17:00:48 <sridhar_ram1> #startmeeting tacker 17:00:49 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Mar 1 17:00:48 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is sridhar_ram1. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 17:00:51 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 17:00:54 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tacker' 17:01:06 <sridhar_ram1> #topic Roll Call 17:01:11 <bobh> o/ 17:01:11 <sridhar_ram1> who is here for tacker ? 17:01:13 <tbh> o/ 17:01:16 <dkushwaha_> o/ 17:01:23 <brucet> o/ 17:01:43 * sridhar_ram1 lost my irc nick in the freenode cloud.. will be know as sridhar_ram1 for the this mtg 17:01:43 <Guest7539> o/ 17:01:50 <vishwanathj> o/ 17:01:55 <Shuaib> o/ 17:02:00 <Jim__> o/ 17:02:02 <sripriya_> o/ 17:02:27 <sridhar_ram1> alright... crowd is here, time to start! 17:02:32 <sridhar_ram1> #topic Agenda 17:02:47 <sridhar_ram1> #info #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Tacker#Meeting_Mar_1.2C_2016 17:03:36 <sridhar_ram1> I hope we will have time today for some open discussions ... 17:03:38 <zeih> hi 17:03:41 <s3wong> hello 17:04:00 <sridhar_ram1> #topic Annoucements 17:04:21 <sridhar_ram1> Tacker big tent application review still in progress at #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/276417 17:04:37 <sridhar_ram1> it couldn't get any more interesting than this... 17:04:47 <bobh> thats one work for it.... 17:04:51 <bobh> word 17:05:26 <sridhar_ram1> I truly hope we cross this bridge to recognize all the hard work that had went in so and more to come 17:05:37 <sridhar_ram1> *so far 17:05:54 <sridhar_ram1> next .. 17:06:07 <sridhar_ram1> We are in Mitaka release R-5 week.. 17:06:17 <sridhar_ram1> that is ... Release -5weeks 17:06:36 <sridhar_ram1> entering FeatureFreeze part of the schedule #link http://releases.openstack.org/mitaka/schedule.html 17:06:58 <sridhar_ram1> now that we are shooting for big tent, it is important to get inline with official release schedule.. 17:07:16 <sridhar_ram1> this also means .. it is crunch time *now*... if a feature looks risky we need to it defer to Newton. 17:08:06 <sridhar_ram1> anyone have questions related to deadline / target dates for their current work ? 17:08:48 <sridhar_ram1> We are shooting for Mar 18 code complete.. with a two week window for bug fixing and release around April 1st 17:09:27 <sridhar_ram1> moving on... 17:09:42 <sridhar_ram1> #topic TOSCA Parser Integration 17:10:03 <sridhar_ram1> first I'd like to land the specs ASAP.. 17:10:32 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: anything pending from your side for #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/275475 ? 17:10:55 <bobh> I have an update I need to push - should be tomorrow 17:11:12 <bobh> I wanted to add the changes to split out Simple Profile from NFV support - for the big tent discussion 17:11:13 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: okay.. 17:11:35 <bobh> maybe tonight if I'm lucky... 17:11:46 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: sounds good... 17:12:05 <sridhar_ram1> next spec.. 17:12:18 <brucet> bobh: Got a question on this 17:12:25 <sridhar_ram1> tbh: what remaining for #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/250291/ ? looks close to me 17:12:34 <bobh> brucet: y 17:12:56 <brucet> Is there anything really needed beyond Simple profile support right now?? 17:13:00 <tbh> sridhar_ram1, updated the patch based on the comments 17:13:26 <sridhar_ram1> tbh: I had a question on work items.. where you able to capture it ? 17:13:53 <bobh> brucet: if we want equivalent functionality to the current yaml format there is some pre/post processing of the TOSCA template required, along with some custom definitions for Tacker 17:13:54 <tbh> sridhar_ram1, except on functional tests, I am okay with the rest of it :) 17:14:28 <brucet> <bobh> Looks like I'm off topic. Will discuss separately. 17:14:50 <sridhar_ram1> tbh: I'm okay with getting func tests in a follow on patchset... we can find some volunteers to help out here 17:15:17 <sridhar_ram1> next .. 17:15:45 <sridhar_ram1> vishwanathj: EVP spec.. #link https://review.openstack.org/257847 17:15:57 <sridhar_ram1> vishwanathj: what is pending ? 17:16:50 <vishwanathj> I need to update the VNFD definition and examples with bobh and your comments, in the midst of doing it 17:17:18 <sridhar_ram1> vishwanathj: can be wrapped up soon ? any ETA ? 17:18:23 <vishwanathj> I hope to have an update to spec no later than tomorrow morning and would like to wrap up end of this week if I have reviewers bandwidth 17:18:47 <sridhar_ram1> vishwanathj: sounds good.. that's a good lead to ... 17:18:58 <sridhar_ram1> tacker-cores: bobh: s3wong 17:19:04 * sridhar_ram1 oops 17:19:36 <sridhar_ram1> tacker-cores: bobh: s3wong: sripriya_: please plan to review and merge these 3 spec over next couple of days... 17:19:44 <bobh> sridhar_ram1: will do 17:20:00 <sridhar_ram1> if you see any issues, follow up w/ the author asap... 17:20:03 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: thanks! 17:20:04 <sripriya_> sridhar_ram1: i will have sometime this week to go through the specs 17:20:09 <s3wong> sridhar_ram1: sure 17:20:30 <sridhar_ram1> frankly all three looks pretty close to land .. 17:20:54 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: I'm done w/ the spec related round up.. 17:21:17 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: do you've anything to update on the code lined in this area ? 17:21:49 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: are you comfortable your patchset with others from tbh and gongysh / vishwanathj gelling well ? 17:22:15 <bobh> just pushed a patchset to heat-translator to get it working for what we need - will be in 0.4.0 release tomorrow 17:22:22 <bobh> sridhar_ram1: yes 17:22:43 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: nice ! 17:23:04 <sridhar_ram1> tbh: any tosca integration questions from your side ? 17:23:39 <sridhar_ram1> tbh: I believe the recent change to direct TOSCA-artifact -> HOT glance will reduce the complexity in your side 17:24:26 <vishwanathj> bobh, I am assuming you will have unit tests as part of your patch set that ensures working with older VNFD templates and newer VNFD templates, right? 17:25:13 <bobh> vishwanathj: that's the plan 17:25:25 <vishwanathj> bobh thanks 17:26:22 <sridhar_ram1> any general TOSCA code integration question ? 17:26:33 <tbh> sridhar_ram1, currently no questions 17:26:45 <sridhar_ram1> tbh: sounds good.. 17:26:54 <sridhar_ram1> moving on... 17:27:06 <sridhar_ram1> #topic Mitaka fit and finish - RFEs and Bugs 17:27:26 <sridhar_ram1> we have concentrated mostly on new features so far in the cycle... 17:27:53 <sridhar_ram1> alongside we got some nice questions related to deployment in #link https://answers.launchpad.net/tacker 17:28:52 <sridhar_ram1> given Mitaka window is closing fast .. I'd like to take some time and get the community' input to see if there are any deployment related issues / quick fixes we should plan to get it in Mitaka 17:29:31 <sripriya_> sridhar_ram1: do you think displaying monitoring status on Horizon should be planned for Mitaka? 17:29:46 <sridhar_ram1> For e.g. RFE bug like https://bugs.launchpad.net/tacker/+bug/1547284 17:29:47 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1547284 in tacker "Expose port-security knob for all network ports (connection points)" [Medium,New] 17:30:26 <sridhar_ram1> sripriya_: you mean a visual clue indicating an active monitoring driver is active for a VNF ? 17:30:37 <sripriya_> sridhar_ram1: yes 17:30:44 <bobh> sridhar_ram1: that may actually get resolved as part of the tosca work - we need to add it to the CP definition anyway 17:31:26 <tbh> sridhar_ram1, and this one https://bugs.launchpad.net/tacker/+bug/1525808 17:31:26 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1525808 in tacker "OpenWRT vnf stuck in "PENDING-UPDATE" state." [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to bharaththiruveedula (bharath-ves) 17:31:26 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: I see. Out template need to expose new knob ? 17:32:07 <bobh> sridhar_ram1: we need to add it to the CP definition for our own use anyway, so exposing for use by end users is trivial 17:32:10 <tbh> sridhar_ram1, couple of people tried tacker using OpeWRT and stuck there I believe , I need to close this asap 17:32:36 <sridhar_ram1> tbh: ah, that's a serious one.. need to be addressed, agree! 17:33:10 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: do you suggest a follow on or you could absorb into your work item ? 17:33:23 <bobh> sridhar_ram1: let me look - can probably absorb 17:33:35 <tbh> sridhar_ram1, sure 17:33:51 <sridhar_ram1> bobh: okay, thanks.. 17:34:20 <sridhar_ram1> I'll introduce a new tag for these "must do" Mitaka issues (RFEs & Bugs)... 17:34:43 <sridhar_ram1> feel free to mark other candidate issues for Mitaka 17:35:14 <sridhar_ram1> sripriya_: for the visual aid for monitoring .. we need both API support and Horizon enhancements, correct ? 17:36:00 * sridhar_ram1 thinking about an appropriate launchpad tag and wonders if anyone have a suggestion 17:36:42 <sripriya_> sridhar_ram1: yes.. i think it would be quite involved and may take some time 17:37:10 <sridhar_ram1> sripriya_: yeah, could be tight for this cycle.. 17:37:21 <sripriya_> sripriya_: may not be a candidate even though it is very helpful to see the status in horizon than in logs 17:37:49 <sridhar_ram1> btw, there was a related one .. to show VNF details in Horizon.. 17:37:58 <sridhar_ram1> mgmt-ip of the VDUs etc.. 17:38:20 <sripriya_> yes there was a ask on answers forum 17:38:26 <sridhar_ram1> we now display the template (which is nice!) but we could show more about an active VNF 17:38:44 <sridhar_ram1> sripriya_: yep, those are direct input from our customer base.. 17:39:23 <tbh> sridhar_ram1, yes, probably more details about VDU in horizon 17:39:54 <sridhar_ram1> will create a launchpad RFE bug for this.. it seems small enough to squeeze into Mitaka 17:40:30 <sridhar_ram1> #action sridhar_ram1 will create a RFE bug to display runtime VNF instance details in Horizon GUI 17:40:54 <sridhar_ram1> tbh: make sense.. will capture that in this RFE 17:41:12 <sridhar_ram1> btw, any volunteers to pick this work ? 17:41:38 <sridhar_ram1> reach out me if you are interested ... 17:42:04 <sridhar_ram1> other things in "fit & finish" is things like py34 support... 17:42:13 <dkushwaha_> sridhar_ram1, I would like to pick this. 17:42:25 <sridhar_ram1> zeih: thanks for picking it up... 17:42:30 <sridhar_ram1> dkushwaha_: great, thanks! 17:43:03 <sridhar_ram1> py34 will help to keep the project hygiene inline with rest of the active openstack projects! 17:43:27 <zeih_> all: feel free to add missing py27 tests and integrate py34 compatibility :) 17:44:25 <sridhar_ram1> zeih_: agree, we can always use more py27 tests .. 17:45:48 <sridhar_ram1> Documentation is also an important item in this category .. we can get to it after late Mar once most of the code lands 17:46:01 <sridhar_ram1> anything else to discuss in this topic ? 17:46:23 <sridhar_ram1> moving on... 17:46:32 <sridhar_ram1> #topic Open Discussion 17:47:02 <sridhar_ram1> A shout out to SONATA team from EU who are attending this meeting for the first time.. 17:47:12 <sridhar_ram1> Jim__: welcome to the team! 17:47:24 <sridhar_ram1> Fyi, #link http://www.sonata-nfv.eu/ 17:47:39 <Jim__> thank you! 17:48:29 <sridhar_ram1> Jim__: I believe we have many things common in our goal in the area of NFV orchestration... 17:49:05 <sridhar_ram1> FYI, SONATA team is planning to look into areas related to NFV Catalog (catalog split out, img mgmt, etc...) 17:49:46 <Jim__> We think so, too, we're looking forward to collaborating. We're working on a Google Doc to introduce that catalog vision to you for next meeting. 17:50:47 <sridhar_ram1> Jim__: great! lets use a slot in next week's mtg to go through that... 17:50:59 <Guest7539> I have a question related to the NVF Catalog and also the descriptors: Who is mainly working on that from your side currently? 17:52:09 <sridhar_ram1> Guest7539: descriptor related work is lead by bobh in the track related to TOSCA parser integration... 17:52:12 <Jim__> Hi Michael, you're Guest7539, right? If so, you're asking who is working on it from Tacker, no? 17:52:46 <Guest7539> Yes, I am Michael ... did not manage to get a proper name :-) 17:53:21 <sridhar_ram1> Guest7539: we need to discuss that choice of irc-handle as the first thing in the next meeting! 17:53:34 <zeih_> :) 17:53:35 <sridhar_ram1> Guest7539: Hi Michael! 17:54:26 <sridhar_ram1> Guest7539: we haven't done any work related to NFV Catalog beyond what we have .. which is just the VNFD Catalog 17:54:51 <sridhar_ram1> .. which is again today tightly integrated within VNFM component of tacker 17:54:58 <sridhar_ram1> we need to break it out 17:55:18 * sridhar_ram1 5mins left 17:55:57 <sridhar_ram1> s3wong: quick check on the neutron-sfc driver.. any updates from your side ? 17:55:59 <Guest7539> Maybe I can reach out to Bob within the next days. I would like to understand your current status a bit better. 17:56:57 <sridhar_ram1> Guest7539: bobh's hourly consultant charges are reasonable ;-) 17:57:43 <sridhar_ram1> will sync up on SFC w/ s3wong and trozet separately 17:57:55 <sridhar_ram1> anything else team? 17:57:59 <s3wong> sridhar_ram1: spec should be posted in a day or two 17:58:24 <sridhar_ram1> s3wong: thanks.. will discuss w/ you offline.. 17:58:32 <s3wong> sridhar_ram1: though I haven't seen much from trozet's side --- so don't know what the risk there is 17:59:13 <sridhar_ram1> Team - as mentioned earlier - get your specs land and code posted ASAP.. next couple of weeks are critical to make it to Mitaka release! 17:59:45 <sridhar_ram1> s3wong: trozet just came back from paternity leave.. lets sync up offline! 17:59:50 <santoshk> sridhar_ram1: apart from multi vim, enhanced placement support and SFC what are other imp features coming next few days... 18:00:03 <sridhar_ram1> that's it folks for this week... 18:00:12 <santoshk> sridhar_ram1: we can continue in tacker channel 18:00:13 <sridhar_ram1> santoshk: that's the main list ! 18:00:21 <sridhar_ram1> bye folks! 18:00:24 <santoshk> ok..thankyou.. 18:00:28 <sridhar_ram1> #endmeeting