18:00:16 <amrith> #startmeeting trove
18:00:16 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Sep  7 18:00:16 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is amrith. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
18:00:17 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
18:00:20 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'trove'
18:00:39 <songjian> o/
18:00:47 <amrith> songjian, hello
18:00:54 <amrith> let's give folks a couple of minutes to come in
18:00:56 <aliadil_> o/
18:01:04 <amrith> hi ali
18:01:05 <songjian> amrith,hello
18:01:16 <johnma> hello amrith
18:01:23 <amrith> hi mariam
18:01:41 <amrith> #agenda https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/TroveMeeting#Running_The_Meeting
18:01:44 <aliadil_> Hi Amrith
18:03:13 <amrith> let's get started
18:03:15 <peterstac> o/
18:03:16 <dloi> o/
18:03:20 <amrith> hi folks
18:03:32 <amrith> #topic Trove Pulse Update
18:03:34 <vgnbkr> o/
18:03:43 <amrith> #link https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vJxNaoR3VVNS1Cpiz7U--1zyJRZ6ybMxzJoayrjdduo/edit?usp=sharing
18:03:50 <amrith> #link https://gist.github.com/anonymous/a318d682c692aa0afbc38cf9fa776f39
18:04:00 <amrith> Oh, I forgot
18:04:03 <amrith> courtesy ping for peterstac johnma dougshelley66 pmalik vgnbkr mvandijk trevormc aliadil spilla songjian trevormc apsarshaik
18:04:30 <amrith> we have a number of changes pending review
18:04:48 <amrith> as always, have to pick up the pace on reviews
18:05:15 <amrith> and we need to get some of these changes merged pretty soon
18:05:21 <amrith> so, please take some time and do more reviews.
18:05:31 <amrith> not much else I can add
18:06:01 <amrith> anybody have something they want to add on the subject of trove pulse update
18:06:25 <peterstac> it's really easy to break into the top 10 :)
18:06:42 <johnma> :)
18:06:53 <amrith> the bar is quite low, right ...
18:07:29 <amrith> fyi, there's an ongoing debate on what constitutes an 'active contributor' and an 'active reviewer' and unfortunately a lot of people won't make it to that list.
18:07:36 <amrith> #topic Newton release schedule
18:07:50 <amrith> #link http://releases.openstack.org/newton/schedule.html
18:07:57 <amrith> we are now focusing on FFE's and bug fixes
18:08:06 <amrith> We have the list of FFE's from last weeks meeting
18:09:14 <amrith> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/ZQDPrQ2aq0
18:09:21 <amrith> and we starred the changes from that list
18:09:42 <amrith> The meeting agenda contains the ones we're tracking now
18:09:52 <amrith> The first one https://review.openstack.org/#/c/366466
18:09:55 <amrith> is done
18:09:59 <amrith> thx peterstac johnma
18:10:29 <amrith> I think there are a couple that are ready to go
18:10:51 <johnma> I am testing the postgres one , will approve that soon
18:11:07 <amrith> https://review.openstack.org/267736, https://review.openstack.org/358874, https://review.openstack.org/286159, https://review.openstack.org/288712 and https://review.openstack.org/329627
18:11:16 <amrith> all require a second +2/+1
18:11:40 <peterstac> I think there's 5 or 6 that I still need to look at - trying to get that done today
18:11:54 <amrith> yes and I think everyone can help with this
18:12:10 <amrith> if you can review the patch, cherry-pick it and test it, all welcomed
18:12:44 <amrith> peterstac, johnma maybe we can circle back later in the evening and see where we're at.
18:12:55 <amrith> the deadline for getting these FFE's in is the end of this week
18:12:56 <johnma> sure
18:13:01 <amrith> with only exceptions for next week
18:13:15 <amrith> so if we don't get enough +1's behind some of these changes, they may miss the boat for newton
18:13:40 <amrith> johnma, how are the DB2 changes coming, I see you had new patches up today
18:14:32 <johnma> the backup ones are ready for review. i need to push one more for the config changes
18:15:01 <johnma> the only thing thats left is the scenario tests for them.
18:15:29 <amrith> peterstac, there seems to be a race in the redis scenario test
18:15:29 <amrith> http://logs.openstack.org/66/366466/1/gate/gate-trove-scenario-functional-dsvm-redis/c7be188/console.html#_2016-09-07_17_39_57_399048
18:15:33 <amrith> thx johnma
18:15:38 <amrith> pmalik_ ^^
18:16:36 <amrith> johnma, the postgresql thing you were testing was replication?
18:16:42 <amrith> https://review.openstack.org/288712
18:17:15 <johnma> yes replication one
18:17:56 <amrith> ok, thx
18:18:15 <amrith> I've been looking at the quota thing again
18:18:22 <amrith> https://review.openstack.org/331323
18:18:26 <peterstac> I looked at the Redis failure, but couldn't see anything obvious about it ...
18:18:57 <amrith> ok, will look again at that.
18:19:06 <amrith> the big one remaining is instance upgrade
18:19:13 <amrith> https://review.openstack.org/326064
18:19:22 <peterstac> yeah, on my list to test
18:20:08 <amrith> are we all ok with https://review.openstack.org/329627?
18:20:15 <amrith> this is scheduled backups, the mistral workbook
18:20:24 <amrith> that should be good to go, I think
18:20:45 <peterstac> yeah - it'd be good to have the devstack plugin load if it if exists, but we can do that in a follow-up
18:20:58 <amrith> ok, is there any specific other bug that people want to discuss as a priority for reviews now?
18:21:46 <songjian> Maybe this bug fix worth looking, about pid_file, because it is real, but encountered some unknown answers, hope to be able to modify as soon as possible. https://review.openstack.org/#/c/365398/
18:22:16 <vgnbkr> I looked into having devstack add the workbook (again), but couldn't get it to work.
18:24:21 <amrith> thx songjian
18:24:25 <peterstac> I haven't run stuff in fake mode (I test using devstack) so it's not a priority for me :)
18:24:47 <amrith> I don't know that anyone does; I just observed it in passing and added a bug.
18:24:56 <amrith> it doesn't strike me as much of a priority for this stage
18:25:05 <peterstac> right
18:25:06 <amrith> I do have a problem with the choice of default though ...
18:26:29 <songjian> I also wonder if this default problem how to solve, want to listen to your opinion...
18:26:30 <amrith> thx vgnbkr
18:27:12 <amrith> songjian, does pid_file need to be in CONF?
18:27:21 <amrith> I'm not sure it has to be
18:27:44 <amrith> I suspect that it was at some point, and got removed, but not completely removed
18:28:20 <amrith> I suspect that this was when Trove was MySQL only
18:28:27 <amrith> and therefore CONF.pid_file made sense
18:28:28 <amrith> not any more
18:29:17 <amrith> ok, as there's nothing else to discuss
18:29:21 <amrith> #topic Open Discussion
18:29:29 <amrith> anyone have anything else they want to talk about ...
18:29:42 <amrith> or reclaim 30 minutes of your day.
18:31:21 <amrith> going once
18:31:26 <peterstac> or 30 extra min for reviews ;)
18:31:36 <amrith> 30 minutes for reviews
18:31:44 <amrith> thanks everyone
18:31:45 <amrith> #endmeeting