17:06:36 <LouisF> #startmeeting service_chaining
17:06:36 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Dec  8 17:06:36 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is LouisF. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:06:38 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:06:40 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'service_chaining'
17:06:45 <LouisF> hi all
17:06:49 <pcarver> hi
17:07:27 <bcafarel> hi (I won't be there for long, have to drop in a few minutes)
17:07:42 <LouisF> agenda for today https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/ServiceFunctionChainingMeeting#Agenda_for_the_Networking-SFC_Meeting_.2812.2F8.2F2017.29
17:08:29 <LouisF> bcafarel: thanks for your latest pacthes
17:08:56 <LouisF> #topic stadium work
17:09:08 <bcafarel> LouisF: thanks for reviewing and merging :) I hope we can get these stable (and voting)
17:09:19 <LouisF> bcafarel: yes
17:10:15 <LouisF> API reference https://review.openstack.org/#/c/389385
17:10:47 <LouisF> pcarver: how is progress on this?
17:10:54 <pcarver> The API reference part is ok, I think. The API definition part is a bit more hassle.
17:11:17 <pcarver> I need to figure out if I need to move the converters too.
17:11:47 <pcarver> pulling out constants was one thing, but the resource map depends on SFC specific converters.
17:11:57 <LouisF> pcarver: ok
17:12:11 <pcarver> So now the question is, do those converters need to be moved too.
17:12:50 <LouisF> pcarver: armando would be able to answer that
17:12:52 <pcarver> I guess I could possibly pull out the definitions file into a separate change so that the API ref change can merge
17:13:09 <pcarver> but moving the definitions is also a stadium criteria
17:13:25 <pcarver> which is why I was doing both
17:13:30 <LouisF> pcarver: ok
17:13:47 <LouisF> how have other projects handled this?
17:14:06 <LouisF> networking-ovn for instance?
17:14:23 <pcarver> not much has been merged yet
17:14:47 <pcarver> https://github.com/openstack/neutron-lib/tree/master/neutron_lib/api/definitions
17:14:56 <bcafarel> everybody wating for the first working example?
17:15:04 <pcarver> That's what's currently been merged. Just trunk and a "dummy" example
17:15:53 <pcarver> FWaaS is on patch set 9 and not merged yet: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/389388/
17:17:13 <pcarver> I'm working the BGPVPN one in parallel with SFC. That hasn't merged yet but has a different problem.
17:17:21 <LouisF> pcarver: which convertor functions are needed?
17:17:45 <pcarver> normalize_sf_parameters, normalize_port_pair_groups, normalize_chain_parameters, normalize_ppg_parameters
17:18:04 <pcarver> I could just go ahead and move the function definitions into neutron-lib and see if anyone complains
17:18:48 * bcafarel has to drop off, will read the meeting log later
17:18:50 <pcarver> I don't think we want to import them from networking-sfc to neutron-lib because that would cause neutron-lib to have a dependency on networking-sfc (which I think is not wanted)
17:19:06 <LouisF> pcarver: agree
17:19:17 <pcarver> The function definitions aren't large
17:19:33 <LouisF> pcarver: sounds like a good approach
17:20:02 <pcarver> ok. I'll do that. It's easy enough to copy and paste and then undo it if it turns out to be wrong.
17:20:23 <LouisF> pcarver: ok let us know if you need help
17:20:34 <pcarver> ok
17:20:54 <LouisF> next CLI in python-neutronclient https://review.openstack.org/#/c/407271/
17:21:49 <LouisF> i contacted Mohan and he indicated he would do the port
17:22:11 <LouisF> s3wong: hi
17:22:25 <s3wong> LouisF: hello --- sorry, late again
17:22:28 <LouisF> #topic Ocata work
17:23:27 <LouisF> btw now that tempest/func tests are working we plan to make them voting
17:24:07 <LouisF> igordcard: how is progress with the sfc graph work?
17:25:37 <LouisF> moving on  - symmetric chain work is almost complete
17:25:58 <LouisF> doonhammer: how is ovn work?
17:26:53 <igordcard> LouisF: I'm progressing on it, working on the plugin and tests
17:27:01 <LouisF> igordcard: thanks
17:27:08 <priya> hello, I am collaborating with mohan on port task
17:27:35 <doonhammer> LouisF: Ah been pulled off onto something else for the last few weeks - hopefully I will get back to it next week - I need to start blocking off time for it
17:27:36 <LouisF> priya: thanks
17:27:55 <doonhammer> and Flavio got pulled completely
17:28:11 <LouisF> doonhammer: too bad about Flavio
17:28:40 <LouisF> i'd like to get the basic chaining working
17:29:06 <LouisF> and have a patch for the sfc-ovn driver
17:29:40 <doonhammer> LouisF: Okay agreed
17:30:02 <LouisF> doonhammer: thanks John
17:30:30 <LouisF> priya: let us know progress on the python-neutronclient port
17:31:10 <priya> yeah will do
17:31:21 <LouisF> priya: thanks
17:31:34 <priya> Are there any other tasks going on ? I would like to contribute
17:32:44 <LouisF> priya: yes we have a number of bugs https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-sfc
17:33:24 <LouisF> anyone sign up for a bug please
17:34:03 <priya> okay, will go through the bugs :)
17:34:13 <LouisF> igordcard: question on Revert strict del-flows https://review.openstack.org/#/c/406938
17:34:27 <LouisF> why the revert?
17:34:50 <LouisF> priya: thanks
17:38:22 <LouisF> ok moving on
17:38:34 <LouisF> #topic bugs
17:39:12 <LouisF> as i mentioned there are a number of bugs https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-sfc
17:39:54 <LouisF> some of them lack sufficient detail - i will post questions on those
17:40:49 <LouisF> look them over and sign up where you have interest
17:41:42 <LouisF> #topic Ocata assessment
17:41:49 <LouisF> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/389397/
17:42:54 <LouisF> there are three items that still need work
17:43:36 <LouisF> 1. api reference 2. voting tempest/functional tests 3. cli port
17:44:28 <LouisF> i would like to get this work done soon to ensure we are in Ocata
17:45:08 <LouisF> we are making progress on these items
17:45:33 <LouisF> any other items to discuss?
17:46:08 <LouisF> ok thanks all
17:46:22 <LouisF> bye
17:46:33 <pcarver> bye
17:46:51 <LouisF> #endmeeting