17:00:17 <devkulkarni> #startmeeting Solum Team Meeting
17:00:18 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Mar  8 17:00:17 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is devkulkarni. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:19 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:21 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'solum_team_meeting'
17:00:34 <devkulkarni> #topic Roll Call
17:00:38 <devkulkarni> Devdatta Kulkarni
17:00:40 <ashishjain> Ashish Jain
17:01:16 <devkulkarni> hi ashishjain.. lets wait for few minutes for others to join
17:01:38 <devkulkarni> in the mean time, here is the agenda for today: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Solum#Weekly_Solum_Team_Meeting
17:01:49 <ashishjain> hi devkulkarni
17:03:00 <ashishjain> btw I see we have released a new component solum guest agent
17:03:16 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: it is not new
17:03:27 <devkulkarni> we have it, but have never used it
17:03:29 <vijendar> o/
17:03:35 <devkulkarni> hi vijendar
17:03:41 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, okay
17:03:42 <devkulkarni> we have ashishjain with us as well
17:04:08 <devkulkarni> lets wait for another minute and then we can get started
17:04:16 <ashishjain> hi vijendar
17:04:19 <pt_15> devkulkarni: Hi!
17:04:35 <devkulkarni> pt_15: hi
17:04:42 <devkulkarni> good to see you for the meeting
17:04:50 <devkulkarni> we have ashishjain and vijendar with us as well
17:05:29 <devkulkarni> pt_15 and ashishjain: I wanted to get you two introduced as you are in the same timezone (in India)
17:05:40 <devkulkarni> finally both of you are in the same meeting :)
17:06:08 <ashishjain> pt_15 hi
17:07:05 <devkulkarni> it will be good to brainstorm and discuss between you two if you run into any issues
17:07:12 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, agreed
17:07:19 <devkulkarni> alright, lets get started
17:07:28 <devkulkarni> here is the agenda: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Solum#Weekly_Solum_Team_Meeting
17:07:36 <devkulkarni> #topic Announcements
17:07:43 <devkulkarni> 1) Our CI/CD talk has been accepted for the Austin summit
17:07:49 <devkulkarni> https://www.openstack.org/summit/austin-2016/summit-schedule/events/7842
17:07:54 <devkulkarni> congratulations ashishjain
17:07:55 <pt_15> ashishjain: Hi!
17:08:14 <pt_15> Sorry, my internet connection is a little slow today
17:08:17 <ashishjain> Congratulations devkulkarni,  excited to see this
17:08:28 <devkulkarni> yes, this is very exciting
17:08:29 <vijendar> congrats to ashishjain and devkulkarni
17:08:36 <devkulkarni> thanks vijendar
17:08:38 <ashishjain> vijendar thanks
17:08:45 <devkulkarni> we all worked towards this actually
17:08:55 <devkulkarni> so congratulations to the entire team
17:08:58 <ashishjain> yeah absolutely,
17:09:07 <ashishjain> congrats to everyone
17:09:12 <devkulkarni> we now have official time and place to talk about solum
17:09:13 <vijendar> :)
17:09:38 <devkulkarni> lets work towards making this a great presentation now
17:09:39 <ashishjain> absolutely
17:09:58 <vijendar> let's us know if we can help in any way to make this talk a success
17:10:11 <devkulkarni> +1 vijendar
17:10:18 <ashishjain> surely vijendar
17:10:29 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: let us know if you need any help with Austin travel
17:10:48 <devkulkarni> we should be able to provide you with pointers to hotels etc.
17:10:57 <devkulkarni> I am sure the openstack summit website will have this info
17:10:58 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, sure I am anyways coming to your city this time :D
17:11:04 <devkulkarni> yep
17:11:33 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, My organisation will take care of this but will definitely get in touch with you guys for any pointers
17:11:43 <devkulkarni> sounds good
17:11:52 <devkulkarni> yeah, vijendar and I both are in Austin
17:11:56 <ashishjain> This is my first US travel to so will definitely need lot of pointers :)
17:11:57 <devkulkarni> and dimtruck and mkam
17:12:02 <devkulkarni> oh okay
17:12:15 <ashishjain> wow thats nice
17:12:18 <devkulkarni> best flight for you might be Bangalore - London - Austin
17:12:38 <devkulkarni> we can try to get together as Solum team for a dinner/lunch if folks are interested
17:12:44 <ashishjain> cool, how much time does it take to US from Bangalore
17:13:12 <devkulkarni> 16/17 hours of travel time. if you stop in europe it is roughly half each way
17:13:22 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, that would be cool, I think last day when the summit ends could be a good day?
17:13:41 <devkulkarni> there are directly flights to Austin from London, New Jersey, Houston
17:13:45 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: sure
17:13:55 <ashishjain> and openstack anyways provides lot of opportunities to have fun together
17:14:02 <devkulkarni> let me check with folks and see if we can do something
17:14:07 <devkulkarni> yes, that is true
17:14:29 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, thanks for these flight stuff
17:14:45 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: if you direct flights from banglore to NJ or London, that will be the easiest route for you
17:14:57 <ashishjain> How will weather be in austin, I think it would be pleasant as you pointed out sometime back
17:14:59 <devkulkarni> if not, then you might have to take two stop flights
17:15:08 <devkulkarni> yes, the weather will be very pleasant
17:15:21 <ashishjain> aah okay, would see if I can get direct flight
17:15:23 <devkulkarni> you would not need to bring snow jacket or anything
17:15:39 <devkulkarni> a light sweater/jacket and a umbrella should be enough
17:15:56 <ashishjain> okay, does it rain at this point of time there ?
17:16:15 <devkulkarni> it does occasionally.
17:16:20 <ashishjain> okay
17:16:39 <devkulkarni> alright.. lets continue
17:16:53 <devkulkarni> we can discuss more about logistics in the open discussion or on solum irc channel
17:16:57 <devkulkarni> 2) Solum library releases
17:17:03 <devkulkarni> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-announce/2016-March/000987.html
17:17:08 <devkulkarni> Solum library releases
17:17:13 <devkulkarni> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-announce/2016-March/000988.html
17:17:17 <devkulkarni> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-announce/2016-March/000986.html
17:17:44 <ashishjain> congratulations to the complete team on these releases
17:17:46 <devkulkarni> last week the openstack-release team tagged releases for python-solumclient, solum-dashboard, and solum-infra-guestagent
17:18:00 <devkulkarni> yes, heartiest congratulations on the releases
17:18:10 <devkulkarni> the release for solum itself is also done
17:18:11 <ashishjain> btw why is solum not listed on this?
17:18:27 <devkulkarni> I don't know why the email did not go out on the openstack-announce list
17:18:31 <devkulkarni> ^
17:18:41 <devkulkarni> was planning to check with the release team about this
17:18:46 <ashishjain> aah okay, so it has been released
17:18:55 <ashishjain> solum-dashboard?
17:18:59 <devkulkarni> either that, or it will be released this week
17:19:02 <ashishjain> solum guest agent?
17:19:20 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, do we have more details on these 2 components
17:19:24 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: solum-dashboard is horizon plugin for solum
17:19:37 <ashishjain> okay
17:19:41 <devkulkarni> we are trying to revive it these days
17:19:57 <devkulkarni> now that we have end-to-end app deployment working using cli
17:20:08 <ashishjain> yeah
17:20:12 <devkulkarni> it will be great if we have the horizon plugin working before the summit
17:20:28 <devkulkarni> pt_15 is leading this effort
17:21:03 <devkulkarni> pt_15: do you want to share with the team what have you learnt so far wrt to the solum-dashboard?
17:21:03 <ashishjain> pt_15 ohh wow, nice
17:21:45 <devkulkarni> pt_15 has slow internet connection
17:22:02 <ashishjain> yeah
17:22:05 <devkulkarni> so while we wait to hear from her, let us continue
17:22:28 <devkulkarni> 3) Mitaka global bug smash happening this week (March 7 - 9)
17:22:57 <devkulkarni> if any of you are participating, let me know what bugs you are working on
17:23:09 <devkulkarni> 4) Updates on end-to-end application deployment in devstack
17:23:15 <devkulkarni> https://github.com/devdattakulkarni/solum-provenance/blob/master/steps-to-enable-solum-with-devstack
17:23:19 <devkulkarni> https://github.com/openstack/solum/blob/master/devstack/devstack-provenance
17:23:30 <devkulkarni> https://github.com/rackerlabs/vagrant-solum-dev
17:23:38 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: this update is especially for you
17:23:50 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, yeah looking
17:23:51 <devkulkarni> let me give details about each of those links
17:23:59 <ashishjain> yeah
17:24:18 <devkulkarni> the first link is compilation of steps to get to working solum setup in devstack
17:24:34 <ashishjain> so now we need to follow these steps to build solum?
17:24:41 <devkulkarni> vijendar, pt_15, and I have all tried those steps and they work
17:24:51 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: not necessarily
17:24:57 <ashishjain> so we no longer use vagrant?
17:25:00 <devkulkarni> you can also use vagrant
17:25:07 <devkulkarni> that is the third link above
17:25:13 <ashishjain> okay but these steps are no longer valid
17:25:16 <devkulkarni> I have updated vagrant to use these steps as well
17:25:43 <ashishjain> http://docs.openstack.org/developer/solum/getting_started/
17:25:52 <devkulkarni> no the steps given in https://github.com/devdattakulkarni/solum-provenance/blob/master/steps-to-enable-solum-with-devstack are the steps that one can use to setup solum without vagrant
17:26:00 <ashishjain> vagrant up --provision devstack?
17:26:06 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: that will also work
17:26:07 <ashishjain> aah okay
17:26:11 <ashishjain> cool
17:26:16 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: let me give some background
17:26:21 <pt_15> devkulkarni: ashishjain: wrt to the solum-dashboard one of the main things that needed to be done was rearranging of the folder since the new horizon plugin api requires a different structure than the current one
17:26:37 <ashishjain> sure devkulkarni
17:27:02 <devkulkarni> couple of weeks back, former ptl of cinder asked us in our irc meeting if there are any steps to start solum in devstack without using vagrant
17:27:28 <devkulkarni> that led me to creating this: https://github.com/devdattakulkarni/solum-provenance/blob/master/steps-to-enable-solum-with-devstack
17:27:40 <ashishjain> okay
17:27:45 <devkulkarni> of course, the main issue for us for the longest time has been that the app not becoming READY
17:27:54 <devkulkarni> I wanted to solve that as well
17:28:13 <ashishjain> correct
17:28:17 <ashishjain> how did you solve it?
17:28:27 <devkulkarni> after lot of trial and error and googling, I realized that the issue is with neutron and IPv6
17:28:34 <devkulkarni> so the solution is this:
17:28:54 <devkulkarni> in local.conf we have set variables to make neutron not create IPv6 subnets at all
17:29:15 <devkulkarni> https://github.com/devdattakulkarni/solum-provenance/blob/master/local.conf#L24
17:29:20 <devkulkarni> https://github.com/devdattakulkarni/solum-provenance/blob/master/local.conf#L25
17:29:30 <devkulkarni> that is all
17:29:42 <devkulkarni> this causes neutron to only create ipv4 subnets
17:30:00 <ashishjain> nice, so earlier was neutron only creating ipv6?
17:30:10 <devkulkarni> and this in turn allows nova and docker to correctly use ipv4 addresses
17:30:22 <devkulkarni> no, neutron was creating both ipv6 and ipv4
17:30:38 <ashishjain> okay
17:30:41 <devkulkarni> what was happening was, randomly nova would get ipv6 address from neutron
17:30:57 <ashishjain> okay
17:31:05 <devkulkarni> and that was causing issues for docker
17:31:16 <devkulkarni> it is explained in this link:
17:31:42 <devkulkarni> http://blog.oddbit.com/2015/02/11/installing-novadocker-with-devstack/
17:31:51 <devkulkarni> check the comment by nindate
17:32:01 <devkulkarni> that comment was the clue
17:32:14 <devkulkarni> so ashishjain
17:32:23 <devkulkarni> if you currently have devstack vm
17:32:36 <devkulkarni> I would suggest add those two configuration variables in local.conf
17:32:43 <devkulkarni> and then try unstack and stack
17:33:10 <devkulkarni> if you don't have devstack vm, I would suggest to pull latest Vagrantfile from vagrant repo
17:33:17 <devkulkarni> and then try vagrant up —provision
17:33:34 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: about the liberasurecode issue
17:33:38 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, just updated the vagrant source, will that help?
17:33:56 <devkulkarni> yes, that should help
17:34:03 <ashishjain> aaah ya that should help
17:34:04 <devkulkarni> I have fixed the liberarurecode issue in Vagrantfile
17:34:07 <devkulkarni> https://github.com/rackerlabs/vagrant-solum-dev/blob/master/Vagrantfile#L263
17:34:43 <ashishjain> actually I tried manually installing this library .. liberasurecode-dev somehow it fails all th time
17:35:03 <ashishjain> anyways thanks for these fixes devkulkarni
17:35:06 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: most likely it is failing because it it not finding in sources
17:35:13 <ashishjain> will try it out and let you know my feedback
17:35:17 <devkulkarni> liberasurecode-dev is available in trusty-backports
17:35:29 <devkulkarni> we need to add it to sources
17:35:34 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, aah okay I was adding main universe
17:35:40 <devkulkarni> echo "deb http://archive.ubuntu.com/ubuntu trusty-backports main restricted universe multiverse" >> /etc/apt/sources.list
17:35:47 <devkulkarni> echo "deb-src http://archive.ubuntu.com/ubuntu trusty-backports main restricted universe multiverse" >> /etc/apt/sources.list
17:36:06 <devkulkarni> check lines 263-268 in Vagrantfile
17:36:13 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, yeah it is there in the Vagrantfile
17:36:27 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: definitely try it and let me know if it works for you or not
17:36:39 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, sure
17:36:48 <devkulkarni> cool
17:36:53 <devkulkarni> thanks pt_15
17:37:07 <devkulkarni> alright
17:37:11 <devkulkarni> lets move next topic
17:37:19 <devkulkarni> #topic Action Items
17:37:26 <devkulkarni> (done) Sending space request to summit organizers. Have requested for 1 fishbowl session and 1 work session OR 1 fishbowl session.
17:37:59 <devkulkarni> By last friday all the projects were required to submit request for the space required at the Austin summit to the summit organizers
17:38:01 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, what is fishbowl session
17:38:22 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: the same kind of session that we had in Tokyo
17:38:38 <ashishjain> okay and what about design summit
17:38:45 <devkulkarni> basically a session to provide overall project details etc.
17:38:58 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, okay
17:39:05 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: fishbowl and worksessions are part of the design summit
17:39:09 <anteaya> fishbowls are meant to be discussion sessions
17:39:12 <devkulkarni> the difference between the two is this
17:39:23 <anteaya> worksessions are meant to be like a code sprint session
17:39:28 <devkulkarni> yes
17:39:44 <devkulkarni> it is mainly meant for the contributors
17:39:47 <ashishjain> anteaya, thanks
17:39:50 <anteaya> welcome
17:40:09 <devkulkarni> to come together and discuss about next items to work on etc.
17:40:12 <ashishjain> okay so we have only 1 design session
17:40:29 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: we have requested for 1 work session and 1 fishbowl session
17:40:40 <devkulkarni> I think that should be enough for us
17:40:40 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, okay
17:41:06 <devkulkarni> if we don't get work session (due to space constraints), then we have requested for 1 fishbowl session
17:41:25 <devkulkarni> this time around there are several new projects and the space is limited
17:41:26 <ashishjain> okay
17:41:35 <devkulkarni> cool
17:41:38 <ashishjain> what are the new projects devkulkarni
17:42:01 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: there were quite a few accepted into the the big tent. don't remember off the top of my head
17:42:10 <devkulkarni> can find out before the next meeting
17:42:14 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, sure let us discuss on out channgel
17:42:22 <devkulkarni> sounds good
17:42:23 <ashishjain> *our channel
17:42:38 <devkulkarni> lets quickly go through the next topics
17:42:50 <devkulkarni> #topic Patches for Review
17:42:57 <devkulkarni> 1) Solum dashboard
17:43:01 <devkulkarni> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/solum-dashboard+status:open,n,z
17:43:05 <devkulkarni> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/277197/
17:43:19 <devkulkarni> these are patches on the solum-dashboard repo
17:43:45 <devkulkarni> looks like all of them are failing due to similar issues
17:43:56 <devkulkarni> pep8 is failing because of some pbr issue
17:44:20 <devkulkarni> if any of you have time, check out the errors and see if you get any ideas
17:44:31 <vijendar> what is going on with https://review.openstack.org/#/c/263624/
17:44:33 <devkulkarni> I will also spend some time today looking at these
17:44:44 <devkulkarni> vijendar: yes, good point
17:44:48 <vijendar> all gates are failing for this
17:45:00 <devkulkarni> vijendar: I was looking into it this morning
17:45:10 <devkulkarni> for pep8, it looks to be a pbr issue
17:45:11 <devkulkarni> http://logs.openstack.org/24/263624/2/check/gate-solum-dashboard-pep8/10f7137/console.html
17:45:31 <devkulkarni> http://logs.openstack.org/24/263624/2/check/gate-solum-dashboard-pep8/10f7137/console.html#_2016-03-08_09_56_52_882
17:45:57 <devkulkarni> same thing for the docs gate
17:45:58 <devkulkarni> http://logs.openstack.org/24/263624/2/check/gate-solum-dashboard-docs/57b6f45/console.html#_2016-03-08_09_54_13_383
17:46:03 <vijendar> ok
17:46:34 <devkulkarni> same for py27
17:46:35 <devkulkarni> http://logs.openstack.org/24/263624/2/check/gate-solum-dashboard-python27/a64902e/console.html#_2016-03-08_09_53_19_706
17:47:03 <devkulkarni> and for pypy
17:47:04 <devkulkarni> http://logs.openstack.org/24/263624/2/check/gate-solum-dashboard-pypy/2bc79c1/console.html#_2016-03-08_09_55_06_928
17:47:06 <ashishjain> None of these links seems to be working  http://git.openstack.org/cgit/stackforge/solum-infra-guestagent
17:47:16 <ashishjain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/solum-infra-guestagent
17:47:37 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: where did you get these links?
17:47:53 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, the guest agent announcement
17:47:59 <devkulkarni> vijendar: I am suspecting that fixing that pbr issue will unblock all the other patches as well
17:48:04 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: oh ok
17:48:05 <ashishjain> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-announce/2016-March/000986.html
17:48:06 <devkulkarni> let me check
17:48:09 <vijendar> ok
17:49:10 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: hmm.. strange
17:49:17 <devkulkarni> I will check with the release team about this
17:49:21 <devkulkarni> thanks for catching it
17:49:50 <devkulkarni> I haven't looked at the other announcement emails
17:49:56 <devkulkarni> will be good to check those as well
17:50:18 <ashishjain> solum-dashboard mail does not have any links
17:50:31 <devkulkarni> how about python-solumclient
17:50:52 <ashishjain> that too does not have any links
17:51:00 <ashishjain> about source, or other details
17:51:12 <devkulkarni> ok, so it is just the solum guest agent
17:51:28 <devkulkarni> let me check with the release team about this
17:51:39 <ashishjain> ideally announcements will not have any links?
17:52:05 <devkulkarni> seems like some announcements have links some others don't
17:52:24 <devkulkarni> probably, the first announcement of a project might have links in that annoucement
17:52:42 <devkulkarni> since this was probably the first announcement for guest agent, hence it had links
17:52:43 <ashishjain> ok
17:52:57 <devkulkarni> I don't remember if we had released it before
17:53:06 <devkulkarni> cool
17:53:17 <devkulkarni> we have just about 7 minutes
17:53:28 <devkulkarni> let me skip over to open discussion
17:53:36 <devkulkarni> the bugs which I have listed are from last week
17:53:48 <devkulkarni> no new bug has been filed in this week
17:54:09 <devkulkarni> vijendar: I saw that you had updated the separate app data and param data bug description with details
17:54:13 <devkulkarni> thanks for that
17:54:21 <devkulkarni> #topic Open discussion
17:54:30 <devkulkarni> 1) Push to move away from WSME
17:54:34 <devkulkarni> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2016-March/088658.html
17:54:50 <devkulkarni> there was an email this morning about wsme
17:55:16 <devkulkarni> basically, wsme seems to be not well maintained and folks are suggesting projects to move away from it if possible
17:55:22 <devkulkarni> we use wsme and pecan
17:55:37 <devkulkarni> it will be good for us to figure out what will it take to move away from wsme
17:55:53 <devkulkarni> 2) Keystone single sign-on research
17:55:58 <devkulkarni> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2016-March/088674.html
17:56:05 <devkulkarni> This came out today as well.
17:57:16 <devkulkarni> 3) Configuration management tool for OpenStack
17:57:19 <devkulkarni> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2016-March/088518.html
17:57:47 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: I thought you might be able to provide feedback on this thread based on your use of kolla and openstack-ansible
17:58:00 <devkulkarni> 4) New API guidelines for review
17:58:05 <devkulkarni> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2016-March/088568.html
17:58:13 <devkulkarni> there are new API guidelines for review
17:58:36 <devkulkarni> I had some comments regarding header definitions
17:58:47 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, OpenStack CM
17:58:59 <devkulkarni> if you have interest, I would encourage you to check the patch and provide any feedback
17:59:16 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: yeah, openstack configuration management
17:59:36 <devkulkarni> that is all I had in open discussion
17:59:39 <devkulkarni> anything else that we should discuss today?
18:00:09 <devkulkarni> alright.. it is top of the hour
18:00:21 <devkulkarni> thanks vijendar, ashishjain, pt_15 for joining today's meeting
18:00:23 <ashishjain> thanks devkulkarni
18:00:35 <devkulkarni> see you next week (and in solum irc channel before that)
18:00:39 <devkulkarni> #endmeeting