08:01:27 <ifat_afek> #startmeeting vitrage 08:01:28 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Nov 2 08:01:27 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is ifat_afek. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 08:01:29 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 08:01:31 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'vitrage' 08:01:36 <ifat_afek> Hi everyone :-) 08:02:44 <eyalb> hi 08:03:56 <ifat_afek> #topic Barcelona recap 08:04:26 <ifat_afek> Barcelona summit was extremely successful! 08:04:38 <ifat_afek> Here are links to the recorded sessions: 08:04:55 <ifat_afek> #link https://www.openstack.org/videos/video/demo-openstack-and-opnfv-keeping-your-mobile-phone-calls-connected 08:05:03 <ifat_afek> #link https://www.openstack.org/videos/video/nokia-root-cause-analysis-principles-and-practice-in-openstack-and-beyond 08:05:13 <ifat_afek> #link https://www.openstack.org/videos/video/ptls-and-cores-we-are-not-as-scary-as-you-think-organized-by-the-women-of-openstack 08:05:22 <ifat_afek> #link https://www.openstack.org/videos/video/fault-management-with-openstack-congress-and-vitrage-based-on-opnfv-doctor-framework 08:05:36 <ifat_afek> In addition, we had Vitrage hands-on lab that was supposed to be recorded, and three design sessions. 08:06:23 <ifat_afek> The keynote demo with Doctor made a huge impression. The feedback we got was that it was the best demo in the keynotes this year. I think that as a result of this demo, more people came to Vitrage booth and to the hands-on lab. 08:06:37 <ifat_afek> eyalb: thanks for your help in the keynotes! 08:07:03 <eyalb> I sent an email to the rdo mailing list 08:07:10 <eyalb> updated them about vitrage 08:07:32 <eyalb> I also pushed another package review for the dashboard 08:08:17 <eyalb> and I started working on the puppet integration project that is needed for rdo 08:08:32 <eyalb> thats all 08:08:34 <ifat_afek> eyalb: that’s great, thanks 08:09:21 <ifat_afek> and did you understand that red hat are currently working on it? 08:09:44 <eyalb> yes they started working on this 08:10:30 <elisha_r> hi - sorry I got here late 08:10:31 <ifat_afek> great 08:10:43 <ifat_afek> it’s very important for vitrage installation 08:11:29 <ifat_afek> We had a meeting the next day with Doctor team, and we agreed that the next step should be to finish Vitrage installation using TripleO and then to support Vitrage installation using Apex OPNFV installer. 08:11:39 <ifat_afek> And for that we need to have the rdo ready 08:11:50 <ifat_afek> We understood that there are currently some issues with Apex, so we need to wait some time before we can start working on this integration. 08:13:39 <elisha_r> so I'll update briefly about the session we had on the principles of RCA 08:14:02 <elisha_r> The session took place late Thursday, but we still had a nice crowd 08:15:12 <elisha_r> the session went well, overall, except for the fact that we had some technical glitches with the PPT... :) 08:15:30 <ifat_afek> :-) 08:16:42 <elisha_r> we gave an overview of what RCA is all about, and the motivation behind what we do in vitrage, which we coined "automated expert judgement". I think that working on preparing this session helped me, at least, to clarify our current focus in vitrage, within the world of RCA 08:17:20 <elisha_r> Then Ifat presented a LIVE (!!) demo, which went very well, as well as discussing the future steps of Vitrage 08:18:19 <elisha_r> After the session we had a few interesting questions, which were not recorded, so I'll review them here 08:18:53 <elisha_r> first, we were asked about handling multi-tenancy, specifically in cases where the Admin is not supposed to know or care what the tenanats are doing within their VMs 08:19:17 <elisha_r> I answered that part of this is already supported in the multi-tenancy support added recently, before the summit 08:19:43 <elisha_r> however, it's possible that we would need to enhance this support for such cases, since currently the Admin sees everything 08:20:18 <elisha_r> Alternatively, one coud run several vitrage instances, one for customer, one for admin, each with its own set of relevant datasources 08:20:40 <elisha_r> I think Vitrage should support the first option, but for full flexibility you might need the second no matter what 08:21:26 <elisha_r> I know there were a few more questions, about how simple it would be to add a new datasource. But don't recall the details 08:21:35 <elisha_r> that's it as far as I can recall 08:21:59 <ifat_afek> I was asked several times (after this session and in other times) about Vitrage-Aodh integration 08:23:00 <ifat_afek> I explained that Aodh are the alarm manager, and have no intention of doing RCA. We have a POC of raising Vitrage alarms in Aodh, but it’s not working well at the moment 08:23:29 <ifat_afek> I think it’s extremely important to finish this integration. I realized there is a real need for people to get Vitrage alarms using Aodh 08:24:17 <ifat_afek> Moving on - Our design sessions were very interesting and productive. Among the issues that we discussed: 08:24:23 <ifat_afek> • RCA history 08:24:31 <ifat_afek> • Graph log inspector 08:24:36 <ifat_afek> • Benchmark for Vitrage evaluator 08:24:42 <ifat_afek> • Vitrage UX 08:24:47 <ifat_afek> • Vitrage-Aodh Integration 08:24:53 <ifat_afek> • Vitrage-Congress integration 08:24:59 <ifat_afek> Link to the design sessions etherpad: 08:25:05 <ifat_afek> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/vitrage-barcelona-design-summit 08:27:16 <ifat_afek> We also had Vitrage hands-on lab, which succeeded beyond our expectations. Over 40 people came by to work in this lab, and many stayed after the end 08:27:42 <ifat_afek> This session was supposed to be recorded as well, but we can’t find the video. doffek is checking it 08:28:32 <ifat_afek> Last thing (I think) - we had Vitrage demos in Nokia booth in the market place. The booth was crowded all day long. 08:29:37 <ifat_afek> That’s what I had to say :-) Anything else? 08:33:42 <ifat_afek> So we’re done 08:33:51 <eyalb> bye 08:33:51 <ifat_afek> Bye! 08:33:57 <elisha_r> bye 08:34:01 <ifat_afek> #endmeeting