08:02:15 <gongysh> #startmeeting tacker
08:02:15 <openstack> Meeting started Tue May  8 08:02:15 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gongysh. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:02:16 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:02:18 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tacker'
08:02:57 <gongysh> #topic roll call
08:03:03 <phuoc_> o/
08:03:32 <dangtrinhnt> hi
08:03:33 <phuoc_> hi gongysh
08:03:48 <gongysh> phuoc_ hi
08:04:14 <nguyenhai_> o/
08:05:22 <gongysh> #topic bp
08:05:28 <gongysh> phuoc_ hi
08:05:38 <gongysh> do you have update for your bp?
08:06:12 <phuoc_> gongysh, I have some code for it
08:06:32 <gongysh> phuoc_, need any help from review?
08:06:34 <phuoc_> So, I can create VNFFG between VM and container VNFs
08:06:38 <dkushwaha> o/
08:06:42 <phuoc_> use kuryr-kubernetes
08:06:42 <gongysh> dkushwaha, hi
08:06:50 <mardim> #info Dimitrios Markou
08:07:16 <gongysh> phuoc_, if you can put out testing method along with your patch, it will help lots.
08:07:16 <phuoc_> so, I will record it, and send demo to you guys
08:07:28 <mardim> gongysh, Can I start the update about the demo because I have a conflicting meeting in half an hour
08:07:30 <mardim> ?
08:07:41 <gongysh> mardim, ok
08:08:03 <phuoc_> mardim, sure ^^
08:08:03 <gongysh> #topic demo of sfc in vancuvour
08:08:06 <mardim> So I have a video about the demo
08:08:11 <gongysh> mardim, please.
08:08:23 <gongysh> mardim, i have some updates and comments on demo ppt
08:08:25 <mardim> But today I realised
08:08:41 <mardim> that libvirt shutted off my devstack Vm
08:08:49 <mardim> and right now nothing works
08:09:05 <mardim> I will try to fix that but if I will not make it
08:09:10 <mardim> we will have the video
08:09:15 <mardim> so I think we are coo
08:09:18 <mardim> cool*
08:09:30 <mardim> I hope gongysh like the video
08:09:40 <mardim> Also I ve updated the slides
08:09:45 <mardim> for the presentation
08:09:51 <mardim> please gongysh review it
08:09:53 <gongysh> mardim, the is no audio for the video.
08:10:04 <mardim> Yes I know
08:10:07 <gongysh> the -> there
08:10:15 <mardim> beacuse I wanted to present it to the summit
08:10:27 <mardim> And I do not wanted audio
08:10:37 <mardim> So I can do the live talk
08:10:41 <gongysh> mardim, I have some comments on the google slides.
08:10:50 <gongysh> you can have a look at them.
08:10:56 <mardim> gongysh, ok
08:11:07 <mardim> you can add or remove whatever you want on the slides
08:11:13 <mardim> gongysh, ^
08:11:19 <gongysh> one point I give is the github site for the demo scripts.
08:11:45 <gongysh> so that the audience can practice it offline after the topic.
08:12:07 <mardim> let me check
08:12:36 <gongysh> #link https://drive.google.com/open?id=1Hoq-QT9W-g68K1I87xH1Bu_ft382uOfe
08:12:43 <gongysh> #link https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1oxJeymXFlWhmeVRKEV2cDXWxpADhmw7lt_W8pDVDpOs/edit?usp=sharing
08:13:17 <gongysh> mardim, I hope you limited the edit privilege on the slides. :)
08:13:46 <gongysh> guys, these two links are information about tacker sfc topic at vancouver summit.
08:13:59 <mardim> the link I send you is an edit link
08:14:03 <mardim> not a readonly
08:14:11 <gongysh> anyone can comment on it.
08:14:28 <mardim> Is it ok to just show the video
08:14:39 <mardim> if I do not manage to recreate the hands on demo ?
08:14:45 <mardim> because now is in a bad shpae
08:14:47 <mardim> shape
08:14:51 <mardim> ?
08:15:26 <gongysh> mardim, thanks for the efforts to prepare the slides.
08:15:26 <gongysh> mardim, the video is the last resort.
08:16:11 <gongysh> ok, lets back to bp topic
08:16:13 <gongysh> #topic bp
08:16:17 <mardim> Thanks a lot
08:16:37 <gongysh> mardim, thanks
08:16:47 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, hi
08:16:55 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh hi
08:17:06 <gongysh> do you have some thing to talk about your bp?
08:17:19 <dangtrinhnt> Nothing finish yest. I'm still rushing with the studio
08:17:25 <dangtrinhnt> *yet
08:17:33 <keiko_> o/
08:18:14 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, ok
08:18:16 <gongysh> thanks
08:18:18 <nguyenhai_> Hi, about VNF monitoring using Mistral, I don't have any update too
08:18:59 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, mardim, Can I comment to the slides?
08:19:07 <gongysh> nguyenhai_, you are still stuck with conductor to access the vim credentials:
08:19:11 <mardim> Yes of course
08:19:15 <dkushwaha> nguyenhai_, i think action part is still in wip
08:19:15 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, sure
08:19:33 <gongysh> nguyenhai_, you are still stuck with conductor to access the vim credentials?
08:19:39 <nguyenhai_> yes, I am
08:19:56 <gongysh> YanXing_an, hi
08:20:09 <YanXing_an> hi
08:20:15 <nguyenhai_> anyone is expert in the vim credentials can help?
08:20:21 <gongysh> do we have a way for admin to access the vim credentials stored in barbican?
08:20:43 <gongysh> conductor have to access the vim credentials.
08:20:48 <nguyenhai_> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/486924/
08:20:48 <patchbot> patch 486924 - tacker - Implement VNF monitoring using Mistral
08:21:14 <YanXing_an> gongysh, maybe we need modify the Policy
08:21:22 <nguyenhai_> oslo_messaging.set_transport_defaults(control_exchange='tacker') cannot transport all settings of server to conductor
08:23:24 <gongysh> nguyenhai_, there are two problems here: one is how the conductor get the keystone settings of the tacker conf, second is how the conductor can get the vim credentials.
08:27:05 <gongysh> for the first one, I think we can add keystone config options registry into the conductor codes.
08:27:17 <gongysh> for the second, do you have any idea?
08:27:22 <gongysh> YanXing_an
08:27:23 <gongysh> ?
08:28:21 <gongysh> can we allow someone to access the vim credentials stored in barbican?
08:28:43 <gongysh> how can we make change to barbican setting?
08:29:34 <YanXing_an> i will look into it
08:29:43 <gongysh> mardim, can you write the env setup script for the demo?
08:30:01 <gongysh> I want to find some time to set up the env.
08:30:13 <gongysh> YanXing_an, ok. thanks
08:30:24 <gongysh> keiko_, hi
08:30:27 <gongysh> any update?
08:30:29 <nguyenhai_> thanks YanXing_an
08:31:02 <keiko_> just now on going for vnfm-reservation.
08:31:30 <gongysh> keiko_, ok
08:31:39 <mardim> gongysh, what do you mean ?
08:31:51 <mardim> gongysh, what is the env_setup script ?
08:31:58 <gongysh> mardim, I mean the demo env setup script.
08:32:17 <gongysh> had better step by step guide.
08:32:54 <mardim> I will try to find some spare time to write a step by step guide
08:33:00 <mardim> if this is what do you mean
08:33:03 <phuoc_> mardim, I think you can provide some file, such as local.conf, vnffgd.yaml
08:33:23 <mardim> I have the local.conf and the vnffgd files
08:33:34 <mardim> I can provide them in a github repo
08:33:48 <phuoc_> that's great
08:33:49 <mardim> but I do not have the time right now to write any script or a guide
08:33:50 <gongysh> the openwrt and scruxxx settings
08:33:52 <mardim> so I cannot promise
08:34:03 <mardim> what is scruxxxx
08:34:04 <mardim> ?
08:34:16 <gongysh> Suricata
08:34:18 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, The answer is yes. nguyenhai_: this workflow may help: https://docs.openstack.org/tacker/latest/contributor/encrypt_vim_auth_with_barbican.html#overview
08:34:53 <nguyenhai_> I will look at it
08:35:13 <mardim> gongysh, I can provide links
08:35:19 <mardim> that I used for the configuration
08:35:40 <YanXing_an> gongysh, nguyenhai, what's the use case that conductor access the vim credentials?  monitor the vim at high level?
08:36:10 <dangtrinhnt> mardim, I can help writing the script and guide.
08:36:22 <mardim> dangtrinhnt, thanks
08:36:26 <mardim> you can start writing it
08:36:38 <dangtrinhnt> Just need your configuration file/link.
08:36:39 <mardim> and I can review and help with additional info
08:36:46 <dangtrinhnt> ok cool.
08:36:53 <gongysh> YanXing_an, our policy action is run in tacker conductor, which is oslo message rpc target from mistral monitor tasks.
08:37:10 <mardim> dangtrinhnt, ok I will send you some links after the meeting
08:37:14 <mardim> thanks !!
08:37:28 <dangtrinhnt> No problem. Cool.
08:38:11 <gongysh> YanXing_an,  you can review the https://review.openstack.org/#/c/486924/ and get the idea.
08:38:12 <patchbot> patch 486924 - tacker - Implement VNF monitoring using Mistral
08:38:36 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt,  thanks
08:39:02 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, after that, please send me the github url.
08:39:30 <gongysh> mardim, for the topic, I want you to show us how the odl does the sfc.
08:39:56 <gongysh> just like the comment at the google doc.
08:39:56 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, ok.
08:40:17 <mardim> I can update the slides about odl sfc
08:40:27 <gongysh> mardim, thanks
08:40:31 <YanXing_an> gongysh, if we have only ping action for vim, it's no need to get the vim auth from barbican.
08:40:32 <mardim> gongysh, no pro
08:42:12 <gongysh> YanXing_an, we need to run policy action, such as respawn or scale the vnf from conductor
08:42:15 <nguyenhai_> YanXing_an, we need vim auth for respawn the VNF
08:42:39 <YanXing_an> ok, i see
08:43:46 <gongysh> #topic open discussion
08:43:52 <gongysh> anything else?
08:43:54 <YanXing_an> aguyenhai, it's a good change
08:44:36 <phuoc_> Can you guys review it, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/548109
08:44:37 <patchbot> patch 548109 - tacker - Support exposing Kubernetes service using Loadbala...
08:45:17 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, I don't see docker image for tacker-horizon in kolla
08:45:43 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, there is no independent tacker-horizon stuff
08:45:48 <gongysh> tacker horizon is a plugin in horizon image.
08:46:06 <dangtrinhnt> https://github.com/openstack/kolla/blob/master/docker/horizon/Dockerfile.j2
08:46:38 <gongysh> phuoc_, I am not sure I know the purpose of that patch. is it a part of your bp?
08:46:50 <phuoc_> gongysh, yes
08:47:11 <phuoc_> It will prepare devstack environment for my next patch set
08:47:13 <gongysh> you can mark it as a part of you bp at git commit msg.
08:47:36 <gongysh> and add implements: bp xxxx
08:47:37 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, that patch also fix an incompatibility issue with kuryr-k8s
08:47:39 <phuoc_> gongysh sure, I will do it
08:48:10 <nguyenhai_> I reported a bug: https://bugs.launchpad.net/tacker/+bug/1768386
08:48:11 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1768386 in tacker "Cannot add OpenWRT image while installing by devstack" [Medium,New]
08:48:14 <gongysh> dkushwaha, hi
08:48:16 <nguyenhai_> Devstack installation cannot add OpenWRT image by default.
08:48:26 <nguyenhai_> https://github.com/openstack/tacker/blob/master/devstack/lib/tacker#L316
08:48:43 <nguyenhai_> Can anyone confirm the function tacker_check_and_download_images work or not?
08:48:44 <dkushwaha> gongysh, hi
08:48:57 <gongysh> dkushwaha, anything to talk?
08:49:34 <dkushwaha> gongysh, not now, i am just drafting ppt for project update
08:49:46 <gongysh> dkushwaha, great.
08:49:47 <gongysh> thanks
08:49:54 <gongysh> do you have project update template?
08:50:13 <gongysh> I got the template email from community
08:50:48 <dkushwaha> gongysh, oh, i am preparing own . https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1cJQ6MVvCVLFVJM1RCkk9w-22St1xEDoOqpntpQdK-uI/edit#slide=id.g3379f772a0_0_122
08:51:13 <dkushwaha> gongysh,  please share that template, i will update accordingly
08:51:21 <gongysh> dkushwaha, sure
08:51:45 <gongysh> #link tacker update slides https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1cJQ6MVvCVLFVJM1RCkk9w-22St1xEDoOqpntpQdK-uI/edit#slide=id.g3379f772a0_0_122
08:52:56 <gongysh> dkushwaha, can you send me your email address again here?
08:53:22 <gongysh> s/send/show/  me
08:53:28 <dkushwaha> dharmendra.kushwaha@india.nec.com
08:54:34 <phuoc_> gongysh, Can you share the template to me?
08:54:44 <phuoc_> my email is: phuoc.hc@dcn.ssu.ac.kr
08:54:45 <gongysh> sure
08:54:56 <phuoc_> thank you
08:55:26 <gongysh> phuoc_, dkushwaha , email is on the way.
08:55:41 <dkushwaha> gongysh, Thanks
08:56:05 <gongysh> phuoc_, we can share the k8s feature on project update topic.
08:56:19 <gongysh> even with a small demo.
08:56:57 <phuoc_> gongysh, sure
08:57:14 <phuoc_> I will do it
08:57:19 <gongysh> phuoc_, please help update the https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1cJQ6MVvCVLFVJM1RCkk9w-22St1xEDoOqpntpQdK-uI/edit#slide=id.g3379f772a0_0_122
08:57:21 <gongysh> thanks
08:58:45 <gongysh> phuoc_, dkushwaha ,https://www.openstack.org/summit/vancouver-2018/summit-schedule/global-search?t=Onboarding
08:58:54 <gongysh> we also have a project onboarding topic
08:59:18 <gongysh> I hope you guys can help to do it too.
08:59:33 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, hi
08:59:46 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh hi
09:00:03 <gongysh> can you help to prepare the ppt for onboarding sesstion?
09:00:10 <dkushwaha> gongysh, sure, do we need some saparate ppt for that too?
09:00:12 <gongysh> lets to tacker channel.
09:00:17 <gongysh> #endmeeting