17:00:57 <mmedvede> #startmeeting third-party
17:01:01 <openstack> Meeting started Tue May 31 17:00:57 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is mmedvede. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:01:02 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:01:04 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'third_party'
17:01:37 <asselin> hi mmedvede
17:01:46 <mmedvede> hi asselin
17:02:09 <mmedvede> nothing new on agenda for this week's meeting
17:02:13 <ja3> howdy ho
17:02:53 <ja3> there must be an internet meme for that state of affairs, misha.
17:03:17 <mmedvede> #link meeting agenda https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/ThirdParty
17:03:31 <mmedvede> hey ja3
17:04:03 <ja3> actually "nothing new on agenda" works well for me, I have to ditch in about 10 minutes
17:04:09 <mmedvede> #topic CI Watch
17:04:51 <mmedvede> I did decide to rework the long patch series I have on unit-tests branch to address asselin 's comments and to simplify
17:05:33 <mmedvede> I'd like to merge land patches without it becoming a long chain
17:06:22 <asselin> mmedvede, yeah saw a bunch of related e-mail this morning. Any specific reviews you need? +1 on landing smaller merges, if possible.
17:06:34 <mmedvede> asselin: please give a quick look to this one, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/267980/
17:06:46 <mmedvede> if you +1, I'll merge it
17:07:04 <mmedvede> so we get it moving
17:07:55 <asselin> will take a loook
17:07:59 <mmedvede> thank you
17:08:14 <mmedvede> #topic Common-CI Solution
17:08:38 <mmedvede> I did not see anything new
17:08:47 <mmedvede> asselin: any updates?
17:09:05 <asselin> seems stable now. saravana had issues on the mailing list, but no replies yet.
17:09:40 <mmedvede> thanks
17:09:42 <mmedvede> #topic Open Discussion
17:10:06 <ja3> bob is starting to construct our dev CI using the latest upstream infra so we can converge prod CI to it
17:10:28 <mmedvede> ja3: are you using openstackci?
17:10:37 <mmedvede> *puppet-openstackci
17:11:37 <ja3> I think that's his intent.  latest+greatest.
17:12:03 <asselin> anyone know what's going on with this patch? https://review.openstack.org/#/c/239810/
17:12:25 <ja3> not me
17:12:37 <mmedvede> asselin: no
17:12:55 <mmedvede> looks like it has not been updated lately
17:13:10 <asselin> no...getting stalled since last -1
17:14:11 <mmedvede> I wonder if the work should be split into bite-size pieces, like migrate single thing to common CI
17:14:18 <ja3> I have to drop, see you folks in 2 wks.
17:14:20 <mmedvede> I personally just deployed graphite/grafana
17:14:32 <mmedvede> so I think it is useful for other operators
17:14:40 <mmedvede> ja3, thanks for being here
17:15:04 <asselin> mmedvede, yeah that's a good point. It is a bit too open-ended.
17:17:51 <mmedvede> asselin: I did not have time to work on the spec, and probably would not have time in near future
17:18:34 <asselin> mmedvede, if you could add your comment ^^ I think that can help.
17:18:43 <asselin> add to the patch
17:19:05 <mmedvede> bump it :)
17:19:58 <mmedvede> asselin: also, I still think I need to remove the logstash/elastic search puppet that has landed in puppet-openstaci
17:20:14 <mmedvede> and abandon the other patch that removes it from system-config
17:20:22 <asselin> mmedvede, why's that?
17:20:57 <mmedvede> it was supposed to be an atomic change - as soon as it landed, it should have been removed from system-config
17:21:06 <mmedvede> now there are two copies
17:21:20 <mmedvede> and they have diverged a lot
17:21:41 * asselin sighs
17:21:45 <mmedvede> yeah
17:22:07 <mmedvede> in retrospect it should have been smaller change, not entire elk moved
17:23:38 <asselin> there's 3 manifests
17:24:30 <asselin> so you'd prefer to do each separately?
17:25:17 <mmedvede> yes
17:25:30 <mmedvede> if we still would move it. it needs to be smaller pieces
17:25:59 <asselin> ok, maybe we should discuss with more folks. perhaps in the infra meeting?
17:26:18 <mmedvede> yes
17:26:48 <mmedvede> I am checking agenda to see if there is a spot
17:26:50 <asselin> today's agenda is light. we can add it
17:27:24 <mmedvede> asselin: I'll add it. thanks for bringing it up
17:27:59 <asselin> cool
17:28:13 <mmedvede> I have another thing
17:28:18 <mmedvede> (should have added to agenda)
17:28:29 <mmedvede> zuul-merge hangups
17:28:50 <mmedvede> I brought it up during another meeting last week
17:29:04 <mmedvede> and noone seemed to have seen the problem
17:29:38 <asselin> I haven't seen it either....what's the issue?
17:29:54 <rcarrillocruz> hey folks
17:29:57 <rcarrillocruz> randomly reading
17:30:05 <rcarrillocruz> so, i chatted with pschwartz at the meeting
17:30:08 <mmedvede> hi rcarrillocruz
17:30:10 <asselin> rcarrillocruz, yeah ricky
17:30:20 <rcarrillocruz> he told me he planned to get back to that spec
17:30:26 <rcarrillocruz> to sort out -1s, etc
17:30:31 <rcarrillocruz> hey asselin :-)
17:31:13 <rcarrillocruz> to be fair, nibalizer comments are spot on
17:31:25 <rcarrillocruz> i had same opinion and removed the server abstraction in a previous patchset
17:31:40 <rcarrillocruz> but per yolanda's comment, i refused to get into that rabbit hole
17:31:50 <rcarrillocruz> imho, server abstraction should be out of puppet-openstackci
17:31:55 <rcarrillocruz> that should be a downstream thing
17:32:10 <rcarrillocruz> creating an interface to server seems a bit unnecessary to me
17:32:41 <mmedvede> I need to reread the spec. But what you are saying makes sense to me
17:32:55 <mmedvede> server class should not be part of openstackci
17:34:21 <mmedvede> server setup is specific to each environment
17:35:02 <mmedvede> rcarrillocruz: thanks for the update
17:35:36 <rcarrillocruz> np
17:36:20 <mmedvede> asselin: on zuul-merger: git fetch is basically taking upwards 15 minutes to get changes off of review.o.o. Maybe you would not notice if you are not looking for it
17:37:04 <mmedvede> my workaround so far is to detect the stall and to kill the ssh process that is hanging
17:37:12 <asselin> cbader, have you noticed this ^^ ?
17:40:49 <asselin> i'll follow up with him later
17:41:26 <mmedvede> I mentioned I'll get an email out once I have something tangible, nothing I can see so far. At least the workaround works
17:41:30 <mmedvede> asselin: thanks
17:41:57 <mmedvede> this is all on zuul-merger topic
17:43:01 <asselin> ack
17:44:59 <mmedvede> if nothing else to discuss, see you here in 2 weeks
17:45:10 <mmedvede> thank you for attending
17:45:26 <mmedvede> #endmeeting