15:00:26 <mmedvede> #startmeeting third-party
15:00:27 <openstack> Meeting started Mon May 16 15:00:26 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is mmedvede. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:28 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:30 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'third_party'
15:01:11 <mmedvede> anyone around for third-party CI meeting?
15:01:31 <asselin__> good morning. I'm around.
15:01:37 <mmedvede> asselin__: morning
15:02:54 <kcalman> o/
15:03:16 <mmedvede> hi kcalman
15:03:20 <lennyb> hi
15:03:31 <kcalman> Hi there
15:03:49 <mmedvede> yay, more people! hi lennyb
15:04:23 <lennyb> mmedvede, hi.
15:04:54 <mmedvede> anyone has anything to discuss? I did not see anything on ML that was of interest for our CI
15:06:08 <lennyb> I've just wanted to let you know about this #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/devstack/+bug/1581922 bug.
15:06:10 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1581922 in devstack "rping fails when no IP address on the port" [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to Lenny (lennyb)
15:06:32 <lennyb> we are also checking the proposed fix
15:06:53 <lennyb> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/315758/
15:08:49 <mmedvede> thanks lennyb
15:10:12 <mmedvede> so that is related to having a special OVS config?
15:10:46 <lennyb> mmedvede, no, we do not define public_interface in the local.conf, so this caused the problem.
15:12:57 <mmedvede> ok, moving on
15:13:33 <mmedvede> kcalman: sorry I did not see you in the past meetings, are you starting a new CI, or maintaining an existing one?
15:14:36 <kcalman> I have been here for a couple of monthes,though not saying much.
15:14:51 <kcalman> I am seeting up a hardware CI for Ironic
15:15:30 <kcalman> and could use a little mentoring ;-)
15:15:42 <mmedvede> kcalman: that is cool! where are you at right now?
15:15:58 <kcalman> At Dell in Austin
15:16:02 <kcalman> TX
15:16:12 <lennyb> kcalman: interesting, we will start doing it in a couple of weeks. We had 1 server doing some APIs for now
15:16:13 <kcalman> I think we met at the summit
15:16:29 <mmedvede> kcalman: oh, I meant in the process of setting up, what stage are you in :)
15:16:52 <mmedvede> kcalman: hi neighbor! I am in Austin
15:16:58 <kcalman> we have the no-op gerrit gate job and zull/Jenkins set up
15:17:14 <kcalman> But I need som guidance configuring hardware networking
15:17:32 <kcalman> s/zull/zuul/
15:17:40 <lennyb> kcalman, sorry, not there yet.
15:18:47 <mmedvede> kcalman: we have setup an Ironic CI (no me personally, krtaylor leads an effort), and have it working
15:18:54 <lennyb> kcalman, we installed Jenkins Slave and were running ironic-tempest-plugin
15:19:21 <kcalman> can anyone suggest some documentation that would provide an overview of setting up a 3rd party hardware CI?
15:20:42 <mmedvede> kcalman: there is a blog post describing how-level how we did it https://developer.ibm.com/opentech/2016/04/20/ironic-continuous-integration-testing-with-hardware-pool-management/
15:20:57 <mmedvede> kcalman: I am not aware of "Official hardware CI" docs
15:21:10 <mmedvede> *hi-level
15:21:29 <mmedvede> *high-level (argh)
15:21:48 <kcalman> Excellent!
15:22:34 <kcalman> Besides me, is there much call for that kind of thing?
15:22:37 <mmedvede> One problem that required custom solution is hardware pool management, which is described in the post
15:25:38 <mmedvede> kcalman: If you mean the doc, then it would be useful. The problem is that, iirc, there is still needs to be support added (e.g. in devstack), to use it as is for ironic HW tests
15:25:57 <kcalman> Thanks, lennyb, mmedvede, and krtaylor, I hope you don't mind if I contact you off-line or on the #openstack-ironic chat?
15:26:08 <lennyb> sure
15:26:40 <mmedvede> kcalman: sounds good
15:26:55 <kcalman> About how many active hardware CI projects are there now, do you think?
15:27:16 <mmedvede> 3 at minimum, it looks like :)
15:27:33 <kcalman> I thought there were more...
15:27:48 <krtaylor> kcalman, sure!
15:29:06 <mmedvede> krtaylor: thx for showing up in here
15:29:23 <mmedvede> kcalman: there are definitely more HW projects
15:30:10 <mmedvede> kcalman: thanks for bringing it up, great to hear more people working on ironic hardware CIs
15:30:19 <krtaylor> mmedvede, I always lurk :)
15:30:50 <kcalman> So, do you think lack of a primer document is holding them back, or are they just quiet?
15:31:55 <mmedvede> I do not know, I think not everyone speaks up what they are working on, or attends the meetings
15:33:27 <mmedvede> anybody has more topics for today?
15:35:17 <krtaylor> kcalman, feel free to comment on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/304683/
15:35:54 <kcalman> I will be lookingh into that this week, thanks
15:36:07 <krtaylor> kcalman, we will have a few more things to add later, but any feedback would be appreciated
15:36:07 <mmedvede> #link Initial commit for MoltenIron https://review.openstack.org/#/c/304683
15:36:12 <krtaylor> thanks!
15:37:56 <mmedvede> any objections to ending the meeting?
15:38:15 <kcalman> I'm good, thanks
15:40:17 <mmedvede> thank you everyone for attending
15:40:23 <mmedvede> #endmeeting