17:08:34 <LouisF> #startmeeting service_chaining
17:08:34 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Nov 16 17:08:34 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is LouisF. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:08:35 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:08:36 <bcafarel> hello
17:08:38 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'service_chaining'
17:08:42 <LouisF> hi all
17:08:47 <vks1> bcafarel: hi
17:08:56 <bcafarel> hey vks1 LouisF
17:08:58 <LouisF> bcafarel: thanks for running  meeting
17:09:30 <bcafarel> LouisF: np, both weeks were quiet
17:09:38 <LouisF> #topic agenda
17:09:41 <LouisF> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/ServiceFunctionChainingMeeting
17:11:23 <LouisF> presented workshop with John Studarus
17:11:24 <LouisF> https://www.openstack.org/summit/sydney-2017/summit-schedule/events/19051/service-chaining-virtual-security-functions
17:11:52 <LouisF> 30+ attended
17:12:03 <bcafarel> nice
17:12:19 <LouisF> several labs
17:12:25 <vks1> nice
17:12:56 <vks1> LouisF: do we have recording uploaded anywhere ?
17:13:10 <LouisF> https://github.com/OpenStackSanDiego/SecurityServiceChains/blob/master/README.md
17:13:37 <LouisF> no recording but I think John has left the labs available
17:14:27 <LouisF> there give a good introduction
17:14:31 <LouisF> they
17:15:11 <LouisF> #topic Zuul
17:15:19 <LouisF> bcafarel: what is status?
17:16:04 <bcafarel> the stable branch patches are waiting for someone with +2 power on stable branches to merge them (not urgent)
17:16:30 <bcafarel> in master we are all good :) jobs definitions are in-repo now, and grafana.openstack.org points to the new jobs now
17:16:52 <bcafarel> we can do some enhancements later on, but at least on the migration front, we can mark this as done
17:17:02 <LouisF> bc great thanks
17:17:31 <LouisF> #topic tempest split
17:18:03 <bcafarel> no news here, I'll bring it to the next neutron meeting on Tuesday (the previous ones were cancelled with the summit)
17:18:17 <LouisF> bcafarel: thanks
17:18:41 <LouisF> #topic sfc graphs/nsh dataplane
17:18:56 <LouisF> I think we about done with this
17:19:34 <bcafarel> yes, the remaining parts are in the "python-neutronclient updates" section
17:20:12 <vks1> bcafarel: thanks for updating neutronclient patch
17:20:51 <LouisF> did the branching-point syntax get merged?
17:21:33 <bcafarel> reviews still open: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+topic:sfc_encapsulation
17:21:51 <bcafarel> LouisF: in python-neutronclient? not yet but looking good
17:22:30 <LouisF> bcafarel: yes, thanks
17:23:30 <LouisF> #topic non-transparent SF
17:23:42 <LouisF> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/481840/
17:23:49 <LouisF> work to resume
17:24:15 <LouisF> #topic python-neutronclient updates
17:24:36 <LouisF> work still in progress..
17:24:55 <bcafarel> it was quiet with most people on the other side of the planet :)
17:25:03 <LouisF> bcafarel: yes
17:25:24 <LouisF> #topic api reference
17:25:40 <LouisF> i met with Thomas Morin at summit
17:28:05 <LouisF> he had some items for sfc: classifier in vm, common classifier, source network in classifier
17:28:41 <LouisF> he also asked if can move the meeting to an earlier time slot
17:29:20 <LouisF> i know this would help people in eu and india
17:29:43 <LouisF> suggestions?
17:30:14 <bcafarel> I recognize all 3 topics, we talked about them a bit before :)
17:30:59 <LouisF> vks1: you were looking at sfc metrics?
17:31:03 <bcafarel> as for time slot, moving earlier works for me
17:31:16 <vks1> moving to earlier slot is also fine for me
17:31:40 <LouisF> how about 1-2 hours earlier?
17:31:50 <vks1> +1
17:32:21 <LouisF> maybe on alternate weeks?
17:32:55 <LouisF> we can see what slots are available and pick on
17:33:08 <bcafarel> yes
17:33:25 <vks1> LouisF: regarding metrics, I am in midst of some changes in my workplace, so didn't investigate on that
17:33:44 <LouisF> vks1: np, we can add that to the list
17:33:50 <bcafarel> LouisF: maybe fill a doodle with possible time slots and send it to mailing list? we can all fill our availabilites in
17:34:11 <LouisF> bcafarel: sounds good
17:34:40 <bcafarel> vks1: don't dare disappear from networking-sfc, or we will start to feel alone around :'(
17:35:07 <vks1> bcafarel: haha no no ... I won't be disappearing :)
17:35:11 <LouisF> +1
17:35:35 <LouisF> ok moving on
17:35:52 <LouisF> #topic vm failure detection
17:36:10 <LouisF> what is status?
17:37:44 <bcafarel> vks1? I'd say probably still at the initial thoughts stage
17:38:01 <vks1> LouisF: me and bcafarel have discussed briefly, but I haven't progressed much there
17:38:07 <LouisF> +1
17:38:26 <LouisF> ok
17:38:39 <LouisF> #topic other items
17:38:48 <LouisF> anything else?
17:39:19 <bcafarel> I have a small patch I have to writ on networking-odl
17:39:58 <bcafarel> now that we accept correlation=nsh, the odl driver should check and require it (as they have always used nsh) and do not allow mpls
17:40:12 <bcafarel> but that's mostly to have correct parameters in our db, nothing major :)
17:40:22 <LouisF> bcafarel: ok thanks
17:40:58 <LouisF> ok, thats all i have
17:41:01 <LouisF> thanks all
17:41:04 <LouisF> bye
17:41:09 <bcafarel> bye!
17:41:13 <vks1> bye all
17:41:22 <LouisF> #endmeeting