04:32:09 <gongysh> #startmeeting tacker
04:32:10 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Feb 28 04:32:09 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gongysh. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
04:32:12 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
04:32:14 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tacker'
04:32:40 <gongysh> #topic roll call
04:32:56 <YanXing_an> o/
04:33:02 <dangtrinhnt> hi
04:33:05 <haint> o/
04:33:10 <joxyuki> hi
04:33:50 <gongysh> YanXing_an, dangtrinhnt , haint, and joxyuki , hi
04:34:25 <masaito> hi
04:34:25 <hyunsikyang> hi
04:34:37 <gongysh> will phuoc be on line?
04:35:24 <gongysh> joxyuki, welcome
04:35:24 <gongysh> hyunsikyang, hi
04:36:29 <gongysh> who can remember what is the etherpad url link for tacker ptg I pasted at tacker channel last week?
04:36:40 <dangtrinhnt> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/Tacker-PTG-Rocky
04:37:28 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, thanks
04:37:42 <gongysh> #link tacker vPTG link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/Tacker-PTG-Rocky
04:38:52 <gongysh> lots of stuff there, please have a look at it before we have a meeting on it.
04:39:30 <gongysh> hope we can have a meeting at next meeting time.
04:39:36 <longkb> hi everyone
04:39:45 <gongysh> hi longkb
04:39:54 <gongysh> #topic bp
04:40:06 <gongysh> cluster feature
04:40:29 <gongysh> we will merge cluster feature after community ptg.
04:40:47 <gongysh> I will first release a new tacker client version of rocky
04:41:17 <gongysh> and then merge the cluster feature after it got core's +2 and  some +1s
04:41:33 <longkb> I received some comments from masaito. And I will try to revise according to these comments
04:41:33 <gongysh> hi phuoc
04:41:42 <phuoc> gongysh, hi
04:42:06 <gongysh> bp tacker client oc commands
04:42:10 <gongysh> osc commands
04:42:27 <gongysh> we received lots of osc command patches
04:43:00 <gongysh> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/owner:nguyentrihai93%2540gmail.com
04:43:03 <dangtrinhnt> Looks like haint has finished all of them.
04:43:09 <gongysh> from haint
04:43:11 <gongysh> thanks
04:43:43 <gongysh> please revise some of conflicted patches
04:43:56 <haint> yes i will
04:44:12 <YanXing_an> great, thanks to haint
04:44:26 <gongysh> bp horizon web studio
04:44:48 <gongysh> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/547018/
04:44:58 <phuoc> thats nice bp
04:45:44 <gongysh> it is a very nice feature. looking forwards to it.
04:45:51 <YanXing_an> nice bp +1
04:45:56 <gongysh> I have said on a previous meeting, we should introduce a ui tosca design tool for our vnf templates.
04:46:01 <gongysh> that is it.
04:46:38 <longkb> dangtrinhnt: nice proposal +1
04:46:47 <dangtrinhnt> I'm prototyping, need everybody's ideas. Will release a demo early next week.
04:47:19 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, hi
04:47:51 <gongysh> do you want to talk about the bp: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/448109/
04:48:09 <dangtrinhnt> Yes, sure.
04:49:03 <dangtrinhnt> In need of you, YanXing_an, and dkushwaha updates on the previous progress.
04:51:09 <YanXing_an> dangtrinhnt, thanks  a lot to make this bp step forward, i will help to update it
04:51:59 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt,  first, we are using embed vnffgd in the nsd, instead of import external vnffgd.
04:52:16 <dangtrinhnt> Thanks YanXing_an.
04:52:39 <dangtrinhnt> gongsh, yes, I removed the import external vnffgd based on phuoc's comments.
04:52:57 <phuoc> dangtrinhnt, you should update it with the detail steps
04:53:04 <YanXing_an> gongysh, we will not use the external vnffgd?
04:53:11 <phuoc> it will be better
04:53:19 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, yes.
04:54:33 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, we also need the way how to update the vnffg of a given ns.
04:54:50 <dangtrinhnt> YanXing_an, if you decide to allow external vnffgd we will have to deal with conflicts ...
04:55:00 <phuoc> we can do it like the same way in updating VNFFG
04:55:12 <gongysh> so the vnffg instances of ns should also be visible if we run tacker vnffg-list
04:55:46 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh,got your comments. phuoc's right.
04:57:03 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, phuoc , YanXing_an lets do review at review patch.
04:57:25 <gongysh> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/448109/
04:57:26 <YanXing_an> gongysh, ok
04:57:54 <dangtrinhnt> ok
04:58:06 <gongysh> phuoc, I remember you will add a new bp for kuryr k8s?
04:58:37 <phuoc> gongysh, I am preparing for it
04:58:57 <gongysh> phuoc, thanks
04:59:00 <phuoc> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/548109
04:59:25 <phuoc> so this patch is for kuryr-kubernetes purpose
04:59:57 <phuoc> to support full Kuryr-Kubernetes features to support c-VNF with neutron networking
05:00:21 <gongysh> phuoc, won't you use a bp to do it?
05:00:37 <phuoc> gongysh, I will create a bp too
05:02:07 <gongysh> phuoc ok
05:02:07 <gongysh> #topic bug
05:02:49 <gongysh> https://bugs.launchpad.net/tacker/+bug/1750975
05:02:51 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1750975 in tacker "VNF OpenStack VIM creation error when enable K8S VIM" [Undecided,New]
05:03:06 <gongysh> it seem we have no update on this bug yet.
05:03:30 <phuoc> hmm, I tried several time to test with the devstack
05:03:45 <phuoc> but I don't have this error
05:03:47 <dangtrinhnt> I tested and still not success
05:04:10 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, so you think this bug is valid, right?
05:04:48 <dangtrinhnt> Yes, I think so. I wonder if there is any difference of my devstack environment.
05:04:50 <phuoc> dangtrinh, you should check the heat too
05:05:13 <dangtrinhnt> phuoc, ok, I will look at heat today.
05:05:23 <gongysh> I will have a test too.
05:05:25 <phuoc> if the stack in heat works right or not
05:05:56 <gongysh> #topic open discussion
05:06:17 <gongysh> meeting time change
05:06:20 <phuoc> gongysh, I have some problem with eventlet
05:06:30 <gongysh> phuoc, ok, you go first
05:07:13 <phuoc> I think we should change: eventlet.monkey_patch(all=True, thread=False)
05:07:55 <phuoc> because I met conflicts between multiprocessing and evenlet
05:08:03 <gongysh> phuoc, how do other projects use it?
05:08:15 <gongysh> I mean the monkey_patch
05:08:23 <phuoc> some of them use thread=False
05:08:23 <dangtrinhnt> About eventlet, I put some notes at https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/Tacker-PTG-Rocky
05:08:43 <gongysh> do you have list of them?
05:09:01 <phuoc> gongysh, I will check again and send it to you
05:09:09 <gongysh> phuoc, ok
05:09:29 <gongysh> and maybe you can send an email to openstack-dev maillist
05:10:04 <gongysh> ok back to  meeting time change.
05:10:59 <gongysh> for mardim to work with team, I think we can change the meeting time, move the meeting some hours later.
05:11:20 <gongysh> phuoc, do you remember what is his time zone?
05:11:41 <phuoc> and egonzalez too
05:12:31 <phuoc> I think his timme zone is +2 or +3
05:13:24 <gongysh> who knows how to set up a time vote?
05:13:46 <phuoc> I suggest we can change to 3 hours later
05:14:26 * gongysh is searching how to set up time vote
05:14:55 <dangtrinhnt> https://docs.openstack.org/infra/system-config/irc.html#voting
05:15:02 <dangtrinhnt> ?
05:15:18 <gongysh> not that
05:15:59 <gongysh> have a web tool for us to choose what time slot each one want.
05:17:21 <gongysh> I will set up one and put it to tacker channel,
05:17:43 <gongysh> next topic I want to say is ptg.
05:18:03 <gongysh> I will go through the ehterpad, and set up an arrangement
05:18:13 <gongysh> and next meeting we will set up a time for vPTG.
05:18:23 <YanXing_an> what's the ptg time?
05:18:56 <gongysh> 2018.3.14
05:19:04 <YanXing_an> ok
05:19:44 <gongysh> so if you want something to talk or to do at rocky cycle, please put them on etherpad page.
05:19:46 <gongysh> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/Tacker-PTG-Rocky
05:19:59 <joxyuki> oops, I added my topic but I cannot atted at 3.14
05:20:10 <gongysh> is the sugguested time.
05:20:21 <gongysh> we need to set up a vote for it.
05:20:46 <gongysh> that's all from my side
05:20:47 <joxyuki> gongysh, i see thanks
05:21:30 <gongysh> do you guys have any thing to talk?
05:22:15 <joxyuki> I submitted a new bp too, did you see it?
05:22:25 <gongysh> joxyuki, got
05:22:54 <joxyuki> gongysh, thanks. it is helpful for me if you give some comments.
05:23:00 <gongysh> sure
05:23:13 <joxyuki> now POC and spec are in progress.
05:23:30 <gongysh> joxyuki, also please help team for other features, testing, review etc.
05:24:07 <joxyuki> gongysh, sure. I will be in tacker team more in rocky cycle
05:24:24 <phuoc> joxyuki, its nice to meet you
05:24:25 <gongysh> joxyuki, thanks
05:24:26 <phuoc> :-)
05:24:48 <joxyuki> :-)
05:24:55 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, this bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/tacker/+bug/1750250
05:24:57 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1750250 in tacker "Tacker client fail to register k8s vim using basic auth" [Undecided,Confirmed]
05:25:39 <gongysh> I think it should be put on phuoc's plate.
05:25:57 <gongysh> phuoc, right? :)
05:26:04 <phuoc> that's right
05:26:05 <phuoc> :-)
05:26:13 <dangtrinhnt> ok :)
05:26:38 <gongysh> phuoc, you can assign it to yourself.
05:26:40 <phuoc> It will lead some features related to container in Tacker
05:26:51 <phuoc> gongysh, sure I will do it
05:27:27 <gongysh> ok, 3 mins left.
05:27:46 <haint> do we have another bp still not be implementation?
05:28:29 <gongysh> haint, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/486924/
05:28:50 <gongysh> you can work with dharmendra
05:29:08 <gongysh> that is it.
05:29:14 <gongysh> thanks everyone.
05:29:17 <gongysh> #endmeeting