08:04:45 <dkushwaha> #startmeeting tacker
08:04:46 <openstack> Meeting started Tue May  7 08:04:45 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is dkushwaha. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:04:47 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:04:50 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tacker'
08:04:57 <dkushwaha> #topic Roll Call
08:05:06 <dkushwaha> who is here for Tacker weekly meeting?
08:05:52 <joxyuki> hi
08:06:41 <hyunsikyang> Hi
08:06:49 <hyunsikyang> Hi jo and dkushwaha
08:07:02 <dkushwaha> hello joxyuki hyunsikyang
08:07:22 <joxyuki> hi, hyunsikyang
08:07:29 <dkushwaha> How was the summit?
08:07:56 <hyunsikyang> not many people, compare to last summit.
08:08:20 <bhagyashris> O/
08:08:28 <joxyuki> snow at Tuesday :(
08:08:35 <dkushwaha> hi bhagyashris
08:08:36 <hyunsikyang> and in the tacker session, around 20~ people attended.
08:09:01 <dkushwaha> hyunsikyang, ~20 is also good :)
08:09:10 <dkushwaha> hyunsikyang, how was your talk?
08:09:10 <takahashi-tsc> Hello all, this is my first participation in Tacker meeting.
08:09:21 <hyunsikyang> Hi takahashi
08:09:37 <JangwonLee_> Hi
08:09:40 <joxyuki> hi
08:09:43 <jaewook_oh> Hello
08:09:47 <dkushwaha> hello takahashi-tsc, welcome in Tacker Team
08:09:48 <hyunsikyang> Um.. I only have 10 min so I brifely explain it
08:10:27 <dkushwaha> hyunsikyang, yea, 10 minute is really too short
08:10:50 <dkushwaha> hello jaewook_oh JangwonLee_
08:10:52 <hyunsikyang> but, some people doesn't know about tacker. so That session was good for introducing Tacker.
08:11:38 <hyunsikyang> I get namecard from some teleco company.
08:12:05 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, hyunsikyang , do you want to share some input(if any) from summit
08:13:47 <hyunsikyang> I talked with fenix PTL and Fenix also consider ETSI spec to adapt it to fenix. So we also good chance to consider ETSI spec as a MANO
08:13:56 <hyunsikyang> And
08:15:01 <hyunsikyang> More and More , Many people focus on the container, so whatif, tacker also focus on the container related features, it also good.
08:15:53 <hyunsikyang> and we also consider how we provides some feautures for Edge cloud collaboration kinds of things
08:15:55 <dkushwaha> hyunsikyang, yea, we needs to prioritize C-VNF related activities
08:16:44 <joxyuki> yeah, generally edge computing session increased.
08:17:46 <joxyuki> it seems affected by 5G growing.
08:18:32 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, hyunsikyang yea, 5g growing rapidly now a days
08:18:32 <hyunsikyang> That is, We should think about features as a perspective of telco view.
08:19:03 <joxyuki> for example, I think, Multi-VIM support might be required.
08:19:12 <hyunsikyang> Maintenance,Edge, lightweight things..
08:19:45 <dkushwaha> have you got chance to talk some telco operators and there views/inputes for tacker?
08:20:16 <joxyuki> sorry nothing from me
08:20:19 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, what it mean by Multi-VIM(as we already supporting it)??
08:20:54 <joxyuki> yeah, we already support it but is it feasible for edge?
08:21:03 <hyunsikyang> I talked with one guy who come from middle east and he asked me why tacker is not well known..
08:21:38 <joxyuki> I mean, for edge, such as StarlingX will be supported as VIM
08:21:40 <hyunsikyang> And he said, these feautres is good for telco provider. but, he want to know how they adapt tacker to real environment.
08:22:02 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, I see, need to check us more for Edge cloud things
08:22:33 <hyunsikyang> yes. Our team also consider it how we adapt it to tacker.
08:22:57 <hyunsikyang> I met Jo and we also talked about etsi spec.
08:23:09 <dkushwaha> nice :)
08:23:14 <hyunsikyang> It also good features:)
08:24:18 <dkushwaha> Thanks joxyuki hyunsikyang for good inputs.
08:24:24 <dkushwaha> moving next..
08:24:36 <hyunsikyang> you're welcome.
08:24:39 <dkushwaha> #topic BP
08:25:15 <dkushwaha> #topic VNF Package support BP
08:25:23 <dkushwaha> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/582930
08:25:53 <joxyuki> I wrote my memo on https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tacker-train-grooming
08:26:06 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, I gone though the spec, and overall looks good to me as of now
08:26:26 <dkushwaha> I have few questions
08:27:00 <joxyuki> thanks, but biggest problem is that we need to support ETSI NFV-SOL001.
08:27:50 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, Any approach on that ?
08:28:18 <joxyuki> yes, my team are also plannning to address it but it will be U cycle.
08:29:15 <joxyuki> then, at Train, just creating VNF package will be availble but not able to create VNF from it.
08:29:30 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, I see it will be a big task
08:30:39 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, I hope that should be ok, to move step by step.
08:31:05 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, regarding VNF package do you have some plan to how deal with extracted CSAR resources ?
08:31:33 <joxyuki> ok, I will keep to make effort
08:32:21 <joxyuki> dkushwaha, current plan is storing VNF packages to local file system
08:32:35 <joxyuki> such as /var/lib/tacker but it is configurable
08:33:22 <joxyuki> and VM images shall be registerd to Glance if any.
08:33:46 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, agree to that approach. one more approach can be...
08:35:37 <dkushwaha> create a temp VM(may be we can call it as resource/package manager), and use it to extract CSAR bundle, upload all images/binaries/meat etc files there. And once deployment done, clean that VM
08:36:17 <dkushwaha> It will help to keep all  csar resources separate and secure.
08:36:40 <dkushwaha> It is one of my point, but yes I wanted all your opinions on that
08:37:09 <dkushwaha> %s/meat/meta
08:37:10 <joxyuki> dkushwaha, thanks for your idea :)
08:39:17 <joxyuki> I will examine it
08:39:48 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, cool, we can discuss more in vPTG
08:40:14 <dkushwaha> moving next..
08:40:49 <dkushwaha> #topic visually design TOSCA templates
08:40:59 <dkushwaha> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/553684
08:41:49 <dkushwaha> Looking for some volunteer who can pick it up
08:43:08 <hyunsikyang> what you mean? Trinh Nguyen want to get off this work?
08:43:12 <dkushwaha> visually design TOSCA templates support can help to make Tacker user friendly
08:44:09 <dkushwaha> hyunsikyang, As Trinh is busy in some other activities, so it will be good if some other  can lead it
08:45:12 <hyunsikyang> Ah, OK:)
08:45:40 <dkushwaha> moving next..
08:46:02 <dkushwaha> #topic #Tacker vPTG
08:46:17 <dkushwaha> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/Tacker-PTG-Train
08:47:34 <dkushwaha> I am thinking to have one day vPTG on 14th May
08:48:02 <dkushwaha> Let me know if it ok, otherwise please suggest as per your availability
08:48:46 <hyunsikyang> It's good to me.
08:50:16 <dkushwaha> and timing: it will be 4 hours virtual meetup 08:00 UTC to 12:00 UTC
08:51:12 <dkushwaha> joxyuki, bhagyashris jaewook_oh JangwonLee_ takahashi-tsc ^^
08:51:24 <takahashi-tsc> It's good to me, and I'd like to join vPTG. I'm interested in support ETSI.
08:51:48 <joxyuki> almost OK, but until 11a.m. UTC
08:52:19 <joxyuki> let me talk my topic first
08:52:58 <dkushwaha> joxyuki,  ok, sure
08:53:03 <jaewook_oh> ok
08:53:17 <joxyuki> very thanks team :)
08:53:21 <bhagyashris> Agree with joxyuki
08:53:23 <jaewook_oh> i'll attend at that time
08:53:29 <bhagyashris> Thank you :)
08:54:21 <dkushwaha> thanks all
08:54:47 <dkushwaha> I will share meeting channel later
08:55:18 <dkushwaha> #topic OpenDiscussion
08:55:38 <dkushwaha> I have noting to discuss as of now.
08:56:45 <dkushwaha> couple of more minutes left.
08:56:47 <hyunsikyang> I will present my blueprint in the vPTG. but, before that could you check my blueprint?
08:57:03 <hyunsikyang> https://review.opendev.org/#/c/643242/ and https://review.opendev.org/#/c/636272/
08:57:30 <hyunsikyang> one is related fenix. another one is for multi interface for C-VNF.
08:57:36 <dkushwaha> hyunsikyang, sure, it is in my list, will review it
08:58:31 <hyunsikyang> are you gonna make a etherpad for vPTG?
08:59:03 <dkushwaha> hyunsikyang, it is https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/Tacker-PTG-Train
08:59:09 <dkushwaha> we use this one
08:59:12 <hyunsikyang> OK
08:59:14 <hyunsikyang> Thanks
08:59:37 <dkushwaha> ok
08:59:40 <dkushwaha> Thanks Folks for joining this meeting.
08:59:50 <dkushwaha> closing it now.
08:59:53 <joxyuki> :)
09:00:02 <dkushwaha> #endmeeting