14:01:04 <weshay> #startmeeting tripleo
14:01:05 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Nov 26 14:01:04 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is weshay. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:01:06 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:01:09 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tripleo'
14:01:14 <weshay> #topic agenda
14:01:15 <weshay> * Review past action items
14:01:15 <weshay> * One off agenda items
14:01:15 <weshay> * Squad status
14:01:15 <weshay> * Bugs & Blueprints
14:01:15 <weshay> * Projects releases or stable backports
14:01:17 <weshay> * Specs
14:01:19 <weshay> * open discussion
14:01:21 <weshay> Anyone can use the #link, #action and #info commands, not just the moderatorǃ
14:01:23 <weshay> Hey folks! who's around?
14:01:24 <d0ugal> \o/
14:01:25 <weshay> howdy folks
14:01:29 <weshay> put your hands in the aIr
14:01:34 <fultonj> o/
14:01:38 <marios|ruck> \o
14:02:03 <weshay> 0/ 0/ \0 \0
14:02:07 <ccamacho> hola!
14:02:14 <tkajinam> o/
14:02:18 <leanderthal> o/
14:02:20 <rlandy> o/
14:02:58 <beagles> o/
14:03:21 <weshay> #topic review past action items
14:03:39 <weshay> ykarel, going to revisit your agenda item from last week
14:03:48 <weshay> will do so in a minute
14:03:52 <ykarel> ack
14:04:16 <weshay> #topic one off agenda items
14:04:16 <weshay> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-meeting-items
14:04:31 <weshay> mr. fultonj
14:04:32 <weshay> (fultonj) Multiple External Ceph Blueprint
14:04:32 <weshay> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/tripleo/+spec/multiple-external-ceph (seeking approval for U)
14:04:32 <weshay> (fultonj) Split Control Plane Glance Cache (seeking approval for U)
14:04:32 <weshay> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/tripleo/+spec/split-controlplane-glance-cache
14:04:34 <weshay> related to this blueprint, will be running haproxy on edge nodes without pacemaker
14:04:37 <jfrancoa> o/
14:04:46 <weshay> let's start w/  (fultonj) Multiple External Ceph Blueprint
14:04:57 <fultonj> yes, may i please have these blueprints approved and targetted for U ?
14:05:25 <weshay> fultonj, is looking for approval on the blueprints... I've reviewed both. +2 from me
14:05:30 <fultonj> gfidente: abishop_: (fyi) ^
14:05:32 <fultonj> thanks weshay
14:05:43 <weshay> mwhahaha, EmilienM any input?
14:05:59 <mwhahaha> nope
14:06:00 <chkumar|rover> \o/
14:06:07 <mwhahaha> fultonj: what's the deal with the ssh bits in ceph-ansible?
14:06:12 * mwhahaha recalls seeing something on the ML
14:06:35 <fultonj> ssh bits in ceph-ansible?
14:07:06 <fultonj> mwhahaha: on openstack-disucss?
14:07:08 <mwhahaha> i think it was brought up in the kolla thread
14:07:09 <mwhahaha> yea
14:07:24 <mwhahaha> from ajeager
14:07:36 <mwhahaha> I suggest to talk with the Ceph community before spending more work
14:07:36 <mwhahaha> here. ceph-ansible is getting replaced in March by "SSH orchestrator", see
14:07:36 <mwhahaha> https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1JpcETNXpuB1JEuhX_c8xtgNnv0gJhSaQUffM7aRjUek/edit#slide=id.g78e5cb0e10_0_0
14:07:37 <openstackgerrit> Bogdan Dobrelya (bogdando) proposed openstack/tripleo-quickstart-extras master: Fix indentation for the rendered launcher-playbook  https://review.opendev.org/696091
14:08:12 <weshay> chkumar|rover, fyi ^ that may impact 3rd party dep testing
14:08:15 <fultonj> first i've heard of it
14:08:30 <fultonj> replaced?
14:08:31 <weshay> same
14:08:38 <mwhahaha> right, that's why i asked
14:08:40 <gfidente> thanks fultonj
14:08:56 <fultonj> is this k8s only?
14:09:12 <weshay> ok.. going to move on to ykarel's topic
14:09:23 <openstackgerrit> Ronelle Landy proposed openstack/tripleo-ci master: Add ironic-python-agent-builder to the dib elements path  https://review.opendev.org/695575
14:09:23 <weshay> (ykarel/weshay) Tag releases for TripleO stein, any plan?
14:09:24 <weshay> Last tag releases were 2 months ago https://review.opendev.org/#/c/681098/
14:09:24 <weshay> Commit diff example for tht:- https://github.com/openstack/tripleo-heat-templates/compare/10.6.1...stable/stein
14:09:40 <weshay> ykarel, can summarize while we have a crowd
14:10:01 <ykarel> don't we have periodic releases?
14:10:08 <mwhahaha> only if you do them
14:10:09 <ykarel> like last release was 2 months ago
14:10:11 <mwhahaha> they aren't automated
14:10:14 <mwhahaha> so if you want one, propose it
14:10:25 <mwhahaha> EmilienM was doing it because of the kindness in his heart
14:10:29 <mwhahaha> which we've killed
14:10:30 <fultonj> more work here...
14:10:34 <ykarel> :)
14:10:34 <fultonj> wait...
14:10:34 <mwhahaha> so if you want one, propose it
14:10:50 <fultonj> we need this in U either way
14:10:59 <mwhahaha> fultonj: what is U?
14:11:07 <ykarel> sure will do it, but i think releases needs to be done for other tripleo repos as well
14:11:07 <mwhahaha> er what is 'this'
14:11:13 <ykarel> as they are related
14:11:18 <ykarel> like puppet-triple, tht
14:11:20 <fultonj> ussuri
14:11:21 <ykarel> i mainly need for tht
14:11:36 <openstackgerrit> Brent Eagles proposed openstack/tripleo-ci master: Adds a scenario 10 to run tests with OVN provider  https://review.opendev.org/696092
14:11:49 <mwhahaha> fultonj: yea i know what is U (brain no worky), what is the 'this' you were refering to
14:12:04 <fultonj> the blueprint..
14:12:10 <weshay> k.. I'll sync up w/ EmilienM and ykarel and get something going.. fyi
14:12:11 <fultonj> the 1st topic
14:12:20 <mwhahaha> ok sure, i don't see anything wrong with that
14:12:29 <ykarel> Thanks weshay
14:12:36 <fultonj> i'd like to get this feature in U
14:12:56 <fultonj> so i don't want to block the blueprint because of that slide deck
14:13:01 <fultonj> but i will look into it
14:13:12 <mwhahaha> i don't think they are related, just wanted to raise if we had more work to do
14:13:13 <fultonj> ceph will be commited to ceph-ansible for sometime
14:13:19 <fultonj> mwhahaha: ok, thanks
14:13:20 <weshay> chkumar|rover, ^ perhaps we need to chat w/ the ceph folks as well
14:13:25 <fultonj> i will
14:13:27 <weshay> maybe w/ fultonj
14:13:49 <weshay> ok..
14:14:11 <fultonj> thanks
14:14:11 <weshay> #topic Squad status
14:14:11 <weshay> ci
14:14:12 <weshay> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-ci-squad-meeting
14:14:12 <weshay> upgrade
14:14:12 <weshay> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-upgrade-squad-status
14:14:12 <weshay> edge
14:14:14 <weshay> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-edge-squad-status
14:14:16 <weshay> integration
14:14:18 <weshay> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-integration-squad-status
14:14:20 <weshay> validations
14:14:22 <weshay> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-validations-squad-status
14:14:24 <weshay> networking
14:14:26 <weshay> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-networking-squad-status
14:14:28 <weshay> transformation
14:14:30 <weshay> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-ansible-agenda
14:14:34 <weshay> Any squad wanting to bring up their status, or a topic for the general public?
14:14:36 <weshay> Anybody want to highlight anything?
14:14:52 <weshay> I would like to thank that upgrades squad for attacking and fixing the updates and upgrades for Train!!  Well done
14:15:45 <weshay> Any mistral removal folks want to highlight anything? d0ugal apetrich cloudnull lhinds ?
14:16:23 <weshay> anything from the transformation squad?
14:17:31 <weshay> Ok... fine then...  from the CI-Squad..   We are running tests against vexxhost to ensure its a stable platform and meets perf specs
14:17:59 <weshay> that work will be on-going and we'll signal when periodic or check jobs start to move to vex
14:18:13 <gfidente> weshay fultonj but yeah ssh orchestrator is rook/k8s based
14:18:21 <fultonj> exactly
14:18:24 <fultonj> i read it more
14:18:27 <weshay> refreshing the goal:  stable third party platform to allow 3rd party to -2 your patches :)
14:18:27 <fultonj> this is the k8s thing
14:18:44 <gfidente> weshay fultonj I might have missed to add a topic but was curious now that we can do rpm builds for ceph-ansible PRs
14:19:04 <weshay> chkumar|rover, probably has the most recent context there ^
14:19:09 <gfidente> I think we still miss the actual job configuration (like scenario004) to be able to consume the generated RPM?
14:19:17 <weshay> I think arxcruz just sent an email about that
14:19:30 <gfidente> ok sorry, don' want to derail the conversation, will look for that
14:19:48 <weshay> np... gfidente your point guys are arxcruz and chkumar|rover
14:20:01 <arxcruz> all the pieces are in place
14:20:14 <arxcruz> we are building rpm with check-rdo comment on the PR
14:20:19 <gfidente> arxcruz right
14:20:21 <gfidente> check-rdo
14:20:28 <arxcruz> it's failing though
14:20:38 <gfidente> then we need to trigger a job like scenario004 and make it consume the RPM right?
14:20:44 <gfidente> I mean that bit still needs to be "done"
14:20:45 <arxcruz> gfidente: exactly
14:20:47 <gfidente> cool
14:20:56 <gfidente> thanks guys
14:20:56 <arxcruz> just comment check-rdo on the pr
14:21:04 <weshay> :)
14:21:26 <weshay> last change for squad status..  I will be calling folks out for squad status in the future
14:21:29 <arxcruz> once the error goes off, we can enable automatically
14:21:58 <gfidente> arxcruz /me unsure about enabling automatically still, we can discuss this later
14:22:10 <arxcruz> sure, just saying the option is there :)
14:22:40 <weshay> aye.. better to see it working in practice for a while before addressing that ci kicking automatically
14:22:42 <weshay> ok
14:22:45 <slagle> mschuppert: for https://review.opendev.org/#/c/695805/ now, you won't have any data from the existing stack in all_nodes, as it will all get overwritten by what's from all_nodes_extra_map_data
14:22:49 <slagle> mschuppert: is that what you expect?
14:22:50 <weshay> thanks arxcruz gfidente  :)
14:23:01 <weshay> in a mtg atm
14:23:04 <weshay> #topic bugs & blueprints
14:23:05 <apetrich> sorry. no weshay not much news for mistral today
14:23:10 <weshay> apetrich, k
14:23:12 <weshay> thanks
14:23:26 <weshay> #link https://launchpad.net/tripleo/+milestone/ussuri-1
14:23:27 <weshay> ( note ) Check https://launchpad.net/tripleo/ussuri for the current counts
14:23:27 <weshay> Bugs targeted: 5 New, 21 Incomplete, 14 Invalid, 6 Confirmed, 376 Triaged, 116 In Progress, 2 Fix Committed, 120 Fix Released
14:23:41 <weshay> Storyboard bugs.
14:23:41 <weshay> #link https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/project_group/76
14:23:41 <weshay> Blueprints targeted: 1 Unknown, 1 Not started, 1 Started, 1 Good progress
14:24:14 <weshay> few more will be added by fulton :)
14:24:33 <weshay> FYI.. https://review.opendev.org/#/c/693933/  we're setting a deadline of Dec 6th for feedback
14:24:46 <weshay> re: tripleo-operator-ansible
14:25:01 <mschuppert> slagle: keys from all_nodes_extra_map_dat should overwrite existing keys from all_nodes, but additional keys from all_nodes should be still there
14:25:18 <weshay> any questions / concerns about that deadline?
14:25:36 <weshay> k...
14:25:41 <weshay> FYI...
14:25:42 <weshay> Latest Registered Blueprints:
14:25:42 <weshay> Ansible roles and modules to interact with TripleO
14:25:42 <weshay> Registered on 2019-11-12
14:25:42 <weshay> Pattern to safely spawn a container from a container
14:25:42 <weshay> Registered on 2019-11-11
14:25:44 <weshay> Multiple External Ceph Support
14:25:46 <weshay> Registered on 2019-09-11
14:25:48 <weshay> Replace Mistral with Ansible
14:25:50 <weshay> Registered on 2019-08-15
14:25:52 <weshay> Remove Puppet
14:25:54 <weshay> Registered on 2019-07-18
14:25:58 <weshay> moving on
14:26:01 <weshay> #topic projects releases or stable backports
14:26:13 <weshay> #topic specs
14:26:13 <weshay> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/tripleo-specs+status:open
14:26:36 <weshay> any new specs or changes one would like to raise?
14:26:51 <weshay> moving on
14:27:01 <weshay> #topic open discussion
14:27:01 <weshay> Anything else that folks want to bring up to the meeting?
14:27:13 <weshay> free for all
14:27:40 <weshay> so shy
14:27:48 <weshay> #endmeeting tripleo