17:00:09 <LouisF> #startmeeting service_chaining
17:00:10 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Nov 17 17:00:09 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is LouisF. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:11 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:13 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'service_chaining'
17:00:30 <pcarver> hi
17:00:36 <mohankumar> hi
17:00:37 <igordcard> hi
17:00:38 <scsnow> hi
17:00:49 <bcafarel> hello
17:00:58 <LouisF> ho all
17:01:46 <LouisF> agenda for today https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/ServiceFunctionChainingMeeting#Agenda_for_the_Networking-SFC_Meeting_.2811.2F17.2F2017.29
17:02:31 <LouisF> in the process of pulling a newton branch
17:03:35 <LouisF> #topic stadium work
17:04:06 <LouisF> we have made good progress with commits recently
17:04:45 <LouisF> hi doonhammer
17:04:54 <doonhammer> Hi louisF
17:05:40 <LouisF> osc commit is done
17:06:09 <LouisF> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/344920/
17:06:40 <LouisF> grafana commit https://review.openstack.org/#/c/386081 done
17:07:07 <LouisF> release notes https://review.openstack.org/#/c/389799/ in review
17:07:38 <LouisF> pcarver: where are we on the api-ref?
17:07:39 <bcafarel> the grafana part was committed? I see it "Needs Workflow"
17:08:36 <pcarver> LouisF: I think it's mostly done, but I've been having trouble getting networking-sfc running in Devstack from trunk. I was going to validate all the examples but got bogged down by that.
17:09:04 <pcarver> I did validate most of the examples with the Mitaka release
17:09:36 <LouisF> bcafarel: see https://review.openstack.org/#/c/396440/
17:09:46 <LouisF> pcarver: ok thanks
17:10:15 <pcarver> I'm also behind on reviews in general so there might be some review comments buried in my inbox. I'll get to them if there are any.
17:10:25 <bcafarel> LouisF: ok :) another stadium checkbox ticked, nice
17:10:31 <pcarver> But on the whole, I think the api-ref is ok
17:10:40 <LouisF> pcarver: good
17:11:08 <pcarver> I believe that Armando's requirement is that all the other stadium checkboxes need to be checked before we're allowed to merge the api-ref
17:11:26 <LouisF> we hace come a long way in getting stadium compliant
17:12:45 <LouisF> pcarver: networking-ovn has several unchecked although they are a well run project
17:14:19 <LouisF> ocate assessment https://review.openstack.org/#/c/383913/
17:16:08 <LouisF> the ones we have not completed are C4 - fullstack testing
17:16:09 <bcafarel> generated version is at: http://specs.openstack.org/openstack/neutron-specs/specs/stadium/ocata/networking-sfc.html
17:16:53 <LouisF> C6 - upgrade testing
17:17:52 <LouisF> D3 - release notes in in progress
17:18:29 <LouisF> i'm not sure how benefit is added by fullstack testing - anyone?
17:20:15 <LouisF> N2 neutron-lib support can be down by helping out there
17:21:27 <LouisF> ok moving on
17:22:00 <LouisF> #topic ocata work
17:23:16 <LouisF> key items include: symmetric chain in ovs driver/agent, graphs, horizon, heat, ...
17:23:57 <mohankumar> LouisF , Heat support already done
17:23:58 <LouisF> ovn driver
17:24:17 <LouisF> mohankumar: thanks what is  the commit?
17:25:31 <mohankumar> https://github.com/openstack/heat/tree/master/heat/engine/resources/openstack/neutron/sfc
17:25:55 <LouisF> mohankumar: thanks for your work on that
17:26:50 <LouisF> there is quite a bit of work - please volunteer for areas you have interest
17:28:29 <doonhammer> LouisF: I can work on the ovn driver - though I have a lot of internal work (day job) for the next several months
17:28:48 <LouisF> doonhammer: thanks
17:28:56 <LouisF> moving on
17:29:36 <LouisF> let me know if anyone wants to work on any area or have other suggestions
17:29:47 <LouisF> #topic current work
17:30:03 <mohankumar> LouisF, Horizon we completed 75%  on coding (dashboard able to make up with horizon tree ) , But JS plugin support need to add to include horizon bindings dymanically .. anyone can help on this ?
17:30:26 <LouisF> anyone?
17:31:08 <LouisF> let mohan know if you can work with him on horizon
17:31:18 <LouisF> Added CLI parameter validation https://review.openstack.org/#/c/388597/
17:31:53 <LouisF> please review this
17:32:38 <mohankumar> LouisF , okay .. will review
17:32:48 <LouisF> mohankumar: thanks
17:33:06 <LouisF> scsnow: you did this patch - right?
17:33:19 <scsnow> LouisF, correct
17:33:31 <LouisF> scsnow: thanks for your work
17:34:07 <scsnow> LouisF, np, if you have more tasks - let me know.
17:34:43 <LouisF> scsnow: there was the service_type we mentioned in the review
17:34:54 <igordcard> ;
17:35:09 <scsnow> LouisF, right, I'll submit separate review
17:35:17 <LouisF> scsnow: thanks
17:35:25 <scsnow> How to handle this parameter in agent?
17:36:29 <LouisF> scsnow: depends on behavior of SF
17:37:18 <LouisF> some backends may need this
17:37:31 <scsnow> So just add this parameter in API/CLI for now?
17:37:39 <LouisF> scsnow: yes
17:39:03 <LouisF> ok we covered release notes and api patches
17:39:39 <LouisF> igordcard: what is the status of your work?
17:40:43 <igordcard> I'm rebasing the current patches and will be finishing the graphs work
17:41:08 <igordcard> I was on vacation and then working on pending tasks
17:41:13 <LouisF> igordcard: great - enjoyed your talk at the summit
17:41:18 <igordcard> graphs work will still be ready around end of nov / begin of dec
17:41:29 <igordcard> thank you LouisF
17:42:06 <LouisF> any other work i have missed?
17:42:20 <igordcard> the nsh patch is essentially done and tested, but I have to do some manual testing specially on corner cases like crossing vlans
17:42:35 <igordcard> but the team can already start doing some light reviews
17:42:44 <LouisF> igordcard: ok thanks will review when you post
17:43:19 <bcafarel> I will take a "light look" then
17:43:46 <LouisF> bcafarel: can you clarify?
17:44:29 <igordcard> LouisF: I mentioned "light reviews" regarding my nsh patch :)
17:44:56 <bcafarel> indeed :) I did not take a look at it yet as it was still WIP
17:45:06 <LouisF> aha i need another cup of joe
17:45:41 <LouisF> ok moving on
17:45:49 <LouisF> #topic bug  scrub
17:46:15 <LouisF> there several new bugs
17:46:52 <LouisF> https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-sfc/+bug/1642352
17:46:52 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1642352 in networking-sfc "ImportError: No module named db" [Undecided,New]
17:47:16 <LouisF> https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-sfc/+bug/1638421
17:47:16 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1638421 in networking-sfc "Flow Classifier Validation Error" [Undecided,Confirmed]
17:47:34 <LouisF> https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-sfc/+bug/1638282
17:47:34 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1638282 in networking-sfc "The output of neutron port-chain-create have duplicate tenant_id " [Undecided,New]
17:47:58 <LouisF> https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-sfc/+bug/1630657
17:47:58 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1630657 in networking-sfc "project_id not being leveraged by the OVS driver" [Undecided,New]
17:48:34 <LouisF> https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-sfc/+bug/1634493
17:48:34 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1634493 in networking-sfc "port chain update breaks the chain in certain cases" [Undecided,New]
17:49:10 <LouisF> https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-sfc/+bug/1637405
17:49:11 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1637405 in tacker "SfcDriverError: create_port_chain_postcommit failed" [Medium,New]
17:49:51 <LouisF> please review this list and take a bug
17:50:06 <bcafarel> ack, I can take a look at some of these
17:50:14 <LouisF> bcafarel: thanks
17:50:47 <mohankumar> LouisF : ok
17:50:48 <LouisF> post questions if there is not sufficient information
17:50:52 <LouisF> mohankumar: thanks
17:52:15 <LouisF> this is all i have - any other questions, ideas?
17:53:15 <LouisF> ok thanks all
17:53:46 <LouisF> that's it for today - there will not be a meeting next as its thanksgiving in the us
17:53:52 <LouisF> next week
17:54:03 <bcafarel> ok
17:54:30 <LouisF> bye all
17:54:43 <bcafarel> see you in 2 weeks then, bye!
17:54:57 <LouisF> ok
17:55:03 <LouisF> #endmeeting