05:30:28 #startmeeting tacker 05:30:29 Meeting started Wed Feb 15 05:30:28 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is sridhar_ram. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 05:30:30 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 05:30:32 The meeting name has been set to 'tacker' 05:30:41 #topic Roll Call 05:30:44 hi 05:30:52 gongysh: hi ! 05:31:03 who is here for tacker meeting? 05:31:09 hi all 05:31:17 tung_doan_: howdy! 05:31:36 o/ 05:31:48 o/ 05:32:05 sripriya: tbh: hi 05:32:20 o/ 05:32:26 Janki is travelling, may not make it 05:32:44 dkushwaha: are you here? 05:32:48 diga_: hi 05:32:58 sridhar_ram, o/ 05:33:06 alright, let's start... 05:33:09 #topic Agenda 05:33:18 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Tacker#Meeting_Feb_15th.2C_2017 05:33:26 #topic Announcement 05:33:42 #info sridhar_ram last meeting as PTL :) 05:34:00 ohhh.... 05:34:14 sridhar_ram, ai.... 05:34:30 Tacker logo files are available here vvvv 05:34:32 #link https://www.dropbox.com/sh/yyt1lazllah7ccf/AACkW8LkIiG32OXLYBqeP-RJa?dl=0 05:34:40 sridhar_ram: should be a special meeting :)) 05:35:00 Please start using this in powerpoint and webpages.. 05:35:10 tung_doan_: gongysh: :) 05:35:26 * sridhar_ram note to self, update Tacker wiki with this logo 05:35:34 next.. 05:35:46 sridhar_ram, Just want to remind to put them on wiki. 05:35:53 sridhar_ram: thanks for running these meetings as PTL diligently 05:36:08 gongysh: sure, will do 05:36:33 sripriya: thanks.. but you all made this an amazing time 05:36:50 sridhar_ram: Thanks for efforts & leading Tacker from its incubation. I appreciate your work 05:37:09 sridhar_ram: we have a good team indeed 05:37:14 diga_: thanks a lot! 05:37:20 sripriya: +100 05:37:25 we will go to Ocata Release and PTG topics .. anything else beyond those two items? 05:37:28 sridhar_ram, it is always a great experience working under your guidance 05:37:39 dkushwaha: thanks .. 05:37:46 sridhar_ram: you are welcome! :) 05:37:59 * sridhar_ram reaches for cleanex tissues to wipe the soob 05:38:16 #topic Ocata Release 05:38:32 This is release week .. 05:38:43 most blocking items are taken care .. 05:39:09 i created this etherpad to track any outstanding items.. 05:39:15 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tacker-ocata-rel-checklist 05:39:30 dkushwaha: we need a relnotes for a NSD 05:40:01 sridhar_ram, sure, will put it today 05:41:09 dkushwaha: thanks for taking the sriov fix.. 05:41:22 dkushwaha: can you respin based on gongysh comments ? 05:41:38 sridhar_ram, sure 05:41:56 sridhar_ram, Regarding https://review.openstack.org/431855 . Do we needs MANIFEST file? 05:42:27 dkushwaha: yes, it is used by packagers like RDO and Ubuntu 05:42:32 sridhar_ram, ass in some other components, I observed that they are removing it Ex https://review.openstack.org/#/c/369154/ 05:42:36 I thought it is for package. 05:42:45 s/ass/as 05:43:31 dkushwaha: i recently learnt from OPNFV / tripleo teams .. it is important to have it to pick non-python files like alembic_migration scripts 05:43:58 dkushwaha, I keep it for the workflow -1 05:45:49 gongysh: why workflow-1 ? 05:46:14 gongysh: i was looking to include it in the ocata tacker packages 05:46:22 dkushwaha said about the manifest file. 05:46:45 sridhar_ram, the conclusion is to let go? 05:47:05 sridhar_ram, gongysh it looks fine from my side as we need MANIFEST file 05:47:14 ok 05:47:15 gongysh: no we need it 05:47:53 done 05:48:11 gongysh: thanks 05:48:35 next .. janki's template_source db fix 05:48:42 gongysh: tbh: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/431339/ 05:48:58 gongysh: tbh: gate test are failing .. 05:49:23 the log says the quota of RAM is exceeding 05:49:33 note, janki is not available as she is travelling .. 05:49:40 sridhar_ram, I just rechecked it, I don't think that's problem with the patch 05:49:49 I will put one patch to unlimit the ram quota. 05:50:08 gongysh: okay.. 05:50:11 sridhar_ram, yup as gongysh said all the logs contains host not found error 05:50:44 btw, openstack-ci is quite stressed due to too many CI runs due to ocata release 05:50:54 could be a transcient issue 05:51:29 Quota exceeded for ram: Requested 4096, but already used 50688 of 51200 ram 05:51:54 from which log? 05:52:02 nova ? 05:52:04 http://logs.openstack.org/39/431339/7/check/gate-tacker-dsvm-functional-ubuntu-xenial-nv/7aae290/logs/screen-tacker.txt.gz 05:52:35 okay .. we can continue to resolve this outside this meeting 05:52:59 that it from my list .. rest seems minor that we can punt to Pike 05:53:09 *thats it 05:53:35 anyone else have any blocking / must-merge Ocata PS ? 05:54:13 vnffg parameter attributes 05:54:29 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/434048/ 05:54:48 https://bugs.launchpad.net/tacker/+bug/1664803 05:54:48 Launchpad bug 1664803 in tacker "Fail to create a new vnffg instance" [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to Jimmy.Ye (jimmy.ye) 05:55:00 * sridhar_ram looking up 05:55:13 without it, tacker cannot support parameterized VNFFG. 05:55:49 gongysh: yes, this is a must in then 05:56:22 this patch should have functional tests 05:57:06 gongysh: VNFFG doesn't have much functest coverage, we need to improve this in Pike 05:57:31 sridhar_ram, definetely 05:58:22 FYI, I'm planning to request tacker ocata release and stable/ocata branch by Wed EOD Pacific .. 05:58:39 .. approx same time tomorrow 05:59:31 anything else on Ocata? 05:59:39 sridhar_ram, on nsd bp, "User Guide" is mentioned as TODO in work items. IMO we already have this 05:59:42 https://github.com/openstack/tacker/blob/master/doc/source/devref/nsd_usage_guide.rst 06:00:11 dkushwaha: will make it done, thanks for pointing it out 06:00:45 BTW this is the releasenotes that will go out for Ocata https://docs.openstack.org/releasenotes/tacker/unreleased.html 06:01:15 let me know if anything is missing from ur side 06:01:34 Hopefully we will wrap up Ocata by tomorrow! 06:01:36 sridhar_ram, not easy to tell which number is for ocata 06:02:15 gongysh: 0.6.0 is Ocata 06:02:43 Do we have a doc for it? 06:03:15 Doc for ocata ? 06:03:33 doc for the mapping between number and code name 06:03:50 AFAIK, no.. 06:04:04 you can look here at the release repo... 06:04:06 https://github.com/openstack/releases/blob/master/deliverables/ocata/tacker.yaml 06:04:21 replace ocata with previous names to get the ver # 06:04:43 ok, I will try to compile one on wiki. 06:05:14 sounds good.. 06:05:31 Tacker wiki needs some spring cleaning 06:05:52 Lots of work went in to Ocata.. 06:06:08 .. hope this is a good release.. 06:06:37 any bugs now need to get fixed in master and cherrypicked to stable/ocata 06:06:43 moving to next topic .. 06:07:03 #topic Pike Project Technical Gathering (PTG) 06:07:28 Here is the etherpad .. 06:07:31 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tacker-pike-grooming 06:08:13 as usual trozet is sponsoring the conference call (bluejeans) .. will add the dial-in access number once i receive it 06:08:27 sridhar_ram, we need to divide the time into sessions, maybe 30 mins for each. 06:09:02 gongysh: yep... 06:09:25 gongysh: did you had a chance to put some topics in focus / priority ? 06:09:49 sridhar_ram, 10:00:00 UTC will be too late into night for someone too. 06:10:24 gongysh: including me, it is going to be 2AM ! 06:10:32 sridhar_ram, yes 06:10:41 sridhar_ram, is it possible get audio recording after PTG? it will be very helpful 06:11:15 dkushwaha: yes, trozet has enabled recording option.. we just need to remind to start the recording :) 06:11:15 sridhar_ram, I needed to prepare report for my office :( 06:11:36 can we start earlier, and make the meeting 4 hours. 06:11:41 dkushwaha: sure 06:11:48 sridhar_ram, thanks 06:12:20 start 3:00 UTC to 7:00 UTC? 06:12:34 gongysh: I can't before 4:30 UTC 06:13:47 gongysh: we can split the event into two days 06:14:13 sridhar_ram, sure. 06:14:33 lets finish at 8:00UTC 06:14:57 gongysh: sure . 06:15:21 and if we have too much topics for next day, we can have one more day. 06:15:42 so, 5:00 UTC -> 8:00 UTC * (Wed & Thur) 06:15:54 yes 06:16:09 does this sound okay for rest of the folks here ? 06:16:38 I think its better to keep one day meeting if we keep 5-6 MEETING a day fine for me 06:17:01 Because its day time for us, I dont think I can get two for meeting officially 06:17:23 s/5-6/5-6 hours 06:17:25 sridhar_ram: doodle poll? 06:17:40 sripriya: it is too late for a doodle poll :( 06:17:55 we need to quickly come to a consensus here ... 06:18:29 sridhar_ram: ack 06:18:36 i understand the earlier preferene is to do a one day 06:18:36 sridhar_ram: sridhar_ram gongysh : we can run 22th feb meeting, if some items will remaing, then we can decide 06:19:10 how about 4:00 UTC -> 8:00 UTC and finish in one day 06:19:34 I am ok 06:19:35 Fine! 06:20:02 okay.. any major issues for this slot ? 06:20:13 dkushwaha ? 06:20:30 tbh: sripriya: tung_doan_ 06:20:38 gongysh, sridhar_ram I am ok with all options 06:20:51 sridhar_ram, yup I am fine with that 06:20:58 sridhar_ram: works for me 06:21:00 sridhar_ram: fine for me. thanks 06:21:18 ok, I will going to put the topic into slot, each slot will be 30min. 06:21:31 gongysh: sounds good.. 06:22:14 and I will ping you guys who has regiester topics and pike candidate on pike grooming etherpad. 06:22:30 https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tacker-pike-grooming 06:23:02 gongysh: works! 06:23:25 gongysh: Sure! 06:23:55 gongysh: it will be good if we can come up with 1 or more focus areas for Pike ... 06:24:34 gongysh: we can see how the discussions goes and decide 06:24:49 sridhar_ram, make sense 06:25:10 alright, anything else on PTG meetup ? 06:25:45 #topic Open Discussion 06:26:23 if nothing else, will talk to you all next week... 06:26:33 about blocking device booting 06:26:41 please help w/ any last minute ocata requests if it comes your way! 06:26:43 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/422066/ 06:26:57 https://bugs.launchpad.net/tacker/+bug/1649459 06:26:57 Launchpad bug 1649459 in tacker "Add volume support" [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to yong sheng gong (gongysh) 06:27:12 i remember a related BP to support storage volumns 06:27:35 https://blueprints.launchpad.net/tacker/+spec/persistent-block-storage 06:28:13 yes, I have do the relationship. 06:28:28 one of my customers are using this feature. 06:28:41 gongysh: I see.. nice! 06:29:13 overall happy with where we are heading w/ Tacker ... 06:29:18 good times ahead! 06:29:42 Mike drop .. over to you gongysh, good luck ! 06:29:43 guys , heard that ECOMP will merge with OPENO 06:29:53 Wow, really ?!! 06:29:57 that is a big news 06:30:12 but it is good for the industry if it happens 06:30:13 It is heard. 06:30:29 times up folks! 06:30:32 #endmeeting