08:01:43 <ueha> #startmeeting tacker
08:01:43 <opendevmeet> Meeting started Tue Dec 13 08:01:43 2022 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is ueha. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:01:43 <opendevmeet> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:01:43 <opendevmeet> The meeting name has been set to 'tacker'
08:02:00 <ueha> I heard that yasufum can not join this meeting today, so I will start the meeting.
08:02:25 <ueha> #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/tacker-meeting
08:02:45 <yuta-kazato> Yes, I heard too. Thanks ueha-san.
08:02:52 <ueha> We have two item from yuta-kazato on the etherpad today,
08:03:05 <ueha> yuta-kazato: can you share about your topic?
08:03:12 <yuta-kazato> OK!
08:03:33 <yuta-kazato> Hi, Tacker team. I propose two items for today's meeting.
08:04:17 <yuta-kazato> First item is ``Development plans of the Tacker Zed Specifications in Antelope Cycle.``
08:04:37 <yuta-kazato> We share the development plans to implement two specifications merged in Zed Release for Antelope.
08:04:46 <ueha> #topic Development plans of the Tacker Zed Specifications in Antelope Cycle
08:06:01 <yuta-kazato> In Tacker Zed Release, the following specs are not implemented, so we will develop them for Antelope.
08:06:21 <yuta-kazato> No.1: Enhance ChangeCurrentVNFPackage API
08:06:27 <yuta-kazato> #link https://specs.openstack.org/openstack/tacker-specs/specs/zed/enhance_change_current_vnf_package_API.html
08:06:39 <yuta-kazato> No.2: Enhance Placement Process
08:06:45 <yuta-kazato> #link https://specs.openstack.org/openstack/tacker-specs/specs/zed/enhance_placement_process.html
08:07:29 <yuta-kazato> We also fix spec of "Enhance Placement Process" for Antelope.
08:07:45 <yuta-kazato> #link  https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/tacker-specs/+/867316
08:08:14 <yuta-kazato> We look forward to your review:) That's all from my side regarding topic 1.
08:08:26 <ueha> Thank you
08:08:44 <ueha> any comment for topic 1?
08:08:49 <manpreetk> Shoudn't these spec move to 2023.1 folder.
08:09:39 <manpreetk> As we are enhancing or completing them in Antelope version. What do you think?
08:10:54 <yuta-kazato> Thank you for your comments, manpreetk-san!
08:11:34 <yuta-kazato> I think It is no problem with keeping the Zed folder, but if necessary, I'm fine with moving to the 2023.1 folder.
08:13:03 <yuta-kazato> I would like to hear PTL and core developer's opinions.
08:14:08 <ueha> I don't know if it's necessary or not, but I think we have changed the folder of spec in the same situation.
08:14:41 <ueha> takahashi-tsc: what do you think?
08:15:09 <takahashi-tsc> I remember that we move some spec to next release directory... If there was no output in Zed release, moving to 2023.1 is better.
08:15:33 <ueha> +1
08:16:21 <yuta-kazato> Thank you for your comments. I understood the previous situations.
08:17:19 <yuta-kazato> In fact, ``Enhance Placement Process`` is no output in Zed release, so it is better to be moving to 2023.1.
08:17:42 <ueha> The following patch is implementation of "Enhance ChangeCurrentVNFPackage API"?
08:17:45 <ueha> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/tacker/+/854691
08:18:00 <ueha> in Zed release.
08:20:20 <ueha> If so, I think you can leave the spec for  "Enhance ChangeCurrentVNFPackage API"  as it is.
08:20:46 <takahashi-tsc> +1
08:21:21 <yuta-kazato> ueha-san> Yes, that's right. I agree too.
08:22:43 <ueha> thank you
08:23:38 <yuta-kazato> We leave ``Enhance ChangeCurrentVNFPackage API`` as it is and move ``Enhance Placement Process`` to 2023.1.
08:23:45 <yuta-kazato> Thanks.
08:24:04 <ueha> I added conclusion to etherpad. thanks.
08:24:18 <ueha> any other comment for topic 1?
08:24:56 <ueha> good, let's go to next topic.
08:25:15 <ueha> #topic Request for Extension of Spec Freeze for Antelope
08:25:49 <yuta-kazato> OK, move to topic 2.
08:27:04 <yuta-kazato> Our team will submit Tacker Antelope Specifications in this week, but current deadline (16th Dec) is not enough time for community's review..
08:27:58 <yuta-kazato> These specs are approved by Antelope PTG, so we hope Tacker community will agree that extending the deadline.
08:28:09 <yuta-kazato> It will improve the quality of the spec and developments too.
08:28:36 <yuta-kazato> In my proposal, Extended Deadline is 28th Dec. Would you agree to this, Tacker team?
08:29:00 <yuta-kazato> That's all from my side, topic2.
08:29:20 <ueha> Thanks for your suggestion
08:30:50 <ueha> I think "28th Dec" is is the last working day of this year for Japanese members (and other country memvers?).
08:32:23 <ueha> Wouldn't it be better to make it 26th or 27th..?
08:35:50 <yuta-kazato> ueha-san> Thanks for comments. In fact, I chosed the extended dedline refer to previous meeting's discussion.
08:36:03 <yuta-kazato> #link https://meetings.opendev.org/meetings/tacker/2022/tacker.2022-11-01-08.01.log.html
08:36:28 <takahashi-tsc> I think 28th seems OK... It means we should submit final specs 1 weeks ago and review rework will be finished about 26th.
08:37:42 <takahashi-tsc> At least, I will review and merge specs til 28th.
08:38:05 <ueha> I think it's OK if other people don't have any problems. :)
08:40:03 <yuta-kazato> Thank you all for your cooperation, we will submit and review specs as soon as we can.
08:40:40 <ueha> Thank you too!
08:40:43 <takahashi-tsc> Thanks
08:41:52 <ueha> any other comment?
08:41:54 <manpreetk> ueha: could you update new timeline in etherpad
08:42:35 <manpreetk> thanks
08:43:06 <ueha> Okay, I updated Spec freeze deadline
08:43:19 <yuta-kazato> Thanks!
08:43:30 <ueha> any other comment or topics?
08:44:27 <ueha> good
08:44:37 <ueha> Let's close this meeting, thanks for joining, bye!
08:44:40 <manpreetk> Thanks and Bye!!
08:44:45 <takahashi-tsc> thanks
08:44:47 <yuta-kazato> Thanks bye!
08:44:56 <ueha> #endmeeting