18:01:50 <SlickNik> #startmeeting trove
18:01:50 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Sep  9 18:01:50 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is SlickNik. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
18:01:51 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
18:01:53 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'trove'
18:01:53 <SlickNik> there we go :)
18:01:58 <ashleigh> yay.
18:02:00 <peterstac> hi all
18:02:12 <SlickNik> hello all!
18:02:23 <SlickNik> giving folks a couple of minutes to trickle in.
18:03:01 <dloi> o/
18:03:02 <vgnbkr> o/
18:03:11 <schang> o/
18:03:13 <cp16net> hello everyone
18:03:32 <SlickNik> Meeting agenda at:
18:03:35 <SlickNik> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/TroveMeeting#Trove_Meeting.2C_Sept_9.2C_2015
18:05:28 <SlickNik> #topic Trove pulse update
18:05:43 <SlickNik> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/trove-pulse-update
18:06:57 <SlickNik> Lots more reviews last week — awesome, given that it was the week of the Liberty-3 cut when we had to get our Liberty-3 features merged.
18:08:43 <SlickNik> We did run into all sorts of gate issues this week — including changes to the nova-API which caused our gate to break.
18:09:49 <amrith> SlickNik, we had some discussions about the pulse update at mid-cycle. I had an action item to catch you up on that ahead of this meeting and I just realized that I didn't follow up on that. Will find notes on that conversation and send you links.
18:10:38 <SlickNik> amrith: sounds good — will follow up with you regarding it after the meeting.
18:11:33 <SlickNik> Any other questions regarding reviews?
18:12:28 <SlickNik> In not let's move to taking a look at the current state of Liberty (RC1)
18:12:53 <SlickNik> #topic State of Liberty (RC1)
18:13:06 <SlickNik> #link https://launchpad.net/trove/+milestone/liberty-rc1
18:14:18 <SlickNik> Good news is that all of the reviews relating to the Feature Freeze Exceptions that we've had to take have now merged at this point.
18:14:44 <cp16net> i just want to say awesome job across the board from everyone that it doesnt look like we have any issues with trove master after all the merges we did
18:15:15 <amrith> SlickNik, I do have a concern about the horizon changes
18:15:32 <SlickNik> nice job cp16net getting the gate issues figured out.
18:15:39 <peterstac> I noticed that none of the Cassandra stuff made it in - do we still want that for Liberty?
18:15:42 <amrith> the comment says that they are -2'ed because of FF for liberty
18:15:48 <peterstac> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/TroveLibertyPriorities
18:15:53 <amrith> and will open for MickeyMouse or whatever it is called now
18:16:00 <amrith> that doesn't seem right to me
18:16:45 <peterstac> Yeah, looks like the Horizon stuff won't be in Liberty
18:17:36 <SlickNik> amrith: right now horizon is under Feature Freeze, so any new Feature related changes won't merge in Liberty.
18:18:27 <amrith> so our FFE doesn't extend to Horizon
18:18:31 <amrith> unfortunate ...
18:18:32 <SlickNik> If we want to merge a horizon change in Liberty, we need to get an exception — which means sending a FFE request on the mailing list to  the release mgmt team and david-lyle.
18:19:27 <SlickNik> amrith: Yes, the horizon PTL along with the release mgmt team manages FFEs for their project separately.
18:19:41 <amrith> ok
18:21:41 <SlickNik> So as far as the state of the current gate goes.
18:21:42 <peterstac> SlickNik, wrt Cassandra - do we want FFE's for that work?
18:22:42 <SlickNik> peterstac: speaking to the release team, we didn't specifically get FFEs for those changes. Talking to cp16net, it seemed like we were okay punting that to Mitaka.
18:23:38 <peterstac> Ok, just checking
18:24:03 <SlickNik> So we ended up moving the BPs to the M release.
18:24:49 <cp16net> we didnt have objections on that last time
18:25:24 <cp16net> unless things have changed
18:25:27 <pmalik> @SlickNik That's OK. Would be great if we could make sure it merges soon into the M-cycle...
18:26:19 <SlickNik> pmalik: When we cut RC is when M opens for check-in. So we could merge the changes as soon as we cut the Liberty RC.
18:26:34 <SlickNik> (in the next couple of weeks)
18:27:08 <pmalik> @SlickNik Sounds good. :-)
18:27:23 <SlickNik> Speaking of the Liberty RC — I've triaged the bugs that I know folks have been working on into Liberty-RC1
18:27:28 <SlickNik> #link https://launchpad.net/trove/+milestone/liberty-rc1
18:28:07 <SlickNik> If there are other bugs that you're working on for Liberty which are not in the list, please target them to RC1
18:30:37 <SlickNik> Okay, any other questions regarding RC1?
18:31:44 <SlickNik> .
18:31:51 <SlickNik> #topic Open Discussion
18:32:10 <SlickNik> Anyone have anything for open discussion?
18:32:56 <cp16net> SlickNik: we need get this patch merged https://review.openstack.org/#/c/221539/
18:34:20 <SlickNik> Yup, I'll try and reach out to the stable-branch folks as soon as this meeting is done.
18:34:37 <SlickNik> I think that's the last of the patches that are needed for the gate issues, right?
18:35:00 <cp16net> yeah then we can reenable the gate
18:35:18 <SlickNik> Hopefully we can get that merged in the next few minutes.
18:36:30 <SlickNik> Anything else?
18:37:36 <SlickNik> Alright, that's all folks!
18:37:49 <SlickNik> You can have some of your time back.
18:37:53 <SlickNik> #endmeeting