04:30:12 <gongysh> #startmeeting tacker
04:30:13 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Oct 18 04:30:12 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gongysh. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
04:30:14 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
04:30:16 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tacker'
04:30:23 <gongysh> #topic roll call
04:30:45 <phuoc_> o/
04:30:47 <gongysh> hi phuoc_ yamahata
04:30:47 <yanxingan> o/
04:30:53 <gongysh> yanxingan
04:31:33 <diga> o/
04:31:38 <gongysh> hi diga
04:31:44 <diga> gongysh: Hello
04:31:44 <phuoc_> hi all
04:32:05 <MinWookKim> #JOIN tacker
04:32:18 <diga> gongysh: I think most of the india team is on leave because of Diwali festival
04:32:41 <diga> Lets see who is able to join
04:32:44 <gongysh> trinath is coming
04:32:52 <diga> ok
04:32:56 <gongysh> MinWookKim, hi
04:33:02 <MinWookKim> Hello :)
04:33:18 <diga> In between, I have one announcement to make, can I ?
04:33:26 <gongysh> diga, sure, please
04:33:38 <gongysh> diga, wedding?
04:33:40 <diga> Hello Everyone
04:33:42 <yanxingan> MinWookKim, hi
04:33:43 <diga> No man
04:33:52 <MinWookKim> diga, hi
04:34:04 <MinWookKim> yanxingan, hi
04:34:11 <diga> My company is very much interested in this project
04:34:34 <diga> and we want to contribute officially to make tacker one of best NFV orchestration in OpenSTack
04:34:36 <phuoc_> diga, that is a good new :)
04:34:52 <yanxingan> good news!
04:34:53 <diga> We will dedicate some people along with me and resources for this project
04:34:56 <gongysh> diga, yes. fantastic news
04:35:13 <diga> My company name is Calsoft inc.
04:35:26 <phuoc_> join containerized vnf with me :)
04:35:41 <diga> Pune, India based company worked only in Networking, Virtualization, Storage and cloud
04:35:48 <gongysh> ok, look forwards to new colleagues from your company.
04:36:03 <gongysh> #topic bp
04:36:06 <diga> phuoc_: We do have plan to work on containers
04:36:15 <diga> gongysh: Yep
04:36:23 <gongysh> http://launchpad.net/tacker
04:36:35 <trinaths> o/
04:36:49 <gongysh> since the review site is down ( infra team is busy with rescue it)
04:37:02 <diga> We would like to take some ownership of items in this projects
04:37:03 <phuoc_> hi janki :)
04:37:10 <gongysh> we can have a review our pike-1 milestone.
04:37:39 <gongysh> https://launchpad.net/tacker/+milestone/pike-1
04:37:41 <janki> o/
04:37:43 <janki> phuoc_, hey
04:38:01 <MinWookKim> janki, hi
04:38:12 <gongysh> sorry, it should be queens-1
04:38:13 <janki> MinWookKim, hello
04:38:37 <gongysh> https://launchpad.net/tacker/+milestone/queens-1
04:38:52 <trinaths> hi all
04:39:08 <gongysh> trinaths, welcome
04:39:11 <phuoc_> hi trinaths :)
04:39:11 <gongysh> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/tacker/+spec/vnffg-ns
04:39:29 <gongysh> yanxingan, do you have progress on it?
04:39:56 <trinaths> phuoc_: i will reply the BP review comments
04:40:11 <gongysh> tbh_, hi
04:40:19 <yanxingan> yes, still coding, but slowly
04:40:32 <MinWookKim> trinaths, hello
04:40:45 <gongysh> queens-1 is coming to close.
04:40:53 <gongysh> I have to move it to queens-2
04:40:54 <tbh_> hi gongysh
04:41:23 <yanxingan> gongysh, ok
04:41:43 <gongysh> another one queens-1 is https://blueprints.launchpad.net/tacker/+spec/doc-how-to-install-openstack-vim
04:41:44 <phuoc_> yanxingan, I will spend time to review your patch
04:41:56 <gongysh> this is one doc patch
04:42:01 <trinaths> MinWookKim: hello
04:42:26 <gongysh> if no one is object, I will merge it at the end of queens-1
04:42:41 <gongysh> the queens-1 is end at oct. 20th.
04:43:01 <gongysh> if no one -1 to this doc patch
04:43:25 <yanxingan> as disscussed in last PTG,  specs should be merged together with codes?
04:43:28 <gongysh> diga, if you have new comers, you guys can start with doc.
04:43:41 <phuoc_> gongysh, I commented about that
04:43:46 <trinaths> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/508720/
04:43:55 <trinaths> review site is UP
04:43:56 <phuoc_> I think it is fine for me, but Zun -1 for now
04:44:44 <gongysh> phuoc_ is not an issue to it, but I will have a look at it
04:45:04 <gongysh> phuoc_, zun -1 should not caused by this patch.
04:45:15 <diga> gongysh: yes
04:45:38 <diga> gongysh: we are interested in taking one feature
04:45:39 <trinaths> zun? zuul ?
04:45:49 <phuoc_> gongysh, I think we should push https://review.openstack.org/#/c/511448/ to queens-2
04:46:09 <diga> gongysh: I have some items here, api-framework, will help in contributing to containerized VNf's
04:46:09 <phuoc_> and https://review.openstack.org/#/c/510003/ too
04:47:00 <janki> diga, how will api-framework help with cvnfs?
04:47:45 <gongysh> phuoc_, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/510003/ has no bp or bug for it.
04:47:49 <gongysh> I have commented it.
04:48:12 <diga> janki: API-framework is different item here
04:48:29 <gongysh> phuoc_, do you want to take the responsibility to triage the bug?
04:48:36 <janki> diga, your previous comment was bit confusing then
04:48:44 <trinaths> diga: may be can you give us a outline and also share a document to understand the work
04:49:05 <diga> trinaths: which work you mean
04:49:13 <gongysh> I can put you into driver group then you can arrang bug's milestone.
04:49:53 <diga> gongysh: I am working on indirect VNFM also
04:49:59 <diga> with Yanxin
04:50:04 <trinaths> diga api-framework
04:50:29 <trinaths> indirect vnfm ?
04:50:33 <phuoc_> gongysh, I more focus on containerized vnf bp, but I can be a reviewer for that patch
04:50:34 <gongysh> phuoc_, about bug triage, what do you think of?
04:50:49 <gongysh> ok
04:51:17 <janki> gongysh, what topic are we discussing here? Its bit confusing
04:51:41 <trinaths> diga: indirect vnfm ?
04:51:51 <gongysh> janki, we are talking about bp
04:52:02 <janki> looks like 3 topics are being discussed simultaneuosuly
04:52:12 <gongysh> guys, can we talk one by one?
04:52:21 <diga> trinaths: https://blueprints.launchpad.net/tacker/+spec/indirect-mode-vnfm
04:52:44 <gongysh> diga, just wait until your turn.
04:53:10 <gongysh> more bps under active developement are k8s vim
04:53:26 <gongysh> phuoc_, do you want to talk about your work?
04:53:44 <phuoc_> gongysh, yes
04:54:09 <phuoc_> the first I want to ask is can we make a new c-VNFM
04:54:45 <gongysh> phuoc_, I think you can talk from the k8s vim first
04:54:48 <trinaths> diga: what is the real use-cases you are seeing with indirectmode-vnfm ?
04:54:58 <gongysh> trinaths, hold on.
04:55:06 <trinaths> gongysh: sorry.
04:55:24 <diga> trinaths: will discuss in detail after the meeting
04:55:33 <trinaths> phuoc_: you can make a new vnfm.. but can that inherit from generic vnfm ?
04:55:59 <phuoc_> K8s as VIM is fine for now, but for storing ssl_ca_cert, I need your comments here
04:56:15 <phuoc_> because I am confusing in this
04:56:16 <gongysh> phuoc_,  I want to merge the k8s vim bp and code pathes first
04:56:35 <gongysh> patches.
04:56:39 <janki> phuoc_, I did comment on the client side patch of k8s vim
04:56:43 <phuoc_> I am coding for that, some patch is fine
04:57:01 <phuoc_> janki, I will change and upload new patch
04:57:11 <phuoc_> other problem is in Tacker horizon
04:57:30 <diga> phuoc_: are we considering K8s as Vim installation in this patch ?
04:57:38 <gongysh> phuoc_, do you have plan for horizon change?
04:57:42 <phuoc_> diga, yes
04:58:00 <diga> phuoc_: okay
04:58:04 <trinaths> phuoc_: what horizon changes do you think are needed ? for k8s as VIM
04:58:13 <phuoc_> gongysh, I plan add option to support bearer_token
04:58:23 <trinaths> also, such a changes where not added to BP at all
04:58:54 <phuoc_> trinaths, thats right, at this time I don't usually use horizon
04:59:10 <gongysh> phuoc_, you can first ignore the horizon.
04:59:26 <gongysh> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/tacker+branch:master+topic:bp/kubernetes-as-vim
04:59:30 <trinaths> agree phuoc_ but it is essential that we document it so that others can help with improvements.
05:00:10 <phuoc_> gongysh trinaths, sure I will do that
05:00:27 <diga> phuoc_: may be you can update the k8s spec and horizon details there
05:00:33 <gongysh> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/508828/ is for python client
05:01:52 <phuoc_> gongysh, I will follow janki way, it don't change the old document too much
05:02:12 <gongysh> phuoc_, what is janki's way?
05:03:07 <janki> gongysh, phuoc_ it is about adding an argument to specify which vim we want. how else is tacker going to know which vim it is
05:03:52 <phuoc_> use --type or --vim-type (the default will be openstack)
05:04:37 <janki> --type should suffice. its going to be used along with vim-register anyway
05:05:15 <phuoc_> janki that is right, I forgot it is in vim-register :)
05:05:20 <diga> janki: phuoc_ : but any way, we define it at the time of creation aren't we ?
05:05:36 <phuoc_> diga, right :)
05:06:01 <trinaths> ok
05:06:01 <gongysh> no --type or --vim-type should be given in vim register.
05:06:10 <gongysh> all are in vim-config file.
05:06:38 <gongysh> phuoc_, could we merge this in queens-1?
05:06:46 <gongysh> oct. 20?
05:07:04 <gongysh> if that, we can move your k8s vim bp in queens-1
05:07:26 <phuoc_> gongysh, spec k8s as VIM can merge in queens-1
05:07:40 <gongysh> phuoc_
05:07:41 <gongysh> ok
05:07:50 <gongysh> who can help to test this feature?
05:08:31 <diga> gongysh: I will help on this but I will work on it on next week as I am on leave for next 3 days
05:08:47 <gongysh> ok, thanks.
05:09:03 <diga> phuoc_: will connect after this meeting
05:09:09 <gongysh> to run desvstack which will install k8s cluster, and then register k8s vim.
05:09:18 <diga> ok
05:09:26 <gongysh> phuoc_, diga , thanks
05:10:14 <gongysh> another bp from phuoc_  is https://review.openstack.org/#/c/511991/
05:10:39 <gongysh> since there is no review yet, we can have a talk at next meeting.
05:10:59 <phuoc_> Mr. Zala suggest that, use Heat translator to translate TOSCA to k8s template
05:11:26 <gongysh> phuoc_, that is a way.
05:11:31 <phuoc_> I think it is reasonable, I will figure it out and update that spec
05:11:41 <gongysh> #topic bugs
05:11:56 <gongysh> we have many new bugs reported
05:12:05 <gongysh> what bug do you guys want to talk here?
05:12:58 <gongysh> ok, if no, we can go to next topic
05:13:05 <gongysh> #topic open discussion
05:13:15 <gongysh> janki, what do you want to talk?
05:13:41 <diga> gongysh: trinaths : about indirect vnfm, we have one patch - https://review.openstack.org/#/c/510812/2/specs/queens/indirect-mode-vnfm.rst
05:13:48 <diga> please you guys take a look at it
05:14:12 <trinaths> looking
05:14:22 <janki> gongysh, how many sessions are we having at summit?
05:14:25 <diga> okay
05:14:27 <gongysh> diga, sure, thanks
05:14:37 <gongysh> janki, I have one project update
05:14:40 <diga> welcome
05:15:03 <phuoc_> see all guys in Sydney :)
05:15:28 <diga> who are going to Sydney ?
05:15:34 <phuoc_> diga, I will look at it :)
05:15:35 <MinWookKim> Please take a look my zabbix-plugin blueprint https://review.openstack.org/#/c/505466/ :)
05:15:39 <trinaths> phuoc_: we have to meet at summit.
05:15:39 <gongysh> me
05:15:41 <MinWookKim> Yang Xian an, Thanks to your feedback, I've made a lot of changes :)
05:16:01 <gongysh> MinWookKim, thanks that
05:16:23 <yanxingan> MinWookKim, thanks, will review it soon
05:16:47 <phuoc_> trinaths, hope to meet you :)
05:16:48 <gongysh> MinWookKim, you have to come up some implementation to show it works
05:16:51 <diga> phuoc_: thanks
05:17:45 <gongysh> do you guys have interests in graphic design TOSCA template?
05:17:46 <janki> gongysh, cool
05:17:48 <diga> phuoc_: will ping you separately after this meeting
05:17:54 <trinaths> diga: today I will review the bp and post my coments
05:18:02 <diga> trinaths: sure
05:18:16 <MinWookKim> gongysh, I will upload the code soon.
05:18:34 <MinWookKim> yanxigan, thanks :)
05:19:17 <trinaths> MinWookKim: Do you have a working poc for the proposed BP ?
05:20:10 <phuoc_> gongysh, Is it like AWS, graphic design and then translate to code :)
05:20:19 <gongysh> phuoc_, yeah
05:20:49 <MinWookKim> trinaths, it is using for application monitoring with zabbix
05:21:19 <MinWookKim> trinaths, please see https://review.openstack.org/#/c/505466/
05:21:40 <phuoc_> gongysh, I will have a look at it :)
05:21:45 <trinaths> ok
05:21:55 <MinWookKim> trinaths, thanks
05:21:56 <gongysh> phuoc_,  nice
05:22:19 <gongysh> then we will have a nicer tacker user experience.
05:22:52 <trinaths> :)
05:24:06 <gongysh> if there is no other topic, we can end meeting and talk at tacker channel
05:24:10 <phuoc_> many works to do noew :)
05:24:37 <gongysh> thanks for everyone
05:24:43 <gongysh> #endmeeting