01:01:02 <joehuang> #startmeeting tricircle
01:01:03 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Jul  5 01:01:02 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is joehuang. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
01:01:04 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
01:01:06 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tricircle'
01:01:16 <joehuang> #topic rollcall
01:01:25 <joehuang> #info joehuang
01:01:35 <Yipei> #info Yipei
01:01:51 <yinxiulin> info xiulin
01:02:10 <zhiyuan> #info zhiyuan
01:02:26 <dongfeng> #info dongfeng
01:02:45 <joehuang> #topic feature implementation
01:03:37 <xuzhuang> #info xuzhuang
01:03:41 <joehuang> let's look at feature implementation which wants to land in pike-3
01:04:42 <zhiyuan> I am working on improving our smoke test, I propose to use YAML to define our tests. here is the spec: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/479752
01:05:14 <joehuang> good to know the smoke test improvement is on the way
01:05:28 <joehuang> could you please register a BP in launchpad too?
01:05:38 <xuzhuang> I have completed job paginate_query, and I am working  on doing some tests
01:05:49 <RonghUI> hello
01:05:57 <joehuang> for pagination query, a BP is also welcome
01:06:00 <joehuang> hi ronghui
01:06:00 <zhiyuan> two implementation patches based on this idea: https://review.openstack.org/477500 and https://review.openstack.org/480051
01:06:16 <zhiyuan> to joe, so still on launchpad?
01:06:50 <Yipei> trying implementing LBaaS in multiple regions and importing external network
01:07:01 <joehuang> at least now, we haven't migrate to storyboard yet
01:07:38 <joehuang> to yipei, thank you very much, hope that LBaaS and external network importing could be landed in pike
01:07:48 <dongfeng> I think resource routing pagination feature can be landed in pike 3.
01:07:56 <zhiyuan> ok, will register a BP on launchpad
01:08:03 <Yipei> yes, i hope so, i try my best to make it
01:08:16 <joehuang> I am very busy these days, will try to review patches AFAP
01:08:54 <yinxiulin> sfc's update patch may be be landed in pike 3
01:10:43 <joehuang> seems that everything fine :)
01:11:02 <joehuang> #topic open discussion
01:11:14 <joehuang> any topic to be discussed?
01:11:38 <dongfeng> no from me
01:11:43 <RonghUI> no
01:11:54 <Yipei> no from me
01:12:04 <yinxiulin> no for me
01:12:12 <xuzhuang> no from me
01:12:30 <joehuang> to xuzhuang, thank you for the pagination patch
01:12:43 <joehuang> could you register a BP too?
01:12:48 <zhiyuan> to Ronghui, has Xiongqiu tested his three patches? if so, I would like to try them out in my own environment
01:13:18 <RonghUI> his has tested his patches
01:13:26 <joehuang> patch1 and patch2 should be merged for testing coverage, isn't it?
01:13:46 <xuzhuang> you mean job pagination also needs a bp?
01:14:51 <joehuang> job pagination is another patch, but not the patch for resource routing?
01:14:54 <RonghUI> if you say the two patches merge into one patch and tested it, no for this situation
01:15:12 <zhiyuan> patch2 has been changed to use driver to implement, but I don't see code to load the driver
01:15:34 <xuzhuang> yes, two independent patches
01:16:16 <RonghUI> yes we try to fix it
01:16:41 <zhiyuan> we need to merget the three patches, otherwise the feature is not complete
01:16:47 <zhiyuan> s/merget/merge
01:17:28 <joehuang> to xuzhuang, ok. then no BP is needed, but the API documentation update is needed, to describe in detail how the API will function
01:17:36 <RonghUI> yes next version, the two patches will merge into one patch
01:17:56 <xuzhuang> ok, got it
01:19:19 <joehuang> please review the smoke test spec, all new features should be added and tested with its own smoke test cases, so the spec is important for all
01:19:42 <RonghUI> ok
01:20:10 <joehuang> without smoke test cases, the feature quality has no guarantee.
01:20:32 <xuzhuang> ok
01:20:40 <dongfeng> ok
01:20:43 <zhiyuan> yeah, would like to hear your opinion whether the design of the YAML schema is reasonable
01:20:47 <RonghUI> ok
01:20:49 <Yipei> ok, got it
01:21:44 <joehuang> because smoke test will test the system on living two region openstack together tricircle, so only such an real environment can make sure the feature work.
01:22:55 <joehuang> passing smoke test is basic requirement for all features, though it comes later, but we need to make it become the gate for all features.
01:23:24 <joehuang> other topic?
01:23:30 <RonghUI> no for me
01:23:33 <dongfeng> no for me
01:23:42 <zhiyuan> the YAML file is also usable for your local test during feature development, you can write a YAML then run it to test your feature, no need to type the long command again and again
01:23:55 <zhiyuan> no for me
01:24:04 <Yipei> no for me
01:24:12 <xuzhuang> no for me
01:25:02 <joehuang> ok, if there is no other topic, we can end the meeting a little early, and continue discussion in #openstack-tricircle if needed
01:25:10 <joehuang> #endmeeting