14:00:35 <dkrol> #startmeeting trove
14:00:35 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Sep 12 14:00:35 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is dkrol. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:36 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:38 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'trove'
14:00:47 <dkrol> Hello All
14:01:01 <mpiwowarczy> dkrol: hello
14:01:05 <dkrol> is there anyone for trove meeting ? :)
14:01:13 <mpiwowarczy> me :)
14:01:25 <dkrol> great
14:01:33 <dkrol> I knew I can count on you :)
14:01:34 <dkrol> #topic roll call
14:01:50 <dkrol> let's wait a few more minutes
14:02:52 <czukowski> hi all
14:03:06 <mpiwowarczy> czukowski: hi
14:03:24 <dkrol> hi
14:03:48 <wangyao> hi
14:03:58 <dkrol> wangyao: hello
14:05:42 <dkrol> Ok so I believe we can start
14:06:13 <dkrol> there are 3 points on our agenda for today, so lets start with the first one
14:06:30 <dkrol> #topic recent changes and reviews
14:06:47 <dkrol> let's start with recent changes and reviews
14:07:01 <dkrol> do you want to share what did you work on recently ?
14:07:54 <wangyao> seems we have few patches rencently, and sorry for have no time for trove recently
14:08:13 <mpiwowarczy> from my side
14:08:46 <mpiwowarczy> python-troveclient and change https://review.openstack.org/#/c/596699/ is done, thanks for a review
14:09:30 <mpiwowarczy> same with https://review.openstack.org/#/c/572986/ but not merged yet
14:09:40 <mpiwowarczy> there are still two unstable tests
14:10:04 <dkrol> mpiwowarczy: unit tests ?
14:10:26 <mpiwowarczy> this is because fakemode tests uses old version of trove client - not from master
14:10:48 <mpiwowarczy> I need to investigate how to fix that
14:11:15 <mpiwowarczy> new release of troveclient would solve issue, but not sure it is correct way
14:11:27 <dkrol> ok, I see
14:11:50 <mpiwowarczy> I have also made review of minor fix https://review.openstack.org/#/c/600624/
14:11:50 <dkrol> I was reviewing recently - https://review.openstack.org/#/c/575229/
14:12:25 <dkrol> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/601586/
14:12:46 <dkrol> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/575230/ - this is related to https://review.openstack.org/#/c/575229/
14:13:25 <dkrol> and https://review.openstack.org/#/c/601581/
14:13:55 <dkrol> and there is also something new from a new contributor -> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/601886/
14:14:08 <dkrol> I will check it this week
14:14:45 <dkrol> and Bartosz Zurkowski shared a new change regarding tempest scenario test of trove
14:15:28 <dkrol> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/600013/
14:15:36 <mpiwowarczy> no much time to review there changes in last week
14:15:37 <dkrol> anything else ?
14:16:26 <mpiwowarczy> I will try to help with review in nearest days
14:16:47 <mpiwowarczy> that'is all from me
14:17:37 <dkrol> ok
14:18:04 <dkrol> #topic Trovestack redesign
14:18:23 <dkrol> lets talk a little bit about progress on trovestack redesign
14:18:30 <dkrol> is there anything new ?
14:19:20 <mpiwowarczy> no see any new comments on this matter in etherpad
14:20:01 <dkrol> I think there is no much progress about it as we are occupied with other work
14:20:57 <mpiwowarczy> thats right
14:21:17 <dkrol> we still need to better understand how zuul works
14:21:30 <mpiwowarczy> moreover, we are able to work on in parallel
14:21:35 <dkrol> and how it builds testing environment
14:21:39 <mpiwowarczy> yes, that is start point
14:22:29 <mpiwowarczy> later, we need to consider whether use trovestack script snippets in devstack or rewrite it to ansible
14:22:57 <mpiwowarczy> second point is building images process
14:23:36 <mpiwowarczy> but still need more time to work on it
14:24:17 <dkrol> it seems this task needs a lot of time but it has not so high priority
14:25:21 <dkrol> so maybe we can move to priorities
14:25:33 <mpiwowarczy> I will take care of python3-first task
14:25:38 <dkrol> #topic Stein goal
14:25:48 <mpiwowarczy> is there any place where we can write down priorities?
14:26:04 <dkrol> yes, python3-first task is the top priority for us
14:26:09 <mpiwowarczy> any bucktracker or etherpad?
14:26:26 <dkrol> yes -> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/trove-stein-priorities-and-specs-tracking
14:26:30 <dkrol> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/trove-stein-priorities-and-specs-tracking
14:27:19 <dkrol> for the python3-first goal the biggest issue is with trovestack
14:27:48 <mpiwowarczy> tasks order against priorities is still current?
14:27:59 <dkrol> I mean that we need to investigate how it these integration tests will work with python3
14:28:23 <dkrol> yes, it is based on my priorities :)
14:28:33 <mpiwowarczy> great :)
14:28:42 <dkrol> and there were no other comments
14:29:23 <dkrol> so let's keep it this way for a moment
14:29:50 <dkrol> how do you estimate python3-first task ?
14:30:06 <mpiwowarczy> ok, I think we know what to focus on in next days
14:30:22 <mpiwowarczy> hard to say
14:31:01 <mpiwowarczy> I have no idea for now what need to be done to use latest troveclient in tests
14:31:16 <dkrol> ok, I see
14:31:42 <dkrol> we need to investigate it further
14:31:58 <mpiwowarczy> but it will not be rocket science i guess :)
14:32:14 <mpiwowarczy> thats right
14:34:18 <dkrol> ok, I was looking at TroveClient - OSC migration
14:34:37 <dkrol> #link https://blueprints.launchpad.net/trove/+spec/trove-support-in-python-openstackclient
14:34:46 <dkrol> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/trove-support-python-openstackclient
14:34:49 <dkrol> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:bp/trove-support-in-python-openstackclient
14:34:57 <dkrol> these are main links for this task
14:35:14 <dkrol> I've tried to take a look at changes on gerrit
14:35:28 <dkrol> there is one WIP -> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/583952/1
14:35:48 <dkrol> and there are two abandoned: ttps://review.openstack.org/#/c/429068/ and  https://review.openstack.org/#/c/536855/
14:35:59 <dkrol> and there is a lot of changes merged
14:36:16 <dkrol> so it seems from my side this task is mostly done
14:36:46 <dkrol> there is however many unchecked functionalities:
14:36:47 <dkrol> trove root-show <instance_or_cluster> -> openstack database show --root <instance_or_cluster>
14:36:54 <dkrol> trove show <instance> -> openstack database cluster show <cluster>
14:37:02 <dkrol> trove user-show <instance> <name> -> openstack database user show <instance> <name>
14:37:03 <dkrol> trove user-show-access <instance> <name> -> openstack database user show --access <instance> <name>
14:37:08 <dkrol> trove backup-show <backup> -> openstack database backup show <backup>
14:37:11 <wangyao> yes, now we are mainly left with log/module and schedule
14:37:14 <dkrol> trove configuration-show <configuration_group> -> openstack database configuration show <configuration_group>
14:37:22 <dkrol> trove module-show <module> -> openstack database module show <module>
14:37:25 <dkrol> trove cluster-show <cluster> -> openstack database cluster show <cluster>
14:37:29 <dkrol> trove datastore-show <datastore> -> openstack datastore show <datastore>
14:37:33 <dkrol> trove flavor-show <flavor> -> openstack database flavor show <flavor>
14:37:35 <mpiwowarczy> are these changes planed on stain release?
14:37:53 <dkrol> IMHO we should do it
14:38:18 <dkrol> some of these unchecked functionalities seem to be done actually :)
14:38:53 <dkrol> so probably we need to verify what is actually needed
14:39:10 <dkrol> if only log/module and schedule then great
14:39:35 <mpiwowarczy> ok, found this at point 3 in trove-stein-priorities-and-specs-tracking etherpad
14:39:42 <dkrol> we can do it in stein release easily :)
14:40:10 <mpiwowarczy> great
14:40:35 <dkrol> in my opinion this should be our top priorieties after openstack wide goals
14:41:14 <mpiwowarczy> actually it is :)
14:41:34 <dkrol> :)
14:42:04 <dkrol> otherwise we have also tempest tests, nova file injection support, and documentation
14:43:26 <dkrol> there is also another openstack wide goal - 2. Support Pre Upgrade Checks
14:43:51 <dkrol> If I remember correctly Bartosz did some work about it
14:44:42 <wangyao> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/trove-support-python-openstackclient  I updated TODO
14:44:44 <czukowski> dkrol: I can start working on the documentation, we can talk offline about details
14:45:15 <dkrol> wangyao: great, thanks
14:46:07 <dkrol> czukowski: sure, documentation is very important for newcomers and you are in a great position to help us with it
14:47:39 <czukowski> are there any partticular tasks associated with the documentation, or we should create ones?
14:48:33 <dkrol> czukowski: it seems there is nothing specific so basically you need to check from scratch how good it is
14:48:53 <dkrol> how easy it is to understand how to start working with trove
14:48:56 <dkrol> in general
14:50:01 <czukowski> certainly, I may enhance the language, but what about the content? With whom discuss the prospect changes?
14:50:18 <dkrol> we can discuss it offline
14:50:28 <dkrol> no problem
14:50:46 <dkrol> and then we should add our ideas to https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/trove-stein-priorities-and-specs-tracking
14:51:12 <czukowski> dkrol: okay, that's right
14:51:45 <dkrol> ok
14:52:00 <dkrol> is there any other topics for discussions ?
14:52:12 <mpiwowarczy> nothing
14:52:22 <wangyao> nothing
14:52:42 <dkrol> ok, then thanks a lot for participating
14:52:50 <dkrol> take care and see you next week
14:53:05 <dkrol> #endmeeting