTW, Anil has a talk on networking-sfc + ODL SFC integration during ODL Sumit --- so my guess is it is at demo stage now?
17:18:02 <LouisF> s3wong: excellent  - i will no be at the odl summit
17:18:16 <LouisF> do you have a pointer to the talk?
17:18:22 <s3wong> LouisF: clearly :-)  It is happening now :-)
17:19:38 <LouisF> s3wong: thanks
17:19:40 <LouisF> Networking-sfc / OVN driver spec https://review.openstack.org/#/c/333172/
17:19:41 <s3wong> LouisF:  http://events.linuxfoundation.org/events/opendaylight-summit/program/schedule  -- look for "Anil Vishnoi" as speaker (he has THREE talks), and look for "OpenStack & OpenDaylight Integration for SFC"
17:19:57 <LouisF> s3wong: very good news
17:21:34 <LouisF> i posted the updated sfc/ovn spec
17:21:47 <s3wong> LouisF: OK --- need to drop off. Time to go to work (glad I had my update already)
17:21:57 <LouisF> s3wong: thanks
17:22:12 <LouisF> please review
17:23:05 <LouisF> doonhammer: do you want to discuss the ovn work?
17:24:19 <doonhammer> LouisF: sure multi-tasking with ovs
17:25:50 <doonhammer> I see three big isues 1) where to insert chain stage in ovn pipeline 2) how to handle fc/acl integration to make sure we do not break anything 3) how ot support stateful lb - could add mutli-subnet ports etc but will eave that
17:26:22 <LouisF> doonhammer: agree
17:27:11 <doonhammer> LouisF: the document you started is what we need to flesh out these issues the ovn team want to meet inBarcelona to dicuss so we shoudl be ready by then
17:27:25 <doonhammer> with a set op options and thoughts
17:27:53 <LouisF> doonhammer: a meeting sounds good
17:28:38 <LouisF> ok lets work through those issues
17:28:57 <doonhammer> LouisF: especcailly if we do the prep :-)
17:29:17 <LouisF> doonhammer: we can do that over the next few weeks
17:29:19 <doonhammer> Can anyone else thing of items to add?
17:29:33 <doonhammer> LouisF: High on my list
17:30:03 <LouisF> lets focus on those items
17:31:12 <LouisF> doonhammer: we can discuss later
17:33:01 <LouisF> that is all that i have
17:33:19 <LouisF> any further topics for discussion?
17:34:27 <LouisF> ok thanks all
17:34:31 <LouisF> bye
17:34:44 <doonhammer> LouisF: Thanks and bye
17:34:50 <LouisF> #endmeeting