14:01:09 <joehuang> #startmeeting tricircle
14:01:11 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Mar 22 14:01:09 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is joehuang. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:01:12 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:01:14 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tricircle'
14:01:37 <joehuang> #topic rollcall
14:01:41 <joehuang> #info joehuang
14:01:51 <zhiyuan> #info zhiyuan
14:01:51 <dongfeng> #info dongfeng
14:02:01 <fanyishi> #info fanyishi
14:02:11 <yinxiulin> #info xiulin
14:02:17 <RongHui11> #info ronghui
14:02:55 <hejiawei> #info hejiawei
14:03:12 <joehuang> #topic Pike-1 patches review
14:04:32 <joehuang> for VxLAN L2 networking, there are two patches are waiting for approve
14:04:50 <joehuang> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/425131/
14:05:10 <joehuang> Shared VxLAN (Part4: bridge network l3)
14:05:32 <joehuang> Shared VxLAN (Part5: bluk create shadow port) https://review.openstack.org/#/c/444112/
14:06:23 <joehuang> and the spec is waitfing for approve too:
14:06:26 <joehuang> Cross-pod VxLAN network spec
14:06:31 <joehuang> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/429155/
14:07:00 <joehuang> I would like to know if there are more comments on the way for these patches
14:07:21 <zhiyuan> I have just submitted a patch for the vxlan network doc and release notes: https://review.openstack.org/448524
14:08:11 <joehuang> thank you, zhiyuan, this is what we just need to have pike-1 release
14:10:39 <joehuang> ok, will talk to Victor after he is online if he need to do more review for the first 3 patches
14:11:29 <joehuang> how about other patches which target at pike-1 is still in review
14:12:39 <joehuang> as far as I know, QoS spec is still in review
14:14:01 <zhiyuan> there are three features: qos spec, wsgi deployment and multi-region job
14:14:22 <zhiyuan> I have voted +2 for the second and third one
14:15:07 <joehuang> ok, for wsgi and multi-region, need to consult victor, whether he need more time to review
14:15:56 <joehuang> For Qos spec, several rounds review may be needed
14:16:00 <zhiyuan> qos spec was updated this afternoon. I will check it tomorrow morning
14:16:09 <joehuang> good
14:17:26 <longxiongqiu> thinks zhiyuan. :)
14:17:55 <RongHui11> thank you zhiyuan
14:18:15 <joehuang> #topic Pike-1 release
14:19:41 <joehuang> consider that there are still several patches in review, and our milestone is ahead of Neutron pike-1, how about to postpone the milestone pike-1, we need to include VxLAN features
14:21:12 <joehuang> as tricircle is cycle-with-intermediary project
14:21:13 <zhiyuan> postpone to the end of this month?
14:21:35 <joehuang> it's not date based milestone, but feature based milestone
14:22:11 <joehuang> I think it's ok, Neutron's pike is in early of Apirl
14:23:02 <joehuang> It's Apr.10 ~ Apr.14
14:23:52 <joehuang> what's your proposal for milestone pike-1 reschedule?
14:24:33 <zhiyuan> I think the end of this month is fine. So we can have enough time to review the qos spec and my change for the doc
14:25:23 <electrocucaracha> #info electrocucaracha
14:25:31 <joehuang> hello, victor, morning
14:25:57 <electrocucaracha> hey good morning joehuang
14:26:16 <zhiyuan> morning victor
14:26:22 <joehuang> we are talking about whether to postpone pike-1
14:26:22 <electrocucaracha> hey zhiyuan
14:26:33 <joehuang> consider that there are still several patches in review, and our milestone is ahead of Neutron pike-1, how about to
14:26:36 <joehuang> postpone the milestone pike-1, we need to include VxLAN features
14:26:42 <joehuang> as tricircle is cycle-with-intermediary project
14:26:53 <joehuang> it's not date based milestone, but feature based milestone
14:27:46 <joehuang> zhiyuan's proposal is " the end of this month "
14:28:23 <electrocucaracha> basically all depends on reviews instead of coding right?
14:28:56 <electrocucaracha> I mean, the patches has been submitted and it's only matter of doing reviews to complete them
14:28:57 <joehuang> yes, and also want to know do you need more time to review these patches, there 5 patches got zhiyuan's or mine +2
14:29:06 <joehuang> yes
14:29:25 <joehuang> for patches target at pike-1
14:29:29 <electrocucaracha> yes, sounds reasonable
14:30:21 <joehuang> so let's postpone the pike-1 to Mar.31
14:30:51 <joehuang> and for tricircle-client, could submit a patch to make a release
14:31:18 <electrocucaracha> yes, I'm going to consult to dasm how do it
14:31:29 <dasm> electrocucaracha: ack. i can assist you with that
14:31:45 <joehuang> I know how to do that
14:31:48 <joehuang> one second
14:31:52 * dasm is neutron release liaison :)
14:32:16 <joehuang> ok
14:32:29 <joehuang> just like this one https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432166/
14:32:49 <electrocucaracha> princenana and sindhu are adding more UTs to the client, that will give us more stabiliy
14:32:56 <joehuang> submit a patch in release repository
14:33:04 <joehuang> ok, we can wait for that
14:33:36 <joehuang> after these patches are merged, then I can do the release work for tricircle-client
14:33:53 <joehuang> #info pike-1 postponed to Mar.31
14:34:15 <joehuang> #info add more UT for tricircle-client to make it more stable
14:34:20 <dasm> joehuang: fyi. pie1 is Apr 10-Apr 14
14:34:25 <dasm> https://releases.openstack.org/pike/schedule.html
14:34:27 <dasm> *pike1
14:34:55 <dasm> so, you're not even postponing, but you're planning to release it earlier
14:35:14 <joehuang> yes, but tricircle released a little early, should we make it being aligned to Neutron
14:35:19 <dasm> joehuang: ack
14:35:45 <joehuang> tricircle is cycle-with-intermediary
14:35:54 <joehuang> but not cycle-with-milestone
14:37:07 <joehuang> we planned to release pike-1 tomorrow, from our plan, it's "postpone" :)
14:38:08 <joehuang> more comment on the release plan?
14:38:50 <joehuang> sorry, I missed some information
14:39:28 <joehuang> electrocucaracha said he can do release, and dasm can assist electrocucaracha
14:39:44 <joehuang> my fault, I did not catch this information
14:40:06 <joehuang> so, electrocucaracha, I am pleased that you can do the release work
14:40:28 <electrocucaracha> joehuang: sure no problem
14:40:48 <electrocucaracha> sindhu, dasm and I are in the same office
14:41:00 <joehuang> that's great!
14:41:42 <joehuang> I am so sorry that I just made a fault
14:42:13 <joehuang> thank you electrocucaracha and dasm, sindhu :)
14:42:52 <joehuang> #info electrocucaracha to release tricircle-client
14:43:28 <joehuang> next topic
14:43:36 <joehuang> #topic Demo and talk of VNF high availability across OpenStack with Tricircle in OPNFV Beijing summit
14:43:42 <joehuang> hello
14:44:20 <joehuang> for the demo, there is one video conferrence APP is recommended
14:44:37 <joehuang> to do the high availability across OpenStack cloud
14:45:02 <joehuang> with the help by Tricircle
14:45:15 <sindhu> joehuang: hi :)
14:45:22 <joehuang> hi, sindhu
14:45:29 <joehuang> nice to meet you here
14:45:34 <sindhu> joehuang: sorry for joining in late
14:46:01 <joehuang> always welcome
14:46:56 <joehuang> I will discuss with the committers in OPNFV in more detail about the demo
14:46:56 <sindhu> thank u :)
14:47:05 <joehuang> and will share information here
14:47:19 <joehuang> and discuss topics as needed
14:48:20 <joehuang> And also planned to submit a presentation in OPNFV beijing summit together with Victor
14:48:52 <joehuang> victor proposed to use the title ¡°Shared networks to support VNF High Availability across OpenStack Multi Region deployment¡±
14:49:12 <joehuang> your comments?
14:49:26 <joehuang> and more presentations to submit?
14:49:59 <zhiyuan> good titile
14:51:04 <joehuang> thank you zhiyuan
14:51:32 <joehuang> if no more comments, then it's time for open discussion
14:51:41 <joehuang> #topic open discussion
14:51:57 <joehuang> any other topic to be discussed
14:52:27 <electrocucaracha> well, yesterday I saw a patch for removing log translations
14:52:49 <electrocucaracha> apparently there is an effort from i18n team to remove that information
14:52:55 <joehuang> yes, it's good idea to remove log translation
14:53:00 <electrocucaracha> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/448162/
14:53:19 <joehuang> it's hard to do maintainnce using translated info :)
14:53:30 <joehuang> +1, will review that
14:53:56 <joehuang> and I also submitted a spec for east-west networking enhancement
14:54:02 <joehuang> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/448359/
14:55:33 <joehuang> please review the enhancement, it'll make it more flexible on networking demands
14:55:52 <electrocucaracha> ack
14:55:54 <zhiyuan> Shall we also create a patch to remove log translations in tricircle?
14:55:57 <princenana> ok
14:56:24 <joehuang> already some patches submitted in tricircle for log translation
14:56:47 <zhiyuan> i see
14:57:38 <joehuang> ok, if no other topics, we may end the meeting
14:57:52 <joehuang> think you for attending the meeting
14:58:24 <joehuang> /s/think/thank
14:58:29 <electrocucaracha> fyi, we won't be able to attend the summit
14:58:36 <electrocucaracha> :'(
14:58:47 <joehuang> electrocucaracha, a little pity
14:59:28 <joehuang> I think whether I can fly to Austin to meet with you
15:00:08 <electrocucaracha> that will be nice, at least you'll have the opportunity to meet all OSIC
15:00:15 <joehuang> yes
15:00:26 <joehuang> discuss offline
15:00:35 <joehuang> #endmeeting