08:00:04 <gongysh> #startmeeting tacker
08:00:05 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Mar 27 08:00:04 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gongysh. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:00:06 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:00:08 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tacker'
08:00:19 <gongysh> #topic roll call
08:00:24 <gongysh> phuoc, hi
08:00:49 <phuoc> gongysh, hi
08:00:56 <keiko> o/
08:00:59 <YanXing_an> o/
08:01:05 <joxyuki> hi team
08:01:32 <phuoc> o/
08:01:44 <dangtrinhnt> hi
08:02:09 <Li_Jiale> o/
08:03:22 <haint_> o/
08:03:26 <egonzalez> o/
08:03:31 <gongysh> egonzalez, hi
08:04:34 <gongysh> ok, it seems others are not able to join for the time being
08:04:43 <gongysh> #topic p1 tasks
08:05:01 <gongysh> phuoc,  how is your p1 tasks progressing?
08:05:45 <phuoc> gongysh, I will finish this patch first https://review.openstack.org/#/c/549354/
08:06:09 <phuoc> and move to hybrid SFC feature
08:07:08 <gongysh> ok, but it seem the progress is not good. we have no patch to review now. :)
08:08:26 <gongysh> haint_, how is your p1 tasks?
08:08:30 <phuoc> gongysh, I will improve this patch
08:08:39 <gongysh> mistral monitoring patch
08:08:41 <haint_> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/486924/
08:08:46 <gongysh> phuoc thanks
08:08:54 <haint_> I'm testing
08:09:19 <gongysh> haint_, you can add more information on this patch.
08:09:23 <dkushwaha> o/
08:09:41 <haint_> yes, I will update later. Now, it can add VNF workflow action to Mistral
08:10:00 <gongysh> for example,  what task it is trying to fix, how we can test.
08:10:02 <gongysh> haint_, thanks
08:10:12 <haint_> the next patch is update Tacker database via Tacker conductor
08:10:26 <gongysh> dkushwaha, hi
08:11:19 <dkushwaha> sorry i was late
08:11:42 <gongysh> dkushwaha,  haha
08:12:00 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, hi
08:12:07 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, hi
08:12:09 <gongysh> what about the ui sudio?
08:12:14 <gongysh> can you show us?
08:12:21 <dangtrinhnt> Sorry, not ready yet
08:12:28 <dangtrinhnt> Quite complicated than I thought.
08:12:38 <gongysh> sure, it is complex.
08:13:00 <gongysh> do you have looked at other mano system for their web studio?
08:13:05 <dangtrinhnt> Trying to decide where to put the template files.
08:13:06 <dangtrinhnt> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/553684/
08:13:32 <dangtrinhnt> The only one available is heat-dashboard that I'm awared of.
08:14:02 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt,   can u show us where it is storing the file locally by heat-dashboard?
08:14:48 <dangtrinhnt> I'm not sure exactly where but it's store as files somewhere: https://github.com/openstack/heat-dashboard/blob/master/heat_dashboard/api/heat.py#L115
08:15:01 <dangtrinhnt> I will update the exact directory later in the patch.
08:15:44 <dangtrinhnt> My first idea is to store in Tacker's database but that add dependency
08:16:19 <YanXing_an> seems this is a database via web
08:17:01 <gongysh> heat-translator is using https:// or http: so it is a remote url.
08:17:35 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, but it is not a big deal, you can have a setting config for the time being.
08:17:41 <dangtrinhnt> Ok
08:18:02 <YanXing_an> +1
08:18:07 <gongysh> user can set this path as a NFS path, later we can put it as a tacker API.
08:18:44 <dangtrinhnt> Agree. I will update the patch. Thanks gongysh, YanXing_an.
08:19:06 <gongysh> ok.
08:19:20 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, you can show us as soon as possible
08:19:30 <dangtrinhnt> Ok, I'll try my best :D
08:19:50 <gongysh> and it will be much better if we have compared to other mano's web studio.
08:20:04 <dangtrinhnt> Sure.
08:20:21 <gongysh> so no need to hurry to code. lets have some investigation first.
08:20:44 <YanXing_an> dangtrinhnt, does the web studio call tacker vnfm's api?
08:21:23 <dangtrinhnt> yes, to import VNFD, VNFFGD, NSD directly
08:21:27 <dangtrinhnt> that's the idea.
08:22:34 <gongysh> haint_, do you have plan when you can finish the mistal action patch?
08:23:21 <haint_> at least three more weeks, gongysh
08:23:34 <YanXing_an> dangtrinhnt, ok.
08:23:57 <haint_> register vnf monitor to mistral is going to finish soon, next patch will take time.
08:24:11 <gongysh> haint_, it is a long time. but thanks
08:24:17 <gongysh> got it
08:24:42 <gongysh> #topic vancouver summit
08:25:12 <gongysh> project update session
08:25:47 <gongysh> Hoang Cong Phuoc and dkushwaha , please start to prepare the topic.
08:26:03 <dkushwaha> gongysh, sure
08:26:19 <gongysh> community gives you extra free code which i will send them to you.
08:26:31 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, I'll be there. Working on my VISA :)
08:27:09 <haint_> can I have a free ticket code?
08:27:16 <phuoc> gongysh, I will prepare for it, and my visa too
08:27:23 <gongysh> thanks.
08:28:00 <gongysh> dkushwaha,  phuoc , do you guys have topic selected/
08:28:02 <gongysh> ?
08:28:22 <dangtrinhnt> Yes, as lightning talk (10m).
08:28:29 <dkushwaha> gongysh, yes, but in lighting talk
08:29:25 <haint_> I want to go there but I have only 50% discount.
08:30:00 <gongysh> dkushwaha,  so you should have a free code already?
08:30:19 <gongysh> we can give one code to haint_
08:30:21 <haint_> if i have free ticket, i will convince
08:30:21 <haint_> my advisor to support travel code
08:30:39 <dkushwaha> gongysh, yes, and i will start visa processing by nex week(after my company approval)
08:31:01 <dkushwaha> *next
08:31:12 <gongysh> haint_, Ok, I can send a code to you.
08:31:26 <haint_> yes, my email: nguyentrihai93@gmail.com, thanks gongysh
08:31:35 <dangtrinhnt> cool :D
08:33:02 <gongysh> thant for summit
08:33:16 <gongysh> #topic open discussion
08:33:23 <gongysh> anything to talk about?
08:34:21 <gongysh> osm.etsi.org is another open source mano
08:34:31 <gongysh> you guys can see how it works
08:34:43 <gongysh> it supports some public cloud vim.
08:35:02 <gongysh> that we can introduce.
08:35:05 <phuoc> gongysh, we sometimes look at it too
08:35:18 <dangtrinhnt> Thanks, I'm looking at https://osm.etsi.org/wikipub/images/2/26/OSM_R2_Information_Model.pdf
08:36:21 <gongysh> of course, onap is another big one.
08:37:05 <gongysh> joxyuki, hi
08:37:11 <joxyuki> hi
08:37:31 <gongysh> policy feature
08:37:43 <gongysh> Affinity/Anti-Affinity policies for VDUs .   - masaito, joxyuki, keiko [10m]
08:37:48 <gongysh> do you have any update?
08:39:42 <gongysh> ok
08:39:49 <gongysh> it seems no new update.
08:39:55 <joxyuki> now we are reconsidering the problem that tacker healing is VNF level.
08:40:52 <joxyuki> one solution is that deploying Act and Standby to 2 VNF and manage policy at NS level.
08:41:44 <joxyuki> but how about supporting VDU leve healing?
08:43:15 <gongysh> I think we can support at any level.
08:43:25 <gongysh> VDU is for respwaning policy
08:43:43 <gongysh> VNF for affinity policy for its member VDUs.
08:43:54 <phuoc> yes, it can be a good feature
08:44:25 <gongysh> NS level , we can also have placement policy, NS1's vud1 should be balabala with NS2's vdu2.
08:45:11 <phuoc> but Tacker uses Heat to launch all VMs, we need more investigate about it
08:45:23 <joxyuki> got it.
08:46:17 <gongysh> anything else?
08:46:53 <phuoc> joxyuki, you can upload spec, and we can put more comments to support you guys
08:47:20 <gongysh> I have one more free code, if team member needs it,  ask for it.
08:47:31 <joxyuki> phuoc, thanks I will try.
08:47:52 <egonzalez> i have a ticket free ticket from last ptg
08:47:56 <egonzalez> can give to someone
08:48:02 <gongysh> ok, please email me or ping me anything about the project.
08:48:26 <gongysh> if there is no more questions, let end this meeting. thanks
08:48:32 <gongysh> #endmeeting