18:00:04 <amrith> #startmeeting trove
18:00:05 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Aug 31 18:00:04 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is amrith. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
18:00:07 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
18:00:09 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'trove'
18:00:14 <amrith> #agenda https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/TroveMeeting
18:00:22 <songjian> o/
18:00:36 <dougshelley66> o/
18:00:41 <spilla> o/
18:00:44 <amrith> courtesy ping for peterstac johnma dougshelley66 pmalik vgnbkr mvandijk_
18:00:52 <aliadil_> o/
18:00:53 <amrith> courtesy ping for ApsarShaik
18:00:56 <johnma> I am here amrith
18:00:59 <amrith> hello
18:01:02 <dougshelley66> mvandijk_ is off this week
18:01:08 <amrith> let's give folks a couple of minutes to get here
18:01:26 <trevormc> o/
18:03:19 <amrith> sorry, had to update the agenda page
18:03:21 <amrith> let's get going
18:03:30 <amrith> #topic action items from last week
18:03:51 <amrith> peterstac got the non voting jobs in, they don't pass yet. py35 now passes and is voting.
18:03:54 <ApsarShaik> hi
18:04:02 <amrith> also some other restructuring of tox.ini has happened.
18:04:24 <amrith> hi johnma dougshelley66 aliadil_ trevormc songjian ApsarShaik
18:04:43 <amrith> next ... ApsarShaik to follow up with mistral on bug/1607788
18:04:53 <amrith> ApsarShaik, floor is yours
18:05:00 <amrith> I see that the bug was fixed
18:05:25 <amrith> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/mistral/+bug/1607788
18:05:25 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1607788 in Mistral "Cron Trigger failed to get openstack service authenticaton" [High,Fix released] - Assigned to Shaik Apsar (sa709c)
18:05:46 <ApsarShaik> it;s fixed
18:06:07 <amrith> is that it?
18:06:30 <amrith> anything further to add
18:07:05 <amrith> .
18:07:21 <amrith> #topic Trove pulse update
18:07:29 <amrith> #link https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vJxNaoR3VVNS1Cpiz7U--1zyJRZ6ybMxzJoayrjdduo/edit?usp=sharing
18:07:35 <amrith> #link https://gist.github.com/anonymous/08011b961edeeb6a4f44386217ab6628
18:08:00 <amrith> more reviews last week (by a bit). have to keep it going because there will be more changes coming in the next few weeks
18:08:05 <amrith> as we get to the end of newton
18:08:19 <amrith> nice going trevormc!
18:08:45 <amrith> anyone have anything to add ...
18:09:21 <amrith> .
18:09:33 <trevormc> thanks amrith i'm working on getting better with reviews
18:09:42 <dougshelley66> definitely will need more review bandwidth to get thru end of newton cycle
18:09:51 <amrith> thanks for the detailed comments trevormc
18:10:11 <amrith> just a perfunctory +1 or -1 is not as valuable as the details that you are providing. so thank you!
18:10:20 <amrith> dougshelley66 ++
18:10:23 <amrith> will definitely need that
18:10:49 <amrith> to all of you who are sitting there wondering why your code isn't getting reviewed, I'd like to suggest that you review some code as well.
18:11:25 <amrith> we will need all the bandwidth we can get
18:11:34 <amrith> #topic Newton release schedule
18:11:46 <amrith> #link https://releases.openstack.org/newton/schedule.html
18:11:52 <amrith> So, this week is R-5
18:12:01 <amrith> and the client is currently at 2.5.0 and set to freeze
18:12:26 <amrith> at this point, if you have any fixes for things that must go in necessarily for newton, it is important that we get them in
18:12:48 <dougshelley66> at which milestone does master become ocata?
18:12:49 <amrith> if you have server side code that is targeted for newton, and has a client side dependency, please make sure that your code in client 2.5.0 is working as expected.
18:13:11 <amrith> dougshelley66, that should be just before R+0 if memory serves me correctly
18:13:26 <amrith> Not quite R-2, maybe R-1
18:13:29 <amrith> I don't know for sure
18:13:42 <amrith> also it happens at different times for different projects
18:13:49 <amrith> over a small period of time.
18:14:03 <amrith> at least, that's what I recall from M->N transition time.
18:14:06 <dougshelley66> ok
18:14:27 <dougshelley66> so sounds like about a month from now
18:14:30 <amrith> dougshelley66, do you want me to get a specific date; are there things you are holding for master to be created?
18:14:38 <amrith> I have some that I'm sitting on for now
18:14:44 <amrith> which I will -2/-1 till then
18:14:49 <amrith> do you have some as well?
18:15:06 <dougshelley66> no - just wondered what the timing was
18:15:11 <amrith> blueprints for trove-specs/ocata are open
18:15:14 <amrith> ok
18:15:21 <dougshelley66> good to know
18:15:30 <amrith> anything else re: release schedule?
18:15:43 <johnma> Amrith, are we talking about client changes or server changes as well
18:16:24 <johnma> I have 2 features that need to go in for newton. Should I go ahead and put in request for FFE
18:16:35 <amrith> at this point we are at feature freeze and client freeze
18:16:48 <amrith> yes, if you need ffe's please send mail to the ML
18:17:10 <johnma> amrith: ok, will do that. Thanks
18:17:30 <amrith> I will tag n-3 tomorrow.
18:18:44 <amrith> and additional 'feature' patches will land with FFE
18:18:49 <amrith> we have some of those
18:18:53 <amrith> for which client changes went in
18:19:17 <amrith> at this point, the list of FFE's I'm seeing are
18:19:22 <amrith> (just reading from the list now)
18:19:30 <amrith> trove workbook for scheduled backups
18:19:58 <amrith> quota management? doug is that FFE for newton?
18:20:38 <amrith> instance upgrade (https://review.openstack.org/326064)
18:20:54 <amrith> dougshelley66 ^^ re: https://review.openstack.org/331323
18:21:40 <amrith> peterstac, dougshelley66 https://review.openstack.org/301936
18:21:46 <amrith> johnma, you said you had two, correct?
18:22:07 <johnma> thats right amrith. configuration mangement and online backups for DB2
18:22:20 <dougshelley66> amrith those features were intended for newton
18:22:20 <amrith> ok. that is the list I'm currently tracking
18:22:28 <amrith> yes, hence the FFE
18:22:28 <dougshelley66> i think the client sides have merged
18:22:44 <amrith> yes, n-3 is tomorrow and I doubt they'll all merge by then
18:22:53 <dougshelley66> pgsql replication
18:23:02 <dougshelley66> that still seems to be stuck
18:23:09 <amrith> so if you and johnma send me a list, I'll handle them as FFE's.
18:23:26 <amrith> https://review.openstack.org/288712
18:23:29 <amrith> is that the one?
18:24:15 <amrith> johnma, is there a review for db2 backup
18:24:18 <amrith> I'm not seeing one
18:24:53 <johnma> amrith: I need to push one up. Should put one out today. have some final tests to run
18:25:04 <amrith> ok, thx
18:25:42 <dougshelley66> amrith yes
18:26:32 <amrith> dougshelley66, johnma please review https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/ZQDPrQ2aq0
18:26:55 <amrith> that's the list of 5 ffe's that I know of now, I understand that there will be a sixth for db2 backup
18:27:20 <johnma> right, I will update it as soon as I push a changeset
18:27:30 <amrith> thx johnma
18:28:23 <amrith> anything further re: n-3 and client freeze
18:28:31 <ApsarShaik> amirth
18:28:39 <amrith> yes ApsarShaik
18:29:00 <ApsarShaik> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/340022/ this patch is not needed?
18:29:19 <dougshelley66> amrith we can still merge patch sets for bugs just not blueprints, right?
18:29:29 <amrith> dougshelley66, absolutely
18:29:52 <amrith> n-3 is the deadline for 'featureful' changes. feature changes after N-3 upto RC1 with PTL approval.
18:29:58 <amrith> per https://releases.openstack.org/newton/schedule.html
18:30:05 <amrith> ApsarShaik, is that patch a feature?
18:30:10 <amrith> or a bug fix
18:30:16 <ApsarShaik> bugfix
18:30:56 <amrith> thx for adding the link for that doug
18:31:05 <amrith> I just mentioned it by name above withotu the link
18:31:13 <amrith> ApsarShaik, does that answer your question?
18:31:56 <amrith> anything further re: n-3 and client freeze?
18:32:11 <peterstac> so all those on the FFE list won't need them if they merge by Friday, right?
18:32:27 <amrith> no, friday isn't the deadline, it is thursday
18:32:39 <amrith> so if you can have them in by thursday, no ffe
18:32:44 <amrith> after thursday, ffe
18:32:49 <dougshelley66> what about dashboard changes
18:33:04 <amrith> dougshelley66, good point, I should add dashboard to my lis
18:33:06 <amrith> list
18:34:28 <dougshelley66> there are 10 dashboard patches
18:35:13 <amrith> dougshelley66, I list 5 as features and 5 as fixes
18:35:20 <amrith> no
18:35:21 <amrith> no?
18:35:58 <dougshelley66> sorry i should have qualified
18:36:09 <amrith> I just added a dump of those 10 to the etherpad
18:36:17 <amrith> pick the ones that are FFE'd
18:36:24 <amrith> some are part of the same feature (with host changes)
18:36:51 <amrith> lmk what are ffe'd
18:36:56 <amrith> ok?
18:36:58 <dougshelley66> ok
18:37:21 <amrith> ok, if no one has anything further on n-3, client freeze, ffe's, ...
18:38:06 <songjian> I am so sorry,Because of my depends on the cause of the error, so the client code has been the merge, but no server-side code... So I think that can consider to merge server add - disk - in - flavor - the list, if the change at the service there is no problem...https://review.openstack.org/#/c/352786/
18:38:54 <amrith> songjian, done
18:39:05 <amrith> I've added it to the list
18:39:17 <songjian> thx
18:39:56 <amrith> everyone ok with the list https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/ZQDPrQ2aq0
18:41:06 <amrith> dougshelley66, I took the ones from the list at the bottom and merged them into the earlier list
18:41:07 <johnma> sounds good Amrith. So do we still have to send the request for FFE to the mailing list or are we good?
18:41:12 <dougshelley66> looks good
18:41:25 <pmalik> Couchbase Cluster Support [dashboard]? We don't have that in the server.
18:41:27 <amrith> johnma, I'll take care of it as soon as I have your db2 backup review
18:41:39 <johnma> ok, thanks
18:42:15 <amrith> pmalik, are you saying that the code isn't up yet or that it has already merged?
18:42:19 <amrith> or something else?
18:43:07 <pmalik> I don't think we even had an approved spec for it in this release...
18:43:49 <amrith> let me look
18:43:56 <dougshelley66> i'll pull that off the list
18:43:57 <peterstac> I can't find one
18:44:14 <amrith> thx doug
18:44:53 <amrith> OK, let's scrub the list one more time, wait till we have the last change from johnma and then we can make the FFE's
18:45:07 <amrith> but in any event, all we get with FFE's is one extra week
18:45:12 <amrith> so we have to get them merged ...
18:45:56 <amrith> ok, moving along if we don't have anything further ...
18:46:43 <amrith> #topic Open Discussion
18:47:06 <amrith> anyone have anything for discussion ...
18:48:19 <amrith> ok, so please spend time reviewing others code.
18:48:35 <trevormc> +1
18:48:38 <amrith> it is community
18:48:52 <amrith> and you reap what you sow ...
18:49:09 <amrith> if no one has anything else to add, we can adjourn
18:49:52 <amrith> #endmeeting