01:01:04 <joehuang> #startmeeting tricircle
01:01:05 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Jun 21 01:01:04 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is joehuang. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
01:01:06 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
01:01:08 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tricircle'
01:01:23 <joehuang> #topic rollcall
01:01:28 <joehuang> #info  joehuang
01:01:30 <dongfeng> #info dongfeng
01:01:41 <Yipei> #info Yipei
01:01:42 <yinxiulin> #info xiulin
01:02:08 <zhiyuan> #info zhiyuan
01:02:13 <fredli__> Hi all, I am Liyongle
01:02:25 <joehuang> hello, fred, welcome to join
01:03:08 <joehuang> #topic summary of tricircle demo in OPNFV summit
01:03:22 <joehuang> before the summary of the summit
01:03:37 <joehuang> one info about storyboard
01:04:13 <joehuang> the launchpad will be switched to storyboard in recent future
01:04:41 <joehuang> so please try storyboard and community is collecting feedback
01:05:01 <joehuang> https://storyboard.openstack.org
01:05:32 <joehuang> the migration has not been started yet, but we have to be prepared for this
01:05:52 <joehuang> that means all blueprint and bug management will be migrated to storyboard
01:06:21 <joehuang> #info feedback for the storyboard https://storyboard.openstack.org
01:06:54 <rongHui> #info Ronghui
01:07:05 <joehuang> for opnfv tricircle demo, it's quite successful
01:07:08 <diablo_rojo_phon> As soon as I get the okay from you I can set a date to migrate Tricircle.
01:07:42 <joehuang> to diablo_rojo_phon: ok, will let you know when we are ready
01:08:02 <joehuang> shall we submit a patch to open a space for Tricircle in storyboard?
01:08:34 <zhiyuan> feedback from me: storyboard is convenient for tracking blueprint, since we can create several tasks for one blueprint.
01:09:09 <zhiyuan> in launchpad, we have to put the tasks in the single white board
01:10:39 <joehuang> ok, I'll dive into storyboard in more detail and check to see if a patch is needed for tricircle
01:11:28 <joehuang> for the opnfv tricricle demo, video and slides are available
01:12:11 <joehuang> #info opnfv tricircle and demo video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbcc7-eZnkY
01:12:43 <joehuang> #info slides is available here  https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1WBdra-ZaiB-K8_m3Pv76o_jhylEqJXTTxzEZ-cu8u2A/
01:13:19 <joehuang> and video conference demo is recorded at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nK1nWnH45gI
01:13:50 <joehuang> BoucherV will record vIMS video this week, once the link is available I'll share to you
01:14:20 <joehuang> there are several groups showed interest to integrate tricircle in OPNFV
01:15:05 <joehuang> and several guys told me they would like to contribute in tricircle, hope that they will join soon
01:15:42 <joehuang> that's the major info from tricircle demo in OPNFV summit
01:15:54 <joehuang> any questions
01:17:32 <joehuang> ok, next topic
01:17:39 <joehuang> #topic feature implementation review
01:18:13 <joehuang> before the feature implementation discussion, the milestone 3 of pike will be July 28
01:18:31 <joehuang> #info milestone 3 on July 28
01:18:59 <joehuang> so if you want your features to be landed, please submit your patch ASAP
01:19:45 <joehuang> please share your feature implementation and challenge to be discussed here
01:20:40 <dongfeng> for me, 1) a patch for resource routing pagination has been committed.  2) job cli feature is under development.
01:21:45 <Yipei> for labs, have some problems with plugging vip via the AmphoraAPIClient. it responses with 500 status code. still working on it
01:21:52 <joehuang> thanks dongfeng, will review the patch soon
01:21:59 <zhiyuan> oh, I see "merge conflict" for the resource routing pagination patch
01:22:06 <dongfeng> en,
01:22:16 <Yipei> s/labs/lbaas
01:22:17 <dongfeng> I base this patch on your previous patch
01:23:15 <zhiyuan> to dongfeng, rebasing is needed I think
01:23:22 <dongfeng> ok
01:23:45 <dongfeng> local repo has been rebased, I am waitting your comment and then update the next version
01:24:00 <zhiyuan> i see
01:24:16 <joehuang> ok
01:24:30 <joehuang> for Tricircle can work with cells v2 now
01:25:19 <yinxiulin> i'am modify sfc's patch according to yesterday's discussion
01:25:38 <joehuang> it's good to update the term of "cross OpenStack L2 network" to "cross Neutron L2 network", can someone help to update this in all document?
01:26:13 <Yipei> to joehuang, i would like to do it
01:26:13 <dongfeng> it's easy, I can do it.
01:26:18 <dongfeng> oh
01:26:37 <dongfeng> got it.
01:26:39 <joehuang> ok, please submit a patch, because Nova support cells V2 in pike
01:26:52 <ubuntu_> for Qos, we will update all the patch today and submit the last patch ASAP
01:27:09 <joehuang> if Tricricle can support cells V2 in networking side, it'll bring lots of value to cloud operators
01:28:16 <ubuntu_> and metering spec has passed the test, so other guys can continue to review
01:28:46 <zhiyuan> to ronghui, since you are going to update all the patches, please change to title of the patches to reflect to correct order. in fact, the current part2 needs to be merged first
01:29:01 <zhiyuan> s/to correct/the correct
01:29:32 <ubuntu_> ok  just like we talk before
01:30:12 <ubuntu_> part 2 is the base
01:30:31 <zhiyuan> does QoS require some special configuration to make it work?
01:30:38 <joehuang> part 2 is the base? are you using  reverse order
01:31:12 <zhiyuan> if so, we need to document them
01:31:38 <ubuntu_> to zhiyuan: just like openstack qos configuration
01:31:42 <joehuang> yes, documentation for the guide is need
01:31:55 <fredli__> ubuntu_: have you responded all the comments zhiyuan
01:32:36 <ronghui> yes
01:33:05 <ronghui> to joe: yes
01:33:05 <zhiyuan> to fred, yes, we have discussed the patch in the review page yesterday afternoon
01:33:19 <ronghui> part 2 is the base
01:33:30 <zhiyuan> so I am waiting for the update
01:33:46 <ronghui> we need to adjust the order of merge
01:34:56 <ronghui> Xiongqiu is try to update the patch and solve the problem you submit and will update the patch today
01:35:27 <joehuang> who is updating the patch, I am confused
01:35:48 <ronghui> Xiongqiu
01:36:20 <joehuang> ok, hope that xiongqiu can talk to us directly
01:36:48 <ronghui> there is some problem with his network
01:36:49 <joehuang> seems that we have reviewed all features in queue, next topic
01:36:58 <joehuang> ok, I see
01:37:10 <joehuang> #topic open discussion
01:37:26 <joehuang> any topic to discuss
01:37:46 <fredli__> nothing more from my side.
01:38:05 <joehuang> one topic from mine is tricircle integration support
01:39:23 <joehuang> just as what I mentioned in the first topic, there are several installer showed interest to integrate tricircle, and Vikram also said whether it's possible to integrate Tricricle with OVN
01:40:14 <joehuang> so if there are lots of integration, some one may ask help, how can we help?
01:42:36 <zhiyuan> firstly I think we need to investigate that if it's easy to integrate Tricircle with other components. Is there any required patches to be implemented for that intergration.
01:43:12 <fredli__> what actions do we need to do if we support?
01:43:32 <joehuang> currently passive reaction is good enough I think
01:43:52 <fredli__> is it possible to provide one document/script so that partners can do it by themselves?
01:43:59 <zhiyuan> as I know, if the component is not using l2pop, we need some works to support sdn/l2 gateway mode for vxlan networking
01:44:21 <zhiyuan> this part is not tested
01:45:01 <joehuang> for OVN if it can recognize the shadow agent/port, I think it can deal with itself
01:46:19 <joehuang> and seems that cells V2 also have its own devstack plugin for multi-cells installation
01:47:16 <joehuang> Tricricle plugin multi-cells installation may not work well with cells V2 multi-cell installation, though function works
01:47:24 <zhiyuan> that script has been already merged? if so, we can write our own script to integrate cell V2 based on that script
01:47:38 <joehuang> only use Tricricle plugin?
01:48:13 <joehuang> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/436094/
01:48:37 <zhiyuan> I am thinking that cell V2 script may provide some functions that we can call
01:48:55 <joehuang> not merged yet, but I am sure it'll merge soon
01:49:38 <zhiyuan> ah, lib/nova is updated in that patch
01:49:48 <joehuang> so except feature implementation, lots of engineering work is needed after more and more integration will be done, and bugs will be reported
01:52:42 <joehuang> tricricle provides documentation for installation/configuration/networking, https://docs.openstack.org/developer/tricircle/
01:53:05 <joehuang> have you found that it's not clear enough? does it work according to the guide?
01:53:15 <joehuang> what's missing in the guide?
01:53:48 <joehuang> I remembered that the transport URL configuration is missing in configuration or manual installation guide
01:54:40 <joehuang> #link https://docs.openstack.org/developer/tricircle/configuration.html#common-options
01:54:48 <joehuang> could some one update this guide
01:55:05 <zhiyuan> in the configuration guide, we just mention that "Logging, messaging, database, keystonemiddleware etc configuration which are generated from OpenStack Oslo library, will not be described here"
01:55:42 <zhiyuan> so transport URL is not covered in the guide
01:56:26 <joehuang> ok
01:56:59 <zhiyuan> transport_url is discussed in the manual installation guide
01:57:14 <joehuang> ok, any other topic?
01:57:23 <zhiyuan> no from me
01:57:26 <dongfeng> no from me
01:57:37 <Yipei> no for me
01:57:45 <ronghui> no for me
01:57:57 <fredli__> good
01:58:15 <joehuang> ok, thank you for attending the meeting
01:58:18 <joehuang> #endmeeting