05:03:14 <yamahata> #startmeeting servicevm-device-manager
05:03:15 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Jul 22 05:03:14 2014 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is yamahata. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
05:03:15 <natarajk> hi
05:03:16 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
05:03:18 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'servicevm_device_manager'
05:03:50 <yamahata> Do we have Bob? Let's give him minutes
05:05:34 <dougwig> whereabouts is everyone on this team?
05:06:28 <yamahata> To be honest, I'm not sure. I know it's early morning for Bob.
05:06:58 <ChristianM_> 7 am in Sweeden
05:07:12 <yamahata> It seems he won't attend. let's start
05:07:18 <s3wong> Bob is in Sweden
05:07:29 <yamahata> #topic Announcement
05:07:55 <yamahata> two neutron blueprints for routervm have been approved
05:08:02 <yamahata> congrants for bob and natarajk
05:08:10 <yamahata> we can make progress
05:08:11 <natarajk> yamahata: thanks
05:08:16 <natarajk> sure
05:08:52 <yamahata> I had replied to comments on servicevm api.
05:09:04 <yamahata> and I pushed new one.
05:09:10 <natarajk> yamahata: yes, i am planning to review the new patch tomorrow
05:09:18 <yamahata> natarajk: thanks,
05:10:03 <natarajk> yamahata: i hope the ml2 port security extension spec gets approved
05:10:05 <yamahata> we can start with it to come up with working reference routervm plugin
05:10:28 <yamahata> natarajk: yes, I applied for spec freeze exception of ml2 port security extension
05:10:55 <yamahata> any other announcements?
05:11:37 <yamahata> #topic api discussion
05:11:58 <yamahata> okay,do we have any items on api on irc?
05:12:21 <yamahata> any discussion can be continued at gerrit.
05:12:37 <natarajk> natarajk: i'll post my comments in gerrit tomorrow
05:12:50 <natarajk> oops
05:13:05 <natarajk> yamahata: i'll post my comments in gerrit tomorrow
05:13:14 <yamahata> Now I'm wondering where router-attach/dettach-interface should be done.
05:13:23 <yamahata> natarajk: thanks
05:13:58 <yamahata> I mean which neutron plugin or servicevm should call nova attach vif.
05:14:15 <yamahata> This is just a heads up for future discussion
05:14:52 <natarajk> yamahata: all the nova api related calls should be handled in service vm
05:15:20 <natarajk> so that i can be used by other plugin/drivers
05:15:32 <yamahata> natarajk: Yes. That's same to my current thinking.
05:16:00 <natarajk> but i believe bob's approach has static vifs
05:16:14 <natarajk> brocade relies on dynamic attach/detach vifs
05:16:33 <yamahata> natarajk: Bob's code has nova-attach/detach calls.
05:16:59 <yamahata> we can be looking at different code base, though.
05:17:35 <natarajk> in CSR plugin code, i saw that the VM with two vNICs were doing VLAN/VxLAN trunking
05:18:18 <yamahata> natarajk: It define plugging driver, the driver handles such stuff.
05:18:39 <yamahata> Unfortunately We don't have Bob today.
05:19:18 <natarajk> yamahata: anyway we need to have methods for attach/detach interfaces
05:19:27 <yamahata> natarajk: agreed
05:19:54 <yamahata> let's move on to the next topic
05:20:01 <yamahata> #topic l3-routervm-plugin
05:20:42 <yamahata> I'm still working on l3-plugin to consolidate csr and vyatta code. But I haven't have something which can be published yet.
05:20:56 <yamahata> I guess I need 1 or 2 weeks.
05:21:10 <yamahata> to publish something
05:21:29 <yamahata> #topic open discussion
05:22:26 <yamahata> anything to discuss?
05:22:58 <natarajk> yamahata: do we any requirements from NFV subgroup ?
05:23:04 <s3wong> yamahata: K-Summit speaker preso submission is three days away - you want to submit something for tacker?
05:23:25 <yamahata> s3wong: sounds good idea!
05:23:39 <yamahata> I'll give it a try
05:24:16 <yamahata> #action yamahata try to apply for K-summit speaker preso submission
05:24:18 <natarajk> s3wong, yamahata: Design summit session or speaker session ?
05:24:23 <s3wong> yamahata: cool - submission deadline is this Thursday (US time, I believe)
05:24:29 <s3wong> natarajk: speaker session
05:24:41 <s3wong> natarajk: design summit submission deadline is much much later
05:26:10 <natarajk> May be we can do combine session
05:26:19 <natarajk> combined session
05:26:26 <yamahata> natarajk: yeah, joint session
05:26:53 <s3wong> yamahata: natarajk: probably want to include Bob also
05:27:08 <natarajk> sure
05:27:08 <yamahata> #action yamahata contact Bob for joint session
05:28:28 <yamahata> natarajk: regarding to requiremnt NFV, I'd like to see that port without subnet will be settled down.
05:28:45 <natarajk> ok
05:28:53 <yamahata> But it seems we need to wait for Kilo cycle
05:29:31 <natarajk> yamahata: Do you how CSR plugin handles ip-spoofing issues ?
05:29:32 <s3wong> yamahata: a good number of what ijw filed didn't get approved by SAD
05:29:56 <natarajk> yamahata: Do you know how CSR plugin handles ip-spoofing issues ?
05:30:10 <yamahata> natarajk: although I don't know the details
05:30:30 <yamahata> natarajk: I guess they uses their own vif driver or something.
05:30:51 <yamahata> Or other cisco guy also proposing port security of ML2 plugin.
05:31:30 <natarajk> i'll send an e-mail to Bob to understand the details
05:31:43 <yamahata> natarajk: please CC to me.
05:31:51 <natarajk> sure
05:32:00 <yamahata> any other topics?
05:32:41 <yamahata> okay thank you everyone. See you next week.
05:32:46 <natarajk> bye
05:32:50 <yamahata> bye
05:32:51 <s3wong> thanks!
05:32:56 <yamahata> #endmeeting