14:04:37 <bzurkowski> #startmeeting trove
14:04:37 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Mar 20 14:04:37 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is bzurkowski. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:04:38 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:04:41 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'trove'
14:05:37 <bzurkowski> OK
14:05:54 <dkrol> Do we have any agenda for today?
14:06:10 <bzurkowski> I guess, recent changes first, then datastore versioning
14:06:21 <bzurkowski> Same as the last meeting
14:06:28 <dkrol> Ok
14:06:32 <bzurkowski> One more
14:06:43 <bzurkowski> Tempest integration is the first topic
14:07:11 <bzurkowski> *the third
14:07:26 <dkrol> Ok
14:07:37 <dkrol> Recent changes first?
14:07:41 <bzurkowski> #topic recent changes
14:07:56 <dkrol> I can start
14:08:45 <dkrol> I had only time to work on docs and a few changes made by Kacper
14:09:15 <dkrol> I didn't check tempest change or vagrant file
14:10:40 <bzurkowski> Both docs changes have been approved, one is already merged
14:10:44 <bzurkowski> Nice
14:11:12 <dkrol> Thanks
14:11:47 <khasior> I worked on galera cluster bootstrapping method
14:13:01 <khasior> And I adapted my previous patch so that it follows Bartosz remarks
14:13:40 <dkrol> Sounds great
14:16:09 <bzurkowski> khasior: Great. I will review it soon.
14:17:18 <bzurkowski> From me, I made a couple of reviews
14:17:45 <bzurkowski> Mostly docs, but also Galera bootstrap thing
14:17:59 <bzurkowski> In parallel, I worked on integrating Tempest with Trove
14:18:09 <dkrol> I suppose Marcin and Cezary are no longer involved in trove?
14:18:38 <bzurkowski> dkrol: Unfortunately not, sorry
14:19:22 <dkrol> I understand. Let's move on
14:20:16 <bzurkowski> Someone more about recent changes?
14:21:00 <bzurkowski> #topic datastore versioning
14:21:21 <bzurkowski> This topic is worth discussing
14:21:56 <dkrol> I thought we already solved it :)
14:22:24 <bzurkowski> Initialy
14:22:29 <khasior> I have prepared a proposal code with datastore versioning - it's introduces support for newer Cassandra versions - https://review.openstack.org/#/c/642050/
14:23:36 <dkrol> Is it different from what we discussed?
14:24:07 <dkrol> Unfortunately I'm on a phone right now so I cannot read it
14:24:10 <bzurkowski> khasior: I'm reviewing it, you shoud soon get some feedback
14:25:00 <bzurkowski> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/trove-datastore-versioning
14:25:28 <bzurkowski> As far as I remember we decided to follow option nr 1
14:25:41 <bzurkowski> With a separate datastore manager for each version
14:26:02 <bzurkowski> This is the approach that what we inherited by Tesora
14:26:13 <bzurkowski> And Kasper already started adopting it
14:26:55 <dkrol> Ok, it is the simplest one and it doesn't require any change in the code
14:27:09 <dkrol> Great
14:27:15 <dkrol> Anything else?
14:27:25 <khasior> Not from my side
14:29:22 <bzurkowski> dkrol: I have an impression that you have limited time so I will not go into details
14:29:55 <bzurkowski> We can discuss design decissions during the next meeting or offline
14:30:31 <bzurkowski> #topic tempest integration
14:30:56 <bzurkowski> It would be great to have at least one working scenario for Stein release
14:31:01 <bzurkowski> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/600013/
14:31:06 <bzurkowski> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/638694/
14:31:43 <bzurkowski> I am just giving you a hint that above changes are live and soon you will have to review them
14:32:14 <bzurkowski> The first one introduces Tempest foundations and basic provisioning scenario
14:32:25 <bzurkowski> The second adds Tempest config to Trove Devstack plugin
14:32:33 <bzurkowski> Stay tuned
14:32:43 <bzurkowski> #topic stein release
14:33:25 <bzurkowski> dkrol: What is the plan for releasing Stein?
14:33:33 <bzurkowski> On Mar 22 there is RC1
14:35:58 <bzurkowski> I'm afraid we lost connection with Darek
14:37:13 <khasior> Should we wait for him?
14:38:25 <bzurkowski> A couple of minutes I think
14:40:14 <dkrol> hi
14:40:24 <dkrol> I was removed from the meeting
14:43:41 <bzurkowski> Hi
14:43:55 <bzurkowski> Great to have you back
14:44:17 <bzurkowski> I was asking about upcoming Stein release
14:44:26 <dkrol> I didn't get it
14:44:37 <bzurkowski> What is our plan for Stein release?
14:44:59 <dkrol> what do you mean ?
14:45:03 <bzurkowski> How do we prioritize the development
14:45:11 <bzurkowski> What should we focus on first
14:45:14 <bzurkowski> On Mar 22 there is RC1
14:45:22 <dkrol> For Stein or Train ?
14:45:30 <bzurkowski> For Stein
14:45:40 <bzurkowski> Not much time left before Stein is frozen and released
14:45:47 <bzurkowski> We have some opened changes
14:45:58 <bzurkowski> We must think about closing them before the release
14:49:03 <dkrol> I suppose there is no time for any new development
14:49:21 <dkrol> I would recommend to focus on open changes as you suggested
14:49:31 <dkrol> there is also a topic of moving to ubuntu bionic
14:50:00 <dkrol> I had an email discussion about it with openstack infra member and our new PTL
14:50:40 <dkrol> Moving to ubuntu bionic is a community-wide goal of openstack infra for stein
14:50:55 <dkrol> unfortunately we didn't do anything about it yet
14:51:31 <bzurkowski> I haven't heard about it yet
14:51:37 <dkrol> but I'm afraid there is no time in Stein for it any more
14:51:48 <bzurkowski> Agree
14:52:09 <dkrol> so closing open changes should be our top priority
14:52:09 <bzurkowski> So let's focus on closing opened issues
14:52:24 <bzurkowski> Eventually we could manage to complete Tempest integration
14:52:27 <dkrol> also any improvements in documentation would also help
14:53:10 <dkrol> I will forward you an email about it
14:53:35 <dkrol> but Stein is basically over so there is not too many things we can do
14:54:01 <dkrol> ok, my time is up
14:54:46 <dkrol> one more thing - if you didn't notice Lingxian Kong became the new Trove PTL
14:55:20 <dkrol> unfortunately we cannot meet us here during weekly but we is on IRC very actiive
14:55:43 <bzurkowski> Without voting?
14:55:48 <dkrol> thank you all for coming this week
14:56:03 <dkrol> He was the only candidate :)
14:56:40 <bzurkowski> Good to know
14:57:05 <dkrol> election week was about 2 weeks ago
14:57:19 <bzurkowski> Great communication
14:57:23 <bzurkowski> Dariusz
14:57:34 <bzurkowski> Anywa he seems to be a good fit
14:58:18 <dkrol> I wish him all the best
14:58:28 <dkrol> See you next week
14:58:47 <bzurkowski> Bye
14:58:48 <khasior> See you
15:00:39 <openstack> e0ne: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.
15:01:13 <e0ne> oops
15:01:38 <amotoki> hmm.... the last trove meeting started at 23:04:43 (in my local time)
15:01:48 <amotoki> so it seems we need to wait next three mins..
15:02:40 <e0ne> bzurkowski started the meeting and quit from IRC:(
15:03:20 <amotoki> AFAIK, everyone can end a meeting once one hour elapsed
15:04:44 <e0ne> @!
15:04:44 <_pewp_> e0ne (｡Ő▽Ő｡)ﾉﾞ
15:04:59 <e0ne> #endmeeting